You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Signings On The Way
November 22 2026 3.23pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Signings On The Way


Page 106 of 161 < 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 >
mattteo Flag 11 Sep 20 10.22am

Originally posted by Bullhorn76

Why bother ppl still call him James Tompkins and he’s been at palace 2-3 years now

True,I did write Tompkins a couple of times, I admit )))

I don't know why I thought his name was written like that!!

 

mattteo Flag 11 Sep 20 10.25am

About BOS, can he be called a prospect anymore? He's 23. At this age he should have been a certainty. Even if he comes to Palace, he'll definitely stay 2-3 years before making a jump to a bigger club, so he'll be 25-26 at least. Sure, one could say he's still a prospect and possible investment, but I just like many 23 year old much better.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 11 Sep 20 10.49am

Sarr comfortably the most exciting player on that list even at that price. For me he's comparable in ability to Wilf and 5 years younger, so asking half of what we want for Wilf doesn't seem that unreasonable.

Wilf doesn't want to be here. If we could get 60m for him and recruit Sarr and Benrahma I'd bite your hand off for it.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 11 Sep 20 10.52am

Originally posted by mattteo

True,I did write Tompkins a couple of times, I admit )))

I don't know why I thought his name was written like that!!


Don't worry Mattteo, you're not the only one by a long chalk. Also How many people only give you 2 instead of 3ts?

As to BOS and his age, firstly, I haven't seen him play so I don't know whether or not he is a good prospect. However, in general terms:
1. Players develop at different ages
2. Some 23 year olds aren't going to get any better
3. a 23 year old bought for a few million can be sold at a reasonable profit when he's 26/27 if he does develop and shows he's can play at this level.
4. I know you follow a lot of overseas players, but many overseas players - even the good ones, fail to make the grade in the PL or don't live up to the hype. For example, Angel De Maria has been great for PSG but was not so good for Man U. Same applied to Depay. Kepa isn't the keeper Chelsea hoped he'd be, and there are many other examples. In other words, whilst taking a Championship player has risks attached, taking an overseas player has more risks imo.
5. The question re BOS is whether or not he's reached his potential. If he hasn't then he's surely worth a punt. I take the point that he seems to be very one-footed. That's not the end of the world.

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 11 Sep 20 11.18am

BOS is 22

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 11 Sep 20 11.20am

If I were to pick 2 it would be Sarr & Benhrama

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Sep 20 11.20am

Originally posted by Bullhorn76

Why bother ppl still call him James Tompkins and he’s been at palace 2-3 years now

Did Tompkins join after Bolaise left?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 11 Sep 20 11.25am

Originally posted by mattteo

There are big differences though:

Ismaila Sarr is very good for his age, but....38-40 million (!!)

Deulofeu...good player, but hasn't played all season...and he doesn't cost like 2-3 million either

Osayi-Samuel...don't really find him exciting, very one-sided, soon to be 23,hasn't done too much on the Championship until 23

Benrahma...good, but pretty short and bulk, doesn't (can't) run very much or fast coming back with the side defender of the opposing team

I'd add Florinel Coman too, cause he has been rumoured,but he also doesn't come back with his man fast enough and costs 15 million.

Edited by mattteo (11 Sep 2020 9.29am)

Benrahma “bulk”? Please tell me you are not saying he is bulky!! I am afraid I cannot agree with your assessment of him nor does my son who has just completed a football scouting course which involved writing reports on numerous players worldwide, Benrahma was one. He is a very good footballer who would be an extremely good fit for Palace. If you watch him for a whole game he covers a lot of ground

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 11 Sep 20 11.29am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Benrahma “bulk”? Please tell me you are not saying he is bulky!! I am afraid I cannot agree with your assessment of him nor does my son who has just completed a football scouting course which involved writing reports on numerous players worldwide, Benrahma was one. He is a very good footballer who would be an extremely good fit for Palace. If you watch him for a whole game he covers a lot of ground

If a footballer who is 5ft 8 and weighs 10st 5 is considered bulky, I would suggest there is not a professional footballer anywhere who isn’t

 

taylors lovechild Flag 11 Sep 20 11.43am

My issue is that Benrahma prefers to operate on the left, whereas we are crying out for competition on the right. Although he can play there, surely it would be better to go for either Sarr (if we can afford him) or the young QPR lad if we can't, with both preferring to operate down the right. It looks like Eze's role will at least start out as a left-midfielder with the freedom to roam when in possession (he has even stated this himself), plus this is also where Schlupp plays. So this coupled with the sizeable fee that will likely be demanded for Benrahma means I just don't see it as happening. I think we'll get BOS with the view that he'll keep Andros on his toes without breaking the bank.

 

mattteo Flag 11 Sep 20 11.54am

Originally posted by doombear

4. I know you follow a lot of overseas players, but many overseas players - even the good ones, fail to make the grade in the PL or don't live up to the hype. For example, Angel De Maria has been great for PSG but was not so good for Man U. Same applied to Depay.


Well, that's debatable. Imo di Maria was very good, he played well, he just wasn't liked by the manager at the time (I think it was van Haal). If you look at what he did in his time on the pitch,he contributed to a lot of goals.

Depay wasn't that great, but certainly not bad for a 21 year old like he was at the time. You have to take into consideration age. I don't think 10 players under 10 were better than Depay in that year in the whole world of top championships ,but Man United didn't have patience with him.

 

mattteo Flag 11 Sep 20 11.58am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

My issue is that Benrahma prefers to operate on the left, whereas we are crying out for competition on the right. Although he can play there, surely it would be better to go for Sarr .

Sarr has played the entire season on the right for Watford,yes, but I'd prefer a left footer there, if for nothing else, then just for simetry and teaching players the same attacking options both on the right and on the left in training. I made a list if left footed wingers if anyone wants to check that out. plenty from English football.

Before coming tot he PL, Sarr had played quite a lot on thenleft too. I hope he hasn't forgotten how to play there, though 1 year is a lot and close to 40 million is a big gamble.

Meyer for example was a good attacking midfielder, with dozens of assists. Then they forced him to play an entire season as central midfielder at Schalke and he never was the same in an attacking role since. Same could be with Sarr on the left

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 11 Sep 20 12.27pm

Originally posted by doombear


Don't worry Mattteo, you're not the only one by a long chalk. Also How many people only give you 2 instead of 3ts?

As to BOS and his age, firstly, I haven't seen him play so I don't know whether or not he is a good prospect. However, in general terms:
1. Players develop at different ages
2. Some 23 year olds aren't going to get any better
3. a 23 year old bought for a few million can be sold at a reasonable profit when he's 26/27 if he does develop and shows he's can play at this level.
4. I know you follow a lot of overseas players, but many overseas players - even the good ones, fail to make the grade in the PL or don't live up to the hype. For example, Angel De Maria has been great for PSG but was not so good for Man U. Same applied to Depay. Kepa isn't the keeper Chelsea hoped he'd be, and there are many other examples. In other words, whilst taking a Championship player has risks attached, taking an overseas player has more risks imo.
5. The question re BOS is whether or not he's reached his potential. If he hasn't then he's surely worth a punt. I take the point that he seems to be very one-footed. That's not the end of the world.

Not me. I've been trying to get him known as triple T for months now.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 11 Sep 20 12.33pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

My issue is that Benrahma prefers to operate on the left, whereas we are crying out for competition on the right. Although he can play there, surely it would be better to go for either Sarr (if we can afford him) or the young QPR lad if we can't, with both preferring to operate down the right. It looks like Eze's role will at least start out as a left-midfielder with the freedom to roam when in possession (he has even stated this himself), plus this is also where Schlupp plays. So this coupled with the sizeable fee that will likely be demanded for Benrahma means I just don't see it as happening. I think we'll get BOS with the view that he'll keep Andros on his toes without breaking the bank.


Yep - makes sense both in terms of squad balance needs and (in the case of BOS) finances.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 11 Sep 20 12.53pm

Worrying about exactly where some of the muted signings might play , doesnt have to be a major concern. In so much as if last year told us anything it was , our squad was caught well short even to cope with league commitments.
The bottom line is good players will play, not every week obviously , but the schedule and injuries , will ensure that adaptable cover is needed if we are to become an upper half side.
Added to that is the possibility of having more tactical options for certain games and on the bench, something missing in a lot of Palaces match’s . Instead of merely replacing tired legs , a change of tactic might be achieved.

Edited by Putitout (11 Sep 2020 1.01pm)

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 11 Sep 20 1.37pm

Originally posted by mattteo


Sarr has played the entire season on the right for Watford,yes, but I'd prefer a left footer there, if for nothing else, then just for simetry and teaching players the same attacking options both on the right and on the left in training.
I made a list if left footed wingers if anyone wants to check that out. plenty from English football.

Before coming tot he PL, Sarr had played quite a lot on thenleft too. I hope he hasn't forgotten how to play there, though 1 year is a lot and close to 40 million is a big gamble.

Meyer for example was a good attacking midfielder, with dozens of assists. Then they forced him to play an entire season as central midfielder at Schalke and he never was the same in an attacking role since. Same could be with Sarr on the left

Totally disagree With you there mattteo.

What we have lacked (especially against teams where we retain a little more of the ball) is width and the ability to get round the back of the full backs and deliver cross for the striker to come onto. The left footed on the right (and vice versa) means we are often coming back inside and playing in front of the opposition. This slows down our attacks and makes us very predictable and much easier to defend against. (And very frustrating to watch)
I know there will be the very odd occasion when the like of Andros will cut in from the right and hit a “worldy” on his left foot - but you can count them on one hand.
This is one of the reasons why CB hasn’t had a look in - although not the only reason. The point I’m making is it doesn’t play to his strengths.

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 11 Sep 20 1.46pm

Personally the idea of having Eze and Benrahma in the same team, with the amount of creativity they managed last season...I’d be over the moon with that.

Coincidentally both of them made the Championship team of the year this week...I think Benrahma is perhaps the only player that hasn’t already moved to the prem from the team of the year.

The kicker is I don’t see us signing Benrahma unless we lose Wilf.

 

mattteo Flag 11 Sep 20 2.46pm

Originally posted by Elphers40

Totally disagree With you there mattteo.

What we have lacked (especially against teams where we retain a little more of the ball) is width and the ability to get round the back of the full backs and deliver cross for the striker to come onto.


Yeah, but that can also be done with inverted wingers. And even better. Cause when they create space by going on the inside, if you have a good or great fullback who comes very fast, he has the space to cross very dangerously from the advanced winger position, catching the opposing defence off guard.

If you have a right footed winger on the right side, he will almost never dribble on the inside,so our fullback won't have the space to sprint into.

Course, we ought to have great offensive fullbacks for yhis too. Well, PVA is one, but on the right...not so much, as Ward,Ferguson or Kelly are all very defensive.

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 11 Sep 20 3.56pm

Originally posted by mattteo


Yeah, but that can also be done with inverted wingers. And even better. Cause when they create space by going on the inside, if you have a good or great fullback who comes very fast, he has the space to cross very dangerously from the advanced winger position, catching the opposing defence off guard.

If you have a right footed winger on the right side, he will almost never dribble on the inside,so our fullback won't have the space to sprint into.

Course, we ought to have great offensive fullbacks for yhis too. Well, PVA is one, but on the right...not so much, as Ward,Ferguson or Kelly are all very defensive.

LOL Ferguson looks very attack minded to me. He’s got natural pace and good control of the ball. Scored on his debut as well for West Brom. All the potential there for him being an attacking full back.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 11 Sep 20 4.03pm

Originally posted by Hudsoneagle

LOL Ferguson looks very attack minded to me. He’s got natural pace and good control of the ball. Scored on his debut as well for West Brom. All the potential there for him being an attacking full back.


Let's hope so. 3ts main point, though, is valid regarding inverted wingers - they work if you have the full backs to use the space. It's worked for us on occasions on the left with Wilf & PvA but a total waste on the right BUT the future looks a little brighter!

Edited by doombear (11 Sep 2020 4.05pm)

 

Page 106 of 161 < 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Signings On The Way