You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why are we in this mess?
November 16 2026 8.20am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why are we in this mess?


Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
davehuggins Flag 30 Sep 17 11.16pm

The majority of us on here are genuine fans, so what has gone wrong? For me, it all started before the cup final. Somebody had this wonderful idea to change our style and since then everything has gone south big time. SP told us all to change our mentality and look on Palace as a forward-thinking upward bound club, yeah right!! I honestly believe we have good enough players to be mid-table but we look simply lost with no direction. Why really did Pulis leave? Has to be SP and his transfer policy I believe? Big mistake IMO. I just hope we by some miracle can turn this around, but I doubt it.

 

Wilbraham413 Flag 01 Oct 17 2.49am

Yes, I think Parish screwed up by forgetting that we are a team who was just barely good enough to avoid relegation last year. It's like he thought we were an elite team.

He took a bad team, added no better players, and hired a manager who played a style completely opposite for what we should be doing.

Now our two best players are injured.

It's a combination of really bad management and really bad luck.

Since we're not a rich club, the goal each year should be avoiding disaster, and giving us the best chance to avoid relegation.

Parish did the exact opposite. He gambled big and lost.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

matthau Flag South Croydon 01 Oct 17 4.47am

This is intriguing = [Link]

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 01 Oct 17 5.02am

f d b

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 01 Oct 17 5.04am

Originally posted by matthau

This is intriguing = [Link]

Nothing intriguing about it
He's trying to save his job and in the process trying to praise his sad mate that got us in this mess FDB

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 01 Oct 17 5.31am

FDB did nothing wrong, he was hired but not left to do his job, he had targets, they were not met. He wasn't a likeable figure, fair enough - but why didn't they realise this in the hire process.

Ofcourse, in hindsight, he was the wrong choice - but he should't have been sacked after Burnley - that wasn't a sackable offence. He should have been given until xmas, but, all the turmoil in the club, would that have been worse?

Fact is, parish needs to step aside. He hires and fires way too much, he is the problem.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Selhurstboys Flag Basel 01 Oct 17 5.49am

For me it's mainly down to Parish and his sentimental decision making. He likes to surround himself with people that have some sort of identity or affinity with the club or area. I'm talking about people like Puncheon, he's one of our own, Bright a legend, Freedman another legend and now Roy, a nice old gentleman from Croydon. In Freedman's case, I mean, why would you appoint someone who has very little job or PL experience as a sporting director? Ok, there is real talent in some of these decisions like Zaha, and he could be the difference in us staying up, but generally sentimental decision making will fail us.

Don't get me wrong, it's a nice feeling to have people involved in our club where we feel their hearts are in the job, Parish included, but the Premier League is a ruthless multi-billion £ business and for me there's no room for sentimentality to really be successful. That stuff should be left to us fans.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 01 Oct 17 6.07am

Originally posted by Selhurstboys

For me it's mainly down to Parish and his sentimental decision making. He likes to surround himself with people that have some sort of identity or affinity with the club or area. I'm talking about people like Puncheon, he's one of our own, Bright a legend, Freedman another legend and now Roy, a nice old gentleman from Croydon. In Freedman's case, I mean, why would you appoint someone who has very little job or PL experience as a sporting director? Ok, there is real talent in some of these decisions like Zaha, and he could be the difference in us staying up, but generally sentimental decision making will fail us.

Don't get me wrong, it's a nice feeling to have people involved in our club where we feel their hearts are in the job, Parish included, but the Premier League is a ruthless multi-billion £ business and for me there's no room for sentimentality to really be successful. That stuff should be left to us fans.

...and people with more experience of football who have come to the club and gone.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

mseagle Flag 01 Oct 17 6.36am

It has to be said that the club and particularly Parrish have made more good decisions than bad ones. Since taking over he has been nothing but good news for this club, finding ourselves in the fifth
Year in the PL and spending big on some players has been unheard of in our history.
However over the past year big mistakes have been made. Pardew stayed to long and the FA cup final masked that. Crucially also during his reign he was asked to change the style of play - not Pardew fault but this was a disaster and nearly cost us relegation. Mistake three was not keeping Sam. I don't buy the whole retirement story. I suspect once he heard there was little money available that was it, he was gone. Next mistake was FDB. No one apart from SP asked to radically change our style but we went with it but crucially he did not back the manager in transfer market. Like when Pardew was asked to play it differently he had a whole bunch of players who could not easily adapt. Bizarelly just as it started to look better, at Burnley, he was sacked. The final or latest error was not getting at least 2 strikers in. You need depth across all 11 spots and 1 striker only is not how to run a club - it was so predictable.there would be some kind of injury to CB.
So what has gone wrong is not one thing but a catalogue of errors that have left us where we are. Not sure where the Yanks facctor in all this but we are left with a poor squad overall, a club that doesn't seem to have any clear direction whatsoever, save the obvious one that we are already looking at relegation. Don't have fhe answers but the club need to come up with some quickly and start making some better decisions,

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 01 Oct 17 6.37am

too many managers over a short period of time has left us with a squad with no identity .poor transfer dealings have added to our woes leaving us with a squad that is just not premier league .

We have too many players on wages that doesn't match their abilities , we will never be able to transform or even add to the squad while we cant get rid of Championship players on premier league money .

That's just a couple of thoughts of why we are in this mess ,it was catching up with us last season and its caught up with us now . If we can get our injured players back and keep them on the pitch for the rest of the season we might just pull it off again but the problems will not go away , they will be back again

 

oldstand Flag Christchurch 01 Oct 17 7.16am

Big Sam appears to avoid any criticism, his walk out has contributed to this mess. Bought players to get us over the line, not players to take us forward.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 01 Oct 17 7.25am

Originally posted by oldstand

Big Sam appears to avoid any criticism, his walk out has contributed to this mess. Bought players to get us over the line, not players to take us forward.

I read his autobiography and he's been pretty close to retirement from club football for a couple of years, really since he initially turned down the Sunderland job. Put that together with the six-month contract break clause and the writing was very much on the wall if he kept us up. For him it seems to have been about going out on a high after the England debacle. To be fair, he did the right things for us at the time, last season; it's the decisions since then that have got us where we are.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

miles18 Flag Telford 01 Oct 17 7.42am

Parish.

 



.

YT Flag Oxford 01 Oct 17 7.57am

Originally posted by oldstand

Big Sam appears to avoid any criticism, his walk out has contributed to this mess. Bought players to get us over the line, not players to take us forward.

Sam (presumably Sam) recruited Schlupp at £13m, who many on here are now saying is useless. I don't read many plaudits for PVA either, who also wasn't cheap. I wonder what Pulis would have done with that sort of money?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 01 Oct 17 8.08am

Originally posted by YT

Sam (presumably Sam) recruited Schlupp at £13m, who many on here are now saying is useless. I don't read many plaudits for PVA either, who also wasn't cheap. I wonder what Pulis would have done with that sort of money?

They both kept us up so there's probably little mileage in analysing 'oo did what to 'oo. We needed to address the LB position, and had done for some while, and that was sorted. It wasn't cheap, but it never is in January, especially when the selling clubs can smell your desperation, and most of us were happy with that at the time. We also got a decent DM and Sakho on loan. I doubt Pulis would have done much different, or better.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Plaistow Eagle Flag 01 Oct 17 8.26am

Originally posted by miles18

Parish.

This - my "word" exactly.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 01 Oct 17 8.48am

Originally posted by mseagle

It has to be said that the club and particularly Parrish have made more good decisions than bad ones. Since taking over he has been nothing but good news for this club, finding ourselves in the fifth
Year in the PL and spending big on some players has been unheard of in our history.
However over the past year big mistakes have been made.

There is no sentiment in football and if Parish were a player he would have been got rid of ages ago but because he is a significant shareholder he is allowed to retain his privileged position despite all his costly errors as chairman.

Someone posted earlier that FDB wasn't a nice bloke but conversely Steve Parish may well be a nice bloke but is that relevant in either case.

My own opinion (that I haven't expressed before) is that SP should have told FDB early on that he has to revert to a style of playing that the players were happy with and if a few of those that FDB didn't think were up to it went running to teacher to complain then he should have backed his manager not the whingers.

 

MngCPFC Flag 01 Oct 17 8.51am


I agree with Wilbraham413, I still look back to Dougie leaving while we were in 1st place in the Championship and can see only two managerial appointments that made sense in the years since. Both of those, Pulis and BfS made to avoid relegation due to poor managerial appointments and lack of signing.
We are a team that sits in the bottom third of the Premiership but SP obviously has to promote higher now we have US backers that work on results and returns.
Perhaps a drop and rebuild is what we need, football is football and the games are not as public down one league but I don't watch the other leagues, Premier included, when we are down and it is still exciting.
Cheaper tickets as well given the membership rubbish!!.

 

EagleEssex Flag Essex 01 Oct 17 9.01am

Originally posted by MngCPFC


I agree with Wilbraham413, I still look back to Dougie leaving while we were in 1st place in the Championship and can see only two managerial appointments that made sense in the years since. Both of those, Pulis and BfS made to avoid relegation due to poor managerial appointments and lack of signing.
We are a team that sits in the bottom third of the Premiership but SP obviously has to promote higher now we have US backers that work on results and returns.
Perhaps a drop and rebuild is what we need, football is football and the games are not as public down one league but I don't watch the other leagues, Premier included, when we are down and it is still exciting.
Cheaper tickets as well given the membership rubbish!!.

He also appointed Pardew, which was an excellent appointment, and a great coup at the time to prise him from a bigger club, whatever you think about what happened in the following seasons

 

YT Flag Oxford 01 Oct 17 9.02am

Originally posted by bexleydave

They both kept us up so there's probably little mileage in analysing 'oo did what to 'oo. We needed to address the LB position, and had done for some while, and that was sorted. It wasn't cheap, but it never is in January, especially when the selling clubs can smell your desperation, and most of us were happy with that at the time. We also got a decent DM and Sakho on loan. I doubt Pulis would have done much different, or better.

Point taken, Dave. Actually I had in mind another poster suggesting Pulis left because no money was made available to him. So I really was speculating how Pulis would have spent £40m 'back then' rather than if he had been the boss in Jan 17.

I guess my point was that money can be available when there is a sense of - as you say - desperation.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why are we in this mess?