This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Democracy 'Worst form of government ever'
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
SpyroCrystal 26 Nov 19 2.01pm |
|
|
Is it safe to say that democracy which is promoted worldwide is the worst form of government? It has so many flaws and is arguably the instigator to all future and present problems in world and domestic politics.
Edited by SpyroCrystal (26 Nov 2019 2.02pm)
Big up the Palace!!!!
|
Badger11 Beckenham 26 Nov 19 3.00pm |
|
|
Churchill saw the flaws the problem is what do you replace it with.
Any form of government will ultimately be by a group of people, elites if you like. No matter how well intentioned they are if you cannot get rid of them eventually they will become corrupt.
My solution if for more democracy not less. I like the Swiss model where they have referendums all the time. If we had that to avoid being defeated the politicians would have to live up to their promises.
Edited by Badger11 (26 Nov 2019 3.01pm)
One more point
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 26 Nov 19 3.02pm |
|
|
I think this requires more nuance than that. There are many voting systems and types of government that can be labelled democratic - some more democratic than others perhaps. In the original Greek democracy only a few male citizens voted, whilst most people were slaves. Of course, the obvious question is - what are the alternatives? Communism, dictatorship, absolutist monarchy? I could probably write a 100 page thesis here, so probably best I stop there. I'm sure you understand my points.
Red and Blue Army!
|
Stirlingsays 26 Nov 19 3.08pm |
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
I think this requires more nuance than that. There are many voting systems and types of government that can be labelled democratic - some more democratic than others perhaps. In the original Greek democracy only a few male citizens voted, whilst most people were slaves. Of course, the obvious question is - what are the alternatives? Communism, dictatorship, absolutist monarchy? I could probably write a 100 page thesis here, so probably best I stop there. I'm sure you understand my points.
Both fascism and communism are making a comeback....though in genuinely different forms.
They are both getting the old bands back together....though the commies have a long head start.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 26 Nov 19 3.14pm |
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Both fascism and communism are making a comeback....though in genuinely different forms.
They are both getting the old bands back together....though the commies have a long head start.
Communism and Fascism are always diametrically opposed, which I find ironic because when you look at many of the outcomes for the people living under the system, they are relatively similar. The main issue with fascism is that it really means very little. A fasces was a bunch of sticks around an axe carried by a Roman judge. Simply latched onto by Mussolini.
Red and Blue Army!
|
SpyroCrystal 26 Nov 19 3.31pm |
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
I think this requires more nuance than that. There are many voting systems and types of government that can be labelled democratic - some more democratic than others perhaps. In the original Greek democracy only a few male citizens voted, whilst most people were slaves. Of course, the obvious question is - what are the alternatives? Communism, dictatorship, absolutist monarchy? I could probably write a 100 page thesis here, so probably best I stop there. I'm sure you understand my points.
But democracy is now all over the world. In Africa we kind of hate democracy but dare not challenge it openly or get whacked. The 'voting' varients sounds way too fake for my liking. In Europe surely the original governments were monarchs (real leaders). As long as the leaders are rightous to the people they serve in their realms/nations I am sure people would be happy to sacrifice the 'freedoms' democratic systems of governments claims to offer. Plus the media thrives in democratic systems of governance and continues to lie to people look at Brexit manipulation
Edited by SpyroCrystal (26 Nov 2019 3.32pm)
Big up the Palace!!!!
|
SpyroCrystal 26 Nov 19 3.33pm |
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Churchill saw the flaws the problem is what do you replace it with.
Any form of government will ultimately be by a group of people, elites if you like. No matter how well intentioned they are if you cannot get rid of them eventually they will become corrupt.
My solution if for more democracy not less. I like the Swiss model where they have referendums all the time. If we had that to avoid being defeated the politicians would have to live up to their promises.
Edited by Badger11 (26 Nov 2019 3.01pm)
Fair play. Not really a fan of Churchill to be honest but he is a great England hero of WW2 so ok
Big up the Palace!!!!
|
SpyroCrystal 26 Nov 19 3.36pm |
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Both fascism and communism are making a comeback....though in genuinely different forms.
They are both getting the old bands back together....though the commies have a long head start.
Yeah I think it's between corporate dominance and communism not too sure about fascism. Surely we could blame the democratic system that was meant as a means to shape a world and bring world communism to Europe and North America before the whole world? Something that would never happen easily if the West had strong, real leaders (monarchs minus the religion dominance though)
Edited by SpyroCrystal (26 Nov 2019 3.39pm)
Edited by SpyroCrystal (26 Nov 2019 3.40pm)
Big up the Palace!!!!
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 26 Nov 19 4.15pm |
|
Originally posted by SpyroCrystal
But democracy is now all over the world. In Africa we kind of hate democracy but dare not challenge it openly or get whacked. The 'voting' varients sounds way too fake for my liking. In Europe surely the original governments were monarchs (real leaders). As long as the leaders are rightous to the people they serve in their realms/nations I am sure people would be happy to sacrifice the 'freedoms' democratic systems of governments claims to offer. Plus the media thrives in democratic systems of governance and continues to lie to people look at Brexit manipulation
Edited by SpyroCrystal (26 Nov 2019 3.32pm)
I guess you have some kind of a point there. Nevertheless, Britain and the USA and arguably France were at their greatest whilst still being democratic. Perhaps the form of democracy, in places like Britain, has largely served its purpose/ gone past its sell by date. Perhaps an overhaul is required? My idea would be to make manifestos a legally binding contract. Promises would have to be delivered within a certain time frame or a new election be held. That would stop the false promises and outright lies. I would also suggest that new parties will evolve that better represent what people want - or at least purport to.
Red and Blue Army!
|
Stirlingsays 26 Nov 19 4.15pm |
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Communism and Fascism are always diametrically opposed, which I find ironic because when you look at many of the outcomes for the people living under the system, they are relatively similar. The main issue with fascism is that it really means very little. A fasces was a bunch of sticks around an axe carried by a Roman judge. Simply latched onto by Mussolini.
Communism and Fascism both share statism and militarism.
Their most obvious separation point is that one focuses on class and the other race......though obviously those are broad strokes.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Stirlingsays 26 Nov 19 5.44pm |
|
|
Our lefty friends may be upset come mid December but long term they hold the whip hand:
Positive views toward capitalism/socialism 2019 Millennials/Gen Zers: Capitalism 51% positive Socialism 49% Gen Xers: Capitalism 61% Socialism 39% Boomers/Traditionalists: Capitalism 68% Socialism 32% (Gallup)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Tom-the-eagle Croydon 26 Nov 19 6.33pm |
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Our lefty friends may be upset come mid December but long term they hold the whip hand:
Positive views toward capitalism/socialism 2019 Millennials/Gen Zers: Capitalism 51% positive Socialism 49% Gen Xers: Capitalism 61% Socialism 39% Boomers/Traditionalists: Capitalism 68% Socialism 32% (Gallup)
This may because Millennials/Gen Zers don't have anything/earn anything.
Once they get older and therefore start earning well and see how much tax they have to pay they then soon start to jump into the capitalist camp.
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit
|
Tom-the-eagle Croydon 26 Nov 19 6.37pm |
|
Originally posted by SpyroCrystal
Is it safe to say that democracy which is promoted worldwide is the worst form of government? It has so many flaws and is arguably the instigator to all future and present problems in world and domestic politics.
Edited by SpyroCrystal (26 Nov 2019 2.02pm)
I think the idea of having the best of both systems, democracy and communism. Maybe we could all be allowed to vote but only have one party to vote for.
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit
|
Stirlingsays 26 Nov 19 6.47pm |
|
Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle
This may because Millennials/Gen Zers don't have anything/earn anything.
Once they get older and therefore start earning well and see how much tax they have to pay they then soon start to jump into the capitalist camp.
You mean own that home that they can't afford and isn't there for them now......both of them working.
Not being able to pass on much inheritance to their kids.
I think what you're saying was more true in past generations but I think that affect is much less now.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 26 Nov 19 8.43pm |
|
|
japanese shogun/samurai...undemocratic Feudalism. Battlefield elites were calling all the shots.
introduce firearms....suddenly you need tons of people to win a battle....hey presto 'democracy'
greek trireme oarsmen were many and needed...democracy.
imagine if everybody on a double decker bus had a steering wheel. That is democracy.
if you pay no income tax ( or no other major tax contributions ) then you contribute nothing to the pie.
So why be entitled to a vote and a say on the distributing of the pie ?
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
twist Miami, Florida 21 Dec 19 4.46am |
|
|
With your average pleb more interested in what Kim wore to the Met gala this week than the impeachment, its only going to get worse.
Its easier to distract the masses than it used to be.
"washing machines are not working like they used to, i know this because women tell me"...crowd goes wild.
I rest my case.
|
Stirlingsays 21 Dec 19 7.52am |
|
|
When no matter who you vote for you get globalization and colonization....You have to wonder if the game is rigged.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
sickboy Deal or Croydon 21 Dec 19 7.59am |
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
When no matter who you vote for you get globalization and colonization....You have to wonder if the game is rigged.
Not in my favour it isn't.
|
Stirlingsays 21 Dec 19 8.10am |
|
|
Quite.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
| W12 21 Dec 19 9.43am |
|
|
Our problems are not political but social
Years ago the Brexit vote would have been accepted because people would have known that was the right thing to do and the consequences of going against democracy. Now there is widespread corruption and a self interest culture.
|