You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Post EU World
November 21 2026 9.57pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Post EU World


Page 148 of 156 < 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 >
Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 03 Dec 23 8.31pm

Originally posted by cryrst

There are some who are a lost cause so they aren’t worth affecting but there are many on benefits who will be in a worse financial position by being employed. Maybe if the incentive was to be in a better position for making the effort.
Ie if someone has a benefit income inc reductions in rent and council tax etc of £1500 a month say. Then if they get a job then put them in a better position. So they earn £1000 a month give them another £1000. That’s a £500 incentive to work. Over time with pay rises etc keep the equation. That way hmg pay less and the person gets on the job ladder and realises it’s not that bad. Eventually the wages may be enough to have no benefits and independence makes them feel better. The sums and how to is probably not easy but just a thought.

I am out of date on this but believe that Universal Credit does already make incentives of this kind so that you keep your benefits for the first hours you work and then they get reduced incrementally as you earn more. It’s a very complicated system which perhaps others can explain.

It doesn’t though seem to be having the desired impact in all circumstances.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 03 Dec 23 10.07pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I am out of date on this but believe that Universal Credit does already make incentives of this kind so that you keep your benefits for the first hours you work and then they get reduced incrementally as you earn more. It’s a very complicated system which perhaps others can explain.

It doesn’t though seem to be having the desired impact in all circumstances.

It may work as you say but the incentive should be you get more for working. Not the same. That’s the point, there may be no incentive to put the effort in without a reward.if it’s £30 a week what’s the point to get out of bed tbh.

Edited by cryrst (03 Dec 2023 10.08pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 03 Dec 23 11.04pm

Originally posted by cryrst

It may work as you say but the incentive should be you get more for working. Not the same. That’s the point, there may be no incentive to put the effort in without a reward.if it’s £30 a week what’s the point to get out of bed tbh.

Edited by cryrst (03 Dec 2023 10.08pm)

Many people abuse the benefits system. More should be done to stamp out fraud and identify lead swingers. The benefits paid should be substantially reduced - you would suddenly find many of these people then seeking work, although they would probably be pretty mediocre employees.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 Dec 23 8.00am

Originally posted by cryrst

It may work as you say but the incentive should be you get more for working. Not the same. That’s the point, there may be no incentive to put the effort in without a reward.if it’s £30 a week what’s the point to get out of bed tbh.

Edited by cryrst (03 Dec 2023 10.08pm)

I am in favour of incentivizing people to work. The problem is that employers knowing their staff our getting a bung from the taxpayer keep their wages low so we are actually subsiding bad employers through the working tax credit.

The minimum wage is the tool to solve this. Crackdown on the shirkers whilst increasing that forcing employers to pay a decent wage so work pays.

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Dec 23 8.10am

Originally posted by cryrst

There are some who are a lost cause so they aren’t worth affecting but there are many on benefits who will be in a worse financial position by being employed. Maybe if the incentive was to be in a better position for making the effort.
Ie if someone has a benefit income inc reductions in rent and council tax etc of £1500 a month say. Then if they get a job then put them in a better position. So they earn £1000 a month give them another £1000. That’s a £500 incentive to work. Over time with pay rises etc keep the equation. That way hmg pay less and the person gets on the job ladder and realises it’s not that bad. Eventually the wages may be enough to have no benefits and independence makes them feel better. The sums and how to is probably not easy but just a thought.

The problem there is that inflation usually outpaces wage rises.

The problems here are multifactored.....people wanted the covid response, people wanted involvement in foreign wars and thus energy and cost impacts. They want what the media sell them but they don't want the consequences on living standards.

The cost of living with housing and food versus blue collar wages doesn't add up.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Dec 2023 8.55am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 05 Dec 23 2.01pm

Nothing like taking back control is there.

'Tories using Brexit to threaten state pension'.

You would think there was nothing left for them to steal.

[Link]

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 18 Jan 24 2.57pm

It's 2024 and the desperate search for a Brexit benefit intensifies.

Here at last, the Daily Express and tories trumpet 'masses of shellfish beds' in the Thames Estuary which of course can't have been there before Brexit itself.

[Link]

It's sad and pathetic worse than Rwanda.

The Thames is now a class 'B' water (it's full of sewage) you cannot harvest anything there for sale.

The shellfish have to be sent away to be purified.

To the EU, as we don't have anything. and we are not in the single market so it's an expensive hassle.



 

Teddy Eagle Flag 18 Jan 24 3.05pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

It's 2024 and the desperate search for a Brexit benefit intensifies.

Here at last, the Daily Express and tories trumpet 'masses of shellfish beds' in the Thames Estuary which of course can't have been there before Brexit itself.

[Link]

It's sad and pathetic worse than Rwanda.

The Thames is now a class 'B' water (it's full of sewage) you cannot harvest anything there for sale.

The shellfish have to be sent away to be purified.

To the EU, as we don't have anything. and we are not in the single market so it's an expensive hassle.



The benefit of Brexit is schadenfreude at the reaction it provokes. Now you know how everyone else feels about "woke" issues.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Jan 24 5.41pm

What the future of Europe needs to be.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Jan 24 5.56pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

It's 2024 and the desperate search for a Brexit benefit intensifies.

Here at last, the Daily Express and tories trumpet 'masses of shellfish beds' in the Thames Estuary which of course can't have been there before Brexit itself.

[Link]

It's sad and pathetic worse than Rwanda.

The Thames is now a class 'B' water (it's full of sewage) you cannot harvest anything there for sale.

The shellfish have to be sent away to be purified.

To the EU, as we don't have anything. and we are not in the single market so it's an expensive hassle.



I'm going to be interested in how you see this question in a few years Steely as currently both France and Germany are probably on the path to having considerably more right wing governments than what even Farage would be here.

I wonder if you'd be so pro the EU project then.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 22 Jan 24 2.51pm

Surely the greatest irony about Brexit.

'Brexit has made the UK a more multi-cultural, less white place'.

Andrew Marr, unmuzzled from the BBC, turning out a series of thought-provoking videos.

[Link]

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Jan 24 3.19pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Surely the greatest irony about Brexit.

'Brexit has made the UK a more multi-cultural, less white place'.

Andrew Marr, unmuzzled from the BBC, turning out a series of thought-provoking videos.

[Link]

Funny how it's done that all across Europe too. Amazing knock on effect of one country leaving.

Surely too then Brexit should be celebrated by those seeking multi cultural diversity? It's giving them what they want surely? So it is delivering.

 


Red and Blue Army!

silvertop Flag Portishead 23 Jan 24 9.56am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Funny how it's done that all across Europe too. Amazing knock on effect of one country leaving.

Surely too then Brexit should be celebrated by those seeking multi cultural diversity? It's giving them what they want surely? So it is delivering.

By way of unconditional visa terms imposed by countries in unbalanced trade negotiations? Yes, that's what we all wanted.

Also, why do you equate Remain with multi cultural diversity? It was never my motivation as a Remainer. I was for free trade and the free movement of European labour, as well as being inside the tent while the world was becoming more unstable out of it, especially from the East.

In fact, how does being inside increase muti-cultural diversity? Remainers always did and continue to scoff at Brexiteers who thought that leaving the EU would address non EU immigration. Aside for some laws they didn't like - which have not been reversed despite a humungous parliamentary majority - where is the link?

And on those laws, could it be that the government has not scrapped them because every trade deal we seek to strike has easy visas as a condition and the very laws Brexiteers thought would be made to stop immigration and deport immigrants will act against those easy visas?

Interesting comment from Marr that the "imposed" ethnic diversity in media and advertising that drives us al insane is created by capitalists who see the way we are heading, and not the BBC or some woke Council etc.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 23 Jan 24 12.29pm

Originally posted by silvertop

By way of unconditional visa terms imposed by countries in unbalanced trade negotiations? Yes, that's what we all wanted.

Also, why do you equate Remain with multi cultural diversity? It was never my motivation as a Remainer. I was for free trade and the free movement of European labour, as well as being inside the tent while the world was becoming more unstable out of it, especially from the East.

In fact, how does being inside increase muti-cultural diversity? Remainers always did and continue to scoff at Brexiteers who thought that leaving the EU would address non EU immigration. Aside for some laws they didn't like - which have not been reversed despite a humungous parliamentary majority - where is the link?

And on those laws, could it be that the government has not scrapped them because every trade deal we seek to strike has easy visas as a condition and the very laws Brexiteers thought would be made to stop immigration and deport immigrants will act against those easy visas?

Interesting comment from Marr that the "imposed" ethnic diversity in media and advertising that drives us al insane is created by capitalists who see the way we are heading, and not the BBC or some woke Council etc.

This is a twisting of the remain agenda. Brexiteers were labelled as racists several times. Whilst remain was the welcome all argument. The EU allocated refugees by number to each state - so the UK would have literally had to take a certain amount. It doesn't have to now but still does, which is a failure of government - not Brexit.
And this doesn't answer my other points. The EU is awash with migrants - I won't get into who they are. How then has Brexit made Europe full of migrants? Britain is merely following the trends of the rest of Europe. Again, something remainers should celebrate. Britain in line with Europe.
You wanted your own personal type of remain - I can understand that - as most wanted their own personal type of Brexit. Unfortunately, neither has happened.
However, to suggest that immigration is to do with Brexit is clearly false. It is to do with lack of Border Controls, cowtowing to NGOs and being a lackey to the EU courts. Which, is never going to rule in the UK's favour on anything unless it benefits the EU commission. Simple as that.
My post was tongue in cheek in some ways, but funny how humour can indeed frame seriousness.
Remainers want Brexit to fail so even when it has outcomes that they would normally celebrate, Brexit is labelled a failure. I find that humourous and suspect others do to. This is mirrored in many walks of life and politics today. To follow the argument through, am I then to draw the conclusion that remainers in general don't want more diversity? Are they then anti diversity as it is supposedly an outcome of Brexit? The whole argument immediately falls down in several ways. But it did give me a laugh - if no one else.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 23 Jan 24 1.03pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

What the future of Europe needs to be.

White and American?

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 23 Jan 24 1.19pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

White and American?

Californian Chardonnay?

 


Red and Blue Army!

silvertop Flag Portishead 23 Jan 24 4.51pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

This is a twisting of the remain agenda. Brexiteers were labelled as racists several times. Whilst remain was the welcome all argument. The EU allocated refugees by number to each state - so the UK would have literally had to take a certain amount. It doesn't have to now but still does, which is a failure of government - not Brexit.
And this doesn't answer my other points. The EU is awash with migrants - I won't get into who they are. How then has Brexit made Europe full of migrants? Britain is merely following the trends of the rest of Europe. Again, something remainers should celebrate. Britain in line with Europe.
You wanted your own personal type of remain - I can understand that - as most wanted their own personal type of Brexit. Unfortunately, neither has happened.
However, to suggest that immigration is to do with Brexit is clearly false. It is to do with lack of Border Controls, cowtowing to NGOs and being a lackey to the EU courts. Which, is never going to rule in the UK's favour on anything unless it benefits the EU commission. Simple as that.
My post was tongue in cheek in some ways, but funny how humour can indeed frame seriousness.
Remainers want Brexit to fail so even when it has outcomes that they would normally celebrate, Brexit is labelled a failure. I find that humourous and suspect others do to. This is mirrored in many walks of life and politics today. To follow the argument through, am I then to draw the conclusion that remainers in general don't want more diversity? Are they then anti diversity as it is supposedly an outcome of Brexit? The whole argument immediately falls down in several ways. But it did give me a laugh - if no one else.

I know I am arguing from my own viewpoint, but to label Remainers as universally "progressive" is a mistake. Also, I think you have twisted at least the Remain agenda.

To criticize Brexiteers as largely "racist" does not mean that those criticizing are all inclusivity, multi-culturalist, wokes. They may be. They may not be. It is quite possible to despair at someone placing the X informed entirely by a desire to keep people of colour out of the UK when placing that X will do nothing of the sort... while, at the same time, advocating effective modes of stronger border control that might actually achieve that.

Quotas? I am willing to be educated here, but how many migrants have we taken in as part of some EU quota system? I am not talking genuine asylum seekers as no-one but the most rabidly anti immigrant would resist homing them. They are too small in number to be meaningful. I mean largely young, male, wholly economic migrants who are of vast number.

The courts and laws are protective of human rights and those have been exploited by those seeking to migrate here and elsewhere across the EU. So change them? No? That is a fault of government.

As EU members we could have advocated change of the law in light of the 2015 migrant crisis and would have been pushing at an open door had we tried; certainly now with the change in political colour across Europe. We didn't and now can't change what happens on the Continent. However, what is baffling is we have made no real attempt to make those changes here.

There are undoubtedly things we could have done unilaterally as EU members. Austria bans any non Austrians from buying in the Tyrol, for example, and Luxembourg is all but a closed shop.

And we could have properly resourced border control. Again, another thing we could have done without losing the benefit of being inside.

However, I think your attempt to distinguish immigration from border control is specious. Also, it was always a soft border for EU nationals and hard border for most non EU nationals. For the latter, what has changed?

In polls conducted at or around that time, the 2 far ahead topics on people's agenda was the NHS (as always) and immigration. It is the economy now, but then immigration was all there was on the media, especially with the issues and consequences of events in Libya etc. That is what got Brexit over the line.

You clearly didn't watch that Marr podcast. He said that non-white migration has increased under Brexit because we are forced to accept easy visas to negotiate trade deals. This would not have happened under the EU as we already had a trade deal with those countries and, anyway, would have had the collective strength to tell India and so on where to go.

Finally, of course part of the Remainer wants to see Brexit fail and for a return to an altered EU which has tighter borders, more restrictive laws on migration and places most emphasis on free trade and EU labour movement over more sovereign issues. However, another part of this Remainer understands the basic equation: Brexit fail = UK fail. What resident wants his own country to fail?

I am aware I am having a serious argument with a person whose MO is bon mots, but I simply couldn't resist rising to the points you made.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 23 Jan 24 5.10pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I know I am arguing from my own viewpoint, but to label Remainers as universally "progressive" is a mistake. Also, I think you have twisted at least the Remain agenda.

To criticize Brexiteers as largely "racist" does not mean that those criticizing are all inclusivity, multi-culturalist, wokes. They may be. They may not be. It is quite possible to despair at someone placing the X informed entirely by a desire to keep people of colour out of the UK when placing that X will do nothing of the sort... while, at the same time, advocating effective modes of stronger border control that might actually achieve that.

Quotas? I am willing to be educated here, but how many migrants have we taken in as part of some EU quota system? I am not talking genuine asylum seekers as no-one but the most rabidly anti immigrant would resist homing them. They are too small in number to be meaningful. I mean largely young, male, wholly economic migrants who are of vast number.

The courts and laws are protective of human rights and those have been exploited by those seeking to migrate here and elsewhere across the EU. So change them? No? That is a fault of government.

As EU members we could have advocated change of the law in light of the 2015 migrant crisis and would have been pushing at an open door had we tried; certainly now with the change in political colour across Europe. We didn't and now can't change what happens on the Continent. However, what is baffling is we have made no real attempt to make those changes here.

There are undoubtedly things we could have done unilaterally as EU members. Austria bans any non Austrians from buying in the Tyrol, for example, and Luxembourg is all but a closed shop.

And we could have properly resourced border control. Again, another thing we could have done without losing the benefit of being inside.

However, I think your attempt to distinguish immigration from border control is specious. Also, it was always a soft border for EU nationals and hard border for most non EU nationals. For the latter, what has changed?

In polls conducted at or around that time, the 2 far ahead topics on people's agenda was the NHS (as always) and immigration. It is the economy now, but then immigration was all there was on the media, especially with the issues and consequences of events in Libya etc. That is what got Brexit over the line.

You clearly didn't watch that Marr podcast. He said that non-white migration has increased under Brexit because we are forced to accept easy visas to negotiate trade deals. This would not have happened under the EU as we already had a trade deal with those countries and, anyway, would have had the collective strength to tell India and so on where to go.

Finally, of course part of the Remainer wants to see Brexit fail and for a return to an altered EU which has tighter borders, more restrictive laws on migration and places most emphasis on free trade and EU labour movement over more sovereign issues. However, another part of this Remainer understands the basic equation: Brexit fail = UK fail. What resident wants his own country to fail?

I am aware I am having a serious argument with a person whose MO is bon mots, but I simply couldn't resist rising to the points you made.

I genuinely understand your position and am well aware of the views of Marr. I always liked him as a social historian. I would in some ways agree with your argument but it again ignores the migration crisis that the EU openly debates but is rarely mentioned otherwise, leading to widespread ignorance of the situation EU wife. I would suggest that nearly all of the EU has unprecedented numbers of refugee/asylum seekers/ migrants + so it wouldn't really be much to blame on Brexit. Usually official visas are for people with certain skills or people who have proof of income aren't they? I wouldn't think that say Indian visas mean we accept the Delhi untouchables or anything - but you never know I guess.
As for EU quotas - the current deal has each member state to take a mandatory minimum of 30,000 relocated refugees. Then there is some kind of formula about how many more each state should take. I'm not joking to tell you that the EU openly stated they wanted to update the deal before the EU parliament is dominated by right wing parties. I watched the piece on Euronews.
I'm being reductionist and realise I'm not really fully engaging in the debate. I'm in the middle of making dinner and realise you are well educated on the matter. I can completely see the argument - and it is unfair of me to generalise remainers. I just can't help but feel Brexit supporters are stereotyped anyway. And they're clearly not fascists - well in general anyway.
Shepherds pie.

 


Red and Blue Army!

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 24 Jan 24 12.42pm

[Link]

Interesting watching this back - is any of it true?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 24 Jan 24 12.55pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

[Link]

Interesting watching this back - is any of it true?

Potentially.....though I was never really sold on the economic argument.

Why this continually referring back when remainers in both parties (and the civil service) haven't allowed the point of Brexit to occur?

Supporting all the EU's efforts and actually working with them to fight Brexit.

How fair is it to when Brexit was voted for and then deliberately strangled to then turn around and say, 'look, nothing you said would happen, happened'?

It's the opposite of democracy.

It's been one of the outcomes that opened by eyes to the reality of what actually is 'western democracy'.....they lifted the veil on that somewhat.


Edited by Stirlingsays (24 Jan 2024 1.01pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 148 of 156 < 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Post EU World