You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Creation vs. Evolution Debate
November 19 2026 5.51pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Creation vs. Evolution Debate


Page 12 of 18 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
A_JsShorts 09 Jan 05 6.49pm

Quote mattwebb at 09 Jan 2005 6:23pm

Quote A_JsShorts at 09 Jan 2005 3:29pm


I am not going to sit here and prove evolution to you as I am noehter a scientist nor physitian, but I ask you the same question about creation.


If you haven't had evolution scientifically proven beyond doubt to you personally, then surely you are excercising just as much faith believing evolution as i am by believing creation.

Just because science has a theory, evolution actually contradicts natural selection (they are not the same as is commonly a mistaken belief, and many others contradict, but just because some scientists believe something by making loads of assumptions to get there, does not mean it is true.

I can't prove creation to you, except by asking you to witness birth, and then explaining to me what is it that gives that baby the life inside it (Sperm and an egg? - please!), but I can show you some of the many flaws in the theory of evolution.

When I made my desicion as to what I believed I chose the idea that I felt I could understand and was more believable to myself. Nothing you say to me will make me change my mind one bit, the same as what I say to you. But what I have seen on TV, learnt at school and read myself means to me what the bible means to you.

As someone with children I don't need to explain to you how babies are created do I? Think back to biology class when you were at school.

At the end of the day, I don't have the answers. But I would expect you to understand and respect what I think which I unfortunatly don't think you can do.

I am open to ideas, I have been to church and been to the Virgin Marys final resting place, but for me evolution is the only theory.

 

tinkerbell85 Flag Redhill 09 Jan 05 7.00pm

If evolution was true though then how come we haven't found any fossils that are like half fish and half frog or something??

 


Up, up and away in my beautiful balloon!

jcreedy Flag 09 Jan 05 7.33pm

Forgive me if I've missed it, but I don't think the incest question has been answered. If the world was populated by two people, does God allow incest?

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

A_JsShorts 09 Jan 05 7.36pm

This was Matts reply to my incest question :

You are getting into a whole new topic called Devolution. If natural selection is true, which i believe it is then each time we have kids, they lose genes from both parents.

This means that if there were ever two original humans which both evolutionists and creationists believe (otherwise we get into black's being lower down the evolutionary chain etc), then they must have had the genes for all races and creeds.

The more and more genes you lose down the generations, the worse it would be to have children with someone from the exact gene pool as you, because the child will lose genes without gaining any.

God does not allow incest anymore, that was stopped as soon as necessary, but for the first two humans who scientifically MUST have had more gene options, it was fine medically.

 

jcreedy Flag 09 Jan 05 7.48pm

Quote A_JsShorts at 09 Jan 2005 7:36pm

This was Matts reply to my incest question :

You are getting into a whole new topic called Devolution. If natural selection is true, which i believe it is then each time we have kids, they lose genes from both parents.

This means that if there were ever two original humans which both evolutionists and creationists believe (otherwise we get into black's being lower down the evolutionary chain etc), then they must have had the genes for all races and creeds.

The more and more genes you lose down the generations, the worse it would be to have children with someone from the exact gene pool as you, because the child will lose genes without gaining any.

God does not allow incest anymore, that was stopped as soon as necessary, but for the first two humans who scientifically MUST have had more gene options, it was fine medically.

But at the end of the day, he allowed incest.


Edited by jcreedy (09 Jan 2005 7:49pm)

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

Danger Flag Playa del Merstham 09 Jan 05 7.56pm

The way I see it, it has to be down to personal perception because both the creation and evolution arguments have their strong and their weak points.

Firstly my GCSE science hat will come on:

There is the whole big bang theory. A so-called collision of certain particles forming the earth we live in today (or at least as it was when it all began). However surely something must have already been present for these “particles” to be present suggesting some sort of “earth” being present already (although different to the earth we live on at present).

And also if this whole theory is so true, how come it took until 1927 for someone (Belgian priest Georges Lemaître) to mention it and claim it to be the case.

I do find it interesting that a priest – someone in a high standing religious position – was the first to suggest that theory.

On the other hand this theory does make some sense as it is clearly links the reasons why the distant galaxies are travelling away from us at high speeds. The theory also predicts the existence of cosmic background radiation (the glow left over from the explosion itself). The Big Bang Theory received its strongest confirmation when this radiation was discovered in 1964.

Now a little quote that I managed to dig out:

Quote Although the Big Bang Theory is widely accepted, it probably will never be proved; consequentially, leaving a number of tough, unanswered questions.

Now for my (admittedly limited) Religious hat:

From the religious side of things there is also some very valid points that creation by God was how the modern world was started (for want of a better word). However, as with the big bang theory, there are also ways that the argument suffers.

Many creationists believe the following 4 points (had to steal this as I have no knowledge really):

• Although there is plenty of evidence for adaptive changes in species (microevolution), we do not in recorded history see one species becoming an entirely different, more highly evolved organism. For example, we have no examples in recorded history of a fish becoming an amphibian or even a bacteria evolving into anything other than a bacteria.

• The fossil record does not show the gradual changes that Darwin predicted.

• There can be errors in carbon dating and other methods that are used to determine the age of fossils and the Earth itself.

• DNA and RNA comparisons between similar and dissimilar species at times confirm evolution, but in other circumstances are inconsistent.

These are all very good, and true points which work strongly for the creationists argument.

There are also reasons why creation may not have occurred, however, in that some of the theory contradicts a lot of the stuff the bible forbids.

The main issue that brings this argument up for me is the question of who Cain married. One of the chapters of the bible (don’t know exactly which bit) says that Cain had a wife who gave him a son. However this says to me that an incestuous relationship had occurred as the only other people on the earth at the time (the Bible’s words, not mine) were Adam, Eve and their children, meaning that Cain married his sister (the only logical answer).

Incest is something that the bible later condones.

In conclusion to this, I’m going to sit on the fence, I don’t know how the Earth began. Both theories have too many discrepancies to make them justifiable.

Can’t we just accept the world is here, rather than having to prove why? Just enjoy it for what it is.

(sorry for writing this like an essay, it was the easiest way for me to get my point across)

Edited by Danger (09 Jan 2005 7:57pm)

Edited by Danger (09 Jan 2005 7:57pm)

 


FFS MURRAY

rach_cpfc Flag South Croydon 09 Jan 05 9.11pm

Excellent post Nick, one of the most balanced and well thought out of this discussion.

 


"....They will soar on wings like EAGLES; they will run and not grow
weary, they will walk and not be faint."

Danger Flag Playa del Merstham 09 Jan 05 9.13pm

Quote rach_d_cpfc at 09 Jan 2005 9:11pm

Excellent post Nick, one of the most balanced and well thought out of this discussion.

It was always gonna happen one day

 


FFS MURRAY

Bedge Flag Croydon 09 Jan 05 9.16pm

Quote Danger at 09 Jan 2005 9:13pm

Quote rach_d_cpfc at 09 Jan 2005 9:11pm

Excellent post Nick, one of the most balanced and well thought out of this discussion.

It was always gonna happen one day

I never thought i would say this but i agree with Rach, that is a fantastic post by Nick, Didnt know you had it in you!

 


Extran Orange energy drink, Europe's number one hangover cure!

The Special One

Guntrisoft Flag Beckenham, Kent 09 Jan 05 9.29pm

Good post Nick, and not one mention of Saucy-Minx

 


Webmaster - The Holmesdale Online
Follow the HOL on Twitter! [Link] and Facebook [Link]

Danger Flag Playa del Merstham 09 Jan 05 9.32pm

Quote Guntrisoft at 09 Jan 2005 9:29pm

Good post Nick, and not one mention of Saucy-Minx

Damn, I knew I forgot something!

 


FFS MURRAY

mattwebb Flag Sutton 09 Jan 05 9.50pm

Quote Danger at 09 Jan 2005 7:56pm

The main issue that brings this argument up for me is the question of who Cain married. One of the chapters of the bible (don’t know exactly which bit) says that Cain had a wife who gave him a son. However this says to me that an incestuous relationship had occurred as the only other people on the earth at the time (the Bible’s words, not mine) were Adam, Eve and their children, meaning that Cain married his sister (the only logical answer).

Incest is something that the bible later condones.

Danger I appreciate everything else you wrote, but because of my explanation above the following is actually the truth.

God condoned, allowed incest when humans had more genes, ie they hadn't lost the recessive ones in reproduction, but it wasn't until later on when there was no NEED for sister and brother to reproduce, and also they were no longer at the top of the gene pool, because so many recessive genes had already been lost down the reproduction line, GOD then said YOU MAY NO LONGER MARRY YOUR SIBLING.

It was absolutely no issue, like it would be today, at the beginning because of the genes.

Edited by Penge Eagle (09 Jan 2005 10:26pm)

 

ElliottHutchins Flag Wakefield 09 Jan 05 11.43pm

Quote tetley at 09 Jan 2005 1:45pm

and this brings us nicely back to the beginning of the thread.

having read the entire thread again, there are not too many questions that have gone unanswered and there have beenvery interesting answers.

i've learnt a lot about both sides of the argument. it is fairly obvious that both sides require a arge proportion of faith and that neither side holds all of the answers.

however, if your belief makes you happy and suits you best then so be it. as long as you can then accept the views of others and hold a rational debate then there are no problems.

so well done Rach for starting an interesting thread and thanks to all (but one) of the posters who have made this thread so interesting.

Your blatantly talking about me. Im not posting on this thread again. Ive had enough abuse and preachyness. Take yer religion and shove it sideways.

E

 


Ex-HOL Preview Bod
Prediction League - Runner Up 2003/04
HOL Cool Dude of the Season 2004/05

I was there - ElliottHutchins 19/12/2006

R.I.P. staffie & DJ Hardline

A_JsShorts 09 Jan 05 11.47pm

Elliott did I miss something?

 

tetley Flag Wimbledon 09 Jan 05 11.48pm

he has - because i'm not even slightly religious

 


It's not the fall that's important.....it's the landing

All Nature is but Art, unknown to thee;
All Chance, Direction, which thou canst not see;
All Discord, Harmony, not understood;
All partial Evil, universal Good

[Link]

ElliottHutchins Flag Wakefield 09 Jan 05 11.48pm

Read back about 7 pages.

Im going to bed Night

E

 


Ex-HOL Preview Bod
Prediction League - Runner Up 2003/04
HOL Cool Dude of the Season 2004/05

I was there - ElliottHutchins 19/12/2006

R.I.P. staffie & DJ Hardline

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 10 Jan 05 12.26am

Quote tinkerbell85 at 09 Jan 2005 2:52pm

I'm a Christian. Really good website for people who do want to look into the Christian faith is:

[Link]

I'll try and attempt to answer questions too but I'm not very good at it and get myself into a muddle! However, I believe:

That Jesus was real, he existed, he performed miracles and he died so that we could all have eternal life in heaven.

I believe in God as the creator of the world and all things in it. He created everything perfectly and we're the ones that spoilt it.

I believe in the Holy Spirit as God's representative on earth. I believe that people can feel it's power.

I believe the Bible is a book of truth and the fundamental points cannot be interpreted.

I belive that all humans are sinful but we can be forgiven if we ask for it.

I believe that we all have free will and that we have a choice in everything we do whether its a good or bad choice.

I believe also that it's not God who's turned 'his' back on the world it's people that have turned their back on 'him'.

I cannot believe that we are here by chance and that my life has no meaning but to exist and then die. The earth was created on the perfect angle for life to exist. That cannot be by chance surely??

By the way, I still have questions to ask. I'm not perfect.

Edited by tinkerbell85 (09 Jan 2005 3:08pm)

Edited by tinkerbell85 (09 Jan 2005 3:09pm)

I'm not the religious type, and despise the people who try to force religion on you, but I believe in God and Tinkerbell sums up my views entirely. As a kid, stories from the Bible helped me to work out right from wrong. I would send my kids to a Catholic school because I think the religious grounding would stand them in good stead for the future. It's not ramming it down their throats and certainly does no harm. When they become old enough, it's up to them if they want to take religion more seriously.

Respect to mattwebb for taking the time to put his points across over lots of posts in a sensible manner.

As for the creation vs evolution debate, neither science nor religion is wrong. I studied A Level Theology and although I found it boring at the time (aged 16), the subject is more interesting today as I'm older. Must dig out my old books to refresh the memory!

Edited by Penge Eagle (10 Jan 2005 12:33am)

 

mattwebb Flag Sutton 10 Jan 05 12.32am

Cheers mate; I really appreciate support, because I seem to be extremely out numbered.

 

Bean Flag Ipswich 10 Jan 05 10.25am

Quote rach_d_cpfc at 09 Jan 2005 4:09pm

Quote tinkerbell85 at 09 Jan 2005 2:52pm

I'm a Christian. Really good website for people who do want to look into the Christian faith is:

[Link]

I'll try and attempt to answer questions too but I'm not very good at it and get myself into a muddle! However, I believe:

That Jesus was real, he existed, he performed miracles and he died so that we could all have eternal life in heaven.

I believe in God as the creator of the world and all things in it. He created everything perfectly and we're the ones that spoilt it.

I believe in the Holy Spirit as God's representative on earth. I believe that people can feel it's power.

I believe the Bible is a book of truth and the fundamental points cannot be interpreted.

I belive that all humans are sinful but we can be forgiven if we ask for it.

I believe that we all have free will and that we have a choice in everything we do whether its a good or bad choice.

I believe also that it's not God who's turned 'his' back on the world it's people that have turned their back on 'him'.

I cannot believe that we are here by chance and that my life has no meaning but to exist and then die. The earth was created on the perfect angle for life to exist. That cannot be by chance surely??

By the way, I still have questions to ask. I'm not perfect.

Completely agree with all that Becky!

A couple of people have mentioned about not having free-will any more if you're a Christian, but that's not true. Yes, there are rules to follow, but only ones that are there for our own good, and I can still choose to go against those rules.
Think about a loving parent setting rules down for their child. The child may think the rules are completely unfair and are stopping all their fun, but the parent is only thinking of the best for the child. The child can disobey those rules - and the parent will still love them - but if a child loves and respects their parents they'll try their best to follow the rules.
That's how it is with God and me.
I try to do what I know God wants - and fail a lot - but know his love for me doesn't change whatever.


But surely, the Your shall worship no other God than me is quite a big free will taking away statement as it immediately binds you into one way of thinking and behaving

 


Boys are Studpid, Throw Rocks at Them........

mattwebb Flag Sutton 10 Jan 05 10.32am

Bean but if you are already a Christian you have already made that choice with your free will.

I don't understand your problem with the whole free will thing.

Everytime you make a choice you use your free will, and then that choice can sometimes restrict you in the future.

If I decide to get on a plane to Australia with my free will, I have restricted myself to only going to Australia.

I can't very well tell the pilot to turn round I've changed my mind and would rather a weekend in Scarbrough, can I?

 

Page 12 of 18 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Creation vs. Evolution Debate