You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Max Meyer thread


Page 1 of 27 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Mstrobez Flag 01 Nov 18 4.45am

Only just saw the game and I gotta feel sorry for Meyer. It’s inevitable fans will start turning on him.

He can’t get a game, and when he does, he’s being played out of position. He’s a creative midfielder. Not a defensive one.

To me this just stinks of utter incompetence from our scouting department, who seem to be unable to differentiate between “deep” and “defensive”.

He played one season for Schalke “deep” in a Jorginho type role, and they seemed to of translated that to someone who could replace Cabaye.

The guy is not a defensive midfielder, he’s a creative one. I’ve said it since the start, were not gonna get the best out of him playing him in Cabayes role, it’s really as simple as that.

So frustrating to watch Schlupp and Mccarthur as our furthest forward midfielders when Meyer is on the pitch. He’s being completely wasted.

I guess it’s all rather academic, considering he can’t get a game in the league anyway. But, still, it would be utterly criminal for us to waste what is arguably the most technically gifted player we’ve ever had at the club in this way.

Why can’t Roy see this?

Edited by Mstrobez (01 Nov 2018 4.47am)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Elpis Flag In a pub 01 Nov 18 6.06am

I don't know.

Its worrying that a player of Meyers quality is looking pretty average in our team .

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 01 Nov 18 6.40am

We do seem quite good at ruining players at the moment. Benteke can’t hit a barn door, Jairo and now Meyer.
Maybe it’s the rigidity of our system. We are a team that’s whole existence based around merely existing in the premier league and that means we have to play in a certain way.
We are lucky we have Wilf really, without him we would be a pretty dull watch but he is probably the one luxury player a team like us can afford.

Edited by lefty27 (01 Nov 2018 6.41am)

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 01 Nov 18 7.20am

Wasn't defensive midfield where he made his name?

Edit. This from Sky Sports:

Sky Germany reporter Max Bielefeld recently spoke to the Transfer Talk podcast about Meyer, saying: "Without doubt, Max Meyer is a really talented guy but he had one good season with Schalke.

"He owes a lot to the new manager Tedesco because what he did was make Meyer play as a defensive midfielder in a No 6 or No 8 position when previously, he was always considered a No 10. That was last season when he played really well."

I'm not saying you're wrong mind, but there's an impression out there that he was a great DM at Schalke. Maybe there's a nuance between 'defensive' and 'deep' that people have missed though, like you say.


Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (01 Nov 2018 7.29am)

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Mstrobez Flag 01 Nov 18 7.32am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Wasn't defensive midfield where he made his name?

Edit. This from Sky Sports:

Sky Germany reporter Max Bielefeld recently spoke to the Transfer Talk podcast about Meyer, saying: "Without doubt, Max Meyer is a really talented guy but he had one good season with Schalke.

"He owes a lot to the new manager Tedesco because what he did was make Meyer play as a defensive midfielder in a No 6 or No 8 position when previously, he was always considered a No 10. That was last season when he played really well."

I'm not saying you're wrong mind, but there's an impression out there that he was a great DM at Schalke. Maybe there's a nuance between 'defensive' and 'deep that people have missed though, like you say.

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (01 Nov 2018 7.28am)

Made his name as a number 10. Thats where he played when people were making a big fuss. Also where he played for Germany at the olympics and u21 Euro’s.

He played in a 3 for Schalke last season. Mainly with Goretzka and Bentaleb or Geis. Those 2 were box to box and would be in charge of the more physical duties. Meyers role was as a playmaker, just from a deeper position. The simplistic analysis of journalists etc. Is to say that means he was a defensive midfielder, but he just wasn’t. It’s was a particular type of system that just meant he took up a certain position.

Even without these facts. It’s pretty clear to see he isn’t a defensive midfielder & he’s not a like for like replacement for Cabaye at all. Cabaye wasn’t even really a defensive midfielder to begin with, but he had the attributes to be converted into one.

2 entirely different players. Everytime Meyer is in the final 3rd he looks a threat. The “deep” role doesn’t work in our system of play unless you’re also a tenacious and defensive ball winning midfielder.


Edited by Mstrobez (01 Nov 2018 7.41am)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Mstrobez Flag 01 Nov 18 7.34am

Originally posted by lefty27

We do seem quite good at ruining players at the moment. Benteke can’t hit a barn door, Jairo and now Meyer.
Maybe it’s the rigidity of our system. We are a team that’s whole existence based around merely existing in the premier league and that means we have to play in a certain way.
We are lucky we have Wilf really, without him we would be a pretty dull watch but he is probably the one luxury player a team like us can afford.

Edited by lefty27 (01 Nov 2018 6.41am)

It’s true. I agree completely.

The problem is, that plan has a sell by date. And once the sell by dates passed, we get relegated and all of a sudden our survival players that we spend big bucks on leave & our style of play has already been surpassed by half of the teams in the championship.

Been saying this for years.

If we’re gonna stick to the system we use. Meyer should be taking the role Schlupp had last night and the role we see Mccarthur in during league games.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

aashman12 Flag 01 Nov 18 7.41am

Can see this all ending soon in a very palace like manor.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Nov 18 7.54am

Have Luka and/or kouyate in front of the defence, or kouyate to the right, Meyer can pick the ball up deep, midfield or higher up and be that central creative spark I can’t remember the last time we had.

If anyone can’t see that after his sub appearance v Arsenal they need to be asked and ask themselves some serious questions.

We also have lower expectations than Schalke, and less immediate on Meyer to deliver his highest, which should be factored in too.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Nov 18 7.57am

If it becomes obvious Roy is too stubborn to use this dangerous player and we continue to fail then I’m afraid I’ll want Roy gone asap. The match day frustrations with Roy I accepted when he was producing excellent, consistent results, but if he’s not and it’s obvious why and he won’t change... I didn’t go ballistic at all this season btw.

 


COYP

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 01 Nov 18 8.15am

Originally posted by Elpis

I don't know.

Its worrying that a player of Meyers quality is looking pretty average in our team .

Agreed. Our team are a bunch of square pegs being shoved into round holes

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 01 Nov 18 8.30am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

If it becomes obvious Roy is too stubborn to use this dangerous player and we continue to fail then I’m afraid I’ll want Roy gone asap. The match day frustrations with Roy I accepted when he was producing excellent, consistent results, but if he’s not and it’s obvious why and he won’t change... I didn’t go ballistic at all this season btw.

I like Roy, I think he's about right for us at the moment. However, buying players like Guaita and Meyer and then taking 10 years to get them into the team is embarrassing. Wayne is doing ok but we need better than ok and I thought that was why we signed a top European goalkeeper. I can see this turning into a Steve M type situation.

As for Meyer, he's obviously got quality, I love how he changes things when he comes on. I just don't understand why he is not starting in the Prem.

It's the same with Jairo. We try and ship him out to Swansea and for Ayew!!!!!! So glad he said no but he must be feeling like he made a big mistake coming here.

I know Roy doesn't like to change a winning team but he doesn't seem to want to change a losing one either.

That said I have to believe that Roy sees stuff in training that we don't but the fact that AWB would not be in the team now if it were not for the fact that we were just so short at the time that we just needed a body in that position.

It does not fill me with confidence that we can have such a talented player in our academy and he would have probably have been moved on save for Ward being crock.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

PatrickA Flag London 01 Nov 18 8.38am

You can see that Meyer is a good player, neat on the ball, tidy in possession and always available for the ball.
However, I struggle to see how he fits into the way Roy sets out his teams and think he will have a limited role as an impact sub.
I think the scouting department got him in because he was ‘free’ and had a good pedigree with Schalke and Germany.
Clearly he is a different type of player to Cabaye or RLC and Roy doesn’t seem to know what to do with him.
Personally I would like to see him with two defensive midfielders behind him with Meyer as an advanced midfield player trying to release the forwards.
He already seems to be on the same wavelength as Wilf.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 01 Nov 18 8.43am

Or just perhaps Meyer isn’t as good as we all thought he would be? From what I’ve seen so far he isn’t worth 90 minutes in the prem? Hope I’m wrong, but so far I’m not impressed :-(

 

Stirlingsays Flag 01 Nov 18 8.54am

I think Meyer is currently receiving a bit too much criticism from fans who had kind of believed the hype and had him down as some kind of saviour.

What he does well is pass the ball and retain possession in midfield.....he is a 'Ray Wilkins' type of player....who as some of us will remember used to be referred to as the 'crab' because he always passed sideways.

I watched Meyer out there last night and while he didn't have a good game he was most certainly one of our better players with obvious ability......However, this isn't to put gloss on a woeful Palace performance in general.....the lack of pace and artfulness was painful and a little scary.

We have not bought well in the last two seasons.

That said, Meyer has ability and while he isn't the answer (that's Zaha) he most definitely is a player who should be fighting it out with McArthur for a starting place. I get the impression that he's being required to be more attacking, which he is less comfortable with....though for his game I think it's sensible developmentally.....whether it's the best for us in the short term....we will see.

I can see why McArthur is preferred in that sense. I see Puncheon competing there as well...as he's probably the most attacking of all three.


Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Nov 2018 9.33am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Bangell Flag Oxford 01 Nov 18 8.56am

I think he'd be great in a team with a possession-based style - a style we don't and can't play. Maybe he'd have impressed in the games against Wolves and Newcastle at home, when they ceded us most of the possession and we struggled to get things going - if only Roy had thought to play him.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 01 Nov 18 9.03am

Originally posted by Bangell

I think he'd be great in a team with a possession-based style - a style we don't and can't play. Maybe he'd have impressed in the games against Wolves and Newcastle at home, when they ceded us most of the possession and we struggled to get things going - if only Roy had thought to play him.

Agreed.

When Pardew was trying to turn us into more of a 'footballing' side he would have loved Meyer.

I think he has ability and improves our passing ability and ball retention....We will see where he goes from there.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Nov 18 9.03am

Originally posted by palace chick

Or just perhaps Meyer isn’t as good as we all thought he would be? From what I’ve seen so far he isn’t worth 90 minutes in the prem? Hope I’m wrong, but so far I’m not impressed :-(

Thus far he has only been given time on the field from the bench, coming on now and then and perhaps this has proved difficult for him trying to make an impact in a struggling team in the PL.Perhaps circumstances will dictate that he is given a run in the side and if so this might prove very beneficial not only to him but the team as well.

 

Mstrobez Flag 01 Nov 18 9.42am

Originally posted by palace chick

Or just perhaps Meyer isn’t as good as we all thought he would be? From what I’ve seen so far he isn’t worth 90 minutes in the prem? Hope I’m wrong, but so far I’m not impressed :-(

He’s a fantastic young player. I’ve seen him at his best.

Read the previous posts, he’s playing out of position.

This is what I mean. It’s only a matter of time before palace fans turn on him and deem as not good enough, because as always Palace can’t adapt to allow a creative player to thrive.

He’s not gonna impress anyone playing as a defensive midfielder in our team. I said that from the minute we was linked and people got the idea that he would be a replacement for Cabaye.

He came on against Watford, played off Wilf and got an assist within minutes. If he’s afforded that role, he could become one of the best players we ever had.

If he’s continued to be viewed as a like for like replacement for Cabaye just because our scouting department is incompetent, it’ll be the same old story. “Attitude problem” & “not really that good” will be amongst the collection of greatest hits from the experts.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Mstrobez Flag 01 Nov 18 9.46am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I think Meyer is currently receiving a bit too much criticism from fans who had kind of believed the hype and had him down as some kind of saviour.

What he does well is pass the ball and retain possession in midfield.....he is a 'Ray Wilkins' type of player....who as some of us will remember used to be referred to as the 'crab' because he always passed sideways.

I watched Meyer out there last night and while he didn't have a good game he was most certainly one of our better players with obvious ability......However, this isn't to put gloss on a woeful Palace performance in general.....the lack of pace and artfulness was painful and a little scary.

We have not bought well in the last two seasons.

That said, Meyer has ability and while he isn't the answer (that's Zaha) he most definitely is a player who should be fighting it out with McArthur for a starting place. I get the impression that he's being required to be more attacking, which he is less comfortable with....though for his game I think it's sensible developmentally.....whether it's the best for us in the short term....we will see.

I can see why McArthur is preferred in that sense. I see Puncheon competing there as well...as he's probably the most attacking of all three.


Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Nov 2018 9.33am)

That’s just not true though Sterling. He’s played pretty much all of his career as a number 10 and one season as a “deep lying playmaker”. So this idea that he’s uncomfortable with attacking is false. It’s just he’s taking up the position of one of the 2 holding players when he gets given a run out.

He came on against Watford in the Mccarthur position and surprise surprise he had an assist within about 5 minutes.

It’s not rocket science. He’s not playing enough, and when he is it’s out of position. If you put Ozil or Silva as holding midfielders, even in possession based teams - they’d mostly be ineffective and incompetent in defensive duties.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 01 Nov 18 1.01pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Have Luka and/or kouyate in front of the defence, or kouyate to the right, Meyer can pick the ball up deep, midfield or higher up and be that central creative spark I can’t remember the last time we had.

If anyone can’t see that after his sub appearance v Arsenal they need to be asked and ask themselves some serious questions.

We also have lower expectations than Schalke, and less immediate on Meyer to deliver his highest, which should be factored in too.

Been saying this since the start of the season...he needs two tacklers behind him to win the ball and feed him...why the fcuk Roy cant see this I have no idea!

Edited by Midlands Eagle (02 Nov 2018 6.49am)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Page 1 of 27 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread