You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I Love Croydon-Roy
November 19 2026 4.55pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

I Love Croydon-Roy


Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Plaistow Eagle Flag 16 May 21 5.33pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt


I don't think there's specifically a 'Roy in' brigade. It's more a case of people who are merely reacting to the sheer ignorant idiocy of some of the more deluded folks who have no concept of the ins and outs of managing a squadful of egos and who want him out.

So I’m an ignorant idiot am I..!!

Yep well if that’s your level of reasoned debate - enough said..!!

I’ll leave it there..!!

COYP

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 16 May 21 5.37pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

So I’m an ignorant idiot am I..!!

Yep well if that’s your level of reasoned debate - enough said..!!

I’ll leave it there..!!

COYP

I said 'some of'. Yours was not a name that sprang to mind when I said it.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 16 May 21 5.42pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

So I’m an ignorant idiot am I..!!

Yep well if that’s your level of reasoned debate - enough said..!!

I’ll leave it there..!!

COYP

well i am ignorant, i am struggling to remember Palace managers better than Roy ( and loyal) in the last 20 years.

and also struggling to see the young 'Boy Wonder' who will swing in and start miracles at Selhurst.

ignorant indeed

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Plaistow Eagle Flag 16 May 21 6.03pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

well i am ignorant, i am struggling to remember Palace managers better than Roy ( and loyal) in the last 20 years.

and also struggling to see the young 'Boy Wonder' who will swing in and start miracles at Selhurst.

ignorant indeed

Never said there were any better in the last 20 years did I..??"

In fact I said - say thanks to Roy for all he has done, but time to move on.

On "Boy Wonder" - how do you know unless you try something/someone different..!!

What's your plan - to keep 73 year old Roy irrespective of declining results and performances, then what more of the same for another year - is that really a plan for the future..??

COYP

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 16 May 21 6.04pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

I said 'some of'. Yours was not a name that sprang to mind when I said it.

So then why reply to me..??

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 16 May 21 6.05pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Yeah but you miss the obvious thing there - unless young Managers are given opportunities how do they create a track record..??

Are you suggesting that we should only ever appoint aged Managers..!!

Like all things in life all good things come to an end and IMO we’ve reached that stage with Roy.

COYP

..we all understand that quite a few of our players are not going to be able to compete for another full season, don't know why you feel this has anything to do with our manager.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 16 May 21 6.10pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

So then why reply to me..??

Because you posited the existence of a 'Roy in brigade'. I felt it merited a response. Is that ok?

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Plaistow Eagle Flag 16 May 21 6.11pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

..we all understand that quite a few of our players are not going to be able to compete for another full season, don't know why you feel this has anything to do with our manager.

Huh..??

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 16 May 21 6.17pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Never said there were any better in the last 20 years did I..??"

In fact I said - say thanks to Roy for all he has done, but time to move on.

On "Boy Wonder" - how do you know unless you try something/someone different..!!

What's your plan - to keep 73 year old Roy irrespective of declining results and performances, then what more of the same for another year - is that really a plan for the future..??

COYP

Our future is to survive until further notice of increased funds to allow otherwise.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 16 May 21 6.52pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle


Think actually it’s the other way around - every time we have a half decent result or performance the so called “Roy In” brigade appear en masse...!!

Yet when we’re being beaten 7-0 at home by Liverpool, 3-0:against Aston Villa away against 10 men and dire after dire performances in succession are being produced they are nowhere to be seen or heard from..!!

Conversely as today proves my opinion remains constant - irrespective of the result the trend has been on the downward curve for the last 18 months and IMO a more expansive and dynamic Manager would have got/will get more out of this squad than Roy.

That’s my opinion and I’ve been consistent in saying it.

Nothing against Roy he’s done a great job but IMO it’s time to say thanks and move on..!!

COYP


Look at the final placing and points gained after 38 games last season. Then look at the current table. Then admit your opinion is not based on actual fact.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Plaistow Eagle Flag 16 May 21 7.46pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Look at the final placing and points gained after 38 games last season. Then look at the current table. Then admit your opinion is not based on actual fact.

Neillo - I can see entirely where you are going with this - so at the end of the season we are comfortably mid table, so what's all the fuss about..??

Which is a true analogy - if you believe that the end justify the means..!!

Then beyond that and probably more relevant if those means are sustainable and therein lies the problem - IMO they are not..!!

LBH - we've had some really lucky results this season e.g. Brighton away for one and then at the start of the season we caught a few teams cold with minimal pre-season preparation.

In between times there have been some really horrific/ turgid performances, where at times we have been tactically totally inept and that's due to Roy.

So IMO it's a simple question do you believe that Roy and his "conservative" and "defence first" tactics, despite us having the 4th worst defensive record in the league is the way forward..

Or do you think a new more expansive Manager with different and more creative ideas is the way to go.

I'm in the latter camp - IMO Roy's race is run and done - but as I said that's my opinion..!!

Today would suggest that when the defensive shackles are released we are a far better team and certainly more entertaining to watch..!!

But it comes down to whether you believe that Roy will continue and build on performances like today or just revert to type..!!

My opinion of Roy is that he just too stubborn and will always revert to type.

Hence I believe it's time for change and that time is now..!!

COYP

 

PatrickA Flag London 16 May 21 8.17pm

Agree with this 100%.
Can anybody dispute that today’s second half was an atypical performance when compared to our performances under Hodgson over the last 18 months?
It was a bonus to win the game, but for me the most pleasing aspect was to see how we committed players forward and the amount of efforts we had on goal.
We played with fire and purpose for a change which has become all too rare under Hodgson.
It’s no coincidence that Benteke scores when crosses are actually provided to him.
It’s not as if Hodgson’s caution and conservatism has made us defensively sound and solid with lots of 1-0 wins.
And yes I understand that his methods have amassed us enough points to stay in the league another year and I’m also aware about being careful what I wish for.
And I’ve supported the club over 50 years and watched us in the old Division 3 so am not an aspirational newbie who expects us to be challenging for the top 6.

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Neillo - I can see entirely where you are going with this - so at the end of the season we are comfortably mid table, so what's all the fuss about..??

Which is a true analogy - if you believe that the end justify the means..!!

Then beyond that and probably more relevant if those means are sustainable and therein lies the problem - IMO they are not..!!

LBH - we've had some really lucky results this season e.g. Brighton away for one and then at the start of the season we caught a few teams cold with minimal pre-season preparation.

In between times there have been some really horrific/ turgid performances, where at times we have been tactically totally inept and that's due to Roy.

So IMO it's a simple question do you believe that Roy and his "conservative" and "defence first" tactics, despite us having the 4th worst defensive record in the league is the way forward..

Or do you think a new more expansive Manager with different and more creative ideas is the way to go.

I'm in the latter camp - IMO Roy's race is run and done - but as I said that's my opinion..!!

Today would suggest that when the defensive shackles are released we are a far better team and certainly more entertaining to watch..!!

But it comes down to whether you believe that Roy will continue and build on performances like today or just revert to type..!!

My opinion of Roy is that he just too stubborn and will always revert to type.

Hence I believe it's time for change and that time is now..!!

COYP

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 16 May 21 9.04pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Agree with this 100%.
Can anybody dispute that today’s second half was an atypical performance when compared to our performances under Hodgson over the last 18 months?
It was a bonus to win the game, but for me the most pleasing aspect was to see how we committed players forward and the amount of efforts we had on goal.
We played with fire and purpose for a change which has become all too rare under Hodgson.
It’s no coincidence that Benteke scores when crosses are actually provided to him.
It’s not as if Hodgson’s caution and conservatism has made us defensively sound and solid with lots of 1-0 wins.
And yes I understand that his methods have amassed us enough points to stay in the league another year and I’m also aware about being careful what I wish for.
And I’ve supported the club over 50 years and watched us in the old Division 3 so am not an aspirational newbie who expects us to be challenging for the top 6.

I'm tempted to think that the players at half time decided amongst themselves to disregard Hodgson's instructions and just go for it, such was the amount of red and blue shirts I saw in forward positions.

 

glazedallover Flag Allier 16 May 21 9.08pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I'm tempted to think that the players at half time decided amongst themselves to disregard Hodgson's instructions and just go for it, such was the amount of red and blue shirts I saw in forward positions.

'course they did. Bless.

 

AuntyAnne70 Flag Tunbridge WElls 16 May 21 10.36pm

Originally posted by glazedallover

'course they did. Bless.

Absolutely.

Which begs the question if we replace Roy (which I wouldn't) why bother getting in a new manager at all?

 

AuntyAnne70 Flag Tunbridge WElls 16 May 21 10.38pm

May have seemed ambiguous Glazed, but I'm agreeing with you.

 

glazedallover Flag Allier 16 May 21 11.07pm

Originally posted by AuntyAnne70

May have seemed ambiguous Glazed, but I'm agreeing with you.

I got it Aunty . I know what cucking meant by 'deluded folks'.....

 

deleted9 Flag 16 May 21 11.08pm

Will you girls all grow up and stop being so petty. ‘You said...’ ‘I said...’ ‘he said it first’ bla bla bla. Listen to yourselves.

Get on topic and stick with it. If you want to debate, debate. Cut the ridiculous arguments and accept other might have a different opinion to you.

For me, Roy’s worked wonders and behold a professional squad with no money spent. We’ve been lucky to have him. I do reckon he’s thinking of leaving though and I wish him well. I’m excited for our next step and the opportunity to freshen things up in time for fans returning.

 

Mstrobez Flag 16 May 21 11.18pm

I just hope if Roy is to leave (and it's sadly looking more likely), that it'll be of his own accord and not us pushing him out the door. I suspect Parish is aware of a vocal section of fans but I would hope he doesn't pander to them as Roy has done an excellent job.

If he wants to stay, he should be given a go with any potential investment. He's earned that considering the budget he's worked with over the last 4 years.

If we are pushing him before he wants to jump, it would be a real lack of class for me & very disappointing as a club. He's been top drawer for us and put us in an excellent position. Great manager & a gent.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 17 May 21 12.44am

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Neillo - I can see entirely where you are going with this - so at the end of the season we are comfortably mid table, so what's all the fuss about..??

Which is a true analogy - if you believe that the end justify the means..!!

Then beyond that and probably more relevant if those means are sustainable and therein lies the problem - IMO they are not..!!

LBH - we've had some really lucky results this season e.g. Brighton away for one and then at the start of the season we caught a few teams cold with minimal pre-season preparation.

In between times there have been some really horrific/ turgid performances, where at times we have been tactically totally inept and that's due to Roy.

So IMO it's a simple question do you believe that Roy and his "conservative" and "defence first" tactics, despite us having the 4th worst defensive record in the league is the way forward..

Or do you think a new more expansive Manager with different and more creative ideas is the way to go.

I'm in the latter camp - IMO Roy's race is run and done - but as I said that's my opinion..!!

Today would suggest that when the defensive shackles are released we are a far better team and certainly more entertaining to watch..!!

But it comes down to whether you believe that Roy will continue and build on performances like today or just revert to type..!!

My opinion of Roy is that he just too stubborn and will always revert to type.

Hence I believe it's time for change and that time is now..!!

COYP

That was partially what I was getting at. The point I was trying to make was that your 18 month downward trend statement doesn't stack up.

And yes, the ends do justify the means. How many times does it need to be said that the first priority for our club is to stay in the Premier League ?? Now you may not be happy with that and it does say a lot about the short term ambition at Palace. But it is a fact. Hodgson has consistently achieved his main objective, so if you were doing his job, would you be willing to change and therefore risk not achieving that main objective ??

You should know ( assuming you read my posts ! ) that I have agreed that the entertainment value that go alongside Roy's tactics is minimal. Yes, I wish we played with more ambition - as we did in the second half today - but I know it's unlikely to happen while the focus is on the race for 40 points.

We have taken some bad beatings this season which always makes things feel worse. Just about all the pundits have commented on how out of character our defending has been for a Hodgson team. But is it any wonder when we have 4 central defenders, all 30plus and all injury prone ? Not the only reason, but a big factor in my view.

I think Roy will move on and it is about time the club was re set to run on more than just a 12 month basis. Whoever comes in has a big rebuild on their hands. And that of course is a result of the way the club has been run and not of Hodgson's making. And therein is the rub - a new man may get access to the kind of investment that Hodgson has not had.

I don't envy Parish having to make the decision...

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I Love Croydon-Roy