You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Another one bites the dust?
November 21 2026 9.57pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Another one bites the dust?


Page 11 of 20 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 21 Sep 23 9.36am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Parliamentary committees are not government. They don’t make policy. They look into issues so that our representatives are better informed.

Asking a social media provider to clarify their position on a matter of current concern is not to attempt to sanction or direct them. It’s to understand where they stand.

I think there might be an available spot for you on the stand up circuit.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Sep 23 9.48am

Originally posted by Matov

Absolutely.

Beyond comprehension.

A man is accused of crimes committed years, even decades ago. With two of those 'crimes' not even in British jurisdiction. Based on anonymous reports. Not arrested. In fact, an investigation not carried out by any formal law organisation.

And the British Government, in an official capacity, tries to influence organisations to effectively cancel that person's ability to be paid for creating their own content?

f***. This is a genuinely scary. Hand on heart, never saw this coming.

With the question still remaining why? Why is Brand worth all this effort? Or is it not so much Brand, as an individual, but merely being used as a way of allowing the Media-Government complex to flex its muslces by way of warning others? Showing just what they are capable of, if people do not toe the line?

Politically Matov we are poles apart, but on this we have complete agreement.

Back on topic, I listened to a woman who was invited on to the Today Program to discuss her "experience". She explained that she was "only" 16 and Brand was 30. She claimed not have had the life experience to inform her ability to make a choice as to the giving of consent in a heart-tugging, bleating voice. There was no suggestion that he had invited her to his house to e.g. give her a leg up (so to speak) on her proposed media career. Indeed, there was no coercion alleged at all. Even my feminist wife was shouting at the radio on that interview. She willingly got in a car in order to go to a well known lothario's house of her own free will with the inevitable consequences.

30 year old men have been happily having it away with even happier 16 year old girls since time immemorial, so why was this case singled out?

Also, Parliament argued to the death the age of consent and arrived at the conclusion that changes in mental development meant that by that age girls had shifted from fancying their teachers and friends' dads. It was a "safe" age and remains so.

Questions not asked of the interviewee but ones directly relevant to issues of proper and valid consent.

1. Were you a virgin?
2. How many sexual partners had you before then?
3. What were their ages?
4. What did you think was the consequence of getting in the car?
5. Was the consequence more or less what you had thought it would be?
6. Did you enjoy yourself?
7. Was he emotionally or physically abusive/controlling?
8. Did he force himself in any way (other than the obvious)?

None asked. This was legal consensual intercourse. So why was the BBC steaming in suggesting some impropriety? Why had they given this revisionist, opportunist young woman the time of day?

Now I am a fierce defender of the BBC, as you know, but not in this case. The car and driver sent to pick this 16 year old girl up and take her to a house to have it off with a celeb was paid for by the license payer? Now, that is a story!

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Sep 23 11.00am

Originally posted by silvertop

Politically Matov we are poles apart, but on this we have complete agreement.

Back on topic, I listened to a woman who was invited on to the Today Program to discuss her "experience". She explained that she was "only" 16 and Brand was 30. She claimed not have had the life experience to inform her ability to make a choice as to the giving of consent in a heart-tugging, bleating voice. There was no suggestion that he had invited her to his house to e.g. give her a leg up (so to speak) on her proposed media career. Indeed, there was no coercion alleged at all. Even my feminist wife was shouting at the radio on that interview. She willingly got in a car in order to go to a well known lothario's house of her own free will with the inevitable consequences.

30 year old men have been happily having it away with even happier 16 year old girls since time immemorial, so why was this case singled out?

Also, Parliament argued to the death the age of consent and arrived at the conclusion that changes in mental development meant that by that age girls had shifted from fancying their teachers and friends' dads. It was a "safe" age and remains so.

Questions not asked of the interviewee but ones directly relevant to issues of proper and valid consent.

1. Were you a virgin?
2. How many sexual partners had you before then?
3. What were their ages?
4. What did you think was the consequence of getting in the car?
5. Was the consequence more or less what you had thought it would be?
6. Did you enjoy yourself?
7. Was he emotionally or physically abusive/controlling?
8. Did he force himself in any way (other than the obvious)?

None asked. This was legal consensual intercourse. So why was the BBC steaming in suggesting some impropriety? Why had they given this revisionist, opportunist young woman the time of day?

Now I am a fierce defender of the BBC, as you know, but not in this case. The car and driver sent to pick this 16 year old girl up and take her to a house to have it off with a celeb was paid for by the license payer? Now, that is a story!

And you think that's an appropriate line of questioning on a national radio show for a person who is alleging she was a victim of sexual abuse?

You also seem far more comfortable with 30 year old men sleeping with children than I am - it may be legal but it's complete scumbag behaviour.

As far as I'm aware, the woman who was 16 at the time is not alleging rape, so I'm not sure why you've spent so long rebutting that.

Any thoughts on the women who are alleging rape?

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 21 Sep 23 11.05am

Originally posted by georgenorman

The vast majority of the paedophile rape gangs were muslims and of pakistani-heritage. The police were informed of the activities of the gangs and turned a blind eye, it has nothing to do with alleged under-resourcing whatsoever.

You want us to stop “attaching unhelpful labels” – unhelpful to whom – the pakistani-heritage paedophile rape gangs? The activities of the grooming gangs and terrorist gangs have an intrinsic connection to what passes as their ‘culture’ and is very relevant.

You assertion that the different races and cultures in Israel “generally get on ok” is laughable but classic Wisbechian dissembling.

So far as I am aware no data has actually been collected on the ethnicity of the gang members so all you are doing is parroting the assumptions made in the tabloid headlines.

Likewise with the “blind-eye” assertion. That there were individual failures has been established but to suggest the police institutionally turned a blind eye has not. They seem to have been following a nationally devised softly softly approach. Which has since received criticism. Who should be held accountable, the police who had to deliver the policy or those who devised it?

The labels don’t help anyone, including the victims or those trying to bring criminals to justice. They are completely irrelevant to the crimes.

You can dismiss my personal observations if you wish. They were in another country but show that markedly different cultures can exist side by side and for friendly relations to develop on an individual level. The human spirit can always triumph over prejudice when allowed to.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 21 Sep 23 11.25am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

So far as I am aware no data has actually been collected on the ethnicity of the gang members so all you are doing is parroting the assumptions made in the tabloid headlines.

Likewise with the “blind-eye” assertion. That there were individual failures has been established but to suggest the police institutionally turned a blind eye has not. They seem to have been following a nationally devised softly softly approach. Which has since received criticism. Who should be held accountable, the police who had to deliver the policy or those who devised it?

The labels don’t help anyone, including the victims or those trying to bring criminals to justice. They are completely irrelevant to the crimes.

You can dismiss my personal observations if you wish. They were in another country but show that markedly different cultures can exist side by side and for friendly relations to develop on an individual level. The human spirit can always triumph over prejudice when allowed to.

It is absurd for you to pretend that the majority of those convicted in the trials were not overwhelmingly of pakistani-heritage. Merely look at those convicted, for example, Huddersfield convictions in 2018:

Amere Singh Dhaliwal
Irfan Ahmed
Zahid Hassan
Mohammed Kammer
Mohammed Rizwan Aslam
Abdul Rehman
Raj Singh Barsran
Nahman Mohammed
Mansoor Akhtar
Wiqas Mahmud
Nasarat Hussain
Sajid Hussain
Mohammed Irfraz
Faisal Nadeem
Mohammed Azeem
Manzoor Hassan
Mohammed Akram
Niaz Ahmed
Asif Bashir
Mohammed Imran Ibrar
Usman Khalid
Umar Zaman
Samuel Fikru
Banaris Hussain
Banaras Hussain
Usman Ali
Abdul Majid
Gul Riaz
Manzoor Akhtar
Shaqeel Hussain
Talish Ahmed
Mohammed Akram
Banaras Hussain
Saqib Raheel
Sholan James
Rashid Iqbal


Edited by georgenorman (21 Sep 2023 11.26am)

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 21 Sep 23 11.33am

GN, you are arguing with a brick wall.

Much better IMHO to ignore something that is worthless and time wasting

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 21 Sep 23 11.36am

Originally posted by HKOwen

GN, you are arguing with a brick wall.

Much better IMHO to ignore something that is worthless and time wasting

I'm just waiting for him to post that the rapists were all far-right white men who changed their names by deed poll.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Sep 23 12.11pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

If it's hilarious to you then at least you're laughing so there's some positive to come from it.

I've already answered this point you make here, which SW19 previously made but you probably didn't read it so I'll repeat that here....Like him you may not accept it but I feel it's valid as you're implying that to suggest conspiracy for anything other than organic reasons is paranoid.

Your first point is that he's not important enough to take down.

Ok, here is my response to that. Brand has a larger Youtube viewing audience than many official media outlets. Name me an anti establishment figure of a similar size to Russell Brand that hasn't been taken down? Why on earth wouldn't they look to take them down?

Your second point is that not many people are anti establishment and 'conspiratorial type stuff'. Really? Trump is supported by roughly half of America and people aren't into anti establishment 'conspiratorial type stuff'? In reality trust in institutions and government is declining and efforts to restrict 'misinformation' by the establishment is all happening in plain sight.

Yet you seem to think that the establishment are just sitting on their hands doing nothing about it.....When all the evidence goes against that. You obviously have never read the many memoirs from former intelligence who also talk about the many underhands activities that go on.

I'll also make the obvious and strongest point against your claims here is that the investigation against Brand is four years old. Well, Brand has been a celebrity for decades. Brand had been a shagging machine for most of that...maybe all.

Brand's promiscuous behaviour had been commented about pretty much from the start....but while he was in the mainstream nothing.

However, it's only been since he's become political against the mainstream that there's an interest in investigating him. It's nearly always the anti establishment figures that you get to hear about.

But you think noticing that is childish....well ok, I guess I'll have to buy myself an action man.

Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Sep 2023 6.16pm)

It's certainly a much bigger movement in America, but I don't think that's particularly relevant to this, unless we're now suggesting this is a takedown from the 'global establishment'.

How many people do you know in 'real life' (ie. not online communities) who have any exposure to Brand? I'm talking family, friends, colleagues... I'd struggle to name anyone who knows what he's up to these days in any sort of detail. I think the last time I saw one of his videos was an interview with Candace Owens a good few years ago.

I just don't buy that someone getting a few hundred thousand views on Youtube is worth anyone going after - I think it's far more likely these are credible allegations and a bloke with a seriously shady past is finally seeing that catch up with him.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Sep 23 12.55pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

And you think that's an appropriate line of questioning on a national radio show for a person who is alleging she was a victim of sexual abuse?

You also seem far more comfortable with 30 year old men sleeping with children than I am - it may be legal but it's complete scumbag behaviour.

As far as I'm aware, the woman who was 16 at the time is not alleging rape, so I'm not sure why you've spent so long rebutting that.

Any thoughts on the women who are alleging rape?

Long jail term, if proven, of course.

As well as it being legal and not sexual abuse (where is the abuse?), Brand was not so old at the time as to be "that" adult and the girl not so young as to be "that" child. I am 58. If I was the man in the frame and she was 15, I would understand your point. But 30? Come on! He was practically a kid himself.

A girl of legal age and (I will bet you anything you like) enough sexual experience, willingly gets into a car with the purpose of having it off cannot turn around a decade or so later and claim "abuse". It would be laughed out of any court at the time and now.

And before we carry on, I am not one who thinks it appropriate to question rape victims on the length of their skirt etc. As I said, my wife is not a person to be trifled with on issues such as this, and on this I agree with her. This self-serving opportunist was given air time due to the celebrity of her consensual partner of many years ago. However, there are victims of genuine abuse and rape who are given no air time nor public support or funding to prosecute actual scum bags who are left free to walk our streets.

So what is this really about? I am not talking about any genuine allegation of serious criminal misconduct (which this was not) but about what appears to be a new and worrying aspect of the woke witch hunt. Perhaps it is part of a movement to legally limit congress with e.g. someone born within 3 months of you?

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Sep 23 1.02pm

As a PS the "no smoke without fire" argument is classic witch hunt and I give it no credence. That said, I think it all but impossible that a bloke who has had an erection for as long as Brand has not had non-consensual coupling or committed other sexual offences with his innumerable partners. Likewise Charlie Sheen. There must have been instances where, at the very least, the line was blurred. Just not the woman they interviewed.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 21 Sep 23 1.25pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

It is absurd for you to pretend that the majority of those convicted in the trials were not overwhelmingly of pakistani-heritage. Merely look at those convicted, for example, Huddersfield convictions in 2018:

Amere Singh Dhaliwal
Irfan Ahmed
Zahid Hassan
Mohammed Kammer
Mohammed Rizwan Aslam
Abdul Rehman
Raj Singh Barsran
Nahman Mohammed
Mansoor Akhtar
Wiqas Mahmud
Nasarat Hussain
Sajid Hussain
Mohammed Irfraz
Faisal Nadeem
Mohammed Azeem
Manzoor Hassan
Mohammed Akram
Niaz Ahmed
Asif Bashir
Mohammed Imran Ibrar
Usman Khalid
Umar Zaman
Samuel Fikru
Banaris Hussain
Banaras Hussain
Usman Ali
Abdul Majid
Gul Riaz
Manzoor Akhtar
Shaqeel Hussain
Talish Ahmed
Mohammed Akram
Banaras Hussain
Saqib Raheel
Sholan James
Rashid Iqbal


Edited by georgenorman (21 Sep 2023 11.26am)

You think that you can tell a person’s ethnicity from their name alone? Seriously?

It’s not the point anyway.

Just imagine you are a second generation British subject whose parents happen to have been born in pakistan. You didn’t plan that. You just got it. You went to school with other British kids whose parents were born here, and they are your friends. You watch British TV, absorb British culture and support a British football team. Your parents try to teach you about your heritage and to respect it, so you feel conflicted.

Then you read headlines and comments about “pakistani grooming gangs” and feel as disgusted as every other decent person but know how some people now regard you, just because of your heritage and appearance.

What impact is that going to have? What proportion of our population which has a pakistani heritage is involved with the grooming gangs? It must only be very very tiny, meaning that the overwhelming majority are not. Ostracising that majority by associating them with criminals does immense harm and drives wedges where bridges produce better outcomes. That’s why it’s unhelpful and counterproductive to use these labels, even if they are accurate, which they aren’t.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 21 Sep 23 1.29pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

GN, you are arguing with a brick wall.

Much better IMHO to ignore something that is worthless and time wasting

Debating this issue here is for me like trying to get reason out of of a whole street of brick walls.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Matov Flag 21 Sep 23 1.45pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

How many people do you know in 'real life' (ie. not online communities) who have any exposure to Brand? I'm talking family, friends, colleagues... I'd struggle to name anyone who knows what he's up to these days in any sort of detail. I think the last time I saw one of his videos was an interview with Candace Owens a good few years ago.

I just don't buythat someone getting a few hundred thousand views on Youtube is worth anyone going after - I think it's far more likely these are credible allegations and a bloke with a seriously shady past is finally seeing that catch up with him.

All of which I fully concur with. And if he gets convicted in a court of law, then yes, justice will be done.

But at this stage, before the man has even been questioned by the police, let alone arrested or charged, the direct interference by an institution of Government by way of trying to demonintise him on a platform which did not even exist when these annoymous allegations were made?

Come on. Put the politics aside. Is this right?

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 21 Sep 23 1.50pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

It's certainly a much bigger movement in America, but I don't think that's particularly relevant to this, unless we're now suggesting this is a takedown from the 'global establishment'.

How many people do you know in 'real life' (ie. not online communities) who have any exposure to Brand? I'm talking family, friends, colleagues... I'd struggle to name anyone who knows what he's up to these days in any sort of detail. I think the last time I saw one of his videos was an interview with Candace Owens a good few years ago.

I just don't buy that someone getting a few hundred thousand views on Youtube is worth anyone going after - I think it's far more likely these are credible allegations and a bloke with a seriously shady past is finally seeing that catch up with him.

I had not seen any of Brand’s “comedy” before I watched the Dispatches episode on him. I just knew him to be the type of self opinionated presenter I dislike so avoided anything he got involved with. Then his videos started to be pushed under my nose and his attitudes became clearer.

Watching the clips in Dispatches was enough. Whether what he did was legal or not doesn’t mean what he cannot deny he did is immune from criticism.

The content of his “comedy” is disgusting. It’s demeaning, insulting and not at all funny. In my opinion, of course, which I am allowed to express and am grateful to Dispatches for enabling me to form.

That more serious allegations have also been made is obviously more important but knowing the background behaviour helps put those allegations into context.

There is a lot of smoke now surrounding Brand and evidence of a few smouldering embers. I hope this does get tested in Court but whatever happens there won’t change my opinion of him. I fail to see why anyone thinks it’s wise to defend him.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Sep 23 1.53pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Long jail term, if proven, of course.

As well as it being legal and not sexual abuse (where is the abuse?), Brand was not so old at the time as to be "that" adult and the girl not so young as to be "that" child. I am 58. If I was the man in the frame and she was 15, I would understand your point. But 30? Come on! He was practically a kid himself.

A girl of legal age and (I will bet you anything you like) enough sexual experience, willingly gets into a car with the purpose of having it off cannot turn around a decade or so later and claim "abuse". It would be laughed out of any court at the time and now.

And before we carry on, I am not one who thinks it appropriate to question rape victims on the length of their skirt etc. As I said, my wife is not a person to be trifled with on issues such as this, and on this I agree with her. This self-serving opportunist was given air time due to the celebrity of her consensual partner of many years ago. However, there are victims of genuine abuse and rape who are given no air time nor public support or funding to prosecute actual scum bags who are left free to walk our streets.

So what is this really about? I am not talking about any genuine allegation of serious criminal misconduct (which this was not) but about what appears to be a new and worrying aspect of the woke witch hunt. Perhaps it is part of a movement to legally limit congress with e.g. someone born within 3 months of you?

And as I've said previously, our legal system clearly struggles to achieve convictions in this space - I don't have anywhere near the confidence others seem to in it.

I am aged 30 currently and the thought of me, or any of my friends, shagging a 16 year old is absolutely disgusting. If one of my mates shared with the group he'd shagged a 16 year old, it would not go down well with anyone - I'm amazed you think that's normal, frankly. It's an adult and a child and should undoubtedly be illegal.

You clearly do think it's appropriate to ask absurd questions given your first contribution was to suggest someone claiming to be a victim of sexual assault should be asked "did you enjoy it?" on a national radio show.

How do you think the 'genuine' victims of abuse and rape feel when people like you tie yourself in knots to disbelieve every story that comes forward of this type of thing?

You are also ignoring the numerous other allegations against Brand from numerous women - have you watched the Dispatches show?

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Sep 23 1.55pm

Originally posted by Matov

All of which I fully concur with. And if he gets convicted in a court of law, then yes, justice will be done.

But at this stage, before the man has even been questioned by the police, let alone arrested or charged, the direct interference by an institution of Government by way of trying to demonintise him on a platform which did not even exist when these annoymous allegations were made?

Come on. Put the politics aside. Is this right?

For what it's worth, no I don't think it's right principally - but I also don't think it's proof of some big conspiracy.

Equally, I don't extend much sympathy to a scumbag like Brand.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 21 Sep 23 2.03pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

And as I've said previously, our legal system clearly struggles to achieve convictions in this space - I don't have anywhere near the confidence others seem to in it.

I am aged 30 currently and the thought of me, or any of my friends, shagging a 16 year old is absolutely disgusting. If one of my mates shared with the group he'd shagged a 16 year old, it would not go down well with anyone - I'm amazed you think that's normal, frankly. It's an adult and a child and should undoubtedly be illegal.

You clearly do think it's appropriate to ask absurd questions given your first contribution was to suggest someone claiming to be a victim of sexual assault should be asked "did you enjoy it?" on a national radio show.

How do you think the 'genuine' victims of abuse and rape feel when people like you tie yourself in knots to disbelieve every story that comes forward of this type of thing?

You are also ignoring the numerous other allegations against Brand from numerous women - have you watched the Dispatches show?

Possibly, BUT, it is LEGAL!

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Teddy Eagle Flag 21 Sep 23 2.04pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

The reason I brought up the grooming gang issue was not to spark yet another discussion on it. It was to contrast the way that the right wing cohort here are condemning the media for exposing the allegations on Brand with that they displayed over the gangs, where they were in full support.

There are legitimate criticisms of the tabloid coverage of the grooming gangs, as there is of your comment above. The use of “pakistani-heritage” as a descriptor being one, when it is known that they comprised of a variety of ethnicities. I know full well what the enquiries into these matters have revealed and make no excuses for individual failures. Any defence I have made is the more general one that we cannot expect an under-resourced, under-funded police service to not make mistakes. We get the police service we deserve.

I want people to stop attaching unhelpful labels. Child groomers and terrorists are criminals. Their religion and any justification they claim as a motivation need to be binned as an irrelevant excuse and not encouraged by reference to it.

I was in Jerusalem for a few days 2 weeks ago, during which time I was exposed to the many cultures that exist side by side there. No-one treated me as a “kafir”, indeed the Arab section of the city was a more relaxed and pleasant environment than the Jewish one, but people generally get on ok. For sure there are different cultures but people, and especially the children, were happy.

Now perhaps we can return to the subject of this thread.

Under resourcing again.


[Link]


[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

 

Matov Flag 21 Sep 23 2.05pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

For what it's worth, no I don't think it's right principally - but I also don't think it's proof of some big conspiracy.


Which still leaves the 'why' part?

And lets not forget that until recently Brand was considered to be very much of the Left. Chumming around with all kinds of progressive types (this article has been a constant source of mirth for years, and on a multiple of levels... [Link] ).

I always dismissed Brand as a narcist t*** who caused an instant reaction to turn off whatever medium he appeared on. And despite my own far/dissident/looney Right world-view, I have never given him the time of day, seeing him, along with many others on my side of the divide, as a grifter.

Annoying froth. No more, no less.

But this direct interference, and it cannot be underplayed, for a man that nobody with any kind of serious political nous pays any kind of attention to, is beyond my comprehension.

With wider implications that go well beyond the issue of Russel Brand.


 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 21 Sep 23 2.11pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

You think that you can tell a person’s ethnicity from their name alone? Seriously?

It’s not the point anyway.

Just imagine you are a second generation British subject whose parents happen to have been born in pakistan. You didn’t plan that. You just got it. You went to school with other British kids whose parents were born here, and they are your friends. You watch British TV, absorb British culture and support a British football team. Your parents try to teach you about your heritage and to respect it, so you feel conflicted.

Then you read headlines and comments about “pakistani grooming gangs” and feel as disgusted as every other decent person but know how some people now regard you, just because of your heritage and appearance.

What impact is that going to have? What proportion of our population which has a pakistani heritage is involved with the grooming gangs? It must only be very very tiny, meaning that the overwhelming majority are not. Ostracising that majority by associating them with criminals does immense harm and drives wedges where bridges produce better outcomes. That’s why it’s unhelpful and counterproductive to use these labels, even if they are accurate, which they aren’t.

You think there is any doubt about these criminals’ ethnicity, seriously? Why don’t you have a look at the photographs of them published at the time.

So we have to pretend that the paedophile rape gangs were not overwhelmingly muslims of pakistani heritage in case it offends others with pakistani-heritage. Should we pretend that the Nazis were not overwhelmingly German in case it offends other Germans. Should we pretend that the membership of the BNP is not overwhelmingly white British-heritage in case it offends the rest of the white population. Should we pretend that the far-left of the Labour party are not crypto-communist nutjobs in case if offends the rest of the Labour party. Should we pretend that there are not rogue landlords who do not service their gas appliances in case it offends other landlords.

 

Page 11 of 20 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Another one bites the dust?