You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Sorloth thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Sorloth thread


Page 15 of 54 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >
Warlodog Flag Warlingham 02 Nov 18 4.10pm

Boro also made 8 changes to their team on Wednesday. With the exception of one or two, the majority of the team were hopeless the other night and that includes Sorloth. I accept the service to our strikers is not great and would love it if he proved myself and the other doubters wrong, but he looks slow, cumbersome, appears unable to jump and seldom wins a header in the box. He gives away needless fouls (Bournemouth away in particular comes to mind). I don't doubt he is giving it his all (as did the others), but he just doesn't look anywhere near good enough at this level. I fear he may be found wanting in the Championship as well, although hopefully that will not be put to the test any time soon.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 02 Nov 18 4.32pm

Originally posted by Willo

They certainly never hit the ground running.

Vardy joined when Leicester were in the Championship and in his first season only scored 5 goals in 29 apps.

When Mahrez joined, Leicester were also in the Championship and in his initial season scored 3 goals in 20 apps and in the next season 4 goals in 32 apps.

Michu and Defoe hit the ground running. Murray is doing ok since he left.

Are you telling me you think Sorloth will play like Vardy and Mahrez in his second season at the club? I certainly hope you are right.

The argument falls down a bit there though sadly.

Our signing of Sorloth was incredibly poor, its plain and simple. Benteke has been awful in front of goal for over 14 months, Wickham may never come back fully, and we bring in Ayew on loan and Sorloth for almost 10 million quid?

That is simply not good enough.

Did you watch the Boro game? Yes everyone was pretty poor but Sorloth was absolutely woeful and even his demeanor and body language was the worst of all of our players.

We needed to sign players who were ready to contribute immediately given our issues at the position. You can sign players under 10 million quid that can contribute immediately, but its much easier to sign a flop, currently Sorloth sits squarely in the latter camp.

Buying a player who needs to go out on loan immediately is criminal in our position, yet this is what we have done. Erdal Rakip anyone?

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Nov 18 4.50pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Michu and Defoe hit the ground running. Murray is doing ok since he left.

Are you telling me you think Sorloth will play like Vardy and Mahrez in his second season at the club? I certainly hope you are right.

The argument falls down a bit there though sadly.

Our signing of Sorloth was incredibly poor, its plain and simple. Benteke has been awful in front of goal for over 14 months, Wickham may never come back fully, and we bring in Ayew on loan and Sorloth for almost 10 million quid?

That is simply not good enough.

Did you watch the Boro game? Yes everyone was pretty poor but Sorloth was absolutely woeful and even his demeanor and body language was the worst of all of our players.

We needed to sign players who were ready to contribute immediately given our issues at the position. You can sign players under 10 million quid that can contribute immediately, but its much easier to sign a flop, currently Sorloth sits squarely in the latter camp.

Buying a player who needs to go out on loan immediately is criminal in our position, yet this is what we have done. Erdal Rakip anyone?

With respect one cannot compare the situations with Michu and Defoe with that of Sorloth.

Before joining Swansea, Michu had played some 250 games in Spain and of course Defoe was a very experienced player and a recognised goalscorer when he joined Sunderland.

Apropos your other point, I was not advocating that Sorloth will suddenly turn into a prolific goalscorer next season.My intepretation of your post was that you were inferring that both Vardy and Mahrez hit the ground running whereas I demonstrated that they were certainly not prolific in their opening seasons at the club.

Taking all factors into consideration, I am prepared to reserve judgement on Sorloth.We have to hope that he doesn't prove a flop and that he makes a positive contribution at our club.

Edited by Willo (02 Nov 2018 4.53pm)

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 02 Nov 18 5.05pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

He needs to go on loan to a Championship side in January and we should insist that (as far as you can enforce it) they play him every week. He needs to learn English football and one level down is a good place to learn it. That will make or break him.

We will have Benteke back in the New Year and with Wickham back to fitness I would send Ayew back to Wales and use the money for wages on a new striker. If Moses comes back, that will provide wing cover and put pressure on Andros.

My plan for Jan - Sorloth loan, Ayew out, Puncheon out, Schlupp out, Moses or Antonio in plus creative midfielder, plus striker and leave a space hopefully for RLC on loan.

Where does the money come from in this plan?

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 02 Nov 18 5.48pm

Originally posted by Willo

With respect one cannot compare the situations with Michu and Defoe with that of Sorloth.

Before joining Swansea, Michu had played some 250 games in Spain and of course Defoe was a very experienced player and a recognised goalscorer when he joined Sunderland.

Apropos your other point, I was not advocating that Sorloth will suddenly turn into a prolific goalscorer next season.My intepretation of your post was that you were inferring that both Vardy and Mahrez hit the ground running whereas I demonstrated that they were certainly not prolific in their opening seasons at the club.

Taking all factors into consideration, I am prepared to reserve judgement on Sorloth.We have to hope that he doesn't prove a flop and that he makes a positive contribution at our club.

Edited by Willo (02 Nov 2018 4.53pm)

I agree they are not comparable, Michu and Defoe had proven track records, the point I was making was about how much they cost. I am afraid to say Sorloth and Michu/Defoe dont have a whole lot in common, in any department.

I dont agree with your previous sentiment that it is not possible to bring in a striker for under 10 mil who can be productive in the Premier League immediately.

It appeared to me you were making excuses for this very poor signing, inferring that it was somehow unavoidable. It was avoidable and furthermore, should have been avoided. We are not a club who can have a "work in progress" project type striker on the books.

Vardy and Mahrez are further evidence of quality purchases with incredible value. Now dont get me wrong, I think we did very well with the likes of Kouyate and Luka, but for every one of those there is a few Erdal Rakips, Adebayors or Jaroslav Jachs.

In January we need to dig deep, and once and for all address the problem position at the club properly. We need to stop messing around with stop gap, half baked measures like signing a player who is so far away from being PL ready that its almost unfair to Sorloth himself, to put him in this position.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Nov 18 6.04pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I agree they are not comparable, Michu and Defoe had proven track records, the point I was making was about how much they cost. I am afraid to say Sorloth and Michu/Defoe dont have a whole lot in common, in any department.

I dont agree with your previous sentiment that it is not possible to bring in a striker for under 10 mil who can be productive in the Premier League immediately.

It appeared to me you were making excuses for this very poor signing, inferring that it was somehow unavoidable. It was avoidable and furthermore, should have been avoided. We are not a club who can have a "work in progress" project type striker on the books.

Vardy and Mahrez are further evidence of quality purchases with incredible value. Now dont get me wrong, I think we did very well with the likes of Kouyate and Luka, but for every one of those there is a few Erdal Rakips, Adebayors or Jaroslav Jachs.

In January we need to dig deep, and once and for all address the problem position at the club properly. We need to stop messing around with stop gap, half baked measures like signing a player who is so far away from being PL ready that its almost unfair to Sorloth himself, to put him in this position.

With respect, I am not a club spokesman attempting to justify signings or transfer strategy.

The sum of £9 Mill for a striker is a pittance in PL terms in this day and age and clubs and supporters should not be surprised if such a striker doesn't hit the ground running in a bottom half team.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 02 Nov 18 7.00pm

Originally posted by Willo

With respect, I am not a club spokesman attempting to justify signings or transfer strategy.

The sum of £9 Mill for a striker is a pittance in PL terms in this day and age and clubs and supporters should not be surprised if such a striker doesn't hit the ground running in a bottom half team.

Eddie Howe is still able to find a few gems and develop them, Callum Wilson fee £3.5m and Josh King fee free ( a Norwegian forward who can play )

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Nov 18 7.23pm

Originally posted by Painter

Eddie Howe is still able to find a few gems and develop them, Callum Wilson fee £3.5m and Josh King fee free ( a Norwegian forward who can play )

Agreed.

Callum Wilson signed when Bournemouth were in the Championship so he wasn't thrust straight into the PL.

King was signed on a free as his contract expired at Blackburn.He was signed when they were in the PL but he scored in his 13th game for the club (In November) and ended up with 8 goals for the season so hardly prolific.

 

crvenaeagle Flag 02 Nov 18 7.28pm

You can tell from his body language that he's not happy at the club. Perhaps he's not getting along with the other players, it would explain why he's not gelling with the others much.

I wonder if the situ would be any different right now if his goal against Chelsea when he first came to us wasn't bizarrely disallowed.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 02 Nov 18 7.40pm

I havent been on the site since getting home at 3am on Thursday morning, partly due to being totally pissed off at the performance.
Sorloth was absolute rubbish the other night, but he wasnt the only one. I thought Schlupp was on a par with him as being crap and Ayew not far behind.
Sorloth isnt fit to wear the shirt and shouldnt even be at the club. I am totally bewildered as to how we bought him and for how much. Who is to blame??? Its bordering on being a sackable offence.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Jacey Flag 02 Nov 18 7.59pm

Originally posted by kevlee

I havent been on the site since getting home at 3am on Thursday morning, partly due to being totally pissed off at the performance.
Sorloth was absolute rubbish the other night, but he wasnt the only one. I thought Schlupp was on a par with him as being crap and Ayew not far behind.
Sorloth isnt fit to wear the shirt and shouldnt even be at the club. I am totally bewildered as to how we bought him and for how much. Who is to blame??? Its bordering on being a sackable offence.

Stackable offence??

Interesting point but how on earth would Parish sack himself???

 

Username Flag Horsham 02 Nov 18 8.02pm

Originally posted by Painter

Eddie Howe is still able to find a few gems and develop them, Callum Wilson fee £3.5m and Josh King fee free ( a Norwegian forward who can play )

He also spent a fair chunk of money on Afobe and Ibe who were both flops.


 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 02 Nov 18 8.20pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Stackable offence??

Interesting point but how on earth would Parish sack himself???

I think if we stack Ayew on top of Sorloth, we MIGHT have a player that can win some headers, being about 12 feet tall or so.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Painter Flag Croydon 02 Nov 18 8.25pm

Originally posted by Username

He also spent a fair chunk of money on Afobe and Ibe who were both flops.


He sold Afobe back to Wolves at a loss of £2m, not bad business getting a flop of the books. Who is going to pay £7m for Sorloth.
Ibe is a winger, so not comparable.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 02 Nov 18 8.31pm

Originally posted by Willo

Agreed.

Callum Wilson signed when Bournemouth were in the Championship so he wasn't thrust straight into the PL.

King was signed on a free as his contract expired at Blackburn.He was signed when they were in the PL but he scored in his 13th game for the club (In November) and ended up with 8 goals for the season so hardly prolific.

Your point was you don't get much of a striker for £9m, these 2 cost a third of that together. I would take either in place of Sorloth any day of the week.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Nov 18 8.43pm

Originally posted by Painter


Your point was you don't get much of a striker for £9m, these 2 cost a third of that together. I would take either in place of Sorloth any day of the week.

In these days of gargantuan transfer fees, to get a striker for £9 Mill and expect him to slot seamlessly and make an immediate impact in the PL is asking a lot.Wilson was signed when Bournemouth were in the Championship and King was hardly prolific in his first season.They have proved brilliant signings by Howe.

I accept both of these are way above Sorloth at the present time.Maybe in time we will all look back and think that at £9 Mill Sorloth has proved a great buy !

Edited by Willo (02 Nov 2018 8.44pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Nov 18 8.46pm

Originally posted by Username


He also spent a fair chunk of money on Afobe and Ibe who were both flops.

I think Afobe cost £10 Mill and Ibe £15 Mill.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 02 Nov 18 8.51pm

Originally posted by Willo

In these days of gargantuan transfer fees, to get a striker for £9 Mill and expect him to slot seamlessly and make an immediate impact in the PL is asking a lot.Wilson was signed when Bournemouth were in the Championship and King was hardly prolific in his first season.They have proved brilliant signings by Howe.

I accept both of these are way above Sorloth at the present time.Maybe in time we will all look back and think that at £9 Mill Sorloth has proved a great buy !

Edited by Willo (02 Nov 2018 8.44pm)

I assume you have been a long term supporter, so will have seen a fair few of our forwards over the years.
Do you really think Sorloth has anything about his game that suggests he will be a good buy, let alone great.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Nov 18 9.00pm

Originally posted by Painter

I assume you have been a long term supporter, so will have seen a fair few of our forwards over the years.
Do you really think Sorloth has anything about his game that suggests he will be a good buy, let alone great.

Yes I am a long-term supporter, fervently supporting our team since the 60s and have witnessed forwards such as Gareth Taylor,Tommy Langley and Trevor Aylott !

Sorloth has made cameo appearances in the PL and in his fleeting appearance against Arsenal he looked as though he had something about him but I understand he was far from impressive against Middlesbrough.Young lad, trying to make the transition from Danish football in a bottom half of the table team.I shall reserve judgement on him.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 02 Nov 18 9.23pm

Originally posted by Willo


Sorloth has made cameo appearances in the PL and in his fleeting appearance against Arsenal he looked as though he had something about him but I understand he was far from impressive against Middlesbrough.Young lad, trying to make the transition from Danish football in a bottom half of the table team.I shall reserve judgement on him.

Me too. He is big and strong and when in possession doesn't give the ball away easily. It could be that what we are seeing is the best he has to give, but on the other hand .... it may be forgotten that Glenn Murray didn't have a great first season with us and spent quite a bit of time on the subs bench.

 

Page 15 of 54 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Sorloth thread