You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > US politics
November 17 2026 4.26pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

US politics


Page 153 of 424 < 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 >
BlueJay Flag UK 24 Jun 22 6.02pm

Originally posted by W12

Always the most extreme and very rare example.


I stated that absolutist views of looking at this issue, lead to circumstances that would otherwise not come about due to common sense. That was literally the point of my comment.


Quote Do these children deserve to die?

Much in the same way that I see it as abhorrent that people try to push the window for when they can have an abortion further, you'll have to excuse me if I also don't align well with your outlook that a raped woman is a child murderer if she takes a morning after pill.

Or inferences that the health of a woman during pregnancy isn't an important factor

Outside of the States, where this isn't as often a faultline issue, with some exceptions this isn't always an area without common ground or common sense.


Edited by BlueJay (24 Jun 2022 6.17pm)

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 24 Jun 22 7.09pm

Recent gun laws in New York mean that adults are now more likely to suffer gunshot injuries. It's OK to kill adults, it's just not OK for women to have the power (if needed) to have control of their bodies and future.

Bit of a tricky one for Biden on abortion, as I understand Biden is Catholic. And you don't want to upset the kiddy-fiddlers at the top.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 24 Jun 22 7.27pm

Originally posted by W12

Killing babies is wrong. There is no subjective argument.

When is it a baby?

 

W12 24 Jun 22 7.47pm

Originally posted by cryrst

When is it a baby?

When it’s conceived.

Oh and by the way:

F418726A-7053-4BC6-A62B-DDAF4E5CB4CD.jpeg Attachment: F418726A-7053-4BC6-A62B-DDAF4E5CB4CD.jpeg (59.77Kb)

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 24 Jun 22 7.52pm

Originally posted by W12

When it’s conceived.

Oh and by the way:

Don’t want all that data as it’s bollox tbh by the way.
A baby is not a baby once you cum inside a woman.
That’s bull.
A woman has the say not some person with an opinion normally with a religion based argument. This is a huge mistake and I for one think it’s more selfish than laws I’ve seen changed. My opinion won’t change and nor will yours so it is in bed now.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 24 Jun 22 8.04pm

A wonderful day for those of us who consider most abortion a moral wrong.

However, there is much fear mongering around this area and I find it somewhat ironic that it's now the left making the slippery slope arguments.

The slippery slope can be real and not a fallacy, however some of the claims are absurd and just won't happen.

My cut off point for abortion is the start of a heartbeat, which would be around six weeks.

Edited by Stirlingsays (24 Jun 2022 8.10pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Matov Flag 24 Jun 22 8.05pm

A LOT of hyperbole flying around tonight over in the US. Be interesting to see if any of it actually turns into what people are promising.

Seen one idiot trying to encourage enraged Lefties to attack US rural towns because they are 'defenceless'.

That will end well.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 24 Jun 22 8.17pm

Sarah everard, only two genders, trans banned from ‘womens’ sporting events,
No single changing rooms, chivalry etc etc and now a woman cannot choose to get rid of a lump of goo in her belly. Where exactly do womens rights start and end.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 24 Jun 22 8.36pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


The slippery slope can be real and not a fallacy, however some of the claims are absurd and just won't happen.

My cut off point for abortion is the start of a heartbeat, which would be around six weeks.


Edited by Stirlingsays (24 Jun 2022 8.10pm)

It's not a slippery slope argument where the individual specifically says they wish to revisit those areas, it's comment on their stated intention.

Personally, I'd don't think I'd even be against six weeks or thereabouts, as that would exclude the eventuality I mentioned (as long as it is included provisions for where a womens heath is 'genuinely' at risk). My concern is that as of now there are no such exceptions in some states, and I'm not sure that there will be any motivation to add them due to how polarised this issue has been allowed to become.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 24 Jun 22 8.44pm

Originally posted by W12

When it’s conceived.

So again, your view is that a raped woman is a child murderer if she takes a morning after pill. It's not about the frequently, it's comment on the extent to which you feel the government should have complete control over an individual in such a bad spot. Cheering on the erosion of others freedoms to that extent, and you may as well be cheering on the same for your own too, because the topic of the day is irrelevant in comparison to the level of control over the individual sought by government.

Women can get pregnant on birth control too by the way, so by your logic these women should also be forced to give birth in all instances. Seems like you desire rather extreme control over womens lives. Why is a sensible stance of say a few weeks more offensive to you than forcing women at this eary stage to give birth in situations where its clearly better that they have a say?

Edited by BlueJay (24 Jun 2022 8.59pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 24 Jun 22 9.02pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

It's not a slippery slope argument where the individual specifically says they wish to revisit those areas, it's comment on their stated intention.

Personally, I'd don't think I'd even be against six weeks or thereabouts, as that would exclude the eventuality I mentioned (as long as it is included provisions for where a womens heath is 'genuinely' at risk). My concern is that as of now there are no such exceptions in some states, and I'm not sure that there will be any motivation to add them due to how polarised this issue has been allowed to become.

I think the idea that contraception is under serious threat from the Supreme Court just isn't realistic (though I understand the negative arguments against easy sex...even if I often joke around the area).....I could see gay 'marriage' being given back to states.....as for banning gay sex? They would have to shut down the media and Hollywood....and while we could certainly make arguments for that gay sex isn't one of them.

Not going to happen.

On abortion, I agree with the argument that this should be a state issue as America is in reality a collection of separate legal systems and the flaws found in Roe v Wade are real.

I agree that this isn't straight forward and that there are complex issues and questions over it. However, I can only speak for myself now....as I was pro choice before I actually had to face this question in my personal life.

I'm not that sure I'm comfortable forcing my convictions onto others, however we live in an age where....whether from left or right, this is what happens, either directly or indirectly.

Edited by Stirlingsays (24 Jun 2022 9.07pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

BlueJay Flag UK 24 Jun 22 9.29pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I think the idea that contraception is under serious threat from the Supreme Court just isn't realistic (though I understand the negative arguments against easy sex...even if I often joke around the area).....I could see gay 'marriage' being given back to states.....as for banning gay sex? They would have to shut down the media and Hollywood....and while we could certainly make arguments for that gay sex isn't one of them.

Not going to happen.

Considering what has just happened, I'm not sure that we could say that something that was only overturned in 2003 [Link] is never going to happen' . It would certainly be of interest to some States, which is precisely why Roe vs Wade has been overturned.

As for same sex marriage, while I'd put that in a different category as it's not private conduct (and I think a society should decide on what is santioned as a marriage) it even opens the door for revisiting Loving v. Virginia [Link] if in any State views that as something they do not want. I'll admit it sounds far fetched but when precedent set in that very same decade is overturned as has now here, I'm not sure that we can rule out State challenges at some point.

It was the 60's also where the Supreme Court decided that it was unconstitutional for the government to prohibit married couples from using birth control. This is an area Thomas specifically said he wanted to reconsider. People are forgetting that the puritanical religious aspect to certain outlooks has never gone away, it's just been drowned out for a time by the equally wacky far left [Link] In several States there have been efforts and court challenges to in various ways restrict Emergency contraception, which lets remember results in lower aboriton rates. Lots of these beliefs go hand in hand in a sense.

I'm not saying any of the above will happen, just that this ruling, and its accompanying wording (Justice Thomas calling these other rulings an 'error' that should be corrected and also Roe vs Wade sets a new precedent) intentionally open them up as movements that previously would not have gained traction, and now may well be fast-tracked. It pays to remember that it's not about what the nation thinks, rather any individual State and how the Surpeme Court acts on that.

Quote

On abortion, I agree with the argument that this should be a state issue as America is in reality a collection of separate legal systems and the flaws found in Roe v Wade are real.

I agree that this isn't straight forward and that there are complex issues and questions over it. However, I can only speak for myself now....as I was pro choice before I actually had to face this question in my personal life.

I'm not that sure I'm comfortable forcing my convictions onto others, however we live in an age where....whether from left or right, this is what happens, either directly or indirectly.

Edited by Stirlingsays (24 Jun 2022 9.07pm)

In a reasoned society variance in these areas wouldn't be terrible thing, but I see problems at both extremes. With too easy access in some States and a flippant attitude to life, and at the other end the 'at conception' crowd and the health and real world implications on freedom and privacy that can emerge with that. I fear this will now push even further into another guns rights 'all or nothing' type issue, where any reasonable step is increasingly seen as giving ground to an enemy, rather than considering the pros and cons of its actual impact. For all it's faults, Americans are big on their freedoms and government keeping out of their lives. I'm not sure that some States overnight having absolute control over the individual on this issue in all circumstances is a good thing.

Edited by BlueJay (25 Jun 2022 1.23am)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 24 Jun 22 10.20pm

Originally posted by W12

Killing babies is wrong. There is no subjective argument.

Only an idiot would argue that it's OK to kill babies.

When a foetus becomes a baby is a very different question. Until the so called "pro-life" lobby seriously addresses that question, those that do try to answer it are always likely to hold them in contempt

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 24 Jun 22 10.25pm

Very sad day for the USA. Even if completely predictable, as soon as Trump bought off the "pro-life" lobby by promising to stuff the SCOTUS with political Justices.

What a complete shambles that country has become. Technologically highly advanced. Socially extremely backward.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

BlueJay Flag UK 24 Jun 22 10.44pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle


When a foetus becomes a baby is a very different question. Until the so called "pro-life" lobby seriously addresses that question, those that do try to answer it are always likely to hold them in contempt

To my mind it comes down to the number of weeks, and basing that on the science. Easier said than down of course as there are other attitudes at play in both 'pro' camps. But yes, attempting to strips people of their rights immediately at the point of conception is clearly quite mad, and not far off bursting in the blokes house to stop him having a w@nk. Though of course he would deem that outrageous, as that relates to his life rather than other peoples.

 

Wilesy01 Flag Bristol 25 Jun 22 12.15am

Criminalising abortion won't stop abortion it'll just force it underground into unsafe and unregulated methods.

This ruling is going to kill more people than it saves. Sensible regulation is the answer not this partisan nonsense that seems to now be our modern political discourse.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 25 Jun 22 12.47am

Originally posted by Wilesy01

Criminalising abortion won't stop abortion it'll just force it underground into unsafe and unregulated methods.

This ruling is going to kill more people than it saves. Sensible regulation is the answer not this partisan nonsense that seems to now be our modern political discourse.

It will be the poor paying the price and facing the consequences. Other people will go to neighbouring States. Any from conception abortion law (of which there are now automatically several) is an absurd affront to womens freedoms. Remember this momen and its knock on consequences when anyone for it talks of the importance of their own freedoms. They are after all clearly the only freedoms they care about.

Edited by BlueJay (25 Jun 2022 1.28am)

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 25 Jun 22 7.12am

Well, as they say, it could only happen in America...in 2022
Am I surprised? No. Maybe The Handmaids Tale is the future for some US states. String em up, send em back, why not re-introduce slavery?

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

YT Flag Oxford 25 Jun 22 8.29am

Lots of women shrieking online saying that it'll happen here next (ie the outlawing of abortion). Err...no it won't. Perhaps concentrate your hysteria on numerous other countries where abortion is at present either illegal or severely restricted.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Teddy Eagle Flag 25 Jun 22 9.18am

The land of the free?

This is from the BBC:

The reversal of a long-standing precedent has also raised fears for other rights decided upon by the Supreme Court in the past.

Justice Clarence Thomas, in his opinion, wrote: "In future cases, we should reconsider all of this Court's substantive due process precedents, including Griswold, Lawrence, and Obergefell" - referencing three landmark decisions of the past on the right to contraception, the repeal of anti-sodomy laws, and the legalisation of same-sex marriage respectively.

[Link]

 

Page 153 of 424 < 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > US politics