You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson to stay
November 16 2026 3.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hodgson to stay


Page 15 of 41 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >
taylors lovechild Flag 30 May 23 5.32pm

Originally posted by Willo

Steve Cooper's win percentage at Swansea and Nottm Forest, 44.8% and 43.3% respectively.

His PL win percentage is 24% though.

I think people need to look beyond number of wins, as points and even performances is more relevant. For example, while Newcastle only had one more win than Spurs they qualified for the CL and Spurs qualified for nothing, which was thanks to all the draws they achieved. Roy didn't win any more games than Vieira in terms of the reverse fixtures this season, but does that tell the whole story. No, of course it doesn't.

Putting rivalry aside I always enjoyed watching Brighton under Potter. If he could get us playing like that I'd be happy. Vieira got it right last season but ran out of ideas this one. I don't think that would be an issue for Potter. Also, he is known for the importance he places on community involvement which for a family club like ours can't be ignored. Whatever people might think of Vieira as a manager he fully embraced that side of the club.

One final reason for possibly supporting Potter is that it would be hilarious if we did the double over Brighton under Potter after he had failed to beat us once while in charge of them. They would absolutely f*cking hate that

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 30 May 23 5.39pm

Eddie Howe will be available soon enough when they bring in a big name.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Painter Flag Croydon 30 May 23 5.53pm

Originally posted by manwitheagletattoo

If we did go for Potter, and all parties agreed I would like to see Hodgson in some sort of advisory roll.

Why? We have Freeman as Sporting Director/Director of Football or whatever his title is, if Potter is unable to manage on his own, why bother with him?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 May 23 6.06pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

His PL win percentage is 24% though.

I think people need to look beyond number of wins, as points and even performances is more relevant. For example, while Newcastle only had one more win than Spurs they qualified for the CL and Spurs qualified for nothing, which was thanks to all the draws they achieved. Roy didn't win any more games than Vieira in terms of the reverse fixtures this season, but does that tell the whole story. No, of course it doesn't.

Putting rivalry aside I always enjoyed watching Brighton under Potter. If he could get us playing like that I'd be happy. Vieira got it right last season but ran out of ideas this one. I don't think that would be an issue for Potter. Also, he is known for the importance he places on community involvement which for a family club like ours can't be ignored. Whatever people might think of Vieira as a manager he fully embraced that side of the club.

One final reason for possibly supporting Potter is that it would be hilarious if we did the double over Brighton under Potter after he had failed to beat us once while in charge of them. They would absolutely f*cking hate that

It was a challenging time at Nottm Forest who signed nigh on 30 players and a 'Bloated' squad can cause problems for a manager.

 

pssguy Flag 30 May 23 6.11pm

Win % is for the innumerate. Leicester had a higher win % than Everton. Lot of good it did them

 

Joseph Paxton Flag Lancing 30 May 23 7.06pm

Whomsoever it turns out to be, it needs to be an appointment for the long term. We have the unenviable status as being the club with highest number of managers since birth of Premier League in 1992: currently sitting at 27 Managers in that time, 2 ahead of Soton

[Link]

Too much turnover - we will only attract folks with a season to season outlook and not taken seriously by credible candidates.

 


Be where you are; otherwise you will miss your life.

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 30 May 23 7.13pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Potter will be an unmitigated disaster of ginormous proportions, any should be not touched with the eponymous barge pole.

agree.
support will turn on him quickly if not a good start.
season before last (or one before that ?) they were well in the relegation mix until last handful of games.
its a total No.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 May 23 7.20pm

Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall

agree.
support will turn on him quickly if not a good start.
season before last (or one before that ?) they were well in the relegation mix until last handful of games.
its a total No.

In his first season at Brighton they finished 7 pts clear of the relegation zone.
In his second season they were comfortably clear of the relegation zone, by 13 pts.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 30 May 23 7.23pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Potter will be an unmitigated disaster of ginormous proportions, any should be not touched with the eponymous barge pole.

I find myself in agreement. Actually, why Chelsea hired him in the first place is a bit of a mystery, his record is just ordinary.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 May 23 7.33pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I find myself in agreement. Actually, why Chelsea hired him in the first place is a bit of a mystery, his record is just ordinary.

This morning, after the various media reports regarding Potter, I was inundated with calls and messages and the overall view was one of negativity.

 

eaglesdare Flag 30 May 23 7.35pm

Originally posted by Joseph Paxton

Whomsoever it turns out to be, it needs to be an appointment for the long term. We have the unenviable status as being the club with highest number of managers since birth of Premier League in 1992: currently sitting at 27 Managers in that time, 2 ahead of Soton

[Link]

Too much turnover - we will only attract folks with a season to season outlook and not taken seriously by credible candidates.

The average premier league manager is 2-3 years. Look at this season and how many managers got the sack.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 30 May 23 7.52pm

Originally posted by Joseph Paxton

Whomsoever it turns out to be, it needs to be an appointment for the long term. We have the unenviable status as being the club with highest number of managers since birth of Premier League in 1992: currently sitting at 27 Managers in that time, 2 ahead of Soton

[Link]

Too much turnover - we will only attract folks with a season to season outlook and not taken seriously by credible candidates.

I posted recently that we need someone with a 3/5 year plan in mind, another poster accurately mentioned that PL managers don't usually get that length of time. Turnaround is real fast these days, yet there seems to be no end of candidates, after all, one can become a multi millionaire by getting sacked...

 

Joseph Paxton Flag Lancing 30 May 23 8.02pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I posted recently that we need someone with a 3/5 year plan in mind, another poster accurately mentioned that PL managers don't usually get that length of time. Turnaround is real fast these days, yet there seems to be no end of candidates, after all, one can become a multi millionaire by getting sacked...

And there lies the problem. It's a curates egg, do badly over a couple of season's and you get served your P45 but do really well and one of the top 7 or 8 clubs is bound to at least put out the feelers as for one of a crop of managers they may want to talk to. Unfortunately we sit outside those top 7/8+ teams.

But too much turnover and we have had 27 Managers in 31 years. Difficult to foresee a solid 3-5 year candidate? I think I mentioned Slot here about 3 seasons ago...

 


Be where you are; otherwise you will miss your life.

BelfastEagle Flag 30 May 23 8.28pm

Originally posted by Willo

This morning, after the various media reports regarding Potter, I was inundated with calls and messages and the overall view was one of negativity.

Which is probably good news…..anybody who is viewed positively is usually a complete disaster…..look no further than the last permanent manager….less than 9 months ago he was the new messiah !


 

SarfNorwoodAl Flag South Norwood 30 May 23 8.41pm

For once Lanzo I totally agree with you about Potter. Rodgers would be my first choice and if he turned it down I think Jesse Marsch would do well. If they offer Roy a director of football role a lot of managers would be put off as they know if they have a bad run he would take their job.

Other people on here have mentioned Cooper who would be great but I cant see him leaving Forest at the moment.

 

Zaha127 Flag 30 May 23 8.41pm

Who would you like as Palace manager? Rodgers, Potter, Cooper or anyone else?

I would like Roy for one final year give him a new RB, midfielder, winger and striker and top 10 can be a possibility. Long term would not mind Kompany or Carrick so if makes sense to give Roy one more year and Kompany/Carrick after a year can be a possibility.

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 30 May 23 8.49pm

Jesse Marsch ?? In God's name NO, American managers have been an embarassment in the Premiership.
& neither ex-Brighton scum with no real track record at the highest level.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 30 May 23 9.05pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Dont take Roy out of the equation, i am sure he would take a years contract, and i am in the opinion that McCarthy can be groomed to take over the role, at just the time when the youngsters will be ready, its a massive gamble to employ Potter but also his entourage that will come with him.

My hope too.

Fiscally sound and brilliant.

Unless it turns out sh1t

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 30 May 23 9.16pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Dont take Roy out of the equation, i am sure he would take a years contract, and i am in the opinion that McCarthy can be groomed to take over the role, at just the time when the youngsters will be ready, its a massive gamble to employ Potter but also his entourage that will come with him.

Some of this sounds like a former ITV presenters MO. Maybe schofield IS the answer
I’ll get me coat !!!

 

eaglesdare Flag 30 May 23 9.18pm

Originally posted by Zaha127

Who would you like as Palace manager? Rodgers, Potter, Cooper or anyone else?

I would like Roy for one final year give him a new RB, midfielder, winger and striker and top 10 can be a possibility. Long term would not mind Kompany or Carrick so if makes sense to give Roy one more year and Kompany/Carrick after a year can be a possibility.

Is there a face palm emoji I can use?

 

Page 15 of 41 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson to stay