This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 1.57pm
Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 1.41pm
Someone who says i must kill black people,supports apartied,pictured with a racist flag and then kills innocent people is beyond rehabilitation. Dylon Roof is an evil evil person,he deserves whatever punishment comes his way.
He's going to be in jail forever but you can't kill them by any method other than those allowed by law, and you can't bump him up the queue because his crime seems more evil than that of another, already sentenced to death before him. And you'd be wrong. 95% of paroled lifers never commit a serious criminal offence in their lifetime (though I suspect that more due to the time involved than prison service). It does seem weird how difficult it actually proves to legally kill someone in the US. The grounds for appealing a death sentence are massive in law (well they're the same as for any sentence more or less, but with other sentences you've got the prospect of parole, time served and deals to consider and the state has the prospect of 'making it right' after the fact). So it proves a very expensive and consuming process, because essentially you've got appeals on the basis of fairness, predical sentencing, fair trial, proper representation, constitutional law, due process etc stuff that you'd never bother with, where you were tried, poltiical bais etc... Which you'd never really bother with if you weren't facing death.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.06pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 1.44pm
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 12.18pm
The victims of the murderers are certainly not the people they were a decade ago. Scrap all the endless appeals, allow them one and if that fails, go ahead. Society is protected by removing a killer from its midst and saving money avoiding long prison sentences. Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 12.19pm) But society ISN'T protected by the presence of the death sentence. That's exactly the point. If society gained any benefit then violent crime would be lower in countries with the death penalty than those without it. And so far as I know, it isn't. You can argue that it makes everyone feel better to remove killers, but you can't claim it affords any protection to society at large by doing so. As for saving money, there are some costs that simply have to be borne by civilised societies. A functional penal system is one of them. Besides, executing people isn't much cheaper than imprisoning them for life, so far as I am aware. Yes, limiting their right to appeal would reduce that cost but I don't think -- when you're taking away a person's life -- short cuts are something you want to look for. Society is protected in that the murderer is not around to do it again if released - many murderers are released and a significant number kill again. Deterrence is difficult to measure. Perhaps there would be even more murders in the US if some if all States abolished the death penalty. Given that around 95% of UK Murderers never violate their life parole, I suspect those numbers to be actually be insignificant. Certain types of people and offender should NEVER be released. Also, that may even prove more successful in protecting society, as it allows redress from wrongful conviction. The US might be somewhat different, having different degrees of murder, but the number of people committing a first degree murder after being imprisoned, is going to be individual cases out of hundreds of thousands.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.06pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 1.44pm
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 12.18pm
The victims of the murderers are certainly not the people they were a decade ago. Scrap all the endless appeals, allow them one and if that fails, go ahead. Society is protected by removing a killer from its midst and saving money avoiding long prison sentences. Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 12.19pm) But society ISN'T protected by the presence of the death sentence. That's exactly the point. If society gained any benefit then violent crime would be lower in countries with the death penalty than those without it. And so far as I know, it isn't. You can argue that it makes everyone feel better to remove killers, but you can't claim it affords any protection to society at large by doing so. As for saving money, there are some costs that simply have to be borne by civilised societies. A functional penal system is one of them. Besides, executing people isn't much cheaper than imprisoning them for life, so far as I am aware. Yes, limiting their right to appeal would reduce that cost but I don't think -- when you're taking away a person's life -- short cuts are something you want to look for. Society is protected in that the murderer is not around to do it again if released - many murderers are released and a significant number kill again. Deterrence is difficult to measure. Perhaps there would be even more murders in the US if some if all States abolished the death penalty. The same society that is not protected from wrongful conviction and execution by the state?
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 2.03pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 1.50pm
Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 12.54pm
As one poster said on this thread some killers who are released only go on to do it again. if they are put to sleep they won't have the chance to do it again. Your not telling me Roof didn't know there would'nt be a consequence for his actions? Well death row beckons and Roof has only got himself to blame. Does he have sympathy for his victims? Do i have sympathy for him? not in the slightest. only when Roof is wired up to the chair or about to be given a lethal injection will he think maybe what have i done.
Whether Roof has sympathy for his victims is neither here nor there. The bigger point is that the families of his victims have sympathy for him. The irony that compassion can be found in those most hurt by the tragedy while the death penalty posturing is left to those like you thousands of miles away from Charleston says it all about whose values are right and whose are wrong. Edited by sydtheeagle (22 Jun 2015 1.50pm)
Your right the families have found it in their hearts to forgive Roof but at the end of the day in regards to threads like this it is all about opinions. My brother and sister are against the death penalty but i am for it in cases like this. i make no apology saying Roof should be put to sleep because that's what he deserves in my opinion. Actually, you also said he deserves everything he gets, and should fry. Which is the very antithesis of being put to sleep (a statement that equates relatively humane end, largely administered as a kindess to avoid greater suffering, ie an act of compassion and mercy, in which the person making the decision suffers greatly to ease the suffering of another, most typically an animal, but increasingly a person).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Although only one victim, who survived, this case in Wales isn't too disimilar.
Optimistic as ever |
|
| derben |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 2.13pm
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.06pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 1.44pm
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 12.18pm
The victims of the murderers are certainly not the people they were a decade ago. Scrap all the endless appeals, allow them one and if that fails, go ahead. Society is protected by removing a killer from its midst and saving money avoiding long prison sentences. Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 12.19pm) But society ISN'T protected by the presence of the death sentence. That's exactly the point. If society gained any benefit then violent crime would be lower in countries with the death penalty than those without it. And so far as I know, it isn't. You can argue that it makes everyone feel better to remove killers, but you can't claim it affords any protection to society at large by doing so. As for saving money, there are some costs that simply have to be borne by civilised societies. A functional penal system is one of them. Besides, executing people isn't much cheaper than imprisoning them for life, so far as I am aware. Yes, limiting their right to appeal would reduce that cost but I don't think -- when you're taking away a person's life -- short cuts are something you want to look for. Society is protected in that the murderer is not around to do it again if released - many murderers are released and a significant number kill again. Deterrence is difficult to measure. Perhaps there would be even more murders in the US if some if all States abolished the death penalty. The same society that is not protected from wrongful conviction and execution by the state? At least 35 released murderers killed again after release 2001-2011 according to the BBC: [Link] How many innocent people were executed in the last ten years of the death penalty? If less then 35, then I would say we would be ahead of the game in having a death penalty.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.55pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 2.13pm
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.06pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 1.44pm
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 12.18pm
The victims of the murderers are certainly not the people they were a decade ago. Scrap all the endless appeals, allow them one and if that fails, go ahead. Society is protected by removing a killer from its midst and saving money avoiding long prison sentences. Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 12.19pm) But society ISN'T protected by the presence of the death sentence. That's exactly the point. If society gained any benefit then violent crime would be lower in countries with the death penalty than those without it. And so far as I know, it isn't. You can argue that it makes everyone feel better to remove killers, but you can't claim it affords any protection to society at large by doing so. As for saving money, there are some costs that simply have to be borne by civilised societies. A functional penal system is one of them. Besides, executing people isn't much cheaper than imprisoning them for life, so far as I am aware. Yes, limiting their right to appeal would reduce that cost but I don't think -- when you're taking away a person's life -- short cuts are something you want to look for. Society is protected in that the murderer is not around to do it again if released - many murderers are released and a significant number kill again. Deterrence is difficult to measure. Perhaps there would be even more murders in the US if some if all States abolished the death penalty. The same society that is not protected from wrongful conviction and execution by the state? At least 35 released murderers killed again after release 2001-2011 according to the BBC: [Link] How many innocent people were executed in the last ten years of the death penalty? If less then 35, then I would say we would be ahead of the game in having a death penalty.
Only 13 of them would have bee eligible for a death penalty, and one of those killed someone whilst awaiting parole for Murder (so still inside, so not released). Counting people who are convicted of manslaughter is irrelevant to the argument, as they would not have received a death sentence. So that's 12 people. Just over one per year, of the average of around 650 murders per year, or 0.002 percent of murders commited each year (are committed by someone who previously was convicted of murder). I've no idea how many people are wrongfully convicted of murder each year*, but as you're saving 1.2 people per year. Of course that's not accounting for the fact that not all murderers would have gotten a death penalty either in the UK (and very few people were actually hanged even if they were sentenced to death). So you need to divide that 1.2 people saved per year, by the percentage of murder cases receiving a death sentence and then reduce it again by sentences commuted Or you could be realistic, and look at the most serious murder cases, as those that got death penalties typically were, and question how many people serving minimum tariffs of 30 years upwards to whole life sentences, have committed murders after being released from prison? So even if we say 50% of murder cases received a death sentence that was carried out, you've got a 0.6 people per year being saved. The truth is, for a 0.002% drop on murders, the death penalty isn't a very effective means of reducing murders in the UK. Each year 770 convictions in the UK are quashed by the Court service, via the court of appeal (1989-1999), and a further 3500 convictions per year overturned at Crown court (from Magistrates court). There are usually between 600-700 murders in the UK each year. I would say the line between saving lives and taking lives is very narrow, to negligible.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 3.06pm
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.55pm
How many innocent people were executed in the last ten years of the death penalty? If less then 35, then I would say we would be ahead of the game in having a death penalty. Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 2.56pm) I would say that if a single innocent person was executed, ever, then you have all the reason you need for not having the death penalty. Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then? Its gone up? You shouldn't count manslaughter as murder. Killers and murderers are two very different things.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 2.21pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 2.08pm
Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 1.57pm
Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 1.41pm
Someone who says i must kill black people,supports apartied,pictured with a racist flag and then kills innocent people is beyond rehabilitation. Dylon Roof is an evil evil person,he deserves whatever punishment comes his way.
He's going to be in jail forever but you can't kill them by any method other than those allowed by law, and you can't bump him up the queue because his crime seems more evil than that of another, already sentenced to death before him. And you'd be wrong. 95% of paroled lifers never commit a serious criminal offence in their lifetime (though I suspect that more due to the time involved than prison service). It does seem weird how difficult it actually proves to legally kill someone in the US. The grounds for appealing a death sentence are massive in law (well they're the same as for any sentence more or less, but with other sentences you've got the prospect of parole, time served and deals to consider and the state has the prospect of 'making it right' after the fact). So it proves a very expensive and consuming process, because essentially you've got appeals on the basis of fairness, predical sentencing, fair trial, proper representation, constitutional law, due process etc stuff that you'd never bother with, where you were tried, poltiical bais etc... Which you'd never really bother with if you weren't facing death.
Unfortunately, that's as close the details available gets, people who receive life sentences. Its not so much the old and frail, as most people who get a life sentence serve about 15-20 years, but that people really change in 15-20 year, and most of those people killed people for very specific reasons. As it stands, see my reply to Durben, in a 10 year period, 13 people previously convicted of murder committed a murder, of which one was currently serving a life sentence, in prison (and hadn't been released). So that's 1.2 people out of 600-660 convictions for murder each year, are killed by a convicted murderer. If you execute every murderer then you save one life per year, and gain an bonus life every fifth year. However, against that you need to subtract one person for every overturned murder conviction. So for example, when the Guildford four and Birmingham six convictions were overturned, you would have been -9 lives saved that year. 770 Crown Court convictions are overturned on average each year. If only 0.01% of those are murder convictions, then you've actually killed more people than you saved that year.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.37pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 3.23pm
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 3.06pm
Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.55pm
How many innocent people were executed in the last ten years of the death penalty? If less then 35, then I would say we would be ahead of the game in having a death penalty. Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 2.56pm) I would say that if a single innocent person was executed, ever, then you have all the reason you need for not having the death penalty. Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then? Its gone up? You shouldn't count manslaughter as murder. Killers and murderers are two very different things. The point is you and syd seemed more concerned about the death of a murderer than you do about the victims of murder. You Jamie spent what must obviously taken you some time on convoluted refutation of various statistics. If I could be arsed, I expect I could come up with some refutation of the refutation, but I'm not. (Gone up? BBC no doubt has played down the figures anyway - bound to be more! It said they had killed after release, didn't say how many, I expect there were some multiples.) Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 3.41pm) I'm currently studying Psychology and Criminology with the Open University. I don't view the victim or the perpetrator as being more important, I see both objectively. It doesn't matter how takes your life unjustly, state or individual. My concern is that the ideology of 'they won't do it again' is as much as risk to innocent people, as it is a protection of them. If executing people delivered something like a 10-20% reduction in murder, then it might be something to consider (even then the execution should by for a greater good, such as execution by organ harvesting). A 0.002% isn't worth the risk.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.