You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Akshata Murty tax affairs
November 21 2026 9.56pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Akshata Murty tax affairs


Page 13 of 14 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 20 Apr 22 7.47am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3715104]

I can read. You just can't comprehend. She doesn't have to pay income tax. She doesn't earn her income in this country, and is not a registered citizen. Also, she is allowed to live off her husband's income. She is the mother of his children, and has been since they were born. And I doubt she was paid maternity leave. As the law stands, she will be treated as a British taxpayer in due course. As I have said before, if you don't like the tax rules, go and protest for change. Berating her, and trying to blame Sunak stinks of envy. Even if you do earn over £100k pa.

It really doesn’t, as evidenced by the weight of opinion on this issue.

Is this your position on everything? Unless your willing to go and ‘protest for change‘ you shouldn’t offer an opinion on anything?

I want Luka Milovojevic to leave the club - am I alright to post that on a messageboard where people express their opinion, or do I need to go and stage a protest first?

Seems a bit of a silly position..

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Apr 22 8.52am

Can we have clarification on who are ‘outraged idiots’?

People angry about this?
Angry on here about this?
People protesting about this?
People angry because a 2 party system causes this?

Any other groups? Can Tim please clarify who are the ‘outraged idiots’ and what views people are allowed to express in his opinion, without being an outraged idiot in his mind?

 


COYP

Mapletree Flag Croydon 20 Apr 22 10.04am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3715104]

I can read. You just can't comprehend. She doesn't have to pay income tax. She doesn't earn her income in this country, and is not a registered citizen. Also, she is allowed to live off her husband's income. She is the mother of his children, and has been since they were born. And I doubt she was paid maternity leave. As the law stands, she will be treated as a British taxpayer in due course. As I have said before, if you don't like the tax rules, go and protest for change. Berating her, and trying to blame Sunak stinks of envy. Even if you do earn over £100k pa.

I can’t comprehend why you say she pays ‘remittance’. I think you mean she would pay tax on any monies she remits to the UK. So that will be none then

I am not envious. I am angry that yet again the guy that sets the rules doesn’t appreciate that he has to be held to the highest level of ethics, even if he can ‘get away’ with using the rules to his advantage. As Sunak benefited massively from the rules until - to his great anger - the truth surfaced, he had an incentive to limit any potential changes that may have been for the greater good.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 21 Apr 22 12.38am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

It really doesn’t, as evidenced by the weight of opinion on this issue.

Is this your position on everything? Unless your willing to go and ‘protest for change‘ you shouldn’t offer an opinion on anything?

I want Luka Milovojevic to leave the club - am I alright to post that on a messageboard where people express their opinion, or do I need to go and stage a protest first?

Seems a bit of a silly position..

The weight of evidenced opinion shows that three weeks after the leak of this information, it is no longer newsworthy. Nothing has happened. Nobody cares. Only the constantly outraged.

The constantly outraged have since picked up a different stick to wave at authority. And will pick up a different one if and when they find it. Because really, they just want to be outraged by something. It really doesn't matter what. Which is why they are idiots. They simply want to have someone removed from position as that is how the get their get their kicks. A bit like wanting players to leave a football club. Ok to say it, but ultimately pointless and idiotic.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

BlueJay Flag UK 21 Apr 22 12.45am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3715353]

The constantly outraged have since picked up a different stick to wave at authority. And will pick up a different one if and when they find it. Because really, they just want to be outraged by something. It really doesn't matter what. Which is why they are idiots. They simply want to have someone removed from position as that is how the get their get their kicks. A bit like wanting players to leave a football club. Ok to say it, but ultimately pointless and idiotic.

Mr 'Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers' is insulting those who ever dare question authority again. He might want to read back his own signature / complaint. Perhaps, by his logic, there was absolutely nothing wrong with what he feels' dragged down by' and he's just a 'constantly outraged' idiot?

Edited by BlueJay (21 Apr 2022 12.46am)

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 21 Apr 22 12.52am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Can we have clarification on who are ‘outraged idiots’?

People angry about this?
Angry on here about this?
People protesting about this?
People angry because a 2 party system causes this?

Any other groups? Can Tim please clarify who are the ‘outraged idiots’ and what views people are allowed to express in his opinion, without being an outraged idiot in his mind?

Yep, that's easy. Those who are outraged by this are idiots if all they do is moan about the rich. There are tax laws that can be used by anyone to pay less tax. If anybody just whines about it, on a football fans forum, they are idiots too. She has done nothing wrong. It's equivalent to a vegan being outraged at you eating meat. You're allowed to do it, but morally it is wrong according to a vegan. However, it won't stop you eating meat.

However, if outraged people are prepared to protest about it, and I mean go and demonstrate outside somewhere officially linked to HMRC, they are not idiots. They are doing something to try and change it.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 21 Apr 22 1.04am

Originally posted by Mapletree

I can’t comprehend why you say she pays ‘remittance’. I think you mean she would pay tax on any monies she remits to the UK. So that will be none then

I am not envious. I am angry that yet again the guy that sets the rules doesn’t appreciate that he has to be held to the highest level of ethics, even if he can ‘get away’ with using the rules to his advantage. As Sunak benefited massively from the rules until - to his great anger - the truth surfaced, he had an incentive to limit any potential changes that may have been for the greater good.

Well, I came to this thread and asked if she had to pay remittance. And if she does it would be £30k, rising to £60k. If she pays no remittance, I'll stand corrected, but this is the first time it was mentioned.

What Sunak does may anger you, and most others, including me, but to post outrage about it whilst doing nothing to change the system is such a futile approach. Do something, like lobby your MP, or write letters to the press, or organise a protest march.

Just stop whining.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

BlueJay Flag UK 21 Apr 22 1.10am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3715357]

Well, I came to this thread and asked if she had to pay remittance. And if she does it would be £30k, rising to £60k. If she pays no remittance, I'll stand corrected, but this is the first time it was mentioned.

What Sunak does may anger you, and most others, including me, but to post outrage about it whilst doing nothing to change the system is such a futile approach. Do something, like lobby your MP, or write letters to the press, or organise a protest march.

Just stop whining.

Thanks for now deciding that it's fine to be 'angered' but not 'outraged' (with you of course being the sole judge of who fits into either criteria). We will await your full list of acceptable responses in .pdf format.

At least now you've also completely rowed back your multiple insults towards those who would wish to protest. At this rate you'll soon be declaring that those who protest tax laws should be knighted. Good stuff!

 

BlueJay Flag UK 21 Apr 22 1.11am

And one more thing while we're at it.... [Link]

Edited by BlueJay (21 Apr 2022 2.04am)

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 21 Apr 22 1.14am

Originally posted by BlueJay

Mr 'Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers' is insulting those who ever dare question authority again. He might want to read back his own signature / complaint. Perhaps, by his logic, there was absolutely nothing wrong with what he feels' dragged down by' and he's just a 'constantly outraged' idiot?

Edited by BlueJay (21 Apr 2022 12.46am)

The strange thing about this is, you are outraged at someone obeying the law. But you are being outraged, on a football fans forum, at someone who points out that it is idiotic to be outraged at somone obeying the rules.

So for all your twisting of what I say, you are the outraged idiot here. I couldn't be more simple. A bit like somebode else I've come across.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 21 Apr 22 1.26am

Originally posted by BlueJay

Thanks for now deciding that it's fine to be 'angered' but not 'outraged' (with you of course being the sole judge of who fits into either criteria). We will await your full list of acceptable responses in .pdf format.

At least now you've also completely rowed back your multiple insults towards those who would wish to protest. At this rate you'll soon be declaring that those who protest tax laws should be knighted. Good stuff!

Really? You think I decide those things. I haven't changed the outraged accusation. Nor have I "rowed back" on anything. I never said anything about "those who would wish to protest". Only that the outraged idiots, like yourself, should go and protest. I mean, you obviousy don't work, as you're posting on here all day and night, as well as researching stuff to link to, so you have loads of time to get a gang together and go and protest outside Parliament.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

BlueJay Flag UK 21 Apr 22 2.09am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3715362]

Really? You think I decide those things. I haven't changed the outraged accusation. Nor have I "rowed back" on anything. I never said anything about "those who would wish to protest". Only that the outraged idiots, like yourself, should go and protest. I mean, you obviousy don't work, as you're posting on here all day and night, as well as researching stuff to link to, so you have loads of time to get a gang together and go and protest outside Parliament.

I don't have a 'gang' I'm afraid, but certainly do work. It would be unconscionable for me to take a few on others if I didn't pay my way.


Also, I'm glad you have this much respect for Rick Astley. I agree, he's a man of quite some talent. A pop scholar.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 21 Apr 22 2.09am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3715361]

The strange thing about this is, you are outraged at someone obeying the law. But you are being outraged, on a football fans forum, at someone who points out that it is idiotic to be outraged at somone obeying the rules.

So for all your twisting of what I say, you are the outraged idiot here. I couldn't be more simple. A bit like somebode else I've come across.

Don't be so hard on yourself.

And oh now people are 'outraged' at you too? Rather than just disagreeing with you.. You seem to recognise a lot of 'outrage' in others (usually while you're relentlessly peppering them with insults and falsely 'informing them' that they don't even have a job).

Edited by BlueJay (21 Apr 2022 2.26am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Apr 22 10.16am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3715356]

Yep, that's easy. Those who are outraged by this are idiots if all they do is moan about the rich. There are tax laws that can be used by anyone to pay less tax. If anybody just whines about it, on a football fans forum, they are idiots too. She has done nothing wrong. It's equivalent to a vegan being outraged at you eating meat. You're allowed to do it, but morally it is wrong according to a vegan. However, it won't stop you eating meat.

However, if outraged people are prepared to protest about it, and I mean go and demonstrate outside somewhere officially linked to HMRC, they are not idiots. They are doing something to try and change it.

Vegans and tax avoidance (by a family deciding the tax people pay so a vested interest) aren’t the best comparisons are they? Eating meat doesn’t affect anyone. The Sunaks do, through being the chancellor and getting away with as much tax avoidance as possible means others have to pay more/have less assistance.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Apr 22 10.23am

Originally posted by BlueJay

Don't be so hard on yourself.

And oh now people are 'outraged' at you too? Rather than just disagreeing with you.. You seem to recognise a lot of 'outrage' in others (usually while you're relentlessly peppering them with insults and falsely 'informing them' that they don't even have a job).

Edited by BlueJay (21 Apr 2022 2.26am)

I think we need a new hol award.

The most outraged
The most outraged idiot - awarded by Tim

Does Tim have this approach to everything? Shut up, never make a comment unless you’re going to protest or actually change it yourself. No discussion, no debate, no displeasure. Change it or you’re an idiot. An outraged idiot. What a joy to be around. Must get invited out loads.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Apr 22 10.35am

Are opinions on tv, radio and newspapers in print and online allowed or are they all outraged idiots as well? If they aren’t physically protesting on the green and pavement outside parliament?…

 


COYP

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Apr 22 11.31am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I think we need a new hol award.

The most outraged
The most outraged idiot - awarded by Tim

Does Tim have this approach to everything? Shut up, never make a comment unless you’re going to protest or actually change it yourself. No discussion, no debate, no displeasure. Change it or you’re an idiot. An outraged idiot. What a joy to be around. Must get invited out loads.

It seems so! I gave a Palace example and he said expressing that view is idiotic as well.

The mental gymnastics are quite fun to watch - the idiot is tying himself in knots trying to defend his nonsensical position.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Apr 22 11.33am

Originally posted by BlueJay

Don't be so hard on yourself.

And oh now people are 'outraged' at you too? Rather than just disagreeing with you.. You seem to recognise a lot of 'outrage' in others (usually while you're relentlessly peppering them with insults and falsely 'informing them' that they don't even have a job).

Edited by BlueJay (21 Apr 2022 2.26am)

He read the term 'outraged idiots' in a tabloid once so now he keeps saying it in the hope it makes him sound smart... it isn't working.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 21 Apr 22 12.15pm

There are only two issues here.

It is OK to vilify someone for legally avoiding tax?

Is it wise for the Chancellor or his wife to be legally avoiding tax?

Clearly it is not a good look for a man in his position, but I would call anyone a liar who said they would not do the same if they were as wealthy.

The morality of a situation often becomes blurred when large sums of money are involved.

I have found that those who shout the loudest about virtue are usually the biggest hypocrites.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 21 Apr 22 2.35pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

There are only two issues here.

It is OK to vilify someone for legally avoiding tax?

Is it wise for the Chancellor or his wife to be legally avoiding tax?

Indeed


Quote
Clearly it is not a good look for a man in his position, but I would call anyone a liar who said they would not do the same if they were as wealthy.

The morality of a situation often becomes blurred when large sums of money are involved.

I have found that those who shout the loudest about virtue are usually the biggest hypocrites.

It's as much an issue of how rules crafted for the rich by the rich are clearly not in the interests of the average person who elects these 'servants of the people'. As in, it's not even about what 'others would do' or one person, but more that the various ways in which politicians, the rich and corporations pick our pocket should have more push back and shouldn't be options to begin with. If there were easy answers we'd already have them, but I'd certainly say that it's not a useful start for people to be 'outraged' that some 'idiots' would take issue with it to begin with.


People may well scoff but fundamentally it's wider discussion about the lack of accountability of those who 'we' elect and who should be 'working for us' not dictating how it is to us with no shame or accountability attached (it that attracts the ubiquitous 'virtue signalling' tag so be it). That's clearly an issue for you and where you feel politicians have led us as much as it is anyone else though really. I doubt many answers exist in greasing the wheels of the status quo (and i don't mean the band!).

Edited by BlueJay (21 Apr 2022 2.39pm)

 

Page 13 of 14 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Akshata Murty tax affairs