You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Who is to blame?
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who is to blame?


Page 11 of 22 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 16 Dec 19 2.36pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Yet again you are posting your ideals as fact and as usual it's all Bollox.

People vote for a variety of different reasons whether that fits in with your ideals or not. A woman on Radio 5 this morning said that she voted Labour because she always had done and so had her family. Should I have telephoned in and told her that she was wrong as Wisbech Eagle said so?

There were also rumours a few years ago that many women voted Labour because their new leader was good looking and certainly many people were put off voting Conservative as they didn't like Theresa May.

Please stop posting your ideas and opinions as fact

Not for the first time you are either totally misunderstanding or misrepresenting my views. Just in case it's the first I will very patiently, politely and carefully explain them again, without the mindless abuse that so many here seem to favour.

Of course people often just vote for a party and might not even remember the name of the person they have chosen. They might decide to vote for a person simply because of their gender or looks. None of that is in dispute. It has nothing to do with my or anyone else's "ideals".

The fact remains that however a voter reaches their decision the result is that a representative of every constituency is returned whose job it is to represent ALL of the people in their constituency in Parliament and use their conscience to determine what is in their, and the country's, best interests.

If that were not true we may as well just return voting machines and save ourselves an awful lot of money.

We need the collective wisdom of all our MPs to be brought to bear on the issues of the day. Of course there needs to be some structure and organisation to ensure things move forward and constant gridlock is avoided. However, for issues of major constitutional or legal importance it ought to be mandatory that a free vote be taken in secret so that the true belief of the whole House is what determines whether a proposal passes or fails. Using the whip, the threat of it being withdrawn and subsequent deselection, in the way that was done prior to the election, is ultimately in no one's interest other than the party managers and strategists.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Dec 19 2.46pm

Originally posted by W12

Labour lost because they have become a Marxist cult and are followed and represented by people of the "quality" of Owen Jones, David Lammmy, Ash Sarkar, numerous vacuous celebrities and all manor of people that live rarefied and privileged lives and are totally out of touch with the rest of society (as they almost never mix with working class people) . The British people also have a 6th sense for sniffing out extremists (and were continuously insulted and demonized by those people already mentioned).

Tories won because they were the only Brexit party and Boris appealed to people who still consider themselves patriotic (i.e. most)

Lib Fems failed because they sum up all that's wrong with the hyper liberal virtue signalling elite and equally out of touch as Labour.

Christ knows why the SNP did so well, I'm very disappointing in the jocks.

I would dissolve the union, as David Starkey pointed out recently it's been a case of 3 tails (Wales, Ireland and especially Scotland) wagging the dog for years as England is over 80% of the UK population and is the only country without it's own parliament yet is also the economic powerhouse. All of those countries are a drain on our economy and have far more socialist tendencies (although I have sympathy and solidarity with Irish unionists).

We need a revival of the English constitution with the concepts of individual rights, the rule of law, freedom of speech, freedom of association etc at the forefront of our thinking and education. These are the fundamentals that were key to creating the entire western modern world.

Most of all though we probably need a new youth counter culture of free thinking, facts and realism as our youth is currently lost to ideology.

Excellent post.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Dec 19 2.49pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Not for the first time you are either totally misunderstanding or misrepresenting my views. Just in case it's the first I will very patiently, politely and carefully explain them again, without the mindless abuse that so many here seem to favour.

Of course people often just vote for a party and might not even remember the name of the person they have chosen. They might decide to vote for a person simply because of their gender or looks. None of that is in dispute. It has nothing to do with my or anyone else's "ideals".

The fact remains that however a voter reaches their decision the result is that a representative of every constituency is returned whose job it is to represent ALL of the people in their constituency in Parliament and use their conscience to determine what is in their, and the country's, best interests.

If that were not true we may as well just return voting machines and save ourselves an awful lot of money.

We need the collective wisdom of all our MPs to be brought to bear on the issues of the day. Of course there needs to be some structure and organisation to ensure things move forward and constant gridlock is avoided. However, for issues of major constitutional or legal importance it ought to be mandatory that a free vote be taken in secret so that the true belief of the whole House is what determines whether a proposal passes or fails. Using the whip, the threat of it being withdrawn and subsequent deselection, in the way that was done prior to the election, is ultimately in no one's interest other than the party managers and strategists.

We have a party system because we are essentially a tribal society. Even if you removed the party system, alliances would form based on various views and self interests. Therefore the good of the alliance tends to come before the individual whatever its nature.
The electorate vote for a colour for the same reason.
The very existence of the mob you belong to demonstrates this perfectly. You reject one type of tribalism and create another.
There might be instances where people vote for a specific candidate but that is very much a minority attitude and is usually based on self interest regarding local issues.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Dec 19 2.53pm

Originally posted by silvertop


1. Not sure I agree with that Becky. The number of remain voters exceeded the number of leave voters. However, first past the post (check the comparative votes per seat ratio) and the spread of remain among more parties created the illusion of a mandate.

Labour's position wasn't remain, it was fudge.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 16 Dec 19 2.59pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Wisbech that is your opinion not everyone agrees with it. Unless I am mistakened not one of the MPs who changed parties was re-elected they either retired or lost. You have an idealised version of what Parliament should be and in theory it would be great if it worked that way.

But as I just posted on the Brexit thread for example Labour's position to oppose any Tory Brexit deal before it had even been negotiated is the reality of Parliament.

Politicians are partisan and oppose the other side even when the other side is talking sense.

By all means continue to call for MPs to be independent of the party machine but you will be howling in the wind. I wish you luck it's not a bad thing if it ever happened.

A more realistic solution is to vote for independent MPs. I have a friend who is an independent councillor in Froome where all seats are held by local independent people and the public love it.

I am very well aware that there are few on here who agree with me for the obvious reason that this place is dominated by a particular viewpoint. That though doesn't mean that I am wrong or there aren't others in the wider world who do agree, although I freely acknowledge that it is a subject that needs more exposure to become better understood. Something which a large Tory majority may well produce. We face a long period without any kind of effective opposition. Lord Grade just suggested on Radio 4 that as the BBC would be filling that role in the coming years with their responsibility for critical analysis, we can anticipate further Tory attacks on them and threats to their independence. I think he may well be right.

Yes my views are idealistic but where is the downside of that? We ought to aspire to the ideal whilst being pragmatic in how we approach it. If we can improve the way things work then we should. If there is a drift towards an undesirable situation which puts too much power in the hands of an elite unseen few, of whatever political stripe, then we all ought to oppose it, whatever our own politics might be.

Unless the funding basis for elections was totally changed we could never see enough independents in Parliament to hold power.

My own County Councillor is an independent and a friend of mine. He is very active locally and extremely visible, attending local events, meetings, pub quizzes and football matches. He also chairs the planning committee. He does a cracking job and is returned each election by a overwhelming majority. Politically we share many views. He cannot understand why so many in Cornwall voted to leave when EU funding has been so important to the economy here and he is extremely concerned about the impact of Brexit. He is, of course, better placed to understand this than most others.

Edited by Wisbech Eagle (16 Dec 2019 3.01pm)

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Dec 19 3.03pm

Originally posted by Matov

Depends. For my money all that flag-waving and wearing silly costumes is more an expression of a lack of confidence in your national identity. The patriotic equivilent of people obsessed with designer labels and so on.

English nationalism will be about seizing power. About taking control of specifically English only institutions. Not an exercise in Morris dancing and eating Pork Pies.

And not necessarily a guarantee that the Right would triumph. A strong case could be made for a new manifestation of England being a Republic. Even full-on socialist.

I get peoples ire about why other displays of nationalism are cheered on whilst English ones are treated with disdain but I would urge a little caution around making it a defining issue. I know of Irish people who find all the hype around St Patricks day to be more than patronising and certainly not representing how they see the modern Irish state.

English nationalism worries me because it appeals so much to the part of me that craves radical change. Perhaps this might be self-regarding nonsense but having learnt the hard way that the saying 'be careful for what you wish' is rooted in our collective psyches for good reason.

I would urge you relish the contempt of the left. Turn it around and rub their faces in it because as things stand, at least for today, our side is winning. Celebrate that because these things can change in a heart beat.


I get some of these concerns, though I differ.

Nationalism is a concept, a stereotype, and like all stereotypes it suffers from generalization. It exists as a binding force for commonalities.

That's said, holistically it's all rather binary. Without English nationalism....within a global system the English will wither and fade away into the genetic grey.

Japan are an example of an island race who saw that possibility and successfully placed blocks in the way.

What you won't advocate for you will eventually lose anyway.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 16 Dec 19 3.06pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

We have a party system because we are essentially a tribal society. Even if you removed the party system, alliances would form based on various views and self interests. Therefore the good of the alliance tends to come before the individual whatever its nature.
The electorate vote for a colour for the same reason.
The very existence of the mob you belong to demonstrates this perfectly. You reject one type of tribalism and create another.
There might be instances where people vote for a specific candidate but that is very much a minority attitude and is usually based on self interest regarding local issues.

All true (except the bit about being a member of a "mob".

True, but besides the point.

That you think it is just shows that you don't understand it.

It isn't why people vote as they do, but the responsibility of the MP they choose that matters.

To repeat my old mantra. MPs are NOT delegates. They are representatives.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Dec 19 3.16pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

All true (except the bit about being a member of a "mob".

True, but besides the point.

That you think it is just shows that you don't understand it.

It isn't why people vote as they do, but the responsibility of the MP they choose that matters.

To repeat my old mantra. MPs are NOT delegates. They are representatives.

This might well be true but the caliber of the MP is not much of a consideration for most in a general election. Their responsibility exists be they are worthy of it or not.

I don't see how you can deny that an organisation that has its own website and list of aims is not another alliance whether you consider the term 'mob' appropriate or not. You can dress it up as whatever you like.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Dec 19 3.23pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

All true (except the bit about being a member of a "mob".

True, but besides the point.

That you think it is just shows that you don't understand it.

It isn't why people vote as they do, but the responsibility of the MP they choose that matters.

To repeat my old mantra. MPs are NOT delegates. They are representatives.

In nearly every post you have written today, you have insinuated that certain posters on here are wrong and do not understand. That, of course, is your prerogative. You have also criticised them for not saying , they might be wrong. I cannot recall you saying you might be wrong. You do talk down to people and act like you always know best, before bemoaning how people reply to you, perhaps take a long hard look in a mirror.

 

becky Flag over the moon 16 Dec 19 3.39pm

Originally posted by Matov

English nationalism will be about seizing power. About taking control of specifically English only institutions. Not an exercise in Morris dancing and eating Pork Pies.

....not that there is anything wrong with Morris dancing and eating pork pies, eh?

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Dec 19 3.43pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

In nearly every post you have written today, you have insinuated that certain posters on here are wrong and do not understand. That, of course, is your prerogative. You have also criticised them for not saying , they might be wrong. I cannot recall you saying you might be wrong. You do talk down to people and act like you always know best, before bemoaning how people reply to you, perhaps take a long hard look in a mirror.

Sounds like Ash Sarkar, the communist activist. ‘The politics is right, the people are wrong.’ Some people never grow out of student thinking. Some people will always be the same. They can’t change.

 


COYP

chris123 Flag hove actually 16 Dec 19 3.44pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

All true (except the bit about being a member of a "mob".

True, but besides the point.

That you think it is just shows that you don't understand it.

It isn't why people vote as they do, but the responsibility of the MP they choose that matters.

To repeat my old mantra. MPs are NOT delegates. They are representatives.

They represent their parties.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 16 Dec 19 3.56pm

Extreme non PC & Snowflake/leftie upsetting, BUT, its over.

Voting done, people spoke(voted), Ruskies didnt get a look in(not as enjoyable as the US), can the 'losers' now accept this defeat & let this country get back to what it was & should be(oh, & out of Europe).

Just saying

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 16 Dec 19 4.06pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

All true (except the bit about being a member of a "mob".

True, but besides the point.

That you think it is just shows that you don't understand it.

It isn't why people vote as they do, but the responsibility of the MP they choose that matters.

To repeat my old mantra. MPs are NOT delegates. They are representatives.

From the UK Parliament Website

"The UK public elects Members of Parliament (MPs) to represent their interests and concerns in the House of Commons. MPs consider and can propose new laws as well as raising issues that matter to you in the House. This includes asking government ministers questions about current issues including those which affect local constituents"

The point being is that if they are to represent the people then voting during a bill to remain when you represent a leave constituency is not democratic.

Ignoring the national basis then if an MP is representing on a local level this goes against the grain too.

I notice your mention of your friend who is a local county councillor who is also the Chair of the Planning Committee and can't understand why so many voted for Brexit.

Here's a clue for you - he probably hasn't got a low cost housing estate going up in his road.

You accuse everyone else of living in a bubble, yet can acknowledge no viewpoint but your own and I've always tended to find talking down to someone isn't the way to engage them.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 16 Dec 19 4.33pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

The guy who suggests I promoted "elitism" has no idea what he is talking about. Believing in the supremacy of Parliament and for our elected representatives to be free to decide for themselves what is best for their constituents, and the country as a whole, is not elitism. It is a belief in democracy itself and not in the drift towards the kind of pseudo dictatorship we are witnessing. If there is any elitism to be seen it's to be found there, in the hands of those wielding the levers and taking the behind the scenes decisions whilst the system whips the sheep through the lobbies.

Johnson wasn't chosen by his MPs at all. It was the 200,000 or so Tory party members who did that. Who selected the candidates is another question but my understanding is that they all had to commit to supporting the manifesto 100% or they would not be chosen. So much for the one nation "broad church" Tory party of old. It's now bleat our way or you will be in the abattoir tomorrow.

Stirling could be a gal.
That's not very PC wissie.
That's an example of where we be with labour by the way.
Do you see why the tories are a better fit atm.
Give the police some self respect and ability to do their job. Not arrest people for clapping too loud.
etc etc.
Left wing politics doesnt fit in right now.
Far left even less so.
If BJ doesnt follow through you and yours can call him out on election night in 5 years.
At least sit back, sip your chardonnay and watch it fall apart if that's your foresight.
It's very disingenuous to predict epic failure on day 3 tbh.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Dec 19 4.57pm

Originally posted by becky

....not that there is anything wrong with Morris dancing and eating pork pies, eh?

I love pork pies. Not so keen on Scotch eggs.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Dec 19 5.09pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I love pork pies. Not so keen on Scotch eggs.

Where do you stand on those pork pie slices with the egg in the middle?

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Dec 19 5.11pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Where do you stand on those pork pie slices with the egg in the middle?

Not my cup of tea. I prefer the Melton Mowbray originals.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Dec 19 5.13pm

Originally posted by cryrst



Stirling could be a gal.

That's not very PC wissie.
That's an example of where we be with labour by the way.
Do you see why the tories are a better fit atm.
Give the police some self respect and ability to do their job. Not arrest people for clapping too loud.
etc etc.
Left wing politics doesnt fit in right now.
Far left even less so.
If BJ doesnt follow through you and yours can call him out on election night in 5 years.
At least sit back, sip your chardonnay and watch it fall apart if that's your foresight.
It's very disingenuous to predict epic failure on day 3 tbh.

I could be......but it's not Wednesday.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Beanyboysmd Flag 16 Dec 19 5.14pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

For what I expect you to ask and that, of course, depends on your perspective.

If you voted Tory then right now maybe you feel only celebrations are in order, but I am not so sure. Since the size of the majority was known just about everyone has suggested this means that Johnson's new government can sideline the ERG, ignore Farage and pursue a much softer Brexit deal. Something they must do if they stand any chance of reaching a deal in 12 months. Along with the fact that many of their new MPs come from constituencies with very different priorities to their southern heartlands this could well mean a move to the centre is about to happen, something seemingly confirmed today by Johnson himself.

For a hardline Brexiteer this has to be a disaster. Who is to blame? Farage is! If he hadn't tried (and succeeded) to spike the LibDems in the south by standing down all those candidates, the Tory majority would have been much smaller, and he might even have had a handful of his own MPs. With a smaller majority Johnson would need the ERG onside and his room for maneuver would be much less. If we now get a soft Brexit then you can blame Farage.

If you are a remainer then the blame falls on several heads. Cameron for his miscalculation but mostly on Corbyn for choosing to stay as Labour leader when it was obvious that he is so unpopular that failure was inevitable. The opportunity existed a few months ago to remove Johnson, install a temporary PM and a cross party government of national unity with the sole purpose of holding a confirmatory vote on whether the country wanted the "deal" or now wanted to remain. It only required Corbyn to agree and then stand aside. His stubbornness is to blame for the fact that although even with this landslide result more people voted for a party that wanted such a vote than did not, we still don't get one.

The other thing to blame is our out of date voting system which is no longer fit for purpose. Many, if not most, people seem to have voted against something rather than for it. This isn't healthy in a democracy. We need people to vote for what they want and for that to be proportionately represented in the Parliament so that compromises can be reached by our representatives.

This is a watershed moment in the UK's political life. A united Ireland now looks a racing certainty to me in the next 10 years. Scotland looks less certain but will be a continuing thorn.

I am not though without hope. The coming days and weeks will tell a lot. If Johnson reshuffles and sends the likes of Rees Mogg and Patel to the back benches then he will have made a good start. I hope Labour totally collapses and that a new centre left party emerges, funded by both more moderate unions, and socially responsible wealthy citizens and businesses. Whether the current LibDems provide the foundations for such a development is an open question, given the failed attempt by the 2 Davids almost 40 years ago but we need such a party now as never before. There are many wonderful politicians who would immediately fit into such a party. All they need is the structure.

So I don't vote for any of the main parties but I am very much a leftie, but the numbers involved are interesting. The vote between left and right parties were about even (Its been that way for a long time now) so a first past the post system will never suit anyone but the right. Wierdly if the Brexit party didn't s*** the bed at the last minute then we could have been looking at a hung parliament right now.

Labours demise could have been predicted if people had paid more attention to Scotland. Voting intentions for Labour were nose-diving for the last year and most people predicted that northern England was starting to drift the same way.

Labour had 2 choices, stop the Tories or stop brexit. They tried to stop Brexit and failed at both. Nobody who wanted Brexit wanted another referendum and even a lot of remainers weren't keen. Telling 60% of your constituents that you know better was a terminal mistake.

If Corbyn had said "We agree with the Tories on Brexit, we will try to get a better deal and if we cant, we will use the terms that May or Johnson got". It would have been a strait out battle on non-brexit issues. Even with Corbyns problems with his past I think he would probably have edged in.

He just didn't learn from the LibDems, they announced they would hold a 2nd referendum or yank us out of Brexit and even remainers didn't switch to them.

Tories only gained 1% more than before and that election was seen as a disaster so this wasnt a case of the Tories doing something right, it was a simple case of Labour getting things horribly wrong by resonating with the wrong people.

On the subject of Northern Ireland and Scotland, until the next polls come in, its going to be really hard to know where they stand, I am still scratching my head on how Scotland democratically get Independence now,which I hate. Its a painfully childish approach that borders on turning your phone off in case your girlfriend dumps you. Cameron only let them ask the question because polls had yes at about 25% at the time, they wont make that mistake again.

With Northern Ireland its out of Westminster hands so they can have one whenever they want but before the election the numbers were short, don't expect change though because no proud Brit is going to decide they want to be Irish no matter what politics are going on in the background.

Farage is going to move to America and make a fortune being a public speaker, he hasnt given a toss about any of this for a long time. He will pop back if he wants attention or money but he will check out any day now.

God Ive talked a lot and not really said anything! Tried to be as impartial as I can be but there is no such thing as an impartial thought really!

 

Page 11 of 22 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Who is to blame?