You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Showing Gratitude To Roy
November 16 2026 4.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Showing Gratitude To Roy


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 05 Mar 21 12.25pm

Three things.

First, and I know it’s a thorny subject for some of you, but I think Roy has served the club well during his tenure here. Sure, we’ve seen some dour football and, secretly, I confess I’ve even been known to change channels occasionally during our games.
When I stayed with it I’ve shouted at the telly ‘For Gawd’s sake, Roy, change the tactics!’ ‘Let’s have a fresh pair of legs!’ ‘Please make a substitution NOW!’. Like most of us I suspect. But, we’re currently sitting 13th in the table on 34 points and, for our club, in this crazy season, I reckon that ain’t bad.

Secondly, I’m assuming we’ll finish the season with a flourish and comfortably stay up for another, record breaking (for us anyway) term.

Thirdly, and this is the part that’s not clear yet, for the sake of this thread anyhow, most of us seem to think Roy will either retire or be asked to resign and be replaced by a new, as yet unknown, manager.

Now it occurred to me this morning, what would it be like for Roy to depart without the fans being able to say ‘Thank you and Good Luck’ According to the latest Government guidelines fans won’t be allowed back into stadiums until May 19th at the earliest, and then only in limited numbers. Our last home fixture with Arsenal is on the 12th and we’re up at Anfield for our last game on the 23rd.

Poor chap, I thought. One of the best manager’s we’ve had, a schoolboy supporter who has Palace in his veins and he leaves without so much as a shout from the Holmesdale end. Imagine the atmosphere at Selhurst with a full house. There’d be a bloody great banner draped all over the Homesdale, Roy would be led out to the centre circle by Mr Parish who would make a presentation and a short(hopefully) speech and then for Roy to acknowledge the adulation of his adoring fans.Then we’d go on to beat Arsenal 3-0 to round off the season.

But, as things stand, none of that will happen. Then I thought, maybe that’s Mr Parish’s cunning plan. He won’t let Roy go with a whimper, because he’s a decent sort of bloke, and he has said publicly that he thinks every club should have at least one game at home before the season ends. Maybe he wants to keep Roy on for another year.

So, what do we think lads? Should Roy at least be given the opportunity to wave us goodbye and be thanked by the fans for his valuable contribution? Or should he just quietly dissolve into a memory to be remembered only when the new guy makes a complete Horlicks of things and we dive into the Championship?

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 05 Mar 21 12.43pm

If he does leave this summer I agree fully with you it would be a real dis-service to Roy if he does not get the send off he deserves.

I would like to think that next season he could make a half time appearance so could be acknowledged by the fans. Sadly I doubt this would happen as it could be seen to undermine the new manager or at least make it awkward for them.

I really would love to believe that although I acknowledge there are very mixed views regarding Roy's tenure that fans would recognise in general he has done well and always acted in good faith towards the club and give him the applause his dignity deserves.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 05 Mar 21 2.45pm

Best thing would be for Roy to move upstairs so if it goes belly up with the new man he could take over again.

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 05 Mar 21 2.54pm

hes being paid millions, i think thats sufficient.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 05 Mar 21 2.55pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

Best thing would be for Roy to move upstairs so if it goes belly up with the new man he could take over again.

Jonathon Pearce thinks he would move abroad for another managerial role, just saying.

Edited by Badger11 (05 Mar 2021 3.33pm)

 


One more point

TheBigToePunt Flag 05 Mar 21 3.00pm

He'll never move 'Upstairs'.

Firstly there's no vacant role for him, and secondly he is a training ground coach. His choices will be either retire or see if he can get another job.

I was thinking this morning that if we finish safely as usual, and if Roy doesn't stay on, it will indeed be a shame not to see him off. On the other hand, if he were led out to the centre circle in front of a full house, I'm not sure he'd quite get an emotional tear-jerking send off either.

I think he's respected more than loved.

It should be possible to send messages to Roy through the club perhaps, for those of us who wanted to say an appropriate 'Thank You and Good Luck', which I might well do if he does move on.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 05 Mar 21 3.39pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

He'll never move 'Upstairs'.

Firstly there's no vacant role for him, and secondly he is a training ground coach. His choices will be either retire or see if he can get another job.

I was thinking this morning that if we finish safely as usual, and if Roy doesn't stay on, it will indeed be a shame not to see him off. On the other hand, if he were led out to the centre circle in front of a full house, I'm not sure he'd quite get an emotional tear-jerking send off either.

I think he's respected more than loved.

It should be possible to send messages to Roy through the club perhaps, for those of us who wanted to say an appropriate 'Thank You and Good Luck', which I might well do if he does move on.

I'm sure you're right btp, Just seems a shame if he goes without so much as a wave to the crowd.

I suspect you're also on the mark about some fans reaction too. If Selhurst had been heaving for various games this season (and the end of last) he may well have been subjected to a chorus of discontent from the gallery.

Still think he's done us proud. South London an' all that.

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 05 Mar 21 3.56pm

Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall

hes being paid millions, i think thats sufficient.

Agreed.

He doesn't do it for the 'fun' of it. Indeed 'fun' doesn't come into it. Not in the last few games, anyway.

Edited by Elwissthebest (05 Mar 2021 3.58pm)

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 05 Mar 21 3.58pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

I'm sure you're right btp, Just seems a shame if he goes without so much as a wave to the crowd.

I suspect you're also on the mark about some fans reaction too. If Selhurst had been heaving for various games this season (and the end of last) he may well have been subjected to a chorus of discontent from the gallery.

Still think he's done us proud. South London an' all that.

I couldn't agree more. Being born and brought up in West Croydon after the war is not perhaps the most generous or promising start life can offer you, and when you add in that his dream of being a footballer didn't get out of first gear, there really wasn't much handed to him on a plate.

He made the long, hard journey to the top of coaching, learned to speak six languages, worked (with great success often) all around the world, is still working (and doing well) at his age, and though not without fault, generally appears to me to be an articulate, honest and polite gentleman.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Mar 21 4.07pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I couldn't agree more. Being born and brought up in West Croydon after the war is not perhaps the most generous or promising start life can offer you, and when you add in that his dream of being a footballer didn't get out of first gear, there really wasn't much handed to him on a plate.

He made the long, hard journey to the top of coaching, learned to speak six languages, worked (with great success often) all around the world, is still working (and doing well) at his age, and though not without fault, generally appears to me to be an articulate, honest and polite gentleman.

Absolutely, and I will add a gentleman of unimpeachable integrity with decency oozing from every pore.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 05 Mar 21 4.11pm

If it was his decision not to stay on then I think a send off might be appreciated, but if it's the club's decision I get the feeling he's the sort of man who would hate it, seeing it as somewhat condescending. He has also made it clear that he is not one for sentimentality, so maybe in fact he would rather leave quietly with a handshake if he does leave. I would also say that some of his post-match comments have been a bit barbed of late so I'm not sure all is well behind the scenes, although that could also be to do with external pressures from the fans and the media.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 05 Mar 21 4.14pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I couldn't agree more. Being born and brought up in West Croydon after the war is not perhaps the most generous or promising start life can offer you, and when you add in that his dream of being a footballer didn't get out of first gear, there really wasn't much handed to him on a plate.

He made the long, hard journey to the top of coaching, learned to speak six languages, worked (with great success often) all around the world, is still working (and doing well) at his age, and though not without fault, generally appears to me to be an articulate, honest and polite gentleman.

Agreed.

Edited by Putitout (05 Mar 2021 4.16pm)

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 05 Mar 21 4.19pm

If this is true then we will miss him. We have had a whole team plus a sub at times missing from the squad, He has had misfiring strikers, midfielders that can't tackle or pass, defenders that can't run, no big money buys and still he is keeping us in the top flight and occasionally dealing out bloody noses to the big boys.

Even keeping him on as general manager (an old term) for a month so we can say goodbye to one of our own is a must.

Obviously the crowd would be reduced by half a dozen anti Roys but I could handle that.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

beak Flag croydon 05 Mar 21 5.33pm

Originally posted by crystal-purley

If this is true then we will miss him. We have had a whole team plus a sub at times missing from the squad, He has had misfiring strikers, midfielders that can't tackle or pass, defenders that can't run, no big money buys and still he is keeping us in the top flight and occasionally dealing out bloody noses to the big boys.

Even keeping him on as general manager (an old term) for a month so we can say goodbye to one of our own is a must.

Obviously the crowd would be reduced by half a dozen anti Roys but I could handle that.

Isn't it the way, six dimwits, a vocal minority annoying the rest of us.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 05 Mar 21 8.07pm

IMO the thing that's most underrated about his tenure is how he's had us safe with a few games to go (hopefully that continues to be the case this year) and the stability and lack of crisis management that brings.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 05 Mar 21 8.34pm

i know its been ugly at times, but he is doing the job he is paid for and has been asked to do, which is not to play sexy football but to maintain our PL membership. He has succeeded every year.
I think he done a good job, but that not to say I want to see the status quo continue, I don't. I would like a young manager with young players - a couple of the old and wise of course. Cahill, for eg, has taken some stick, but to me the guy is a role model. At his age he puts some of the younger players to shame with fitness and attitude.
We should buy Roy a HOL carriage clock!

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 05 Mar 21 9.05pm

Heres an honest question for you all..
Whilst I most certainly apprecaite retaining our prem. status, at the hands of steady Roy, say he was 10 plus years younger, and he was to stay that ten further years, would you want to see another 10 years of what we've had over the last few years.
What kills me is the cup games, thrown to the wind.
As the thread title states, gratitude to Roy, for sure for staying up again, but the style of footy..

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 05 Mar 21 9.13pm

Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall

Heres an honest question for you all..
Whilst I most certainly apprecaite retaining our prem. status, at the hands of steady Roy, say he was 10 plus years younger, and he was to stay that ten further years, would you want to see another 10 years of what we've had over the last few years.
What kills me is the cup games, thrown to the wind.
As the thread title states, gratitude to Roy, for sure for staying up again, but the style of footy..

Honestly, no. Just seems a pity if fans have no opportunity to show appreciation for what he's done for our club.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 05 Mar 21 9.22pm

Originally posted by beak

Isn't it the way, six dimwits, a vocal minority annoying the rest of us.

Dimwits ?

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 05 Mar 21 9.24pm

Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall

hes being paid millions, i think thats sufficient.

Yup
Wages, payment for doing to the best of your ability what the wage payer requests of you.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Showing Gratitude To Roy