You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Signings On The Way
November 22 2026 4.19pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Signings On The Way


Page 131 of 161 < 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 >
Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 29 Sep 20 3.57pm

Originally posted by mattteo

It's not ppssible to get both Sarr and keep Zaha at the same time. Would be great and make us Europa League position candidates, but it won't happen. Either/or. Sarr costs like 40 million. Club wouldn't have that money without letting Zaha go.

Like someone said above, if Zaha leaves without a similar value player coming in, then Eze, Batshuayi, or Brewster won't really mean the squad is better than last year. Younger yes. Better no.

On paper maybe but Zaha did naff all last season and any of the three you mention would provide more in terms of goals and assists in the remaining games than Zaha did last season. No point having a huge earning, quality player in the squad if he’s not performing on the pitch.

 

mattteo Flag 29 Sep 20 4.06pm

Scored 4, assisted 5 and was second in the squad overall, behind Jordan Ayew. Also did aome more on the pitch and was unlucky many times.

A year with a little less from his part, but he usually has 15-20 goals and asists combined per season from a winger position.

I fail to see how the other 3 (Bats, Eze, Brewster or whoever comes) will do that from a winger position. And if they play as center forwards, who will be that winger providing those 8-10 assists pernseason that Zaha usually provides?

Sure, we can have different opinions. You can predict that Eze will have a similar number of assists he had in his only decent Championship season by the age of 23, but I don't think so.

 

sotac464 Flag Berkshire 29 Sep 20 4.27pm

Originally posted by dazza

Things are hotting up, Palace still looking to close at least 2 Deals also may be a loan deal for Reiss Nelson from Arsenal.

We have 4 targets which are: Benrahma, Brewster, Edouard, Sarr

I am still expecting it to be Benrahma & Brewster.

Benteke looking likely to move on as are Innis, Wickham,

Remember deals can still be done with EFL Clubs 16th of October I believe so fringe players could still move on.

Could be an exciting final day window.

Edited by dazza (28 Sep 2020 11.21pm)

Brewster is Sheffield United bound, Sarr won't be coming here, Edouard too expensive, which only leaves Benhrama.

 


My equalibrium unbalanced me. Paul Draper Brighton 19/2/2018

Petereagle Flag Brockley 29 Sep 20 4.41pm

Originally posted by sotac464

Brewster is Sheffield United bound, Sarr won't be coming here, Edouard too expensive, which only leaves Benhrama.

No ITK but I am confident we will sign another young striker. Just don't ask me who!

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 29 Sep 20 5.43pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

No ITK but I am confident we will sign another young striker. Just don't ask me who!

I have heard through the grapevine & i am deffo ITK, albeit in my own lunchbox, that we may or maybe not signing/letting some players leave, as long as 'The Athletic' are up to speed. 'Part from that i know diddly squat

Gonna be a great last few days of the 'transfer' window. Still think we can upset Chelski, its being here in Spain that does it, sorry bout that. Luv u all(ish)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 29 Sep 20 5.45pm

Originally posted by HerneBayPalace

It does but he is on big wages and 33 years old.

If a suitable bid came in, I think we'd have to take a look at it.

This is the window to refresh and reduce the average age, with players like Dann now sadly being part of the problem, in regards to long term.

I don't WANT him to go, but you could see why he could.

I agree. Fully fit squad and he’ll be an expensive bench warmer. He’ll be thinking about his playing opportunities and would walk into a starting position at Boro or QPR for example. I think he’s been such a great servant to the club it would be harsh to deny him a move if the money is right.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 29 Sep 20 7.23pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

I have heard through the grapevine & i am deffo ITK, albeit in my own lunchbox, that we may or maybe not signing/letting some players leave, as long as 'The Athletic' are up to speed. 'Part from that i know diddly squat

Everyone seems to take any pronouncements by anyone at The Athletic as gospel. I wonder if Steve gives them a ring each morning to give them updates as to who we are after

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 29 Sep 20 7.54pm

My guess (not itk) is:

In:
Benrahama - maybe not by end of PL, but by end of EPL window)
Downes - then lent back to Ipswich for the season

Out:
Benteke - not to Spurs, but some Belgium club
Wickham - permanently to Sheffield Wednesday or some other club
Meyer - loaned out to championship club for half a season
Innis - finally time to let him go

IMHO, would still rather us sign Deulofeu than Benrahama, even though he's injured.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 29 Sep 20 8.33pm

Originally posted by Daddyorc

My guess (not itk) is:

In:
Benrahama - maybe not by end of PL, but by end of EPL window)
Downes - then lent back to Ipswich for the season

Out:
Benteke - not to Spurs, but some Belgium club
Wickham - permanently to Sheffield Wednesday or some other club
Meyer - loaned out to championship club for half a season
Innis - finally time to let him go

IMHO, would still rather us sign Deulofeu than Benrahama, even though he's injured.

Very good guesses. My equally nonITK hope is that Sarr will end up in SE25 without Zaha leaving. Fantasy football? You betcha!

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 29 Sep 20 8.50pm

I’d take Sarr. The fact that he is back up on Liverpool and Utd’s list suggests he is a player.

 

kilmenny Flag BROMLEY 29 Sep 20 10.32pm

Not sure getting rid of both Wickham & Benteke is ideal unless there is a new forward identified to come as an injury to either Ayew or Batshuayi would leave squad depth up front in the central positions no better than last year.
Also not sure buying a player & loaning him back is much of an idea as surely the intention should be to strengthen our side.
Roy has already stated his intention not to allow Scott Banks to be loaned out so if we are looking for younger players to strengthen, they should be good enough to go straight into the side or be in the regular squads.

 

Palace Passion Flag Bromley, South London 29 Sep 20 11.25pm

Transfer window done for Palace. We have done our business now with Ferguson, Eze and Batshuayi. Nothing to see here..

 


|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|||||||||||P|A|L|A|C|E|||||||||||
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||


***Oliver Glasner's RED BLUE ARMY***
Be loud.. Be proud.. Be PALACE!

staffie - missed but never forgotten 19/04/15

mattteo Flag 29 Sep 20 11.30pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

I’d take Sarr. The fact that he is back up on Liverpool and Utd’s list suggests he is a player.

Mmmm...I mean no disrespect, butfor 40 million? I feel this is a very serious buy and comments such as "I'd take Sarr" don't do it justice. I mean , sure, I'd take him too. But for a potentially bankruptcy inducing cost? (Cause it's possible with a relegation, hopefully not)

This would need to be analysed very seriously. It's not like paying 10 million on Kouyate and knowing you get your money's worth.

I think the club was pretty shaken having paid those 30 million for Benteke some years ago. A lot of money at that time. Couldn't afford many other buys. Left us in mediocrity for a long time, unable to bring many more talents for much money. We never went high like Leicester, Wolverhampton, even Southampton, cause we couldn't afford their players anymore.

We ought to be very careful with those money.

Edited by mattteo (29 Sep 2020 11.32pm)

 

sprites Flag Auckland 29 Sep 20 11.31pm

Originally posted by Daddyorc

My guess (not itk) is:

In:
Benrahama - maybe not by end of PL, but by end of EPL window)
Downes - then lent back to Ipswich for the season

Out:
Benteke - not to Spurs, but some Belgium club
Wickham - permanently to Sheffield Wednesday or some other club
Meyer - loaned out to championship club for half a season
Innis - finally time to let him go

IMHO, would still rather us sign Deulofeu than Benrahama, even though he's injured.

The thing with Meyer is that if he's not physical enough for the Prem, there's no way he's going to cut it in the championship...where skill/ability give way to strength and endeavour even more so. Maxy needs to play in Spain or somewhere where his obvious ability can shine.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 30 Sep 20 8.03am

Originally posted by mattteo

Mmmm...I mean no disrespect, butfor 40 million? I feel this is a very serious buy and comments such as "I'd take Sarr" don't do it justice. I mean , sure, I'd take him too. But for a potentially bankruptcy inducing cost? (Cause it's possible with a relegation, hopefully not)

This would need to be analysed very seriously. It's not like paying 10 million on Kouyate and knowing you get your money's worth.

I think the club was pretty shaken having paid those 30 million for Benteke some years ago. A lot of money at that time. Couldn't afford many other buys. Left us in mediocrity for a long time, unable to bring many more talents for much money. We never went high like Leicester, Wolverhampton, even Southampton, cause we couldn't afford their players anymore.

We ought to be very careful with those money.

Edited by mattteo (29 Sep 2020 11.32pm)

What you say is true however I do believe SP is probably well aware of any financial implications of high transfer fee. Indeed he has previously stated such. With Benteke possibly going for £10m and £9m for Sorloth both an added bonus this season we should be able to set our sights higher but we will not pay £40m. If Dann goes his fee will be spent on Bella Kotchap imo

Edited by Spiderman (30 Sep 2020 8.04am)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 30 Sep 20 8.45am

Originally posted by Daddyorc

My guess (not itk) is:

In:
Benrahama - maybe not by end of PL, but by end of EPL window)
Downes - then lent back to Ipswich for the season

Out:
Benteke - not to Spurs, but some Belgium club
Wickham - permanently to Sheffield Wednesday or some other club
Meyer - loaned out to championship club for half a season
Innis - finally time to let him go

IMHO, would still rather us sign Deulofeu than Benrahama, even though he's injured.

Not sure Sheffield Wednesday would want him back. If he took a massive drop in wages ( as this club are in financial trouble) Ipswich would have him back like a shot. Son’s girlfriend family are s/t holders there. Perhaps may help getting Downes. However despite the chances of him not finding a club I doubt CW would take such a hit on wages at this time

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 30 Sep 20 9.31am

Originally posted by mattteo

Mmmm...I mean no disrespect, butfor 40 million? I feel this is a very serious buy and comments such as "I'd take Sarr" don't do it justice. I mean , sure, I'd take him too. But for a potentially bankruptcy inducing cost? (Cause it's possible with a relegation, hopefully not)

This would need to be analysed very seriously. It's not like paying 10 million on Kouyate and knowing you get your money's worth.

I think the club was pretty shaken having paid those 30 million for Benteke some years ago. A lot of money at that time. Couldn't afford many other buys. Left us in mediocrity for a long time, unable to bring many more talents for much money. We never went high like Leicester, Wolverhampton, even Southampton, cause we couldn't afford their players anymore.

We ought to be very careful with those money.

Edited by mattteo (29 Sep 2020 11.32pm)

Tbf, I have written a response without analysis and Mattteo has rightly challenged me.

When I said “I’d take Sarr”. If you look the the funds that are potentially available with us being linked with Benrahma and Brewster. I feel the additional 10-15m would be better spent on Sarr.

Sarr had a good first season. Liverpool and united both see him as back up to other targets. If we were to go down, I think we would be able to demand a fee similar to what we paid. At only 22, could be a long term replacement for wilf/townsend.

Yes it is a gamble, but less of a gamble than 20m on Brewster who has only played a handful of professional games. Same with benrahma who has played in the championship, I have not been overly impressed with on the games I have seen him play. He could be another knockhart.

I don’t think the club is that ‘shaken’ by benteke if I’m honest. 80% of the clubs business is on proven premier league players. Players who have been there and done it in the prem. Sarr is someone we would know what we are getting in if we paid the money.

I think the club are more ‘shaken’ by players/managers with no premier league experience hence why we buy the players we do.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 30 Sep 20 9.48am

Originally posted by Spiderman

What you say is true however I do believe SP is probably well aware of any financial implications of high transfer fee. Indeed he has previously stated such. With Benteke possibly going for £10m and £9m for Sorloth both an added bonus this season we should be able to set our sights higher but we will not pay £40m. If Dann goes his fee will be spent on Bella Kotchap imo

Edited by Spiderman (30 Sep 2020 8.04am)

All gone quiet on Kotchap. Google says that he may have been offered to Inter ?

[Link]

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

palace99 Flag New Mills 30 Sep 20 1.17pm

Originally posted by Daddyorc

My guess (not itk) is:

In:
Benrahama - maybe not by end of PL, but by end of EPL window)
Downes - then lent back to Ipswich for the season

Out:
Benteke - not to Spurs, but some Belgium club
Wickham - permanently to Sheffield Wednesday or some other club
Meyer - loaned out to championship club for half a season
Innis - finally time to let him go

IMHO, would still rather us sign Deulofeu than Benrahama, even though he's injured.

Outs - wages will be an issue.

Benteke - no Belgium club could afford his wages.
Wickham - wages ditto. Could happen if Palace subsidise them
Meyer - again wages very high. Back to Germany potentially but we would need to pay him off or subsidise his wages
Inniss - Northampton are interested. If so we will probably pay 100% of his wages whilst on loan

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 30 Sep 20 6.12pm

Originally posted by palace99

Outs - wages will be an issue.

Benteke - no Belgium club could afford his wages.
Wickham - wages ditto. Could happen if Palace subsidise them
Meyer - again wages very high. Back to Germany potentially but we would need to pay him off or subsidise his wages
Inniss - Northampton are interested. If so we will probably pay 100% of his wages whilst on loan

Kind of an update, most of which is already pretty well known . I am posting because it would seem that Palace is a possible loan destination for Reiss Nelson? Obviously a player of great potential, but seems to have gone down the pecking order at Arsenal and prone to injury. maybe a loan with option to buy. Might be a shrewd move? Or maybe not....

[Link]

 

Page 131 of 161 < 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Signings On The Way