This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Sorry Roy in the words of Catherine Jenkins after tonight's display "time to say goodbye"
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I have consistently mentioned about our "Dad's Army" squad and opinied that they would be found out this season, because of a truncated pre-season and the schedule of matches. I’d defy anyone to do better with the squad we’ve got. If anything, Hodgson has massively over-delivered during his time with us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Henry of Peckham
We need four wins from Roy. Please get them ASAP then stand him down to give a new manager some games to motivate the team. Sorry Roy but your permanent retirement is long overdue. NO MORE CONTRACT RENEWALS. Four wins? We’re not going to get four wins between now and the end of the season, that’s for sure. However I expect we will manage at least a win and a couple of draws which is all we will need. I can’t see any of the bottom three getting to 30 points, not without any home fans to give them that extra impetus.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
The Leeds team we played last night is 50% made up of average Championship players, but they all work hard and they are all fit and capable of sprinting around the park for 90 minutes. They have added to their ranks some real talent too and you get the feeling it is a club that knows where it is going. We should be so much better. There are 2 transfer windows each season so Roy has had 8 windows to improve the side. If he was banging down the door of the owners as he should be and brought in one experienced player and one decent youngster (so just two players per window), then we would not be in the position we are now. Instead of investing in the likes of younger players like Eze, we bring in Cahill, Clyne, McCarthy and waste money on players like Jach, Rakip and Sorloth. Unfortunately, it appears Roy is a yes man and has no ambition or desire to stand up to a board and demand changes such that we are now in a situation where we are faced with a squad that is age wise falling off the edge of a cliff. He is in many ways the worst possible manager for us because his system suits, in fact relies upon, old experienced players rather than young dynamic players, therefore unless there is a regular turnover of replacements there is only one direction the club can go in until it becomes unviable. I along with many other Palace fans reckon we have hit that point in time. He has to go and we need to replace probably at least 6 players.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
The Leeds team we played last night is 50% made up of average Championship players, but they all work hard and they are all fit and capable of sprinting around the park for 90 minutes. They have added to their ranks some real talent too and you get the feeling it is a club that knows where it is going. We should be so much better. There are 2 transfer windows each season so Roy has had 8 windows to improve the side. If he was banging down the door of the owners as he should be and brought in one experienced player and one decent youngster (so just two players per window), then we would not be in the position we are now. Instead of investing in the likes of younger players like Eze, we bring in Cahill, Clyne, McCarthy and waste money on players like Jach, Rakip and Sorloth. Unfortunately, it appears Roy is a yes man and has no ambition or desire to stand up to a board and demand changes such that we are now in a situation where we are faced with a squad that is age wise falling off the edge of a cliff. He is in many ways the worst possible manager for us because his system suits, in fact relies upon, old experienced players rather than young dynamic players, therefore unless there is a regular turnover of replacements there is only one direction the club can go in until it becomes unviable. I along with many other Palace fans reckon we have hit that point in time. He has to go and we need to replace probably at least 6 players. Good post some very valid points
|
|
|
Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews
He should go end of season Gary, but they need to have a decent plan in place and be ready to implement it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
The Leeds team we played last night is 50% made up of average Championship players, but they all work hard and they are all fit and capable of sprinting around the park for 90 minutes. They have added to their ranks some real talent too and you get the feeling it is a club that knows where it is going. We should be so much better. There are 2 transfer windows each season so Roy has had 8 windows to improve the side. If he was banging down the door of the owners as he should be and brought in one experienced player and one decent youngster (so just two players per window), then we would not be in the position we are now. Instead of investing in the likes of younger players like Eze, we bring in Cahill, Clyne, McCarthy and waste money on players like Jach, Rakip and Sorloth. Unfortunately, it appears Roy is a yes man and has no ambition or desire to stand up to a board and demand changes such that we are now in a situation where we are faced with a squad that is age wise falling off the edge of a cliff. He is in many ways the worst possible manager for us because his system suits, in fact relies upon, old experienced players rather than young dynamic players, therefore unless there is a regular turnover of replacements there is only one direction the club can go in until it becomes unviable. I along with many other Palace fans reckon we have hit that point in time. He has to go and we need to replace probably at least 6 players. Confronting your employees usually ends one way. You would view it as being a '' yes man '' but equally you could argue that Hodgson is working within the constraints of the financial situation at the club. Here's a quote from November last year ; Hodgson said: “This squad of players has aged together. They have played together, aged together and done a fantastic job. But one has to be realistic and accept that one day that’s going to catch up with us and, maybe, the fresh blood needs to be made available. “It’s something that the chairman and the owners are very aware of, and something that Doug Freedman and I are aware of, too.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
He should go end of season Gary, but they need to have a decent plan in place and be ready to implement it. I agree 100%. It’s strange times at the moment so navigate through this season. Press the reset button with a new manager for 21/22 season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
Confronting your employees usually ends one way. You would view it as being a '' yes man '' but equally you could argue that Hodgson is working within the constraints of the financial situation at the club. Here's a quote from November last year ; Hodgson said: “This squad of players has aged together. They have played together, aged together and done a fantastic job. But one has to be realistic and accept that one day that’s going to catch up with us and, maybe, the fresh blood needs to be made available. “It’s something that the chairman and the owners are very aware of, and something that Doug Freedman and I are aware of, too. All I’m saying is that if the changes were made on a phased but regular basis then we would not be in this position. Shipping 2 out and bringing 2 in each window shouldn’t be beyond the wit of a well run club.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
All I’m saying is that if the changes were made on a phased but regular basis then we would not be in this position. Shipping 2 out and bringing 2 in each window shouldn’t be beyond the wit of a well run club. No you weren't just saying that. You were blaming Hodgson for the club's performance in the last 8 transfer windows. For all his faults, where Palace find themselves now ,with a squad of aging and out of contract players, is not down to Hodgson. Parish has painted himself into a corner with the way the club is being run. Ultimately he carries the can.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
No you weren't just saying that. You were blaming Hodgson for the club's performance in the last 8 transfer windows. For all his faults, where Palace find themselves now ,with a squad of aging and out of contract players, is not down to Hodgson. Parish has painted himself into a corner with the way the club is being run. Ultimately he carries the can. Mr Hodgson is of course the 'Lightning rod' but we have reached the stage whereby the campaign is in it's second half and we have a manager and several players out of contract at the end of the season.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.