You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Players to offload (if we can) in the summer.
November 16 2026 5.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Players to offload (if we can) in the summer.


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Johng Flag 08 Mar 20 10.46pm

I'd be interested to see what people think on this subject.

For me it would be.

Benteke (form and wages)
Sakho (fitness/injuries and wages)
Meyer (won't play enough/lightweight for prem and wages)
Luka (past his best)
Hennessey (liability/little confidence in him. A young hungry option preferred).

Oh and Wilf, of course (he's going anyway)

Edited by Johng (08 Mar 2020 10.49pm)

 

TheArmaniCode Flag 09 Mar 20 12.10am

Sakho and Hennessey are the only ones I can agree with. The rest have all proven they have their uses and aren't worth scrapping especially with a board so reluctant to bring players in

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 Mar 20 12.22am

Reality is we’ll take good money for any of them because we don’t get lots of interest in many of our players for several reasons and the owners want the money.

Reasons:
Players’ ages
Wages
System they play in and it’s rigidity.
Our team is a unit and nobody stands out or will look much better than anyone already has or worth the wages, age, transfer fee.

The one that stands out is Guaita. The time to sell Luca was when Everton were sounding interest at £20 mil but we didn’t see his form dropping or him having already reached his peak and got scared of losing him. Not knocking it because it’s a difficult thing to time right but that’s how it looks now. Unless Luca does some real soul searching his best days look behind him.

 


COYP

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 09 Mar 20 8.21am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Reality is we’ll take good money for any of them because we don’t get lots of interest in many of our players for several reasons and the owners want the money.

Reasons:
Players’ ages
Wages
System they play in and it’s rigidity.
Our team is a unit and nobody stands out or will look much better than anyone already has or worth the wages, age, transfer fee.

The one that stands out is Guaita. The time to sell Luca was when Everton were sounding interest at £20 mil but we didn’t see his form dropping or him having already reached his peak and got scared of losing him. Not knocking it because it’s a difficult thing to time right but that’s how it looks now. Unless Luca does some real soul searching his best days look behind him.


Basically agree with you Rudi. Our team is more than the sum of its parts and to be fair that is down to RH and the way he has them working for each other.

Having said that I wouldn't be unhappy if Sakho were to go (wages and injuries). Whilst I might want to see some of the others mentioned depart I would want to be certain that younger replacements were in first. However, I expect the youngsters we do sign will be along the lines of Scott Banks, namely, unproven, not expensive and us probably having to wait a couple of years or so to see if they will be good enough to make the first team bench.

PS Just hope no-one comes in for Guaita this summer but I'll be surprised if no-one does.

 

Fatherken Flag 09 Mar 20 9.27am

here we go again
same names from the haters of certain payers
last season when a thread like this came up most people wanted to get rid of Ayew , when we got him back most people wondered what he hell we were doing ,now most people think he is a great player .
funny old game
lets leave to Roy he knows what he is doing

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 09 Mar 20 9.30am

Originally posted by Fatherken

here we go again
same names from the haters of certain payers
last season when a thread like this came up most people wanted to get rid of Ayew , when we got him back most people wondered what he hell we were doing ,now most people think he is a great player .
funny old game
lets leave to Roy he knows what he is doing

You're right, why bother having a forum to discuss anything at all?

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 Mar 20 9.46am

Originally posted by Fatherken

here we go again
same names from the haters of certain payers
last season when a thread like this came up most people wanted to get rid of Ayew , when we got him back most people wondered what he hell we were doing ,now most people think he is a great player .
funny old game
lets leave to Roy he knows what he is doing

The players in the opening post have been here for quite a while and have not been producing or playing for quite a while, costing a serious amount of money. Ayew had been at the club not even a year and without a pre season. He was useful for a squad member and cost as much.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (09 Mar 2020 11.02am)

 


COYP

Johng Flag 09 Mar 20 10.53am

Originally posted by Fatherken

here we go again
same names from the haters of certain payers
last season when a thread like this came up most people wanted to get rid of Ayew , when we got him back most people wondered what he hell we were doing ,now most people think he is a great player .
funny old game
lets leave to Roy he knows what he is doing

Nobody has said they hate anybody. These are the weekly wages for the following. Are they really providing value for money. These salaries are a massive drain on the club's finances.

Max Meyer £125,000
Christian Benteke £120,000
Mamadou Sakho £100,000

Edited by Johng (09 Mar 2020 10.54am)

 

EddieMac Flag 09 Mar 20 11.01am

How about we have a vote to see who we can offload off this forum ? There is plenty of people I can think of.

There is a site called miserablesods.com that im sure a lot of you would be welcome on.

 

Johng Flag 09 Mar 20 11.11am

Originally posted by EddieMac

How about we have a vote to see who we can offload off this forum ? There is plenty of people I can think of.

There is a site called miserablesods.com that im sure a lot of you would be welcome on.


Only one person on here that's a miserable sod pal and it ain't me. If you don't like the discussion, don't get involved. Simple.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Mar 20 11.13am

Originally posted by EddieMac

How about we have a vote to see who we can offload off this forum ? There is plenty of people I can think of.

There is a site called miserablesods.com that im sure a lot of you would be welcome on.

In any such vote, I suspect that I will be top of the pile! Rest assured, I would depart gracefully with no ill-feeling.!

I am certain that my dear wife would conclude that I am ideally suited to the website in question, especially after a defeat.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 09 Mar 20 11.14am

Originally posted by Fatherken

here we go again
same names from the haters of certain payers
last season when a thread like this came up most people wanted to get rid of Ayew , when we got him back most people wondered what he hell we were doing ,now most people think he is a great player .
funny old game
lets leave to Roy he knows what he is doing

I'm not sure how much Roy has to do with the transfers and my guess would be very little

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 09 Mar 20 11.15am

Originally posted by Johng

Nobody has said they hate anybody. These are the weekly wages for the following. Are they really providing value for money. These salaries are a massive drain on the club's finances.

Max Meyer £125,000
Christian Benteke £120,000
Mamadou Sakho £100,000

Max Meyer's alleged wages have been brought up quite a few times as no-one seems to know where this figure has come from. My understanding is that it's about half of what you quoted.

Benteke has had his contract renewed but no-one knows on what terms

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 09 Mar 20 11.18am

Luka needs to pull his head out of his arse or I would let him go. McArthy for me is a future Captain along with Cahill.

Benteke I have been Benheskey's greatest detractor for all but his last two games. Something has changed in the way Roy plays him, and he is without douby improved now the weight is off him to score. There is a very promising partnership developing with him and Ayew. Much like Bright and wright ( not as dynamic but you get the point ?) for that reason alone he has to stay IMO.

Meyer needs to be the attacking midfielder in a 451 or 442 Roy plays neither so we will never see the best of him which is a shame as he is technically one of our best players. It's a shame but square peg in a round hole so he's got to go I think.

Sakho has struggled with Injury this season, and reminds me a bit of when we Had Anthony Gardener From Spurs, on his day looks like a world beater but always has that one moment in a game where you think how the fcuk is he a professional footballer. His age is an issue as well plus wages, if it's a toss up between him and Tomkins I would keep Tomkins, with Dann doing OK and Kelly able to Cover at Center Back I think Sakho is an expense we can't carry.

Hennessy needs game time elsewhere, Guita has shown just how poor Hennesey actually is. I was never a fan of Hennesey two slow, and for a gurt big lump sh1t at commanding his area. We need better cover for G man.

Wilf - Wouldn't be to certain he will leave to be honest. His performances and goal return do not warrant the fee Parish is after, can you honestly see anyone offering the 70 million we're after ? I would say Adama Traore from Wolves, and Allan Saint-Maximin have probably gone ahead of Wilf in the Bigger clubs "would like to have" lists, and have arguably had better seasons. However the Chelsea deal with Bats coming our way is apparently a done deal so who the feck Knows.

Sorloth - Don't care how many goals he's scored in Turkey, it's a tin pot league and he was absolutely out of his depth in the prem. Championship player at best. Vent.

Wickham - Made of glass and not tearing up tree's with Wednesday get rid.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 09 Mar 20 11.20am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Max Meyer's alleged wages have been brought up quite a few times as no-one seems to know where this figure has come from. My understanding is that it's about half of what you quoted.

Benteke has had his contract renewed but no-one knows on what terms

some of It comes from a website called Spotrac, it quotes various sport stars salaries, whether true or not.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Mar 20 11.20am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Max Meyer's alleged wages have been brought up quite a few times as no-one seems to know where this figure has come from. My understanding is that it's about half of what you quoted.

Benteke has had his contract renewed but no-one knows on what terms

This is my understanding as well.
Perhaps we have the same reliable sources!!!!

 

EddieMac Flag 09 Mar 20 11.29am

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

Luka needs to pull his head out of his arse or I would let him go. McArthy for me is a future Captain along with Cahill.

Benteke I have been Benheskey's greatest detractor for all but his last two games. Something has changed in the way Roy plays him, and he is without douby improved now the weight is off him to score. There is a very promising partnership developing with him and Ayew. Much like Bright and wright ( not as dynamic but you get the point ?) for that reason alone he has to stay IMO.

Meyer needs to be the attacking midfielder in a 451 or 442 Roy plays neither so we will never see the best of him which is a shame as he is technically one of our best players. It's a shame but square peg in a round hole so he's got to go I think.

Sakho has struggled with Injury this season, and reminds me a bit of when we Had Anthony Gardener From Spurs, on his day looks like a world beater but always has that one moment in a game where you think how the fcuk is he a professional footballer. His age is an issue as well plus wages, if it's a toss up between him and Tomkins I would keep Tomkins, with Dann doing OK and Kelly able to Cover at Center Back I think Sakho is an expense we can't carry.

Hennessy needs game time elsewhere, Guita has shown just how poor Hennesey actually is. I was never a fan of Hennesey two slow, and for a gurt big lump sh1t at commanding his area. We need better cover for G man.

Wilf - Wouldn't be to certain he will leave to be honest. His performances and goal return do not warrant the fee Parish is after, can you honestly see anyone offering the 70 million we're after ? I would say Adama Traore from Wolves, and Allan Saint-Maximin have probably gone ahead of Wilf in the Bigger clubs "would like to have" lists, and have arguably had better seasons. However the Chelsea deal with Bats coming our way is apparently a done deal so who the feck Knows.

Sorloth - Don't care how many goals he's scored in Turkey, it's a tin pot league and he was absolutely out of his depth in the prem. Championship player at best. Vent.

Wickham - Made of glass and not tearing up tree's with Wednesday get rid.

Top post. I agree with almost all of what you said but I still think Wilf is a better player than Saint- Maximim and I wouldn't swap Wilf for him.

 

EddieMac Flag 09 Mar 20 11.33am

Originally posted by Johng


Only one person on here that's a miserable sod pal and it ain't me. If you don't like the discussion, don't get involved. Simple.

My post was all in jest Johng and not refering to you in this instance and not even refering to the discussion you started, it was more about the over all negativity of a lot of people on here.

I think it is a worthwhile discussion because we do need to get rid of a couple of players. Meyer woukld be top of my list as he is never going to fit into our team or system. Sakho on the other hand has shown how good he can be.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 09 Mar 20 11.59am

For me the jury is out on Bentenke. If he can play like has in the last few games then he is worth keeping around for one more year. Sakho just seems unable to stay fit and so I would reluctantly listen to offers given his age. Personally I think if Meyer is happy to stay then I can still see him having a future at the club, but he may not have that patience now that Roy will be with us for another year. Luka looked better in 20 minutes on Saturday than he has looked for a long time, so maybe he just needed a break and some competition to shake the cobwebs off. He is still probably the best long passer of the ball and on his day is probably our best central midfielder. Like a number of players it's all about whether he can get back to his old self. A year ago most of us would have happily accepted Riedewald leaving, but now many of us want him to get more of a chance. Like Meyer it may all come down to patience. Wayne is fine as number two. We're too small a club to attract a better GK to sit on the bench in my opinion.

To be honest, there is no one I'd be happy to see leave, especially given how small our squad is. A big factor will be who we bring in.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 09 Mar 20 12.29pm

Originally posted by Willo

This is my understanding as well.
Perhaps we have the same reliable sources!!!!

There was some talk that the 125.000 included the signing on fee, so if the 75.000 a week is correct and the signing fee is added that would make a signing on fee of about 6.5 million, I don't know if that is a realistic amount for that theory

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Players to offload (if we can) in the summer.