This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 07 Sep 2015 11.05am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Sep 2015 9.50am
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 06 Sep 2015 10.30pm
Quote legaleagle at 06 Sep 2015 10.23pm
Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Sep 2015 9.19pm
It is of course nonsense to say that Thatcher won the 1983 General Election primarily because of the Falklands victory. People don't vote for a government to reward the leader of a recent war, witness Churchill after World War II. They voted Tory because they did not want a Michael Foot led Labour government. It would have been like voting for a softly spoken Arthur Scargill. The electorate will take the same view of another softly spoken Scargill - Jeremy Corbyn - if he leads the Labour party.
Was Foot (and the highly effective and successful demonisation of him in the media) something to do with it? Yes.Was the formation of the SDP something to do with it? Yes.Was the Saatchi Bros' dominance of how to run a successful campaign something to do with it? Yes. But all somewhat lesser factors than the Falklands.If the Falklands had "gone wrong",she'd have likely been out the door. People reward successful war leaders in elections generally.Churchill was the exception not the rule,and that because of people's memories of the 30's and the high profile role of some Labour members of the wartime coalition government.Not to mention Churchill's inane suggestion during the election campaign that electing Labour would be akin to having the Gestapo. This is all very subjective. I would say that Labour would have lost the election anyway. Foot, much like Kinnock and Milliband was too easy to mock and far too weak in personality to become PM. The trend was against them in any case. I think its a certainty that if we'd lost the Falklands conflict, then the Conservative's would have lost the election, and that the victory gave them a boost. I don't think you can compare it to Churchill after the war, because Churchill wasn't in power before the war either (and was very much a 'War Prime Minister' not a peacetime candidate). Thatcher for me, did right by the people of the Falklands, and ironically accidently ended a Far Right Wing Junta in South America, and set in motion a series of events that ultimately led to a greater freedom of the left in South American politics.
It certainly boosted them in the run into the election, but I don't think in any way the UK government were somehow complicit in creating the conflict. As I said earlier, they were right to do what they did in response to the threat to British citizens on the island (it would have been different maybe if the Islanders were overwhelmingly keen on being Argentine citizens).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote matt_himself at 07 Sep 2015 11.26am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Sep 2015 9.46am
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 06 Sep 2015 9.17pm
Quote Kermit8 at 06 Sep 2015 8.28pm
There was no big anti-Falklands War sentiment in 1982 from any significant political group or leaning. It was generally felt to be a just war at the time. It was the sinking of the Belgrano that cast a shadow.
Doesn't stop it being a 'war crime' though. Remains a contestable issue, probably in the best interests of the UK forces, but questionable whether it was within the rules of the conflict (remember it wasn't a declaration of war, so anything outside the exclusion zone was an unlawful engagement - I think it was the right decision militarily, but it may well have been a war crime objectively speaking). Incorrect. In the communique issued to the Argentine government about the exclusion zone by the government, it was clearly stated that Britain reserved the right to attack shipping deemed as a threat which was outside of the exclusion zone. The Argentines were planning a 'massive' naval attack the day after the Belgrano sunk which would have included participation by the Belgrano. Action was perfectly acceptable therefore and it is because of lefties trying to make a name for themselves (Tam Dayell) with their politically motivated attacks that the issue of whether the attack was 'legitimate' came about. I think they key point was 'objectively'. I think it was the right decision but you can't really establish a legality of an issue, based on 'reservations' made by one side. Its for an independent arbitrator to decide and rule on. If something is legal, it isn't because one side of says they have the right, but because an independent body says they had the right. Almost every war criminal tends to think they were right, just or just following orders. It isn't for me or you to decide, but case based on the evidence presented to the International Court.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 07 Sep 2015 11.11am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Sep 2015 9.46am
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 06 Sep 2015 9.17pm
Quote Kermit8 at 06 Sep 2015 8.28pm
There was no big anti-Falklands War sentiment in 1982 from any significant political group or leaning. It was generally felt to be a just war at the time. It was the sinking of the Belgrano that cast a shadow.
Doesn't stop it being a 'war crime' though. Remains a contestable issue, probably in the best interests of the UK forces, but questionable whether it was within the rules of the conflict (remember it wasn't a declaration of war, so anything outside the exclusion zone was an unlawful engagement - I think it was the right decision militarily, but it may well have been a war crime objectively speaking).
Or tail it into the exclusion zone and sink it.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 07 Sep 2015 11.54am
The shame of it was that the stupid actions of the Argentinian government forced British soldiers to take Argentinian lives and vice versa. The two peoples are not natural enemies and it was an avoidable tragedy for everyone. This. Despite the frenzy of the tabloids, the faces of those Argentine POW who were barely old enough to shave conscripts pressed into the service of a cruel and murderous regime, said more than anything what a tragic waste of life the Falklands were and how it really was about the ego and greed of a regime unwilling to let go of its power. The UK had no choice but to respond with military action. The Junta would never have backed down.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.