You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I Love Croydon-Roy
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

I Love Croydon-Roy


Page 10 of 12 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 16 May 21 3.26pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Not me...!!

Todays game just reinforces what I have been saying all season - stop playing square pegs in round holes and let the players express themselves in their best positions rather trying to fit them into Roy's preferred rigid defensive formations.

It's no coincidence today, Zaha playing on the the left never a striker, Eze playing central in the 10 role, run the show and looked a different class to anyone on else on the pitch and Townsend on the Right.

Then beyond that we looked more solid when Kouyate moved into central midfield with Tomkins and Cahill in central defence.

Low and behold we look a different team..!!

But it's taken until today to do what many of us have been saying for weeks.

Yes you can argue injuries - especially with Kouyate having to play central defence, due to the long list of injuries in the central defence and clearly Roy doesn't fancy Kelly.

But if that's true why not buy/get in another central defender in January instead of Mateta who has made what 3 appearances..??, To release Kouyate to play in midfield, where we have been seriously missing legs and physicality.

That aside all the others have been consistently available, but played in the wrong positions to suit Roy's rigid formations.

So given all Roy's experience it's taken him until today - even then only in the second half to see what some of us have been saying all season - put the players in their best positions and let them play..!!

This is why it's time to say thanks Roy for all you have done, but it's time to move on..!!

COYP

We went eight games without winning at the end of last season and many blamed it on Roy's "obseession" with 433.

Start of this season we go 442 with Zaha up front. Surprise the opposition a bit Zaha finds his scoring boots again and six points from two games.

Tomkins has barely been available all season.

Parish and Freedman sign the players not Roy as has been well documented.

 

jeeagles Flag 16 May 21 3.30pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid



We went eight games without winning at the end of last season and many blamed it on Roy's "obseession" with 433.

Start of this season we go 442 with Zaha up front. Surprise the opposition a bit Zaha finds his scoring boots again and six points from two games.

Tomkins has barely been available all season.

Parish and Freedman sign the players not Roy as has been well documented.

It was 3 holding midfielders being far too negative that was the issue.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 16 May 21 3.31pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

We went eight games without winning at the end of last season and many blamed it on Roy's "obseession" with 433.

Start of this season we go 442 with Zaha up front. Surprise the opposition a bit Zaha finds his scoring boots again and six points from two games.

Tomkins has barely been available all season.

Parish and Freedman sign the players not Roy as has been well documented.

So what Parish and Freedman also choose the formation, determine the tactics and pick the team do they - don’t think so..!!

COYP

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 16 May 21 3.35pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

So what Parish and Freedman also choose the formation, determine the tactics and pick the team do they - don’t think so..!!

COYP

No, but chose to sign Mateta over a centre back.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 16 May 21 3.36pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

It was 3 holding midfielders being far too negative that was the issue.

No, McArthur has never been a holding midfielder and Schlupp was injured apart from the last couple of games.

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 16 May 21 4.03pm

Unfortunately, the ‘Roy Out’ brigade will never credit Roy when he wins. You just have to look back at the comments. When we lose, it’s Roy’s fault. When we win, it’s something he should have done weeks ago or down to luck.

Given what the players ‘can’ play like and how far up the table we ‘should’ be, it should be a doddle for the next guy coming in.

I hope I am proved wrong, but I think of all the managers currently available, Roy is by far the best equipped to go again next season.

Great point about the transfers. Roy has no say in transfers. You can tell because he would never have agreed to Meyer. It’s the same when FdB was given Sakho. Our managers are given the players to play, if they don’t fit in the system, then tough. Something the new guy will need to get used to.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 16 May 21 4.10pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

Unfortunately, the ‘Roy Out’ brigade will never credit Roy when he wins. You just have to look back at the comments. When we lose, it’s Roy’s fault. When we win, it’s something he should have done weeks ago or down to luck.

Given what the players ‘can’ play like and how far up the table we ‘should’ be, it should be a doddle for the next guy coming in.

I hope I am proved wrong, but I think of all the managers currently available, Roy is by far the best equipped to go again next season.

Great point about the transfers. Roy has no say in transfers. You can tell because he would never have agreed to Meyer. It’s the same when FdB was given Sakho. Our managers are given the players to play, if they don’t fit in the system, then tough. Something the new guy will need to get used to.

Absolutely. I hope Mr Parish reads this and, more importantly, agrees.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Plaistow Eagle Flag 16 May 21 4.23pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

No, but chose to sign Mateta over a centre back.

Hold on a minute - so in your opinion Roy as the Manager has absolutely no say or influence in where his/the team priorities lie in terms of signings.

You’re talking about an ex England Manager with 44 years of managerial experience paid a purported £4.5M a year - yet you honestly believe that Parish and Freedman would just ignore all of that and just sign who they want and Roy has no say or influence..!!!

Do you really believe that, because I don’t..!!

COYP

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 16 May 21 4.29pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

Unfortunately, the ‘Roy Out’ brigade will never credit Roy when he wins. You just have to look back at the comments. When we lose, it’s Roy’s fault. When we win, it’s something he should have done weeks ago or down to luck.

Given what the players ‘can’ play like and how far up the table we ‘should’ be, it should be a doddle for the next guy coming in.

I hope I am proved wrong, but I think of all the managers currently available, Roy is by far the best equipped to go again next season.

Great point about the transfers. Roy has no say in transfers. You can tell because he would never have agreed to Meyer. It’s the same when FdB was given Sakho. Our managers are given the players to play, if they don’t fit in the system, then tough. Something the new guy will need to get used to.

Brilliantly put.

I look forward to someone, anyone who isn't a complete tool should be fine apparently, bringing entertainment and points to Selhurst just by avoiding all the stupid, negative, dour mistakes Hodgson keeps making whilst keeping us miles from the relegation zone all the time.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 16 May 21 4.31pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Hold on a minute - so in your opinion Roy as the Manager has absolutely no say or influence in where his/the team priorities lie in terms of signings.

You’re talking about an ex England Manager with 44 years of managerial experience paid a purported £4.5M a year - yet you honestly believe that Parish and Freedman would just ignore all of that and just sign who they want and Roy has no say or influence..!!!

Do you really believe that, because I don’t..!!

COYP

Hodgson literally could not be clearer on his limited role regarding transfers. He says that same thing every summer and every January.

 

CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 16 May 21 4.41pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Hodgson literally could not be clearer on his limited role regarding transfers. He says that same thing every summer and every January.

As he has also stated how hard Parish and DF work at trying to recruit the right players.

Paint the whole picture, not just half of it.

If you need references, you can find them via Croydon advertiser, London news online, standard etc.
He discusses quite positively about the relationship he has with df and Parish.

Edited by CPFCwetrust (16 May 2021 4.47pm)

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 16 May 21 4.48pm

Originally posted by CPFCwetrust

As he has also stated how hard Parish and DF work at trying to recruit the right players.

Paint the whole picture, not just half of it.

If you need references, you can find them via Croydon advertiser, London news online, standard etc.
He discusses quite positively about the relationship he has with df and Parish.

Edited by CPFCwetrust (16 May 2021 4.47pm)

Not sure I understand what you feel I've left unpainted, but yes, he's been clear that SP and DF handle transfers, with RH offering his opinion.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 16 May 21 4.51pm

i am struggling to think of a list of managers with a better CV than Roy. Anybody on that list would not touch us with a ten-foot barge-pole . Carlo Ancelotti ? yeah, right.

And younger managers ? with a track record of getting such results on a tiny budget ?

we don't know how good we got it with Roy.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Plaistow Eagle Flag 16 May 21 4.54pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

Unfortunately, the ‘Roy Out’ brigade will never credit Roy when he wins. You just have to look back at the comments. When we lose, it’s Roy’s fault. When we win, it’s something he should have done weeks ago or down to luck.

Given what the players ‘can’ play like and how far up the table we ‘should’ be, it should be a doddle for the next guy coming in.

I hope I am proved wrong, but I think of all the managers currently available, Roy is by far the best equipped to go again next season.

Great point about the transfers. Roy has no say in transfers. You can tell because he would never have agreed to Meyer. It’s the same when FdB was given Sakho. Our managers are given the players to play, if they don’t fit in the system, then tough. Something the new guy will need to get used to.


Think actually it’s the other way around - every time we have a half decent result or performance the so called “Roy In” brigade appear en masse...!!

Yet when we’re being beaten 7-0 at home by Liverpool, 3-0:against Aston Villa away against 10 men and dire after dire performances in succession are being produced they are nowhere to be seen or heard from..!!

Conversely as today proves my opinion remains constant - irrespective of the result the trend has been on the downward curve for the last 18 months and IMO a more expansive and dynamic Manager would have got/will get more out of this squad than Roy.

That’s my opinion and I’ve been consistent in saying it.

Nothing against Roy he’s done a great job but IMO it’s time to say thanks and move on..!!

COYP


 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 16 May 21 5.06pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

i am struggling to think of a list of managers with a better CV than Roy. Anybody on that list would not touch us with a ten-foot barge-pole . Carlo Ancelotti ? yeah, right.

And younger managers ? with a track record of getting such results on a tiny budget ?

we don't know how good we got it with Roy.

Yeah but you miss the obvious thing there - unless young Managers are given opportunities how do they create a track record..??

Are you suggesting that we should only ever appoint aged Managers..!!

Like all things in life all good things come to an end and IMO we’ve reached that stage with Roy.

COYP

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 16 May 21 5.14pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle


Think actually it’s the other way around - every time we have a half decent result or performance the so called “Roy In” brigade appear en masse...!!

Yet when we’re being beaten 7-0 at home by Liverpool, 3-0:against Aston Villa away against 10 men and dire after dire performances in succession are being produced they are nowhere to be seen or heard from..!!

Conversely as today proves my opinion remains constant - irrespective of the result the trend has been on the downward curve for the last 18 months and IMO a more expansive and dynamic Manager would have got/will get more out of this squad than Roy.

That’s my opinion and I’ve been consistent in saying it.

Nothing against Roy he’s done a great job but IMO it’s time to say thanks and move on..!!

COYP



I don't think there's specifically a 'Roy in' brigade. It's more a case of people who are merely reacting to the sheer ignorant idiocy of some of the more deluded folks who have no concept of the ins and outs of managing a squadful of egos and who want him out.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 16 May 21 5.22pm

Financially we are punching way above our weight. Thanks to Roy.

Allowing a young unproven manager to use Palace as a testing ground ?

yeah, and i will let my 17 year old nephew drive my Ferrari on a pub crawl

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

beak Flag croydon 16 May 21 5.24pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

i am struggling to think of a list of managers with a better CV than Roy. Anybody on that list would not touch us with a ten-foot barge-pole . Carlo Ancelotti ? yeah, right.

And younger managers ? with a track record of getting such results on a tiny budget ?

we don't know how good we got it with Roy.

Superbly written. Roy is the boy!

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 16 May 21 5.29pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt


I don't think there's specifically a 'Roy in' brigade. It's more a case of people who are merely reacting to the sheer ignorant idiocy of some of the more deluded folks who have no concept of the ins and outs of managing a squadful of egos and who want him out.

So we have a squad full of egos that need to be managed do we? I am not sure when Roy said that and yet again you refer to deluded fans and ignorant idiocy because some have a different perspective of the situation. If you want to debate fine but your post is just arrogant, inflammatory and unnecessary.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 16 May 21 5.32pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

So we have a squad full of egos that need to be managed do we? I am not sure when Roy said that and yet again you refer to deluded fans and ignorant idiocy because some have a different perspective of the situation. If you want to debate fine but your post is just arrogant, inflammatory and unnecessary.

If the cap fits, fella...

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Page 10 of 12 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I Love Croydon-Roy