This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by hedgehog50
Kurt Vonnegut has written about extra-terrestrial visits in 'Breakfast of Champions', his writer character, Kilgore Trout pens a story about a flying saucer creature named Zog arriving on Earth to explain how wars could be prevented and how cancer could be cured. He brought the information from Margo, a planet where the natives conversed by means of farts and tap dancing. Zog landed at night in Connecticut. He had no sooner touched down than he saw a house on fire. He rushed into the house, farting and tap dancing, warning the people about the terrible danger they were in. The head of the house brained Zog with a golfclub. Edited by hedgehog50 (03 Jul 2017 4.55pm)
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
And this thread was going so well... ..I was filling in for Nick
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
The Nazca lines were probably made by people, at great effort and expense, for religious or cultural reasons that were very important to them. Probably because tribal Shaman and people were getting blitzed to the tits on ayhausca and having massive flying out of body visions or something and the lines exist to guide them back to the earth. its like a Medieval Cathedral. They're monumental undertakings, that took decades to build, cost an absolute fortune to build, are intricate as f**k and serve no real purpose other than being very culturally important that's proportional to the effort, cost and sheer sacrifice. Like the pyramids, building them was very important to the people of the time. But that doesn't mean that they served an objective valuable purpose to us. But to them, its like the medieval Cathedral. Ask any anthropologist, and they'll tell you that societies are not as rational, pragmatic or sensible as we'd like to believe, even ours. It only seems reasonable to the people inside the cultural bubble. Edited by jamiemartin721 (03 Jul 2017 5.04pm) Yes I get that, but they literally sliced the tops off of mountains. That's a lot more impressive than scraping some lines in the ground. It would take us decades with earth moving equipment and explosives. If people of the past were capable of such feats then it casts serious doubt on our interpretation of history. It doesn't need to involve aliens to make this a big story.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Yes I get that, but they literally sliced the tops off of mountains. That's a lot more impressive than scraping some lines in the ground. It would take us decades with earth moving equipment and explosives. If people of the past were capable of such feats then it casts serious doubt on our interpretation of history. It doesn't need to involve aliens to make this a big story. Depends on how long it took them to do it. If they did it quickly, sure, its impressive. If it took them say 150 years less so. People dragged stone from wales to build Stonehenge, because it was 'important enough' to not use local stone. The mountain isn't exactly as flat as many of the 'Alien' theorists suggest either, rather they rely on a selection of photographs that support their argument, rather than more detailed and close up photographs (apparently). It also could certainly be the case that its an old delta or river basin, prior to seismic activity that created it and the mountains around it - as a result of which when the mountains formed, it would be 'flat topped', and debris spread. Certainly, geologists seem to think there is evidence that of old tributary flows, and rivers on the flattened top. Which is seen in a number of mountain ranges elsewhere, all across the world. Of course to the Nazca, it probably looked amazing, this flattened mountain top, which they'd never seen and became a sacred site. Evidence of their gods etc. But its probably just an example of a particular kind of mountain formation process, that occurred ages before they even existed. The mistake is we assume mountains are all peaked, because we, as the general public, don't know much about mountains, and how they're formed. We assume they're peaked because most of the ones we've heard of are peaked. But actually there are plenty of flattened mountainous plateaus across the globe. Thing is, we think mountains, we think mountaineering - but mountaineers only go for the peaked mountains - the challenging ones. Turns out flattened top mountains exist in most mountain ranges.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Depends on how long it took them to do it. If they did it quickly, sure, its impressive. If it took them say 150 years less so. People dragged stone from wales to build Stonehenge, because it was 'important enough' to not use local stone. The mountain isn't exactly as flat as many of the 'Alien' theorists suggest either, rather they rely on a selection of photographs that support their argument, rather than more detailed and close up photographs (apparently). It also could certainly be the case that its an old delta or river basin, prior to seismic activity that created it and the mountains around it - as a result of which when the mountains formed, it would be 'flat topped', and debris spread. Certainly, geologists seem to think there is evidence that of old tributary flows, and rivers on the flattened top. Which is seen in a number of mountain ranges elsewhere, all across the world. Of course to the Nazca, it probably looked amazing, this flattened mountain top, which they'd never seen and became a sacred site. Evidence of their gods etc. But its probably just an example of a particular kind of mountain formation process, that occurred ages before they even existed. The mistake is we assume mountains are all peaked, because we, as the general public, don't know much about mountains, and how they're formed. We assume they're peaked because most of the ones we've heard of are peaked. But actually there are plenty of flattened mountainous plateaus across the globe. Thing is, we think mountains, we think mountaineering - but mountaineers only go for the peaked mountains - the challenging ones. Turns out flattened top mountains exist in most mountain ranges. That would be a good explanation if it can be show to be true. It would require conclusive evidence of course like any other theory.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Of course the trouble with the whole alien subject is that people are not generally neutral about it. You have the 'I want to believe camp' who are more likely to see any ambiguous evidence as positive and you have the smug camp who scoff at every bit of evidence because it does not fit with their belief system of what is real. I think the ancient alien theory is flimsy to say the least but it does throw up questions about man's history and our grasp of it. With UFO's and aliens in general I think it helps if you have had some personal experience. For me, genuine UFOs can only be alien, from the future or military misdirection. The people that know don't talk and don't care what we believe. There have been some deathbed confessions but skeptics would have to meet an alien before they believed and some not even then. If we have technology that can stop and make turns of 90 degrees going at enormous speed then that is a huge story in itself. It also begs the question as to what else we have.
The one thing I would say is that there's a film recently released called "Unacknowledged" which contains people who worked in the military etc who are now coming out about what they've seen and the cover ups they've (allegedly) been involved with...its certainly an interesting watch..nothing more than a documentary type affair which poses some interesting questions.
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
That would be a good explanation if it can be show to be true. It would require conclusive evidence of course like any other theory. I'm not sure if its conclusive to that specific incident, but its a common enough phenomena in geology that there are 'plateau topped' mountains, and that geological research typically points to these being river basins etc prior to tectonic shifts. The Nasca mountains do lie on a tectonic line as well. The evidence doesn't have to be conclusive though, it really only has to be more plausible than the alternatives and fit into commonly held knowledge of geological formations.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
The one thing I would say is that there's a film recently released called "Unacknowledged" which contains people who worked in the military etc who are now coming out about what they've seen and the cover ups they've (allegedly) been involved with...its certainly an interesting watch..nothing more than a documentary type affair which poses some interesting questions. Thing is books about alien coverups and alien interaction in the past sell much better, and have a much wider audience that books of geological formations of non-peaked mountains - and most people writing about alien theories don't have an interest in complex geology (or even know where to look) and those that do, aren't selling books anyhow. I read a bit of Timothy Good back in the 90s, and afterwards I read a lot of the Psychological phenomena involved in the 'supernatural' and its just more reasonable, plausible and scientifically backed up - and that's what makes it more plausible. I don't disbelieve in Aliens. Just that maybe they're not travelling across the gulf of space to just abduct one or two people of no consequence and instead that those people, fit into a more plausible explanation that needs to be disproven first. Likewise, people coming forward. You need to vet them thoroughly as eye witnesses, and be able to demonstate some real evidence that lends to their credibility. Anyone who's ex-Service could claim to be part of the conspiracy, and cash in on that market. Problem tends to be the research of 'paranormal investigators' and their methodology is piss poor at best, they don't seem to understand hypothesis testing and immediately make the jump that a question in an answer is the same as proving their end hypothesis. We studied this kind of thing quite a lot when I was studying psychology (I even did a two week unit on parapsychology).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Thing is books about alien coverups and alien interaction in the past sell much better, and have a much wider audience that books of geological formations of non-peaked mountains - and most people writing about alien theories don't have an interest in complex geology (or even know where to look) and those that do, aren't selling books anyhow. I read a bit of Timothy Good back in the 90s, and afterwards I read a lot of the Psychological phenomena involved in the 'supernatural' and its just more reasonable, plausible and scientifically backed up - and that's what makes it more plausible. I don't disbelieve in Aliens. Just that maybe they're not travelling across the gulf of space to just abduct one or two people of no consequence and instead that those people, fit into a more plausible explanation that needs to be disproven first. Likewise, people coming forward. You need to vet them thoroughly as eye witnesses, and be able to demonstate some real evidence that lends to their credibility. Anyone who's ex-Service could claim to be part of the conspiracy, and cash in on that market. Problem tends to be the research of 'paranormal investigators' and their methodology is piss poor at best, they don't seem to understand hypothesis testing and immediately make the jump that a question in an answer is the same as proving their end hypothesis. We studied this kind of thing quite a lot when I was studying psychology (I even did a two week unit on parapsychology).
But cutting through all the if's, what's, and maybe's around peoples motivations and limitations, what are people seeing in the skies? They aren't figments of imagination and they can do things that conventional aircraft can't. Clearly there is money to be made from the UFO phenomenon but are we really saying that it is all nonsense? Because only one event has to be real and there are people who have been in high places who seem convinced.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I'm not sure if its conclusive to that specific incident, but its a common enough phenomena in geology that there are 'plateau topped' mountains, and that geological research typically points to these being river basins etc prior to tectonic shifts. The Nasca mountains do lie on a tectonic line as well. The evidence doesn't have to be conclusive though, it really only has to be more plausible than the alternatives and fit into commonly held knowledge of geological formations.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
But cutting through all the if's, what's, and maybe's around peoples motivations and limitations, what are people seeing in the skies? They aren't figments of imagination and they can do things that conventional aircraft can't. Clearly there is money to be made from the UFO phenomenon but are we really saying that it is all nonsense? Because only one event has to be real and there are people who have been in high places who seem convinced.
You're both right about evidence (or the lack of it) and that its convenient for us all to wait for irrefutable proof that there's something else at play. As Humans we dont like change, we like to feel secure...which is one of the premises in the Documentary. Challenging theories is healthy though...we should never be complacent about the normal state of things, otherwise we'll never evolve as a species....you never know that piece of evidence could be just around the corner waiting to be found...
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
You're both right about evidence (or the lack of it) and that its convenient for us all to wait for irrefutable proof that there's something else at play. As Humans we dont like change, we like to feel secure...which is one of the premises in the Documentary. Challenging theories is healthy though...we should never be complacent about the normal state of things, otherwise we'll never evolve as a species....you never know that piece of evidence could be just around the corner waiting to be found... I just watched 'Unacknowledged'. It was interesting but mainly covered stuff that is already out there. Of course without 'official' conformation or a piece of the Roswell space craft, it remains unconfirmed as far as the public is concerned.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I just watched 'Unacknowledged'. It was interesting but mainly covered stuff that is already out there. Of course without 'official' conformation or a piece of the Roswell space craft, it remains unconfirmed as far as the public is concerned.
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
Yes it's disturbing. The whole idea that there are debunkers placed in the media and scientific community seems totally plausible as well. You only have to create an environment where people are considered cranks for pursuing the subject and then let it proliferate.
|
|
|
My contributions to this thread seem to have put me on the radar of Satanic cults that surprisingly have a decent array of banner adverts.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
These kind of make sense, from a objective view point, because efficient energy patents could affect profits and would have no real interest to energy companies (who clearly wouldn't want to make less money). After all, if your business is fossil fuel, something like 'cold fusion' (for example) represents becoming obsolete. There was similar 'blackening' of the reputation of Nuclear energy (an arguably cleaner fuel than fossil fuels) by the oil and gas industry, focusing specifically on the Nuclear aspect.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The problem is, why would geologists be interested in proving what they know is most probably the case an example of a very basic known phenomena, and UFO aficionados aren't going to want to prove it, they're busy with the 'truth' and they're only going to claim its a cover up, and write new conspiracies this time involving geologist working for the CIA or some such. Its pretty reasonable - Ayres rock and Tabletop mountain are examples of the phenomena, and they occur in most mountain regions across the world. The emphasis is on the researcher to prove that its not the product of a natural phenomena (i.e. you have to prove your hypothesis, by demonstrating that the null hypothesis is false and no other, more plausable explanation exists. People have always had a nice line in making money off believers. From religion, to cults, everyone wants to believe in something.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Clearly there is money to be made from the UFO phenomenon but are we really saying that it is all nonsense? Because only one event has to be real and there are people who have been in high places who seem convinced. Firstly, psychological phenomena aren't nonsense. Oddly, the study of parapsychology has revolutionised human understanding of neurology and how our senses work (read Paranormality - it's a book about how studying claims of the paranormal helps us understand more about the mind and brain). Secondly, I think that there is more to unearth here as well, its just that its in the 5-10% that can't be easily explained or the explaination is effectively a 'dismissal without justification' (i.e. Sceptics being too sceptical) Problem is, when ever an explaination of a paranormal phenomena occurs, its always going to be less exciting than the spurious claims. Telepathy becomes Body Language reading and NLP. Ghosts become infrasound etc and the believers aren't interested in that. People still believe in Spontanous Human Combustion - even though its been proven to be a combination of unlikely events. People claim that the events are 'unlikely' and that's true, but then cases of SHC are also incredibly rare so it wouldn't be unusual for them to consist of a unlikely occurrence of events. Basically the person passes out, or dies, typically exposed to a mild accelerant (usually alcohol or perfume), and a source of fire (cigarettes, fireplace or spark). The accelerant burns slowly but sufficiently to ignite the tissue fat, which causes the person to burn very thoroughly at a very high temperature.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.