You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Cuts
November 21 2026 9.31pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cuts


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
cryrst Flag The garden of England 26 Oct 22 7.09am

So basically instead of tax cuts and investment it is now going to be tax rises and cuts on state spending. All the people wanting the former are now not getting it and the ones wanting the latter will get what they fought so hard for . Happy?

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 26 Oct 22 7.48am

Originally posted by cryrst

So basically instead of tax cuts and investment it is now going to be tax rises and cuts on state spending. All the people wanting the former are now not getting it and the ones wanting the latter will get what they fought so hard for . Happy?

There were always going to be massive cuts in public spending ... In Liz we Truss and Crazy Karteng just made the situation worse because they upped the cost of public borrowing. If you borrow you have to pay it back and if the cost of borrowing goes up obviously it takes longer to repay. The primary way to raise Exchequer money to pay back national debt is to do it through taxation (hence the temporary NI increase). Add to everything else, pandemic debt, international interest rate rises and uncontrollable price increases because of Putin then your timing for unfunded tax cuts has to be considered. It wasn't and our inexperienced politicians and prospects for the UK economy were pounced on by the wolves. Boris was a lying, self interested Oaf and Liz Truss was useless. Step up Rishi. Whoever runs the country has huge problems to resolve and the public will have to bear some pain. The vulnerable should not have to bear it disproportionately but the government needs to act quickly.

The Exchequer could save a huge amount of money by ignoring the triple lock on pensions. Maybe by halving the state pension increase next year but that would have profound implications for those who rely upon their pension as their sole source of income at a time when the price of basic essentials is going through the roof. Good luck Rishi.

Edited by Henry of Peckham (26 Oct 2022 8.24am)

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Oct 22 8.03am

Originally posted by cryrst

So basically instead of tax cuts and investment it is now going to be tax rises and cuts on state spending. All the people wanting the former are now not getting it and the ones wanting the latter will get what they fought so hard for . Happy?

No they wont be because the people who complained about the Tories giving the pubic free money will now complain that the Tories aren't giving people free money, err.

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 26 Oct 22 8.24am

Originally posted by cryrst

So basically instead of tax cuts and investment it is now going to be tax rises and cuts on state spending. All the people wanting the former are now not getting it and the ones wanting the latter will get what they fought so hard for . Happy?

No. Basically instead of unfunded ideology we have been forced to recognise economic reality.

Everyone would like "tax cuts and investment" but you cannot pull them out of thin air. Magic money trees don't exist to plug the gaps left when taxes are cut and investments neither happen overnight, nor are made very quickly when the world is facing recession and we also are already struggling with labour shortages caused, at least in part, by Brexit.

Truss's plans were beyond stupid. They were dangerously irresponsible and have made a bad situation worse. They produced a run on the £, market instability, higher interest rates and inflationary pressures. Any benefit from tax cuts would have been more than wiped out by increased costs.

Why on earth would anyone be happy about that? Having to rescue the country from stupidity is shameful, but necessary.

No-one will enjoy what the next few months, and years, will bring but there's just no alternative. We can argue about the detail but the bottom line is that everyone will face higher taxation and reduced services. My own view is that as many of our services are already stretched to capacity the opportunity to cut them is quite limited. So I expect the emphasis to be on taxation.

I expect a windfall tax on the energy companies. Rather than a cut in income tax I anticipate it increasing and the levels at which the higher bands kick in decreasing. VAT may well increase too. This may all be done in stages to avoid too big a shock to the economy at any one time.

Who-ever was in power would have faced huge problems but having blustering Johnson, and then ideological Truss, as Tory PMs has made things worse and, worse of all, lost the Tory party their reputation for integrity and financial competence, and probably delivered us into the hands of a disjointed, ill prepared and uninspiring opposition.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 26 Oct 22 8.41am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

No. Basically instead of unfunded ideology we have been forced to recognise economic reality.

Everyone would like "tax cuts and investment" but you cannot pull them out of thin air. Magic money trees don't exist to plug the gaps left when taxes are cut and investments neither happen overnight, nor are made very quickly when the world is facing recession and we also are already struggling with labour shortages caused, at least in part, by Brexit.

Truss's plans were beyond stupid. They were dangerously irresponsible and have made a bad situation worse. They produced a run on the £, market instability, higher interest rates and inflationary pressures. Any benefit from tax cuts would have been more than wiped out by increased costs.

Why on earth would anyone be happy about that? Having to rescue the country from stupidity is shameful, but necessary.

No-one will enjoy what the next few months, and years, will bring but there's just no alternative. We can argue about the detail but the bottom line is that everyone will face higher taxation and reduced services. My own view is that as many of our services are already stretched to capacity the opportunity to cut them is quite limited. So I expect the emphasis to be on taxation.

I expect a windfall tax on the energy companies. Rather than a cut in income tax I anticipate it increasing and the levels at which the higher bands kick in decreasing. VAT may well increase too. This may all be done in stages to avoid too big a shock to the economy at any one time.

Who-ever was in power would have faced huge problems but having blustering Johnson, and then ideological Truss, as Tory PMs has made things worse and, worse of all, lost the Tory party their reputation for integrity and financial competence, and probably delivered us into the hands of a disjointed, ill prepared and uninspiring opposition.

Almost precisely my interpretation of it.

Like most people I would rather have a realistic grip on the challenges I and the country will face as opposed to either being lied to, misled or presented with an illusion that everything is OK. I'd also like to hold out for hope in the future based on something more tangible and believable.

I'd also strongly prefer somebody in power who articulates some semblance and understanding of reality than an inanely grinning moron. It may not be pretty for the foreseeable future but with COVID, Russia/Ukraine and other things what do people expect? There is no miracle strategy to immediately fix everything but at least now there's looking like there might be a reasonable plan to start with.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

cryrst Flag The garden of England 26 Oct 22 8.52am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

No. Basically instead of unfunded ideology we have been forced to recognise economic reality.

Everyone would like "tax cuts and investment" but you cannot pull them out of thin air. Magic money trees don't exist to plug the gaps left when taxes are cut and investments neither happen overnight, nor are made very quickly when the world is facing recession and we also are already struggling with labour shortages caused, at least in part, by Brexit.

Truss's plans were beyond stupid. They were dangerously irresponsible and have made a bad situation worse. They produced a run on the £, market instability, higher interest rates and inflationary pressures. Any benefit from tax cuts would have been more than wiped out by increased costs.

Why on earth would anyone be happy about that? Having to rescue the country from stupidity is shameful, but necessary.

No-one will enjoy what the next few months, and years, will bring but there's just no alternative. We can argue about the detail but the bottom line is that everyone will face higher taxation and reduced services. My own view is that as many of our services are already stretched to capacity the opportunity to cut them is quite limited. So I expect the emphasis to be on taxation.

I expect a windfall tax on the energy companies. Rather than a cut in income tax I anticipate it increasing and the levels at which the higher bands kick in decreasing. VAT may well increase too. This may all be done in stages to avoid too big a shock to the economy at any one time.

Who-ever was in power would have faced huge problems but having blustering Johnson, and then ideological Truss, as Tory PMs has made things worse and, worse of all, lost the Tory party their reputation for integrity and financial competence, and probably delivered us into the hands of a disjointed, ill prepared and uninspiring opposition.

Economic reality is where we are and I agree.
As badger posted some will now not see the need for cuts, but couldn’t wait to stop the tax breaks wrongly introduced by the former pm.
Efficiency in the state sector is going to be needed. Less management and more foot soldiers. Waste is huge in health and education. My mrs works in a school and I have seen skip loads of books and paper just in a school of 400 odd kids. Imagine the waste in the huge comps in the big cities. The same with the nhs. Root and branch checks and change is needed.

 

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 26 Oct 22 9.55am

Originally posted by Badger11

No they wont be because the people who complained about the Tories giving the pubic free money will now complain that the Tories aren't giving people free money, err.

I think I missed that particular policy.

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 26 Oct 22 10.15am

I have heard " efficiencies and waste cutting for decades, no Govt ever seems to grasp the nettle.


 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 26 Oct 22 11.43am

What do they imagine there is left to cut?

After 12 years of tory austerity and chaos our public services are in dire straits and we have poverty and hungry kids.

An election would only be a start to a long journey back imo.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Oct 22 12.53pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

What do they imagine there is left to cut?

After 12 years of tory austerity and chaos our public services are in dire straits and we have poverty and hungry kids.

An election would only be a start to a long journey back imo.

I think they should give no police force a go. We’re almost there anyway. No need for BLM defunding the police. We’ll do it so we can all have another takeaway.

 


COYP

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Oct 22 1.55pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

I have heard " efficiencies and waste cutting for decades, no Govt ever seems to grasp the nettle.


It's because they are scared to make real cuts. They could have cancelled Trident / HS2 / Foreign aid. They could slash some of the departments by just abolishing stuff instead all they do is tinker around the edges.

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Oct 22 2.18pm

Originally posted by mezzer

I think I missed that particular policy.

It's literally the welfare state....even with public pensions on average if you live longer than seven years all those contributions are used up.

Just recently Sunak forwarded government checks to people for energy bills.

A lot of people were paid to sit at home on lockdowns....all that was borrowed money from the treasury....400 billion was spent over that period, more than we spent fighting WW2, and we didn't recover from that until the sixties.....most people just nodded along and weren't told the extent of impact to the already massively damaged system.....a system that was done for in 2008 but had been racking up massive debt since the nineties.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Oct 2022 2.22pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

blackheatheagle Flag Beckenham 26 Oct 22 4.42pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I expect a windfall tax on the energy companies. Rather than a cut in income tax I anticipate it increasing and the levels at which the higher bands kick in decreasing. VAT may well increase too. This may all be done in stages to avoid too big a shock to the economy at any one time.


+ windfall tax on banks as well. I guess they are already prepared for this & Santander just announced Q3 profit details which is boosted by increasing rates.

 

blackheatheagle Flag Beckenham 26 Oct 22 4.46pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Efficiency in the state sector is going to be needed. Less management and more foot soldiers. Waste is huge in health and education. My mrs works in a school and I have seen skip loads of books and paper just in a school of 400 odd kids. Imagine the waste in the huge comps in the big cities. The same with the nhs. Root and branch checks and change is needed.

Really upsetting that this is not a prioritized topic. Funding / cutting definitions are not helping. Re-engineering processes & putting them in a plan is less costy and smart thing to do. This may end up with job-cuts for sure but if this was a concern, we would still be managing daily banking activities in branches.

Edited by blackheatheagle (26 Oct 2022 4.47pm)

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 26 Oct 22 4.52pm

Here is a vid of Basingstoke, its a real eye-opener as to the state of the UK:-

[Link]

I recall going there for computer courses in the 1980s it was quite a busy place it is quite shocking to see it now.


 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 26 Oct 22 5.39pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

I have heard " efficiencies and waste cutting for decades, no Govt ever seems to grasp the nettle.

It's the fall back for every government we elect. I was in the Civil Service for 36 years and saw the same old policies recycled 4 times. I remember saying "Do you want us to do it exactly like last time or maybe like the time before?" Same old crap just different faces!

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

cryrst Flag The garden of England 26 Oct 22 7.44pm

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

It's the fall back for every government we elect. I was in the Civil Service for 36 years and saw the same old policies recycled 4 times. I remember saying "Do you want us to do it exactly like last time or maybe like the time before?" Same old crap just different faces!

I haven’t your experience but the problem is that the opposition jump straight on the defence; particularly labour when the state is bought into the save money conversation. I mean atm the nurses and other health worker’s, teachers and associated want a 10% rise. How is that even feasible when the uk is skint. Private sector don’t get the pension perks for a start. I would bet you have a lovely pension due to your former years. No problem; you earned it but it’s forgotten in negotiations for pay rises.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 26 Oct 22 9.47pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Economic reality is where we are and I agree.
As badger posted some will now not see the need for cuts, but couldn’t wait to stop the tax breaks wrongly introduced by the former pm.
Efficiency in the state sector is going to be needed. Less management and more foot soldiers. Waste is huge in health and education. My mrs works in a school and I have seen skip loads of books and paper just in a school of 400 odd kids. Imagine the waste in the huge comps in the big cities. The same with the nhs. Root and branch checks and change is needed.

I am not sure how much efficiency can be gained from this, and it's going off thread, but this annoys me too, but for a different reason.

My understanding is that schools regularly have to change books not only when the curriculum changes, but when social standards change. Which these days is quite frequently. I have spoken to caretakers who just don't know what to do with the redundant books, often in near perfect condition, which end up being incinerated. What an expensive waste.

I spent some years spending the winters in S E Asia, where many schools were very short of resources, often having a few tattered books to share among a class of 50, with little paper or pens etc.

I collected quite a few boxes full of those unwanted books and sent them out there. Only a token of course, but the joy on lots of little faces when they were distributed was wonderful.

I've often wondered if something like that ought to be more widely organised.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 26 Oct 22 10.11pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I am not sure how much efficiency can be gained from this, and it's going off thread, but this annoys me too, but for a different reason.

My understanding is that schools regularly have to change books not only when the curriculum changes, but when social standards change. Which these days is quite frequently. I have spoken to caretakers who just don't know what to do with the redundant books, often in near perfect condition, which end up being incinerated. What an expensive waste.

I spent some years spending the winters in S E Asia, where many schools were very short of resources, often having a few tattered books to share among a class of 50, with little paper or pens etc.

I collected quite a few boxes full of those unwanted books and sent them out there. Only a token of course, but the joy on lots of little faces when they were distributed was wonderful.

I've often wondered if something like that ought to be more widely organised.

Of course it should but it’s the very small tip of very large and wasteful iceberg of state spending.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 27 Oct 22 8.20am

Originally posted by cryrst

I haven’t your experience but the problem is that the opposition jump straight on the defence; particularly labour when the state is bought into the save money conversation. I mean atm the nurses and other health worker’s, teachers and associated want a 10% rise. How is that even feasible when the uk is skint. Private sector don’t get the pension perks for a start. I would bet you have a lovely pension due to your former years. No problem; you earned it but it’s forgotten in negotiations for pay rises.

I wish ... cuts meant wage freezes for civil servants. Not just one year but usually for the term of that government. Add to that working for a department that deliberately paid lower salaries as a lead for other govt entities. Oh and they contract you out so that when your state pension arrives its 3/4 of everyone else's. It's a relatively unrewarding financial experience being a public servant in any capacity.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Cuts