You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Cummings turns on Boris.
November 21 2026 10.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cummings turns on Boris.


Page 10 of 14 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 9.38am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Is German healthcare free at source or primarily privately funded? I genuinely don’t know.

It is funded by a mixture of State funding and a form of levy on employees (krankenkasse) set up by Bismark which goes into one of around 1,100 funds. Employees contribute 7% of their income.

In terms of efficiency, the UK spends 70% per head of what Germany spends.

 

Fatherken Flag 27 May 21 9.43am

Sorry have to disagree .

We have the best health system in the world .

If we had a private health system it would be based on the US one where you have to prove you can pay before treatment .

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 9.46am

Cummings has said:

1 The first lockdown came too late
2 Care Homes were forced to take people from hospitals who would certainly have already had COVID
3 The third lockdown should have been avoided by a 'firebreak'
4 The Government was in disarray and headless
5 Johnson was far more interested in the effect on economics than public health
6 That interest ended up backfiring as the economy suffered for a longer period

All of this falls into the category of 'no sh*t Sherlock'.

I have no doubt if you look back over posts at the time you will see many of us stating all of these things before it was too late

As a businessman I implemented a lockdown before the Government did. We refused hospital patients to protect our residents. We argued for a firebreak and watched a slow motion car crash in the Autumn.

As a result, in December 19 residents in one Home caught COVID and 7 died. It was heartbreaking and absolutely avoidable. Most were people enjoying life with plenty more years to live.

Cummings' confirmation is welcome but hardly news.

Anyone that thinks the Labour Party would have taken the same path isn't paying attention. Johnson was far more interested in financial wellbeing than the health of the nation, which would not have been the case with the Labour Party despite any other failings it may or may not have.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 9.46am

Originally posted by Fatherken

Sorry have to disagree .

We have the best health system in the world .

If we had a private health system it would be based on the US one where you have to prove you can pay before treatment .

With whom?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 27 May 21 9.49am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Please give examples. Are you for example talking about Germany?

Seriously? Are you saying that privatised healthcare doesn't exist in Europe. It tends to be a mixture hospitals are state run GPS and minor procedures private.

just go and Google it.

 


One more point

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 27 May 21 9.51am

Originally posted by Fatherken

Sorry have to disagree .

We have the best health system in the world .

If we had a private health system it would be based on the US one where you have to prove you can pay before treatment .

Why does a private healthcare system have to be based on the US model which I agree I would not like. Plenty of socialist countries have this private public mix we should look at the best.

The US model is not one I would favour.

Edited by Badger11 (27 May 2021 9.51am)

 


One more point

jeeagles Flag 27 May 21 10.09am

Originally posted by Badger11

Yup across Europe many of the most successful healthcare systems are privately run. The idea that the NHS has to be nationalised is nonsense as long as it is free at point of use we need to look at these successful European models.

Croynism around the NHS has lead to ridiculous levels of protection for it.

People from the UK that have never experienced alternative health care don't see how bad it is.

Much like how people who've never left London can't see how bad crime in the capital is.

Free at the point of use for doesn't work. It just creates layers and layers of inefficient bureaucracy. Doctors end up accountable to bureaucrats that pay them and not patient.

GP's surgeries have always been limited companies who get to claim from the NHS based on the number of people registered to them. It's a payment mechanism that incentivises getting as many people registered as possible and not helping patients. They are generally owned by a few old GP's with no idea how to run a business. Full privatisation would make these better.

Those who have the ability to dodge tax get access to free healthcare and people that can't afford to dodge tax pick up the bill.

People are no longer taking accountability for their own health. Then complaining that they can't get access to a free service. People have enough money to shove drugs up their nose every weekend, then complain they can't get free mental health treatment.

I think the poorest should still have access to free healthcare, but I'd much rather pay 30% tax and pay to see a GP rather than 40% tax and get one for free.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 10.46am

Originally posted by Badger11

Seriously? Are you saying that privatised healthcare doesn't exist in Europe. It tends to be a mixture hospitals are state run GPS and minor procedures private.

just go and Google it.

Just go and get a coffee, maybe you will wake up

Give me an example of where a European privatised system outperforms the NHS.

As a matter of interest I know the healthcare system - from the perspective of employees - in each European country. It's my job.

 

Orange1290 Flag 27 May 21 11.25am

Originally posted by Fatherken

Sorry have to disagree .

We have the best health system in the world .

If we had a private health system it would be based on the US one where you have to prove you can pay before treatment .

"In summary, little evidence seems to exist to prove the belief that the NHS is the “envy of the world”, at least if we are talking about the developed world. The UK’s health service surely provides adequate and often excellent care, but many questions remain about whether that care is as good as the standards of our cultural and physical neighbors in Europe and the rest of the world. The author believes that the British public deserves a rational debate about how best to finance, organize and provide healthcare in the UK today.

[Link]

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 27 May 21 11.46am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Cummings has said:

1 The first lockdown came too late
2 Care Homes were forced to take people from hospitals who would certainly have already had COVID
3 The third lockdown should have been avoided by a 'firebreak'
4 The Government was in disarray and headless
5 Johnson was far more interested in the effect on economics than public health
6 That interest ended up backfiring as the economy suffered for a longer period

All of this falls into the category of 'no sh*t Sherlock'.

I have no doubt if you look back over posts at the time you will see many of us stating all of these things before it was too late

As a businessman I implemented a lockdown before the Government did. We refused hospital patients to protect our residents. We argued for a firebreak and watched a slow motion car crash in the Autumn.

As a result, in December 19 residents in one Home caught COVID and 7 died. It was heartbreaking and absolutely avoidable. Most were people enjoying life with plenty more years to live.

Cummings' confirmation is welcome but hardly news.

Anyone that thinks the Labour Party would have taken the same path isn't paying attention. Johnson was far more interested in financial wellbeing than the health of the nation, which would not have been the case with the Labour Party despite any other failings it may or may not have.

I have no faith that there would be any difference if Labour - or in fact any other party - would have been in control at this time of frankly unprecedented circumstances. They may not have made exactly the same decisions, but the end result would be the same - their opponents would look to castigate them for any and everything they may have gotten slightly wrong.
All of these accusations are with benefit of Hindsight. I have To believe that the people in control of this country, be it Tory, Labour, BNP(god save us if this even happens) or Green party, are
doing it for the Countries benefits based on the principles they displayed when they were democratically voted in.

From where I'm sat, Boris et al have had to take us through a very difficult situation where they were attempting to keep the county going whilst minimising risks to public health. We've ended up being one of the few countries with an successful vaccination program - and one that looks like we can see the end to all this the soonest.
Yes mistakes were made, but I'm not going to castigate any of them for this. Especially when there is no apparent alternative who could have done any better.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 11.51am

Originally posted by Orange1290

"In summary, little evidence seems to exist to prove the belief that the NHS is the “envy of the world”, at least if we are talking about the developed world. The UK’s health service surely provides adequate and often excellent care, but many questions remain about whether that care is as good as the standards of our cultural and physical neighbors in Europe and the rest of the world. The author believes that the British public deserves a rational debate about how best to finance, organize and provide healthcare in the UK today.

[Link]

The Commonwealth Fund 2014 report said the NHS was the most cost-effective system of the 11 countries they looked at. A 2011 study found the NHS saved more lives per pound spent than any other country studied except Ireland.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 11.55am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

All of these accusations are with benefit of Hindsight.

Not so

I for one saw all of these mistakes in the making, before they took effect, and stated that.

Just throwing your hands in the air and saying it made no difference how things were led is total nonsense.

If you lead an organisation you make an enormous difference. Our organisation kept COVID out until the final knockings. Our residents were vaccinated just before they died. They needed a couple more weeks, then they would have lived. The lack of a firebreak is what killed them. Look back at what opposition parties were saying at that time.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 27 May 21 12.30pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Not so

I for one saw all of these mistakes in the making, before they took effect, and stated that.

Just throwing your hands in the air and saying it made no difference how things were led is total nonsense.

If you lead an organisation you make an enormous difference. Our organisation kept COVID out until the final knockings. Our residents were vaccinated just before they died. They needed a couple more weeks, then they would have lived. The lack of a firebreak is what killed them. Look back at what opposition parties were saying at that time.

I'm not saying do not investigate mistakes, and don't hold those to account for their mistakes. but no thought has been given to quite what a difficult and unprecedented job that these people have had to do.

I'm not saying that under different Leadership it would not have been different, but different does not equal better.
A firebreak may have helped in your situation, but hindered others (although on the surface, it does appear to be economy over public health) Whats to say, for example, that if we had a firebreak then more businesses go under, this will lead to more poverty leading to more deaths. Ok, not Covid deaths, but deaths caused by the decision Of a government all the same. That's for an enquiry to decide.
And as for opposition Parties, I've no inclination to go back to see what they were saying - their job description appears to be 'disagree with those in power'. It does not mean that that is what they would have done if they were in the same situation. It's all mouth service to them.


 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 12.38pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I'm not saying do not investigate mistakes, and don't hold those to account for their mistakes. but no thought has been given to quite what a difficult and unprecedented job that these people have had to do.

I'm not saying that under different Leadership it would not have been different, but different does not equal better.
A firebreak may have helped in your situation, but hindered others (although on the surface, it does appear to be economy over public health) Whats to say, for example, that if we had a firebreak then more businesses go under, this will lead to more poverty leading to more deaths. Ok, not Covid deaths, but deaths caused by the decision Of a government all the same. That's for an enquiry to decide.
And as for opposition Parties, I've no inclination to go back to see what they were saying - their job description appears to be 'disagree with those in power'. It does not mean that that is what they would have done if they were in the same situation. It's all mouth service to them.


I didn't find it unprecedented. I had written a policy for pandemic management many years ago after the first SARS. I was also used to managing in a crisis, for example the underground bombings.

The Government, it seems, had not learned such lessons.

It beggars belief that you say it wasn't THAT badly managed or it's not really the fault of leadership.

Before the pandemic we were assessed as in a better position than almost any other country to survive a pandemic and cope well. We have a 2.9% case fatality rate and 192 deaths per hundred thousand population. More than Colombia.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 27 May 21 1.08pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I didn't find it unprecedented. I had written a policy for pandemic management many years ago after the first SARS. I was also used to managing in a crisis, for example the underground bombings.

The Government, it seems, had not learned such lessons.

It beggars belief that you say it wasn't THAT badly managed or it's not really the fault of leadership.

Before the pandemic we were assessed as in a better position than almost any other country to survive a pandemic and cope well. We have a 2.9% case fatality rate and 192 deaths per hundred thousand population. More than Colombia.

Hold on. Surely a plan to deal with a Pandemic is not a party issue, neither would it have been written recently. We have known about pandemics for a long time.

You can't blame this government for having no blueprint to fall back on, as much as you would like to.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 1.50pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Hold on. Surely a plan to deal with a Pandemic is not a party issue, neither would it have been written recently. We have known about pandemics for a long time.

You can't blame this government for having no blueprint to fall back on, as much as you would like to.

Just take a look at Exercise Cygnus and its recommendations.

The plan isn't a party issue initially but how the plan is implemented certainly is. And, moreover, making sure each area of the response teams is properly ready is the responsibility of the Minister, no question.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 1.52pm

10 January 2020

WHO issued a comprehensive package of technical guidance online with advice to all countries on how to detect, test and manage potential cases, based on what was known about the virus at the time. This guidance was shared with WHO's regional emergency directors to share with WHO representatives in countries.

Based on experience with SARS and MERS and known modes of transmission of respiratory viruses, infection and prevention control guidance were published to protect health workers recommending droplet and contact precautions when caring for patients, and airborne precautions for aerosol generating procedures conducted by health workers.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 1.57pm

[Link]

A House of Lords committee has concluded years of underfunding left local services ill equipped to cope and “fundamental weaknesses” must be tackled to make services resilient enough to withstand future crises.

Which Government was in charge during these years?

So a weakened infrastructure plus an incredibly slow response to the warnings. Compare with South East Asian countries for example.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 27 May 21 1.59pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I didn't find it unprecedented. I had written a policy for pandemic management many years ago after the first SARS. I was also used to managing in a crisis, for example the underground bombings.

The Government, it seems, had not learned such lessons.

It beggars belief that you say it wasn't THAT badly managed or it's not really the fault of leadership.

Before the pandemic we were assessed as in a better position than almost any other country to survive a pandemic and cope well. We have a 2.9% case fatality rate and 192 deaths per hundred thousand population. More than Colombia.

he Labour Government of 2003 should have created the pandemic policy after the first SARS outbreak Then, should they not?
a tad unfair to point fingers at the current incumbents for not having The foresight to create a pandemic policy for that.

I'm also not commenting on how badly or well it was managed, more that people are quick to find blame and slow on praise for the efforts that people have made.
It's very easy to say that someone could have done better. Who's to say that they could have done given the same decisions in the same circumstances.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 2.05pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

he Labour Government of 2003 should have created the pandemic policy after the first SARS outbreak Then, should they not?
a tad unfair to point fingers at the current incumbents for not having The foresight to create a pandemic policy for that.

I'm also not commenting on how badly or well it was managed, more that people are quick to find blame and slow on praise for the efforts that people have made.
It's very easy to say that someone could have done better. Who's to say that they could have done given the same decisions in the same circumstances.

No point in debating with you if you don't take evidence into account.

The plan was in place. It was found lacking in 2016. Many areas of weakness weren't addressed. The plan was then poorly implemented, partially due to Ministry weaknesses which were pointed out in Exercise Cygnet.

 

Page 10 of 14 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Cummings turns on Boris.