This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
Its clear to me now why the Rail Industry is in such turmoil if you are an example of it's workforce. Your communication skills are like that of a child, not prepared to listen and doing what you like, having tantrums. Being old doesn't make you an expert but it teaches you to listen to more than one side of the story and not dismiss any opinion... even yours! I have done further research on this matter and have established that the Independent Rail Inspectorate have actually signed off Southern Rail's intention to run driver only operated trains as entirely safe and satisfactory. Furthermore Transport Minister Chris Grayling confirmed that fact this morning on R4 Today Programme and also confirmed that no one is losing their job or suffering a cut in pay. So it seems, you and RMT Union are falsely promoting passenger safety as a barrier to progress which has been independently assessed and given the thumbs up. As Tim said above, the strike is illegitimate and causing unnecessary suffering to Southern Rail passengers... some of whom have lost their jobs for reporting late to work. So, as I said all along, you were talking bollocks and in actual fact it is you that is the "moron" and akin to "the thicko down the pub". After all... what kind of moron would side with a Union and not listen to an Independent Inspectorate about safety? Anyway... now we've established that it is of benefit to listen to old people I will make further relevant comment... I don't know if you are old enough to remember the Zeebrugge Harbour disaster involving the Car Transporter Ship "Herald of Free Enterprise" which sunk in 1987 because the bow doors weren't shut before it set sail. That was caused by confusion as to who was primarily responsible for closing the doors. The Inquiry concluded that it was safer to make the captain responsible, ie the driver. I would also remind you yet again that many railways, light railways, London Underground and city trams operate driver only systems that do not require Guards to open and close the doors and have done for decades safely. Finally, I would suggest that the Rail Industry needs a complete overhaul to try and match the efficiency and safety of the rail systems operated in Japan and Switzerland which everyone knows are the best in the world. Our system is beset with problems, made worse by Union interference and often cost cutting and greed by private companies as well as weak government control. As it is now customary to sign off with a cheery disposition...... Enjoy your day at School little boy... Edited by Hoof Hearted (06 Dec 2016 9.03am) Hoof, you have ignored the points made about guards being able to lay SCB, place dets and operate TCOC's. Who does this when they're replaced? Are you suggesting that these safety procedures are now not needed? You're right, guards aren't gonna lose jobs or money... which begs the question, why are they striking and why did they turn down £2k to accept changes to safety procedures? Why are drivers striking over the same thing? They also turned down a bonus to accept changes to safety procedures. It's quite clear that this strike is about safety, and it was a PR own goal by southern to try and buy off their staff. I am not gonna comment on the ferry industry, as I've never worked in that area. I think only a moron would comment on a industry they have insufficient knowledge of. X
|
|
|
Originally posted by gambler
Oh come on hoof, you linked to the findings of a so called independent body re safety. Whatever side of the argument you sympathise with, in no way can the body be called independent when at least one member has a conflict of interests. The point is there is an independent body in place to review this that the relevant people responsible for network safety deem to be sufficiently independent. Whether you personally view them as independent is irrelevant. If we're going to play that game we may as well all go on strike and call our working conditions unsafe for the public because we don't trust the regulators in place. There are a wide range of regulations in place to ensure that our infrastructure is safe and reliable. It's those regulations, and not the employees of a tiny part of that infrastructure that get to decide what is and isn't safe. The rail franchise system makes absolutely no sense to me and I feel for anyone who may lose their job, but let's not kid ourselves into thinking anyone who works there truly gives a toss about safety over their pay check.
|
|
|
Originally posted by gambler
Was he the guard on that train then? Or a driver or guard travelling to his next job? Also are you telling me no one else in the whole country has a sneaky read of a paper or makes a personal phone call while they're at work?! Edited by gambler (06 Dec 2016 12.40pm) He could be going home... taking a sneaky pic of someone without their knowledge is a douche bag move.
|
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
I also mentioned previously that whilst Southern had Birchell as CEO we had very little chance of getting safety procedures removed, he had been in court over the Paddington rail crash, there was no way he would sign off. Horton has a close relationship with DfT and is on the board of RSSB, this helped massively. I work in finance. If I said bankers are doing gods work and deserve monumental bonuses and taxpayer funded bailouts, are you happy to take that as read? I am after all on the inside of the industry so must know more than all those on the outside.
|
|
|
Originally posted by IMpalace
I work in finance. If I said bankers are doing gods work and deserve monumental bonuses and taxpayer funded bailouts, are you happy to take that as read? I am after all on the inside of the industry so must know more than all those on the outside. I worked for Southern with the current management... bit different
|
|
|
The only one of their current management team I don't (properly) know is Horton.
|
|
|
Originally posted by IMpalace
The point is there is an independent body in place to review this that the relevant people responsible for network safety deem to be sufficiently independent. Whether you personally view them as independent is irrelevant. If we're going to play that game we may as well all go on strike and call our working conditions unsafe for the public because we don't trust the regulators in place. There are a wide range of regulations in place to ensure that our infrastructure is safe and reliable. It's those regulations, and not the employees of a tiny part of that infrastructure that get to decide what is and isn't safe. The rail franchise system makes absolutely no sense to me and I feel for anyone who may lose their job, but let's not kid ourselves into thinking anyone who works there truly gives a toss about safety over their pay check. I accept your points. But Charles Horton is a major player in this dispute. He is also on the "independent" panel that Hoof linked to with reference to this very dispute. How can that be right?
|
|
|
Originally posted by gambler
I accept your points. But Charles Horton is a major player in this dispute. He is also on the "independent" panel that Hoof linked to with reference to this very dispute. How can that be right? Some people think Horton has been brought in to do the Dft's dirty work. He has quite a interesting CV. Anyone with a degree of intelligence can see guards/drivers are right. You can't argue that making the railway less safe is a good thing. My money is on Southern/DfT winning though. Judging by this thread and twitter/Facebook.. they seem to have won over the public. Striking without public sympathy is very hard. Southern know this... that's why they did the "strike back" campaign.
|
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
Some people think Horton has been brought in to do the Dft's dirty work. He has quite a interesting CV. Anyone with a degree of intelligence can see guards/drivers are right. You can't argue that making the railway less safe is a good thing. My money is on Southern/DfT winning though. Judging by this thread and twitter/Facebook.. they seem to have won over the public. Striking without public sympathy is very hard. Southern know this... that's why they did the "strike back" campaign. So should we make them more safe, for example have one guard per carriage? Or are we at the "right level" of safety and if so who says so? Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (06 Dec 2016 4.21pm)
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch
So should we make them more safe, for example have one guard per carriage? Or are we at the "right level" of safety and if so who says so? Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (06 Dec 2016 4.21pm) The people operating the system would be quite qualified. The art of politics is mediation and compromise. The fact that strikers have been offered cash as an incentive rather than discussing what would be a happy medium between the parties shows one side at least isn't doing that. ACAS need to up their game! Edited by nickgusset (06 Dec 2016 4.30pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
The people operating the system would be quite qualified. The art of politics is mediation and compromise. The fact that strikers have been offered cash as an incentive rather than discussing what would be a happy medium between the parties shows one side at least isn't doing that. ACAS need to up their game! Edited by nickgusset (06 Dec 2016 4.30pm) Really? People doing the job may have a level of input but to be of the required standard to make such a decision? 7mins stated Anyone with a degree of intelligence can see guards/drivers are right. You can't argue that making the railway less safe is a good thing. This brings me back to my question, who decides what is an acceptable level of safety and are we currently at it?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch
Really? People doing the job may have a level of input but to be of the required standard to make such a decision? 7mins stated Anyone with a degree of intelligence can see guards/drivers are right. You can't argue that making the railway less safe is a good thing. This brings me back to my question, who decides what is an acceptable level of safety and are we currently at it? A ratio of 1200:1 staff is never good. Also in 99% of "out of normal working" the driver is required to stay in the cab to be able to communicate with the signaller.
|
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
A ratio of 1200:1 staff is never good. Also in 99% of "out of normal working" the driver is required to stay in the cab to be able to communicate with the signaller. Probably not, but 1:1 staff/guards might be reflected in the already expensive fares. It's already cheaper to fly (if you have that option)...... It would be pretty safe though. Even if the trains are too full of staff to get all the passengers on it.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by gambler
Was he the guard on that train then? Yes Or a driver or guard travelling to his next job? No Oh, sorry for the late reply but I only posted that at lunch and obviously was working the rest of the day until I spent 2 1/2 hours trying to get home from work. Edited by gambler (06 Dec 2016 12.40pm) Edited by steph_eagle (07 Dec 2016 7.47am)
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 07 Dec 16 9.37am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
Hoof, you have ignored the points made about guards being able to lay SCB, place dets and operate TCOC's. Who does this when they're replaced? Are you suggesting that these safety procedures are now not needed? You're right, guards aren't gonna lose jobs or money... which begs the question, why are they striking and why did they turn down £2k to accept changes to safety procedures? Why are drivers striking over the same thing? They also turned down a bonus to accept changes to safety procedures. It's quite clear that this strike is about safety, and it was a PR own goal by southern to try and buy off their staff. I am not gonna comment on the ferry industry, as I've never worked in that area. I think only a moron would comment on a industry they have insufficient knowledge of. X Quelle surprise.... yet more childish insults in response to my backing of your Industry Regulators position as opposed to your random reasons. Edited by Hoof Hearted (07 Dec 2016 11.24am)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.