This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Seems fair. The country vote for a party to govern and that parties members vote for the person to lead it. 200,000 voters is better than 350 odd. Just wrong. You don't vote for a party. You vote for an MP. That many people don't understand the difference is very unfortunate but doesn't change the facts. Having parties standing behind them allows the system to work but must not be allowed to interfere with the duty of every MP to use their conscience to decide how they themselves vote. The increasing degree of centralisation means that we have no idea who is actually determining policy. It isn't the MPs themselves and they are our representatives.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You conclude incorrectly. I am not tribal. I am a member of More United. Erm. You signed up to More United. That is as tribal as any other political allegiance.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I am not aware of any formal committment required in terms of the manifesto. But of course candidates of whatever hue would be expected to be supportive of the manifestos of their respective parties. Have to depart now to enjoy a coffee and cake with my Conservative chums!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Just wrong. You don't vote for a party. You vote for an MP. That many people don't understand the difference is very unfortunate but doesn't change the facts. Having parties standing behind them allows the system to work but must not be allowed to interfere with the duty of every MP to use their conscience to decide how they themselves vote. The increasing degree of centralisation means that we have no idea who is actually determining policy. It isn't the MPs themselves and they are our representatives. Wisbech that is your opinion not everyone agrees with it. Unless I am mistakened not one of the MPs who changed parties was re-elected they either retired or lost. You have an idealised version of what Parliament should be and in theory it would be great if it worked that way. But as I just posted on the Brexit thread for example Labour's position to oppose any Tory Brexit deal before it had even been negotiated is the reality of Parliament. Politicians are partisan and oppose the other side even when the other side is talking sense. By all means continue to call for MPs to be independent of the party machine but you will be howling in the wind. I wish you luck it's not a bad thing if it ever happened. A more realistic solution is to vote for independent MPs. I have a friend who is an independent councillor in Froome where all seats are held by local independent people and the public love it.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I seldom waste my time responding to your posts as I find that you are as narrow minded as my dog when there is food about so any response is generally a complete waste of time but I would point out that your definition of democracy is at odds with that of our Prime Minister who said in his speech over the weekend that MPs should never forget that they are the servants of the people and not their masters and they should remember that they should carry out the will of the people that elected them. Your statement about drifting towards a "pseudo dictatorship" is as daft as much of the other drivel that you post. We have just had a General Election in which every citizen over the age of 18 cast their vote for whomever they wished. People allegedly turned their backs on Corbyn as they didn't like him or what he represented and anyone who voted Conservative was just as free to do the same and cast their vote elsewhere, Nigel Farage said that he intended to spoil his ballot paper and that avenue was open to everyone else that wished to make a point but it seems that the majority were happy to freely vote for your so called dictator. Your side has lost now twice so just get over it To suggest that I am narrow minded is a little rich given the general level of one track thought to be found here! The PM is right, but only up to a point. MPs are the servants of the people who voted for them. This in turn means that they are NOT the servants of a party machine. To serve those people requires them, and not the machine, to determine what the will of the people electing them really is. This long established principle is now under threat by the moves to exert pressure and reinterpret the role of the MP. I regard it as a dangerous threat to our democracy and taken to its ultimate conclusion would see us ending up with an ineffective Parliament and the real power held in the shadows. I regret that some of you don't see that but I am far from alone and as this Parliament proceeds expect to see this issue aired many times. This is not a simple party issue. It would be equally, if not more, dangerous, if we had a far left government. If we allow this drift to continue you may all come to regret not having resisted it now. It has nothing whatsoever with how or why people cast their votes or spoiled them. I don't have a side! I support the supremacy of individual MPs and Parliament as a whole. I support our country and not one section of it.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
To suggest that I am narrow minded is a little rich given the general level of one track thought to be found here! The PM is right, but only up to a point. MPs are the servants of the people who voted for them. This in turn means that they are NOT the servants of a party machine. To serve those people requires them, and not the machine, to determine what the will of the people electing them really is. This long established principle is now under threat by the moves to exert pressure and reinterpret the role of the MP. I regard it as a dangerous threat to our democracy and taken to its ultimate conclusion would see us ending up with an ineffective Parliament and the real power held in the shadows. I regret that some of you don't see that but I am far from alone and as this Parliament proceeds expect to see this issue aired many times. This is not a simple party issue. It would be equally, if not more, dangerous, if we had a far left government. If we allow this drift to continue you may all come to regret not having resisted it now. It has nothing whatsoever with how or why people cast their votes or spoiled them. I don't have a side! I support the supremacy of individual MPs and Parliament as a whole. I support our country and not one section of it. The parties have been around for hundreds of years. As has the system of the party whip. There have been some notable defections over the years - probably Churchill being the most high profile. They are the exception rather than the rule, however. People have always voted on party lines in Britain - often regardless of the MP.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Just wrong. You don't vote for a party. You vote for an MP. That many people don't understand the difference is very unfortunate but doesn't change the facts. Yet again you are posting your ideals as fact and as usual it's all Bollox. People vote for a variety of different reasons whether that fits in with your ideals or not. A woman on Radio 5 this morning said that she voted Labour because she always had done and so had her family. Should I have telephoned in and told her that she was wrong as Wisbech Eagle said so? There were also rumours a few years ago that many women voted Labour because their new leader was good looking and certainly many people were put off voting Conservative as they didn't like Theresa May. Please stop posting your ideas and opinions as fact
|
|
|
Originally posted by W12
Labour lost because they have become a Marxist cult and are followed and represented by people of the "quality" of Owen Jones, David Lammmy, Ash Sarkar, numerous vacuous celebrities and all manor of people that live rarefied and privileged lives and are totally out of touch with the rest of society (as they almost never mix with working class people) . The British people also have a 6th sense for sniffing out extremists (and were continuously insulted and demonized by those people already mentioned). Tories won because they were the only Brexit party and Boris appealed to people who still consider themselves patriotic (i.e. most) Lib Fems failed because they sum up all that's wrong with the hyper liberal virtue signalling elite and equally out of touch as Labour. Christ knows why the SNP did so well, I'm very disappointing in the jocks. I would dissolve the union, as David Starkey pointed out recently it's been a case of 3 tails (Wales, Ireland and especially Scotland) wagging the dog for years as England is over 80% of the UK population and is the only country without it's own parliament yet is also the economic powerhouse. All of those countries are a drain on our economy and have far more socialist tendencies (although I have sympathy and solidarity with Irish unionists). We need a revival of the English constitution with the concepts of individual rights, the rule of law, freedom of speech, freedom of association etc at the forefront of our thinking and education. These are the fundamentals that were key to creating the entire western modern world. Most of all though we probably need a new youth counter culture of free thinking, facts and realism as our youth is currently lost to ideology. I wish you had stood for Parliament you get my vote
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
I would dissolve the union, as David Starkey pointed out recently it's been a case of 3 tails (Wales, Ireland and especially Scotland) wagging the dog for years as England is over 80% of the UK population and is the only country without it's own parliament yet is also the economic powerhouse. All of those countries are a drain on our economy and have far more socialist tendencies (although I have sympathy and solidarity with Irish unionists). We need a revival of the English constitution with the concepts of individual rights, the rule of law, freedom of speech, freedom of association etc at the forefront of our thinking and education. These are the fundamentals that were key to creating the entire western modern world. I get the arguments for English nationalism but I also don't really trust my instincts that are most fired up by it. Always thought it was the Elephant in the room and the one that could cause the most potential, and unpredictable, damage. Because it has been subdued for so long that it has effectively been allowed to fester albeit in perhaps a way that is more sub-conscious than any clearly rationalised. Never really bought into all this faux-patriotism that our Celtic neighbours like to onaistically indulge on with all their stupid skirts and ludicrous Guinness hats. I would hate for us English to go the same way but I suspect that English nationalism would burst out in a way that nobody could really foresee and might be a precursor to some real upheaval. It takes centuries before barbarism becomes diluted enough to make it a tourist attraction. One of my big fears about Brexit not happening was that English nationalism would have then become the only conduit of protest for millions of people. That faith in the British Parliamentary system would have been so undermined that there could be no logical or reasoned argument to be made for acquiescing to the electoral process anymore. If our votes on June 23rd could be so easily discarded, why bother anymore? Perhaps I am a little guilty of hyperbole over this and am transferring my own feelings of complete rage about anybody who wanted to nullify the result from June 2016 but I suspect not. Because our system of democracy would have been fatally undermined. The reality is England tolerates the smaller parts of the UK. Accepts them as the price to be paid for our shared history. We all have friends and family and even origins from all parts of it. And to be fair, we are richer and enjoy a much higher quality of life (if Scotland leave then us remaining members of the UK live for years longer on average). We even owe a duty of care to the Republic of Ireland because despite all their hot air, they need us to sell into. We have enough of a shared history to mean that they do need looking after. As things stand I would urge people to curb their understandable desire for an England that stands solely on its own two feet. Let's get Brexit done and see how matters pan out. Leave was a UK wide vote. And as such, we need to take a UK wide approach to how it is handled. We need to wipe our mouths and move on, no matter how justified our rage and anger is. Edited by Matov (16 Dec 2019 11.20am)
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
Labour lost because they have become a Marxist cult and are followed and represented by people of the "quality" of Owen Jones, David Lammmy, Ash Sarkar, numerous vacuous celebrities and all manor of people that live rarefied and privileged lives and are totally out of touch with the rest of society (as they almost never mix with working class people) . The British people also have a 6th sense for sniffing out extremists (and were continuously insulted and demonized by those people already mentioned). Tories won because they were the only Brexit party and Boris appealed to people who still consider themselves patriotic (i.e. most) Lib Fems failed because they sum up all that's wrong with the hyper liberal virtue signalling elite and equally out of touch as Labour. Christ knows why the SNP did so well, I'm very disappointing in the jocks. I would dissolve the union, as David Starkey pointed out recently it's been a case of 3 tails (Wales, Ireland and especially Scotland) wagging the dog for years as England is over 80% of the UK population and is the only country without it's own parliament yet is also the economic powerhouse. All of those countries are a drain on our economy and have far more socialist tendencies (although I have sympathy and solidarity with Irish unionists). We need a revival of the English constitution with the concepts of individual rights, the rule of law, freedom of speech, freedom of association etc at the forefront of our thinking and education. These are the fundamentals that were key to creating the entire western modern world. Most of all though we probably need a new youth counter culture of free thinking, facts and realism as our youth is currently lost to ideology. People who have only ever voted Labour voted Tory.
|
|
|
Originally posted by becky
1. The majority of your fellow citizens obviously did want to exit - that's why Johnson won - and that was after seeing the implications for the last 3 and odd years! 2. That makes the assumption that there will still be an EU to rejoin by the time the mood in this country changes - I doubt that there will be, or at least, not in it's current form.
|
|
| W12 16 Dec 19 11.39am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Matov
I get the arguments for English nationalism but I also don't really trust my instincts that are most fired up by it. Always thought it was the Elephant in the room and the one that could cause the most potential, and unpredictable, damage. Because it has been subdued for so long that it has effectively been allowed to fester albeit in perhaps a way that is more sub-conscious than any clearly rationalised. Never really bought into all this faux-patriotism that our Celtic neighbours like to onaistically indulge on with all their stupid skirts and ludicrous Guinness hats. I would hate for us English to go the same way but I suspect that English nationalism would burst out in a way that nobody could really foresee and might be a precursor to some real upheaval. It takes centuries before barbarism becomes diluted enough to make it a tourist attraction. One of my big fears about Brexit not happening was that English nationalism would have then become the only conduit of protest for millions of people. That faith in the British Parliamentary system would have been so undermined that there could be no logical or reasoned argument to be made for acquiescing to the electoral process anymore. If our votes on June 23rd could be so easily discarded, why bother anymore? Perhaps I am a little guilty of hyperbole over this and am transferring my own feelings of complete rage about anybody who wanted to nullify the result from June 2016 but I suspect not. Because our system of democracy would have been fatally undermined. The reality is England tolerates the smaller parts of the UK. Accepts them as the price to be paid for our shared history. We all have friends and family and even origins from all parts of it. And to be fair, we are richer and enjoy a much higher quality of life (if Scotland leave then us remaining members of the UK live for years longer on average). We even owe a duty of care to the Republic of Ireland because despite all their hot air, they need us to sell into. We have enough of a shared history to mean that they do need looking after. As things stand I would urge people to curb their understandable desire for an England that stands solely on its own two feet. Let's get Brexit done and see how matters pan out. Leave was a UK wide vote. And as such, we need to take a UK wide approach to how it is handled. We need to wipe our mouths and move on, no matter how justified our rage and anger is. Edited by Matov (16 Dec 2019 11.20am) I think your perception of "English Nationalism", Like most, has been tainted by leftist propaganda. Try even showing a St George Cross without feeling like a racist and you will realize they got to most of us have been gotten at. England especially has so much to be proud of but it's become entirely taboo to express that (and fashionable to express the opposite). In particular, the mainstream media consensus that nationalism is bad needs to be challenged. The majority think England (or at last the United Kingdom) is a good thing.
|
|
| W12 16 Dec 19 11.42am | |
|---|---|
|
By the way, part of my desire to leave the union is definitely based on seeing the faces of the SNP as we cut them adrift. What an awful political party.
|
|
|
Originally posted by W12
By the way, part of my desire to leave the union is definitely based on seeing the faces of the SNP as we cut them adrift. What an awful political party. Whilst handing them their share of the national debt as a leaving present.
|
|
|
Originally posted by W12
I think your perception of "English Nationalism", Like most, has been tainted by leftist propaganda. Try even showing a St George Cross without feeling like a racist and you will realize they got to most of us have been gotten at. England especially has so much to be proud of but it's become entirely taboo to express that (and fashionable to express the opposite). In particular, the mainstream media consensus that nationalism is bad needs to be challenged. The majority think England (or at last the United Kingdom) is a good thing. Depends. For my money all that flag-waving and wearing silly costumes is more an expression of a lack of confidence in your national identity. The patriotic equivilent of people obsessed with designer labels and so on. English nationalism will be about seizing power. About taking control of specifically English only institutions. Not an exercise in Morris dancing and eating Pork Pies. And not necessarily a guarantee that the Right would triumph. A strong case could be made for a new manifestation of England being a Republic. Even full-on socialist. I get peoples ire about why other displays of nationalism are cheered on whilst English ones are treated with disdain but I would urge a little caution around making it a defining issue. I know of Irish people who find all the hype around St Patricks day to be more than patronising and certainly not representing how they see the modern Irish state. English nationalism worries me because it appeals so much to the part of me that craves radical change. Perhaps this might be self-regarding nonsense but having learnt the hard way that the saying 'be careful for what you wish' is rooted in our collective psyches for good reason. I would urge you relish the contempt of the left. Turn it around and rub their faces in it because as things stand, at least for today, our side is winning. Celebrate that because these things can change in a heart beat.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
Labour lost because they have become a Marxist cult and are followed and represented by people of the "quality" of Owen Jones, David Lammmy, Ash Sarkar, numerous vacuous celebrities and all manor of people that live rarefied and privileged lives and are totally out of touch with the rest of society (as they almost never mix with working class people) . The British people also have a 6th sense for sniffing out extremists (and were continuously insulted and demonized by those people already mentioned). Tories won because they were the only Brexit party and Boris appealed to people who still consider themselves patriotic (i.e. most) Lib Fems failed because they sum up all that's wrong with the hyper liberal virtue signalling elite and equally out of touch as Labour. Christ knows why the SNP did so well, I'm very disappointing in the jocks. I would dissolve the union, as David Starkey pointed out recently it's been a case of 3 tails (Wales, Ireland and especially Scotland) wagging the dog for years as England is over 80% of the UK population and is the only country without it's own parliament yet is also the economic powerhouse. All of those countries are a drain on our economy and have far more socialist tendencies (although I have sympathy and solidarity with Irish unionists). We need a revival of the English constitution with the concepts of individual rights, the rule of law, freedom of speech, freedom of association etc at the forefront of our thinking and education. These are the fundamentals that were key to creating the entire western modern world. Most of all though we probably need a new youth counter culture of free thinking, facts and realism as our youth is currently lost to ideology. Some stuff in that post I do not like. If the parties that got stuffed are so out of step with "real" people, this suggests that the party that won is in touch with those people. While there are clear notable exceptions in terms of the demographic spread of tory MPs, to suggest that a party dominated by elite public school boys that is heavily funded by the finance sector is at one with the ordinary working man is laughable. Their colossal funding allowed them to present the illusion of connection, nothing more. That said, it is hard to disagree with your thoughts on the failure of the opposition. Your view on labour largely echoes mine; but it is the open goal missed by the Lib Dems that is the most shameful. A fractured, hapless opposition gifted the Tories a landslide. And while most who post on this site will rejoice, until the opposition condenses and strengthens, we are without effective checks and balances against abuse of power. If the Tories also intend to extract personal revenge against the Supreme Court and further curb judicial review, that would be an even greater threat to a healthy democracy. They cannot be good things. For me, the best gift would be if the Tories recognise their mandate but use their power responsibly, then last week will not be the end of the world scenario I feared when I woke up on Friday morning. Sadly, this is not how human beings work. I suspect power will have the inevitable corrupting effect in time.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Highlights of the election, Smug Berkows look on his face , when he realised the result. His disgraceful behaviour as Speaker, helped put a nail Labours coffin. The self proclaimed new PM Jo Swinson, when she lost her seat and was kicked out. Labour still in denial, claiming their policies were popular. Edited by Painter (16 Dec 2019 1.38pm) ^^^^^ THIS ^^^^^
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
While there are clear notable exceptions in terms of the demographic spread of tory MPs, to suggest that a party dominated by elite public school boys..... Whilst the Prime Minister may well have been educated at one of your elite public schools the other three great offices of state are held by two ex grammar school pupils and one from a comprehensive school background so hardly elitist
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.