This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
The government should do far less, so called, 'governing' and certainly should not continue with much of the over-regulation and doomed-to-fail 'planning' that the EU gets up to. The problem with "light" government is you end up with businesses run by criminals and lower standards. We need a regulatory framework to ensure both safety and a level playing field.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I am unsure whether these costs include those that I am identifying and seems more likely to just be the direct economic ones. Nevertheless, if the overall cost of our EU membership over 45 years was £216 billion, after adjustment for inflation, then the estimated cost of withdrawal up to 2020 of £200 billion is fairly conclusive proof that Brexit has cost far more than our membership ever did. Can only assume no one knew the amount involved before or did Remain publicise the likely costs? I can't remember.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
How lucky we are that the HOL operates as a benign geniocracy. I think David Dunning and Justin Kruger would have taken an interest here.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Ha. A significant number of contributors to these political threads are about as benign as they are close to meeting the qualifying criteria for a geniocracy. Did you Master in Raëlism?
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
We never lost our national sovereignty. It's a myth which is used by the Brexit lobby to justify some extremely irresponsible claims. Our membership cost billions? I would wager our withdrawal will cost us much more. Of course we gave up our national sovereignty, albeit with the ability to take it back as we did with Brexit. To deny it is a myth which is used by the Remainer lobby to justify some extremely irresponsible claims. Our withdrawal will cost billions? I would wager our membership would cost us much more.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The problem with "light" government is you end up with businesses run by criminals and lower standards. We need a regulatory framework to ensure both safety and a level playing field. Your "heavy" government and over-regulation does practically nothing to stop criminality or low standards, both of which are rampant in socialist economies - and there is no such thing as a level playing field, just successful and unsuccessful businesses.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Can only assume no one knew the amount involved before or did Remain publicise the likely costs? I can't remember. The "Remain" campaign was very poor which together with the fact that selling the status quo is never as sexy as selling something new and unknown, plus a sense of complacency, led to it failing. That it only just failed in those circumstances is instructive! I don't think anyone involved tried to measure these costs or thought they needed to. Their complacency meant they thought they could brush aside UKIP and the "savings" claims. The politicians understood their fallacy, which is why they were overwhelmingly in favour of Remaining, and seemed to think everyone else did too. The Brexit referendum was a disaster from start to finish. It was throwing our future to the winds of political chance and allowing malign actors both at home and overseas to exercise undue influence. It must never happen again. We must choose our representatives carefully and then allow them to do their job.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The "Remain" campaign was very poor which together with the fact that selling the status quo is never as sexy as selling something new and unknown, plus a sense of complacency, led to it failing. That it only just failed in those circumstances is instructive! I don't think anyone involved tried to measure these costs or thought they needed to. Their complacency meant they thought they could brush aside UKIP and the "savings" claims. The politicians understood their fallacy, which is why they were overwhelmingly in favour of Remaining, and seemed to think everyone else did too. The Brexit referendum was a disaster from start to finish. It was throwing our future to the winds of political chance and allowing malign actors both at home and overseas to exercise undue influence. It must never happen again. We must choose our representatives carefully and then allow them to do their job. Except our representatives are also chosen in the face of the winds of political chance, under the influence of maligned (I think you meant) actors.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Of course we gave up our national sovereignty, albeit with the ability to take it back as we did with Brexit. To deny it is a myth which is used by the Remainer lobby to justify some extremely irresponsible claims. Our withdrawal will cost billions? I would wager our membership would cost us much more. You do spout some complete nonsense. The very fact that we were able to enact Brexit proves, beyond the slightest doubt, that our sovereignty has never been compromised. Delegation of actions doesn't imply you give up any responsibility for them. We do it all the time in other areas, without our sovereignty being affected. Our membership of the EU was no different. I suggest you reflect on the post I made at 10.49 pm yesterday and read the link provided by Teddy. This is the only analysis I have read to date on the comparative costs, and this doesn't include many of the hidden ones. It's pretty obvious that Brexit is many times more expensive than our membership was. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (24 Feb 2023 9.37am)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
On the point would we have been economically better off staying in the EU rather than leaving this came up during the Brexit debate on here and my opinion hasn't changed, its pure conjecture either way. You can speculate by pointing to similar countries but there are so many variables whether you are Pro or Remain it is just guess work. I think the only thing you can do is ask people how they feel which for most is not scientific but emotional. Right now we are still untangling ourselves from the EU and this government has yet to have a bonfire of EU red tape or grasp the opportunities. The cost of living crisis has distorted how people fell anyway. Perhaps in 5 years time we will have a better idea. Whilst determining the comparative costs cannot be an accounting exercise it is far from just conjecture. Broad brush calculations by expert analysts can provide sufficient information to know the answers. Only if it was a close run thing would conjecture matter, but it seems it isn't. Look at my post at 10.49 pm yesterday, and the link provided by Teddy. It might be uncomfortable reading for those who want to believe that we will save money through Brexit, but it seems pretty conclusive that what appears obvious to me, is true. Brexit was a mistake in every possible way, including financial. The idea that we will have a bonfire of EU red tape is nonsense. The truth is that we need to retrieve most of it to build our own structures, using a lot of labour to do so, and then keep on building structures and employing people to maintain them. This will cost more than delegating it to the EU. What's the point of "taking back control" if we end up in broadly the same place but the ticket to get there costs 10 times as much? We don't need to wait 5 years to know this. It's obvious now and will only be more so then.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
Except our representatives are also chosen in the face of the winds of political chance, under the influence of maligned (I think you meant) actors. I don't argue that our present system is perfect, or incapable of substantial improvement. Hence, the "carefully". Imperfect though it is, it is still better than a referendum. It might still be subject to the winds of political chance, but the referendum faced a hurricane of opportunism and misinformation. We can also reverse mistakes every 5 years. If only we could do the same with Brexit!
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The "Remain" campaign was very poor which together with the fact that selling the status quo is never as sexy as selling something new and unknown, plus a sense of complacency, led to it failing. That it only just failed in those circumstances is instructive! I don't think anyone involved tried to measure these costs or thought they needed to. Their complacency meant they thought they could brush aside UKIP and the "savings" claims. The politicians understood their fallacy, which is why they were overwhelmingly in favour of Remaining, and seemed to think everyone else did too. The Brexit referendum was a disaster from start to finish. It was throwing our future to the winds of political chance and allowing malign actors both at home and overseas to exercise undue influence. It must never happen again. We must choose our representatives carefully and then allow them to do their job. Remainers are like spoilt children who can't get their own way. Your endless excuses about losing a democratic referendum are increasingly embarrassing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Aha, something useful at last. Although it is from full fact... don't most righties deride it? (Personally I find it pretty helpful) Summarising Over 45 years the EU cost us an estimated £216 billion, net (net of what I'm not sure, but lets go with it for now) That's about 4.8bn a year since we joined. Taking the lower figure of what the estimated next cost of leaving up to 2020 has been... Over 1 year (18-20) the estimated net cost was £130 billion 45 years – £216 billion Now I know it takes time to try and make this work, and hopefully it does, but if it's only taken one year to get us to 60% of that 45 year figure... Jesus. I'd be interested to know what it's up to now, let alone what it will be a decade on in 2028. It would not be unreasonable to suggest much, much higher. Let's hope our overlords can actually make this work, eh? It's funny how remainers want to make it all about money. Brexit was never all about money and it never will be. Also, it's even more amusing that you are happy to extrapolate the costy of Brexit using current figures but find it illogical to do so with population on another thread.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You do spout some complete nonsense. The very fact that we were able to enact Brexit proves, beyond the slightest doubt, that our sovereignty has never been compromised. Delegation of actions doesn't imply you give up any responsibility for them. We do it all the time in other areas, without our sovereignty being affected. Our membership of the EU was no different. I suggest you reflect on the post I made at 10.49 pm yesterday and read the link provided by Teddy. This is the only analysis I have read to date on the comparative costs, and this doesn't include many of the hidden ones. It's pretty obvious that Brexit is many times more expensive than our membership was. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (24 Feb 2023 9.37am) Rather than “some complete nonsense”, the majority of what you spout is complete nonsense.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It's funny how remainers want to make it all about money. Brexit was never all about money and it never will be. Also, it even more amusing that you are happy to extrapolate the costy of Brexit using current figures but find it illogical to do so with population on another thread.
Er Money is a pretty big factor. You are right in saying it's not the only one, but it's amongst the biggest as it has direct impact on everything, from society to resources to prosperity... And you've neatly summarised the stupidity of ideological and dogmatic decison making on both side of the debate 'I don't care about the outcome, or what's likely to be more beneficial, I just want brexit / to stay in the EU'. You're constantly banging on about your grandchildren – if leaving delivers ideologically but in your lifetime demonstrates a negative outcome, therefore a more negative existence for those in the future, and you still stick to your dogma... that's illogical. I'm not even a remainer FFS, I've evolved my view on leaving and I'm fully behind giving it a go as no one can say either way that it will be worse or better medium to long term. But crucially I will adapt my view as we progress, not stay stuck in time. In some ways I respect the commitment but don't understand the logic. On the point about extrapolation – two completely different topics, with two completely different data sets. One completely measurable, simpler to define and with decades of historical data. One with (based on the shared link on the other thread) two years of historical hard to estimate data on something that has never been done before. In that case, literally the only thing you can do is extrapolate based on the little data there is available. In the former, you can be far more rigorous and potentially, accurate. It's also not unreasonable to suggest that based on current figures even if that 130bn were to taper down over the next 10 years and turn into a net positive, which might I add would be what I'd want it to do for all our sakes, it's still likely to be higher over 10 than our entire cost over 45. Fairly simple to understand, and a pretty balanced take. No point in you arguing figures anyway on this topic as you are only interested in this for ideological reasons, irrespective of outcome. Which is weird if you care about the future so much.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.