You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 3.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Vieria Out (LOCKED)


Page 11 of 15 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
Jacey Flag 16 Mar 23 1.50pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Just in case this is perceived as me gleefully revelling, stirring or getting over excited let me be clear I am not, just posting what I've seen/been pointed to on t'internet.

The issue facing the Board is very simple,Vieira stays and we are relegated.
Change has to come after Sunday's inevitable defeat against Arsenal.

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 16 Mar 23 1.56pm

Somewhat of a crisis when the decision on the manager is now like going to the casino and trying to manage the odds! If they continue with PV, the odds are we will go down as I don't buy in to the notion that we will do better against teams in the dog fight (other than Southampton perhaps). If we wait to a poor outcome against Leicester, then the odds will have shortened considerably on relegation and a change of manager will be too hard and too late.

If we change now, the odds may also get worse, however, its game theory where the decision makers appear to be trapped in indecision like the "prisoners dilemma". The theory of strategic rationality says that the optimal course of action is to play the odds, which by definition requires a decision to change the equilibrium of the game. In other words, the status quo will more likely result in a worse outcome, because the odds cannot be changed.

 

NE14T Flag 16 Mar 23 2.02pm

I just want to see a bit of passion from him. His forwards though have let him down massively. Mateta is all legs which often seem to have a mind of their own. He never scores with his head which for such a big man is strange but can probably be explained from his poor reading of the game and positional play. Edouard is not clinical enough, goes into hiding when the going gets tough and you don’t expect him to score.

Dougie Freedman and Parish must take some responsibility for these poor signings.

We are becoming the laughing stock of the Premiership.

Edited by NE14T (16 Mar 2023 2.05pm)

Edited by NE14T (16 Mar 2023 2.06pm)

 


The beatings will stop when morale improves.

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 16 Mar 23 2.07pm

I think we sack him and we are equally likely to go down.

I'm not sure what manager we are going to get in, who is going to get much of a better tune out of the woefully inadequate squad we have. Not many wanted the job when we hired Vieira. I don't fancy Lampard, Gerrard, Marsch or Nathan Jones. And those that think Benitez, Bielsa or Tuchel or the likes will touch us are deluded. Hassentuttl may be the best bet, but I doubt he could turn around our fortunes with the players we have.

I hope SP is also asking himself some very serious questions about how he and the rest of the board have taken the risk and now is letting the manager take the blame for their ineffectiveness.


Originally posted by Jacey

The issue facing the Board is very simple,Vieira stays and we are relegated.
Change has to come after Sunday's inevitable defeat against Arsenal.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 Mar 23 2.21pm

Originally posted by fish mitten

I think we sack him and we are equally likely to go down.

I'm not sure what manager we are going to get in, who is going to get much of a better tune out of the woefully inadequate squad we have. Not many wanted the job when we hired Vieira. I don't fancy Lampard, Gerrard, Marsch or Nathan Jones. And those that think Benitez, Bielsa or Tuchel or the likes will touch us are deluded. Hassentuttl may be the best bet, but I doubt he could turn around our fortunes with the players we have.

I hope SP is also asking himself some very serious questions about how he and the rest of the board have taken the risk and now is letting the manager take the blame for their ineffectiveness.


Hard to argue with much of that.

If he does go, the only hope can be that this hasn't all of a sudden come into the considerations of Parish et al and some research has been done in terms or suitability and availability. Very slim hope mind you.

With regards to board and therefore PV, you'd hope lessons would be learnt but hypothetically, if we do get someone new in, stay up and invest I would expect the same to play out. I think the intention is to find a manager who will do what Hodgson did, keep us up working with naff all but again in a PV mould, creating the illusion we have some sort of clever strategy for competing at the top without buying superstars and playing anachronistic football.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Mar 23 2.26pm

Some interesting news on alternatives here. Apparently looking at Carrick (no idea how he's been doing or where he is?) or Kompany who seems to be hot property currently.
[Link]

 


Red and Blue Army!

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 16 Mar 23 2.33pm

I had hoped that we had finally turned a corner and were going to try and play possession based football rather and this would run all the way through the academy to the full team, so that young players could move effortlessly along the system. However, to do that you need an initial faith and an investment. It seems the board wants us to play better football whilst still thinking you can do it on a shoestring budget.

Both Allardyce and Roy got relegated with their last teams. I think that style of football has been found out and who wants to watch it anyway.

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Hard to argue with much of that.

If he does go, the only hope can be that this hasn't all of a sudden come into the considerations of Parish et al and some research has been done in terms or suitability and availability. Very slim hope mind you.

With regards to board and therefore PV, you'd hope lessons would be learnt but hypothetically, if we do get someone new in, stay up and invest I would expect the same to play out. I think the intention is to find a manager who will do what Hodgson did, keep us up working with naff all but again in a PV mould, creating the illusion we have some sort of clever strategy for competing at the top without buying superstars and playing anachronistic football.

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 16 Mar 23 2.34pm

Carrick ?? better to get Freedman or keep Vieira.
Hang on, Carrick would be cheap ! - Parish's favourite word !!

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 16 Mar 23 2.36pm

Kompany is more likely to get Premier League football by staying at Burnley. Carrick has done well in his short time at Middlesborough. He stands a decent chance of getting them promoted and I'm not sure a rookie manager is the person for a relegation dogfight. Long term managers they could be exceptional options.

But who is available now that is likely to make a difference this season? And that's the problem we face.

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Some interesting news on alternatives here. Apparently looking at Carrick (no idea how he's been doing or where he is?) or Kompany who seems to be hot property currently.
[Link]

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 Mar 23 2.38pm

Originally posted by fish mitten

I had hoped that we had finally turned a corner and were going to try and play possession based football rather and this would run all the way through the academy to the full team, so that young players could move effortlessly along the system. However, to do that you need an initial faith and an investment. It seems the board wants us to play better football whilst still thinking you can do it on a shoestring budget.

Both Allardyce and Roy got relegated with their last teams. I think that style of football has been found out and who wants to watch it anyway.

Yep.

I would caveat however that we did see that and hence the high hopes off the back of last season but as you've highlighted, unfortunately that looks very much to have been a false dawn and the reverting to type (lack of investment) is either through arrogance, ignorance or was always going to be the case all along. In any circumstance we've landed flat on our face and back where we were before.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Swindy Flag Bromley 16 Mar 23 2.39pm

So Parish is 'unimpressed with recent form' is he ?
Steve, can you look yourself in the mirror and be honest that you have given him enough tools to improve the team this year ??
That's a toughie !!

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 16 Mar 23 2.52pm

If he's honest with himself he'd have to say no.

I would like to ask Parish 'So Steve, are you surprised we are in a relegation dogfight when the board decided we could have a squad with two goalkeepers, including one injury prone one, one left back, two right backs who are well past there best, only two strikers (neither of whom are prolific) and try and go half a season with only 2 fit for purpose central midfielders?'

You have at least 2 players for each position. As stated before the fault rests fully with the Board.

Originally posted by Swindy

So Parish is 'unimpressed with recent form' is he ?
Steve, can you look yourself in the mirror and be honest that you have given him enough tools to improve the team this year ??
That's a toughie !!

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 Mar 23 2.58pm

Originally posted by fish mitten

If he's honest with himself he'd have to say no.

I would like to ask Parish 'So Steve, are you surprised we are in a relegation dogfight when the board decided we could have a squad with two goalkeepers, including one injury prone one, one left back, two right backs who are well past there best, only two strikers (neither of whom are prolific) and try and go half a season with only 2 fit for purpose central midfielders?'

You have at least 2 players for each position. As stated before the fault rests fully with the Board.

All does have a 'May I ask what you expected to see out of a Torquay hotel bedroom window?' feel to it.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Swindy Flag Bromley 16 Mar 23 3.06pm

Excellent post.
It is not rocket science but clearly it is for Mr P !
After 10 years at this level with all the incumbent riches our squad should be sorted and organised not the current ragtag affair with players like Ward, Luka, Riedewald, Ayew etc still here.
Also we should be at least remaining unbeaten against similar sized clubs and more recent arrivals at this level like Fulham, Brentford and the seaside scum (3 points and no wins in 5 this year).
But sadly, that what's likely to happen with everything done on the cheap.
(Cue 'the but Saint Steve saved us in 2010 brigade'. Yes, that's true but more recent events and those to come in impending weeks have shown and will show that he ain't up to taking this club on.

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 16 Mar 23 3.23pm

To be fair to SP, he has through a matter of good judgement and luck done well to keep us up this long.

However, as you have stated, we should after 10 years be in a much better situation than we are. Roy was left with a squad of ageing players that needed 75% replacing over the next couple of years. Unfortunately we had one good window and as you state left with players who should have been let go or are third choice because they can play in several positions in a worst case scenario.

I still believe that there must be some kind of impasse at Board
level to allow the squad to have so many holes in it.

As much as SP deserves so much credit for getting us promoted and staying there for so long, he and the rest of the board will deserve the criticism if we go down this season


Originally posted by Swindy

Excellent post.
It is not rocket science but clearly it is for Mr P !
After 10 years at this level with all the incumbent riches our squad should be sorted and organised not the current ragtag affair with players like Ward, Luka, Riedewald, Ayew etc still here.
Also we should be at least remaining unbeaten against similar sized clubs and more recent arrivals at this level like Fulham, Brentford and the seaside scum (3 points and no wins in 5 this year).
But sadly, that what's likely to happen with everything done on the cheap.
(Cue 'the but Saint Steve saved us in 2010 brigade'. Yes, that's true but more recent events and those to come in impending weeks have shown and will show that he ain't up to taking this club on.

 

pssguy Flag 16 Mar 23 3.34pm

I see there is another article about Vieira wanting to be a role model for black coaches. Follows on from one in a similar vein in The Athletic a couple of weeks ago. He's almost daring Palace to sack him and face the outrage

 

EddieMac Flag 16 Mar 23 3.39pm

My main reason for wanting PV gone is that I see it as our best chance of staying up. PV has shown week after week that he doesn’t know what to do with the squad he has and more importantly every single team has worked us out. We are going to struggle against the bottom teams just as much as we did against the top teams and we need something new to just get us over the line.

We have the players to win enough games but they are just completely zapped of all confidence and we are falling apart. I would actually accept a heavy defeat against Arsenal if it meant we got someone new in for the home stretch.

This season has been atrocious from start to now, and the warning signs were there before the World Cup .

People are saying we have got some favourable games coming up but we are away to Leeds, Southampton, Wolves, Home to Everton and Leicester. All teams who are fighting for their lives. Our home form is rotten and our away form worse.

Our only hope is changing the manager because we are in serious serious trouble.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 16 Mar 23 3.45pm

I both don't really think he's the right manager anymore but also can't see the point in changing now.

In the run up to the international break, our 10 fixtures have been against the teams in 3rd, 5th, 3rd, 7th, 8th, 6th, 11th, 2nd, 7th, 1st. That's an average of 5.3.

Our final ten games are against the teams in 16th, 19th, 20th, 15th, 13th, 17th, 4th, 18th, 9th, 14th. An average of 14.5

There's zero point changing now and it could throw the club into turmoil, backfiring spectacularly. My view is that if Vieira was going to be given the ridiculously hard run, we might as well also give him the easy one.

All it will take is a couple of goals and suddenly the confidence will come back. We even dominated Brighton for long periods last night, we just don't have a clinical striker and haven't really had one since promotion.

My view is we should have enough to survive and finish mid-table, there's some real dross in that run in. Let him keep us up and either invest in the bloody squad in the summer and get the players he thinks he needs, or sack him them and get in Bielsa or Hassenhutl.

Also, for the record, Kompany would be my absolute number one choice but he won't leave Burnley for us.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Mar 23 3.49pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

I both don't really think he's the right manager anymore but also can't see the point in changing now.

In the run up to the international break, our 10 fixtures have been against the teams in 3rd, 5th, 3rd, 7th, 8th, 6th, 11th, 2nd, 7th, 1st. That's an average of 5.3.

Our final ten games are against the teams in 16th, 19th, 20th, 15th, 13th, 17th, 4th, 18th, 9th, 14th. An average of 14.5

There's zero point changing now and it could throw the club into turmoil, backfiring spectacularly. My view is that if Vieira was going to be given the ridiculously hard run, we might as well also give him the easy one.

All it will take is a couple of goals and suddenly the confidence will come back. We even dominated Brighton for long periods last night, we just don't have a clinical striker and haven't really had one since promotion.

My view is we should have enough to survive and finish mid-table, there's some real dross in that run in. Let him keep us up and either invest in the bloody squad in the summer and get the players he thinks he needs, or sack him them and get in Bielsa or Hassenhutl.

Also, for the record, Kompany would be my absolute number one choice but he won't leave Burnley for us.

I have to think good luck to anyone trying to make our lot run. Bielsa would probably resign within a week.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Mar 23 3.51pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Some interesting news on alternatives here. Apparently looking at Carrick (no idea how he's been doing or where he is?) or Kompany who seems to be hot property currently.
[Link]

The article is just guesswork as what it says is "Vincent Kompany and Michael Carrick of Middlesbrough among those who could be targeted

"who could be targeted" is just guesswork

 

Page 11 of 15 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic