You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we better without cabaye?
November 16 2026 11.44am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we better without cabaye?


Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6
davehuggins Flag 25 Sep 16 10.49am

Class black eagle you knows your stuff

 

peterg Flag Anerley 25 Sep 16 10.54am

Cabaye is the best passer in the team and he never wastes the ball. However he is not the fastest or strongest either. His yellow yesterday came when he was being out-run and made a desperate late tackle. I would pick him for most matches but we should be aware of his weaknesses.

 


The right place at the right time

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 25 Sep 16 10.56am

Originally posted by davehuggins

Class black eagle you knows your stuff

Thanks Dave, I'm no expert but know a fully fit Cabaye offers alot more to the team defensively and offensively.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 25 Sep 16 11.13am

Well they say class is permanent and form is temporary.

But I don't think we have been seeing the best of Cabaye for some time now.

Certainly Punch contributes more when Cabaye isn't there.

It's a good question, and I would say we are better off with a fully fit and on form Cabaye, but we now have enough quality in midfield to get along without him.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 25 Sep 16 11.29am

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

Is this post supposed to encourage our Cabaye?
1. He is proven quality
2. He is not at his peak
3. When at/near his peak he'll compliment our new style

We are far from better without him. Puncheon still needs maturing and must be benefitting from Cabaye's influence.


I think 80k a week should be enough encouragement for the lad, anyway I doubt he reads this board and if he does I doubt he loses too much sleep over fans opinions.

1. Yes he is proven quality , but has he actually proved it at Palace?
2. Why is he not at his peak ? I know many people have made the excuse that he has been injured since Christmas , but what has actually is wrong with him? Why has he played nearly every week?, Why did the club let him go to the Euro's to sit on the French bench when unfit. Should he not have been rested and been fully fit at start of season? Did he start this season injured?
3. When do you think it might be reasonable to expect to see him at his peak?

As for the maturing of Puncheon , I hope Punch does not follow his example of yesterday of picking up a needless booking after petulantly lashing out in frustration after his shot was blocked.

If he ever does get back to his best of a couple of years back he will be a great asset and Palace will be a much better team , really hope he does , but it can be frustrating to watch and wait.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 25 Sep 16 11.55am

Wasn't Blown away with Ledley yesterday, I thought he had it away too much in our own half even at 2-1 down a couple of times he nearly lost it on the edge of our box. Cabals will be back fully fit soon and I expect the change to be Ledley dropping in to a sub role.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 25 Sep 16 12.19pm

Yesterday didn't really work with both Ledley & Cabaye

Cabaye's ability as a player cannot be in question. How he fits into the puzzle of a team is.

Currently I think we are able to be more offensive with Ledley

He moves across the midfield covering whilst allowing other players to move forward. He even covers the FBs at times.

Cabaye is often harshly judged because of his shocking set pieces last season.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 25 Sep 16 12.20pm

He got the bird from Sunderland fans yesterday why is that because he played for Newcastle or because they feared him (or both)?

 

DivingIsNotGood Flag se25 25 Sep 16 12.37pm

Pound for pound actul true stats like completed passes show Punch is better [Link]

 


VOTING OUT - Brexit will allow Britain to embrace the Commonwealth and be GREAT again

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 25 Sep 16 1.32pm

But how many does he [Puncheon] give away?...

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 25 Sep 16 1.34pm

no. cabaye & jimmy mac are the 2 best holding we have.

i like ledders but hes nowhere near cabaye

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Painter Flag Croydon 25 Sep 16 3.12pm

Originally posted by CPFC/SCCC

Cabaye was a major signing but I feel, we are much better without him in the line up.

Just as well you don't pick the team, as you seem to have no knowledge of football.

 

DivingIsNotGood Flag se25 25 Sep 16 3.23pm

Originally posted by Painter

Just as well you don't pick the team, as you seem to have no knowledge of football.

much more than @PaulPaulryoung

 


VOTING OUT - Brexit will allow Britain to embrace the Commonwealth and be GREAT again

sea-eagle Flag Peacehaven 25 Sep 16 3.29pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

He got the bird from Sunderland fans yesterday why is that because he played for Newcastle or because they feared him (or both)?

Newky links for sure. They would put our rivalry with Brighton to shame historically, the two cities(?) have been at each other's throat for centuries I would guess.

 

DivingIsNotGood Flag se25 26 Sep 16 1.56pm

Originally posted by DivingIsNotGood

Pound for pound actul true stats like completed passes show Punch is better [Link]

Looks like I was right, yet again... [Link]

 


VOTING OUT - Brexit will allow Britain to embrace the Commonwealth and be GREAT again

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 26 Sep 16 2.25pm

Originally posted by DivingIsNotGood

Looks like I was right, yet again... [Link]

Does this show Cabayes stats then?

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 26 Sep 16 2.45pm

First of all what a lovely problem to have for a change.

How I see it, Ledley is playing at somewhere near his best, as is Punch. Cabaye is not. He is under performing so at present it stands to reason he should be dropped he was for the Stoke game and we battered them.

He comes back in against Sunderland and we go two down. He is undoubtedly a class player, but not operating currently anywhere near the best of his ability. I also think I read in today's rags that punch is top in the prem for assists above the 100 million Pogba even !

What we have is a lovely dilemma, about how to fit the talent we have into the system we want to play. If I was AP I'd be on the phone to Wenger for a few tips, love or loathe the man you can't argue with his record of turning unknowns into household names, and finding the right players for the fit of his style of play.

Back to Cabaye:

He is of an age now (30, 31 in Jan 17) where he should be at his peak not struggling for form. If I was AP I would be thinking about offloading in the window and seek a young fresher replacement, obviously if one is available. My personal opinion is that what he offers at the minute can be easily replaced, so unless he starts running games between now and Christmas I think we should vent him, and get in a new face.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Sportyteacher Flag London 26 Sep 16 3.01pm

Neither Cabaye or Pardew need this thread to realise that the former is under-performing and yet he clearly has the innate ability, plus coaching output, to pick up his game. Not helped by past injuries.

 

Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we better without cabaye?