You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread
November 20 2026 5.27pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Benteke thread


Page 14 of 166 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
spartakev2 Flag Anerley 15 Jan 18 7.36pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

This is turning into another hate thread .
I think we should just agree to disagree .
Younglad , Jay-jay , Spartakev we all know you don't like Benteke and think he is lazy , fair enough that is your opinion . My points and others will not change that opinion and you will not change others.
Let's leave it at that we do not need another Hennessey thread.

Fair enough.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 15 Jan 18 8.15pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

the thing I can't abide is the "chase-down the-keeper-you-lazy-f***er" attitude of many at the ground. says so much about those people.

Benteke will come great.

Well said Sir

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 15 Jan 18 8.17pm

Originally posted by jayjaychil

His pass for Sako was sublime??

Haha he lifted it overt the full back out to the wing. Hardly a defence splitting ball. Come on


Perhaps sublime was the wrong choice but not the pass of a s*** player.

 

jayjaychil Flag london 15 Jan 18 9.29pm

Curious....what does it say about hose people who want Benteke to work hard?

Originally posted by Spiderman

Well said Sir


 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 15 Jan 18 10.45pm

Originally posted by jayjaychil

Curious....what does it say about hose people who want Benteke to work hard?

Fair question. In my personal opinion, his job is to be the focal point / link man when we have the ball and when we don't have the ball his job is to either hassle central defenders in his vicinity so they don't get loads of time to pick a pass or to plug up their passing channels.

He can't do this if he's running around chasing everything without the ball (Cameron Jerome / Frazier Campbell style) and his job isn't to run the channels as we then have no-one in the middle to play the ball to.

Hard work from a frontman for the sake of it doesn't make him effective. Hard work, like outmuscling the Burnley player to get on the ball and then pick just the right ball to release Sako for the goal, is the hard work I want him to be doing.

This all just says that you have a different view of what "hard work" from our number 9 should be to others, probably including Roy given that Tekkers is most certainly now doing exactly what the managers wants (apart from stick chances away).

Edited by Mr_Gristle (15 Jan 2018 10.45pm)

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

chateauferret Flag 15 Jan 18 11.03pm

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

Fair question. In my personal opinion, his job is to be the focal point / link man when we have the ball and when we don't have the ball his job is to either hassle central defenders in his vicinity so they don't get loads of time to pick a pass or to plug up their passing channels.

He can't do this if he's running around chasing everything without the ball (Cameron Jerome / Frazier Campbell style) and his job isn't to run the channels as we then have no-one in the middle to play the ball to.

Hard work from a frontman for the sake of it doesn't make him effective. Hard work, like outmuscling the Burnley player to get on the ball and then pick just the right ball to release Sako for the goal, is the hard work I want him to be doing.

This all just says that you have a different view of what "hard work" from our number 9 should be to others, probably including Roy given that Tekkers is most certainly now doing exactly what the managers wants (apart from stick chances away).

Edited by Mr_Gristle (15 Jan 2018 10.45pm)

I thought that first time pass out behind him to Sako was sublime, but some people here think it was a lucky punt.

 


============
The Ferret
============

jayjaychil Flag london 16 Jan 18 12.53pm

If you're normally watching Airdrieonians then I can understand you thinking it was sublime. If on the other hand you've played football at any sort of standard you would probably think it was just a lob out to Sako on the wing. Nothing more!

Originally posted by chateauferret

I thought that first time pass out behind him to Sako was sublime, but some people here think it was a lucky punt.


 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 16 Jan 18 1.34pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

I thought that first time pass out behind him to Sako was sublime, but some people here think it was a lucky punt.

For £120k a week I want a lot more than that!

 


Bring back Brolin

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 16 Jan 18 1.38pm

I think out thoughts are fairly irrelevent, we know he is not burying chances at the moment however the big questions are:

1) Is Benteke providing the work rate on match day that Roy has asked of him on the training pitch?
2) Is he getting into the positions on the pitch that he has been asked to do?

If the answer to both is no then Roy will no doubt try a different striker as soon as we have one.

My feeling from what I have seen is that he is working harder for his teammates and his link play has been good, however he still fails to find that killer position in the box which has actually been found a few times previously this season by Jimmy Mc and Sako.

Some players have a natural instinct of where to stand depending on the angle of where the attack is coming from, others don't but I feel sure that he has now spent enough time on the training ground with Wilf, Andros and Bakary to know what is likely to happen when they are attacking so he should be reading those goal scoring positions better.

I'd love to see him do what Lukaku did for Manure last night, that swivel and shot to take out two players is exactly what a big CF like Tekkers should be capable of.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Jan 18 2.42pm

Originally posted by jayjaychil

If you're normally watching Airdrieonians then I can understand you thinking it was sublime. If on the other hand you've played football at any sort of standard you would probably think it was just a lob out to Sako on the wing. Nothing more!



I have played football thank you. As previously agreed it may not have been sublime but you seem to suggest it was a lucky punt. He was fully aware of where Sako was and was a very good pass.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Jan 18 2.44pm

Originally posted by Spiderman


I have played football thank you. As previously agreed it may not have been sublime but you seem to suggest it was a lucky punt. He was fully aware of where Sako was and was a very good pass.

Yes I agree.
Let's give Benteke some credit.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Jan 18 2.46pm

Originally posted by jayjaychil

If you're normally watching Airdrieonians then I can understand you thinking it was sublime. If on the other hand you've played football at any sort of standard you would probably think it was just a lob out to Sako on the wing. Nothing more!


May I also suggest you watch Luca's goal against Southampton. CB controlled the ball on halfway outwitted defenders and set up the attack down the right hand side. That my friend was extremely good hold up play! Is he scoring enough? of course not. Is he contributing? Absolutely

 

youngpalacefan111 Flag 16 Jan 18 2.56pm

Is he contributing enough to warrant his 120k a week and 30mill price tag. Wayne Hennessey has contributed just as much as benteke yet earns 100k a week less and cost 27mill less.

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 16 Jan 18 4.14pm

Originally posted by youngpalacefan111

Is he contributing enough to warrant his 120k a week and 30mill price tag. Wayne Hennessey has contributed just as much as benteke yet earns 100k a week less and cost 27mill less.

An early contender for most stupidest post of the year.

 

youngpalacefan111 Flag 16 Jan 18 4.25pm

Oh really big man so you think Bentekes performances have been way better than Hennessey, I'm comparing those two as they have both been our worst performers but one cost 3mill the other cost 30mill

 

60 yrs a palace fan Flag 16 Jan 18 4.48pm

Originally posted by youngpalacefan111

Oh really big man so you think Bentekes performances have been way better than Hennessey, I'm comparing those two as they have both been our worst performers but one cost 3mill the other cost 30mill

How you can compare a keeper to a striker is strange.

Unfortunately you and jay jay have a hate campaign against Benteke.

His goal ratio in the premier league is .39. Goals a game.

If you want statistics as you keep on going on about them look up his stats.

Played 34 games at villa 2012/13 19 goals 26 games. 10 goals 13/14. 29 games. 13 goals 14/15

Liverpool 29 games 13 goals 15/16

Palace 36 games 15 goals.16/17

17 games 1 goal.

The stats show that he is not the striker you expect him to be.

Many strikers go through a lean spell and it’s frustrating for the fans but it’s a fact it happens.
Get over it

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 16 Jan 18 4.49pm

Originally posted by youngpalacefan111

Oh really big man so you think Bentekes performances have been way better than Hennessey, I'm comparing those two as they have both been our worst performers but one cost 3mill the other cost 30mill

For a start Speroni has been in goal for half the season, with him and Hennesey making about the same number of appearances this season. If memory serves its about 13 or so each.

And your comparing an outfield players contribution to a goal keepers which is bonkers.

Edited by Dannyh.V2 (16 Jan 2018 4.50pm)

 

Username Flag Horsham 16 Jan 18 4.49pm

Originally posted by youngpalacefan111

Is he contributing enough to warrant his 120k a week and 30mill price tag. Wayne Hennessey has contributed just as much as benteke yet earns 100k a week less and cost 27mill less.

I don't see what his price tag and wages have to do with it at this point? He's already here, we're not discussing a new contract or buying him again?

He is contributing to the team, and in the last few games he's contributed to roughly the same amount of goals as Wilf?

By contributed I mean he has either scored, assisted or been heavily involved in the build up to.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Jan 18 4.55pm

Rightly or wrongly, strikers are judged on the amount of goals they score and whether they are a success or failure is determined by the number of times they hit the back of the net.

Benteke has only scored 1 goal in 17 games so one can understand the 'Negatives' against him, despite the part he has played in some of our goals.

 

jayjaychil Flag london 16 Jan 18 4.57pm

You make some good points.

Of course I don't want him chasing every lost cause and being piggy in the middle when the centre backs are back and forth. But there is a wrong and a right time to press. This is what I mean by his football brain. At the right time he doesn't go.

My biggest concern with his work rate however is his desire to beat that defender to the near post etc. He just doesn't seem to get himself anywhere near those full stop. His positional play is bad. How often to you see him lurking about on the edge of the box when he should be getting across the defender in the 6 yard box.

He was called a statue when he was at Liverpool and that was with better service than we give him on the whole.

A busted flush in my opinion

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

Fair question. In my personal opinion, his job is to be the focal point / link man when we have the ball and when we don't have the ball his job is to either hassle central defenders in his vicinity so they don't get loads of time to pick a pass or to plug up their passing channels.

He can't do this if he's running around chasing everything without the ball (Cameron Jerome / Frazier Campbell style) and his job isn't to run the channels as we then have no-one in the middle to play the ball to.

Hard work from a frontman for the sake of it doesn't make him effective. Hard work, like outmuscling the Burnley player to get on the ball and then pick just the right ball to release Sako for the goal, is the hard work I want him to be doing.

This all just says that you have a different view of what "hard work" from our number 9 should be to others, probably including Roy given that Tekkers is most certainly now doing exactly what the managers wants (apart from stick chances away).

Edited by Mr_Gristle (15 Jan 2018 10.45pm)


 

Page 14 of 166 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread