You are here: Home > News > Penalty pain as 10-man Palace crash out
October 6 2026 2.23pm

Penalty pain as 10-man Palace crash out

January 24 2012

Jermaine Easter

Jermaine Easter

Ten-man Crystal Palace crashed out of the Carling Cup semi-final after a penalty shoot-out defeat to Cardiff.

The Welsh club went ahead after just seven minutes to level the second leg tie at 1-1 when Anthony Gardner headed Don Cowie's cross into his own net.

Palace then had a strong claim for a penalty turned down by referee Howard Webb after Chris Martin had his shirt tugged in the penalty area.

Cardiff dominated for most of the game but could not find a way past some excellent Palace defending even when captain Patrick McCarthy was sent off for a second yellow card on 78 minutes.

The hosts hit the woodwork three times through Kenny Miller in the 90 minutes, then Filip Kiss and Aron Gunnarsson in extra-time.

Palace survived the Cardiff onslaught for a penalty shoot-out but were woeful with their spot-kicks.

Miller missed the first for Cardiff, but Bluebirds keeper Tom Heaton was the penalty shoot-out hero saving from Cardiff-born Jermaine Easter and Sean Scannell before Jonathan Parr skied his effort off target as the Bluebirds reached the final.

Only Burnley (5) have made it to more League Cup semi-finals than Crystal Palace (4) but never made the final.

Today's results and scorers

2011/12 match reports

2011/12 squad stats

Championship table

How did you get on in the Prediction League?

Did you take any photos of the game? Upload them here

Rate the players' performance here

Latest Headlines

Palace Talk Forum Latest

Main Stand redevelopment thread
at 2.19pm by Davepalace707

Man City & The FA Cup
at 1.36pm by chris123

Crystal Palace welcome Bristol City for a friendly
at 1.07pm by Spindle

After 4 months of designing and on the waiting list, have finally immortalised our night in Leipzig.
at 1.03pm by Forest Hillbilly

Ismaïla Sarr
at 11.09am by palace99

WSL
at 8.29pm by steeleye20

JSL
at 6.20pm by MrRobbo

The Academy
at 12.59pm by Isley46

Jake o brien
at 12.40pm by Attilio1905

Our most critical season ?
at 6.46pm by Badger11

You are here: Home > News > Penalty pain as 10-man Palace crash out