This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
I am not swayed by party politics, I just think the system is inherently flawed. (that doesn't make me a communist, either) What I would like to see is more accountability from MP's and politicians. Just for starters, I would suggest. * MP's be put on time-sheets so the electorate know how much time they are spending on constituency or parliamentary work. * Disclosure of fees paid to 'Scientific Advisors', ..or in fact any of the various 'Advisors'. They could start with a proper job description after all the rest of us have one something like: - Minimum number of hours doing constituency work The rest of us have a proper job description against which we are assessed and paid accordingly. I don't see why this doesn't apply to them as well.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
One thing that bothers me is lies in the manifesto. Some are downright fabricated just to get votes. I think I've said it before but how about they are only allowed to put measured and timed actual targets into the manifesto? - making it a real document. Then, when after 12 months what was promised is not delivered - a new election. As someone else said, we have measured things to do, targets to meet, and if we don't do it - we soon hear about it, or even just get the boot. The other thing that Westminster needs is some kind of proportional representation, so that the number of votes a party gets - would give them some representation. Mathematically: it is possible in the current system to get the most votes overall but actually have no seats at all! Seems mad, but if you finished second in most constituencies - that is exactly what could happen. As a caveat to that, the seats generally mirror the amount of votes; but this scenario could change in the current political climes. There was the Labour pledge last year, it was to the women born in the 50's who lost a when the retirement ages shifted for state pension - and that was after the manifesto was issued.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
One thing that bothers me is lies in the manifesto. Some are downright fabricated just to get votes. I think I've said it before but how about they are only allowed to put measured and timed actual targets into the manifesto? - making it a real document. Then, when after 12 months what was promised is not delivered - a new election. As someone else said, we have measured things to do, targets to meet, and if we don't do it - we soon hear about it, or even just get the boot. The other thing that Westminster needs is some kind of proportional representation, so that the number of votes a party gets - would give them some representation. Mathematically: it is possible in the current system to get the most votes overall but actually have no seats at all! Seems mad, but if you finished second in most constituencies - that is exactly what could happen. As a caveat to that, the seats generally mirror the amount of votes; but this scenario could change in the current political climes. So MPs are just like footballers then. They keep their job for a fixed period no matter how crap they are.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
So MPs are just like footballers then. They keep their job for a fixed period no matter how crap they are. That's every work place if you think about it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
85k plus expenses and every forum thinks they can do more hours and a better job. There are a few on this forum that seem to think that they would do a better job with one in particular knowing far more than anyone in government, science or medicine judging by his comments.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
85k plus expenses and every forum thinks they can do more hours and a better job. I wouldn't want the permanent abuse ,whichever colour flag you fly. How do you judge if an MP is doing a good job when they don't have a detailed job description. I'm not saying I could do a better job but it would be nice if we could benchmark them against some form of a standard after all we are their employers.
One more point |
|
|
They don’t do it for the money. They do it for the power and their ego. A handful do it because they want to serve the public.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
How do you judge if an MP is doing a good job when they don't have a detailed job description. I'm not saying I could do a better job but it would be nice if we could benchmark them against some form of a standard after all we are their employers. You cant benchmark success when the public are your accountability. There is always one idiot.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
They don’t do it for the money. They do it for the power and their ego. A handful do it because they want to serve the public. I'm not buying that danh. All colours do it because they want to try to impliment their ideas to make it better for us. Whether we agree or not we get the choice at the polling station.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
You cant benchmark success when the public are your accountability. There is always one idiot. And I would add that the majority didn't vote for you, therefore the majority will always have an axe to grind on you. As is being admirably demonstrated during the current crisis. "What did you do in The Great (coronavirus) War, Daddy?" "Well, son, I stayed at home receiving 80% of my pay for doing nothing and I moaned constantly about those who were trying to do something about it, regardless of the fact that if I'd had to deal with it, I probably would have sh!t myself under the pressure of such responsibility." Not the snappiest poster, I grant you!
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
And I would add that the majority didn't vote for you, therefore the majority will always have an axe to grind on you. As is being admirably demonstrated during the current crisis. "What did you do in The Great (coronavirus) War, Daddy?" "Well, son, I stayed at home receiving 80% of my pay for doing nothing and I moaned constantly about those who were trying to do something about it, regardless of the fact that if I'd had to deal with it, I probably would have sh!t myself under the pressure of such responsibility." Not the snappiest poster, I grant you! Good post
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
You cant benchmark success when the public are your accountability. There is always one idiot. That is why in the examples I gave there was nothing political. Of course people who didn't vote for an MP will always moan but there are certain areas such as how much time an MP spends doing constituency business. George Osbourne was about to be cited by the Labour Party before he resigned as apparently he had not been seen in his constituency in 1 year. Gorgeous George was far too busy with all the other jobs he had outside of Parliament. All I am asking for is a basic job description. Just because an MP spends the allotted time doing constituency work it doesn't mean he is any good but it's a start. Currently if an MP goofs off it is next to impossible to sanction him, who knows if Osbourne would have been sanctioned that is simpley not acceptable in this day and age. After all MPs are dead keen on on league tables for everybody else.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
And I would add that the majority didn't vote for you, therefore the majority will always have an axe to grind on you. As is being admirably demonstrated during the current crisis. "What did you do in The Great (coronavirus) War, Daddy?" "Well, son, I stayed at home receiving 80% of my pay for doing nothing and I moaned constantly about those who were trying to do something about it, regardless of the fact that if I'd had to deal with it, I probably would have sh!t myself under the pressure of such responsibility." Not the snappiest poster, I grant you! Genuinely interested as to where you think the government's response to this crisis has gone well. Not to mention the lies the government has also started to peddle regarding deaths in care homes. Why can't people question the above? Surely thats forcing accountability.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wilesy01
Genuinely interested as to where you think the government's response to this crisis has gone well. Not to mention the lies the government has also started to peddle regarding deaths in care homes. Why can't people question the above? Surely thats forcing accountability. If you’re looking for positives I’d say 1 death toll is decreasing based on actions taken by the government. 2 nhs capacity has been increased to unprecedented levels ie the nhs has not been overwhelmed 3. People are supported by a never before seen £300bn package. Of course, things could’ve been better managed but so far I’d say the government have got more right than wrong. What do you think?
Vive le Roy! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wilesy01
Genuinely interested as to where you think the government's response to this crisis has gone well. Not to mention the lies the government has also started to peddle regarding deaths in care homes. Why can't people question the above? Surely thats forcing accountability. This is a very easy thing to say. However, the government have been led by a group of experts and they have dealt with it in the way that they thought best. The problem with continual requests for accountability is that it makes the assumption that when things haven't gone well then they must have been done on purpose. Well that clearly isn't the case. Find me an expert on pandemics who knows exactly how to balance the economy and the mental health of the people and the safety of the population then maybe we might have got this bang on right from the start, but I would say that person doesn't exist. The blame culture in this country is getting worse and worse. Stop blaming others unless you have a better alternative yourself. (I don't mean this personally by the way).
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wilesy01
Genuinely interested as to where you think the government's response to this crisis has gone well. Not to mention the lies the government has also started to peddle regarding deaths in care homes. Why can't people question the above? Surely thats forcing accountability. What lies about care homes. Starmer quoted half of a letter without including the earlier date of the advice. Is this what you are referring to?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.