This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
This bill - that would override any state's preference as to the permitting of concealed carry - will die in the Senate, but it just shows how gun reform is impossible currently. A sensible, bi-partisan, background check bill gets scuppered because the NRA drags Republicans around like frightened puppies. Edited by Ray in Houston (07 Dec 2017 3.02pm) You need to get rid of Sunset provisions too. All that work to get the assault rifles banned and it can simply expire, rather than requiring new legislation and or a vote to overturn it. I can't believe a few of them getting shot at the baseball game, didn't change an opinion or two. It did in Vegas at least.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It's a good and interesting question to try to define 'natural behaviours'. Mainly because it brings us back into reality on what can fairly asked of either sex in terms of behaviour adjustment. Most importantly anything I or anyone else would say has to be filed under generalization because human beings are a spectrum of behaviours where exceptions to all behaviours will exist in varying percentages. Having said that, it doesn't take a genius to connect the dots and understand that the primary roles nature designed for the human sexes was for males to be the hunters and risk takers and for females to be the child rearers and homemakers. The hormonal and biological functions all point to this. The statistics in so many areas bear this out. While in the modern age....the west has made great strides in providing women with more equal opportunities to men I get greatly irritated at the harm done to both sexes by those who deny human nature and regard human behaviour is simply a social construct.....all based upon their own feelings rather than the science. The half truths implicitly told to youth by both the media and educational institutions .....that males have 'tonic masculinity' and that women can 'do anything a male can do' aren't only harmful but have led to countless cases of guilt and self blame...all pushed by political ideology rather than science. I view the harm done as on a par with the harm done by religion in creating dysfunctional views of human behaviours. It's certainly true that the natural 'hunter/risk taker' mentality given to males by hormones can and does led to anti social behaviours. But when directed usefully these same hormones have created the modern world and most of its wonders.....like most things in different hands these same drives can be used for societal good or harm. They need to be directed....not denied or criticized as 'tonic'. Many of the great educational institutions of the past intrinsically knew this. Females in my country have also been made to feel guilty for choosing to be 'homemakers' as if this was somehow a 'lower' life choice. Instead of being perhaps the most important job to society that a person should do well. I think it's great that we, in the west, live in a society that provides women with a choice of professions. But I learnt during my time as a teacher that this doesn't mean that females are going to choose the same subjects and jobs that males do in anything like the same numbers and you know what.....if that is their choice...then surely that was the whole point and success of feminism....the actual feminism that most of us agree with. I think it's fair to say there are limits to how much a social libertarian I am, but on the fundamental level of allowing you freedom of thought and action (action that doesn't physically harm others) yeah...I think I'm a social libertarian....how others feel is for them of course....the older I've got the more socially libertarian I've become.
The point is that nobody knows what is 'natural difference between the sexes' and what is enforced - either through disciplining or socialisation. That is why everyone should read the seminal work on this topic by John Stuart Mill. Freedom is a funny thing. It can never be absolute and it is in the eye of the beholder. If you know no better then it's hard to picture what you can do with freedom. You do what you have learned to do, even if the structures in which you learned are no longer in place. I spent many years working in the newly opened Central and Eastern Europe. Learning the new rules was massively hard for those countries. Similarly, for women, working out what they want to be when the old rules change must be very difficult. And anyway, have all the rules really changed or have they just become that bit more subtle.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
You need to get rid of Sunset provisions too. All that work to get the assault rifles banned and it can simply expire, rather than requiring new legislation and or a vote to overturn it. I can't believe a few of them getting shot at the baseball game, didn't change an opinion or two. It did in Vegas at least.
I think the sunset provisions included in any number of regulations is a procedural thing, as it reduces some of the hurdles a bill needs to clear in order to become law. This is why it tends to gets used more frequently in theoretically divisive legislation. It's a fact of life politically, but it's just insane that American politics has become so regressive. We're rolling back abortion rights, gun restrictions, voting rights and the social safety net. The rest of the world is moving forwards and we're at best standing still. Edited by Ray in Houston (07 Dec 2017 3.28pm)
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
Bernie Sanders isn't a Democrat; he's an Independent. That's not the point. He ran for its leadership and chairs its committees and without Clinton's cheating would have probably been the candidate and all mainly on grassroot support. He represents the heart of democratic belief systems and politics today. He's not even as far left as many in the democratic party today.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
That's not the point. He ran for its leadership and chairs its committees and without Clinton's cheating would have probably been the candidate and all mainly on grassroot support. He represents the heart of democratic belief systems and politics today. He's not even as far left as many in the democratic party today.
He represents the heart of the progressive movement in the US today, not that of the Democratic Party. If he represented the latter, he'd be President right now. As to claiming that the Party has members more to the left of Bernie...please show your work. Who and why? And I'm expecting lots of names because you said "many". Edited by Ray in Houston (07 Dec 2017 3.36pm)
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
The point is that nobody knows what is 'natural difference between the sexes' and what is enforced - either through disciplining or socialisation. That is why everyone should read the seminal work on this topic by John Stuart Mill. Modern biological research has uncovered many of the natural differences between the sexes.....Damore cited many of them....why would you even say 'nobody knows'? Hormonal differences don't just change bodies they change mental drives and the idea that everyone's bringing up girls a certain way and boys another way and that accounts for differences is holding their heads deep in the sand.. Mill is writing over a 150 years ago and....I imagine writing purely as if differences were purely social constructs.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I have no idea how you can regard the current Democratic party as right wing when they embrace more progressive ideas than even the Labour party. Your description to my mind is from ten years ago.
Because Progressive ideas are not Left wing, they're liberal. You can't really be left wing and embracing pro-corporate policy over social policy. The democrats like progressive policy, because its a cheap give me to those more liberal leaning democrats. Its like New Labour and fox hunting, a bone they threw to the left wing of the Labour party, whilst busily selling out the working classes to corporate agendas.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
Still, he's not a Democrat, which was your original claim. Ok Originally posted by Ray in Houston
He represents the heart of the progressive movement in the US today, not that of the Democratic Party. If he represented the latter, he'd be President right now. Perhaps Originally posted by Ray in Houston
As to claiming that the Party has members more to the left of Bernie...please show your work. Who and why? And I'm expecting lots of names because you said "many". Edited by Ray in Houston (07 Dec 2017 3.36pm) I don't know their names but I see them talking on YouTube videos. Perhaps they are supporters rather than members I don't know.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Modern biological research has uncovered many of the natural differences between the sexes.....Damore cited many of them....why would you even say 'nobody knows'? Hormonal differences don't just change bodies they change mental drives and the idea that everyone's bringing up girls a certain way and boys another way and that accounts for differences is holding their heads deep in the sand.. Mill is writing over a 150 years ago and....I imagine writing purely as if differences were social constructs. Then you imagine wrong. There is no doubt there are differences between men and women. It is just not possible to ascertain them with certainty due to the overlay of environmental and social issues. This was fully recognised by Mill. Better to read the original text, or at least a précis, rather than make assumptions that may (or may not) happen to fit your argument or world view.
This may help:
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Because Progressive ideas are not Left wing, they're liberal. You can't really be left wing and embracing pro-corporate policy over social policy. The democrats like progressive policy, because its a cheap give me to those more liberal leaning democrats. Its like New Labour and fox hunting, a bone they threw to the left wing of the Labour party, whilst busily selling out the working classes to corporate agendas. We see liberals and progressives very differently. Perhaps I identify more with classical liberals then, because these two schools have adherents who aren't seeing eye to eye.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Modern biological research has uncovered many of the natural differences between the sexes.....Damore cited many of them....why would you even say 'nobody knows'? Hormonal differences don't just change bodies they change mental drives and the idea that everyone's bringing up girls a certain way and boys another way and that accounts for differences is holding their heads deep in the sand.. Mill is writing over a 150 years ago and....I imagine writing purely as if differences were purely social constructs.
Ah, you mean James Damore, that well known scientist. Amazing how he hit on the differences so accurately when social scientists have been wrestling with them inconclusively since The Scottish Enlightenment. Not exactly a learned treatise taking into account all of the relevant research and theory available, now was it?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I don't know their names but I see them talking on YouTube videos. Perhaps they are supporters rather than members I don't know.
Thanks! We now have a standard by which to judge all of the many facts you have expressed about which you seemed equally certain.
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Modern biological research has uncovered many of the natural differences between the sexes.....Damore cited many of them....why would you even say 'nobody knows'? Hormonal differences don't just change bodies they change mental drives and the idea that everyone's bringing up girls a certain way and boys another way and that accounts for differences is holding their heads deep in the sand.. Mill is writing over a 150 years ago and....I imagine writing purely as if differences were social constructs. Differences, aren't deterministic though. The influence of biological factors, such as neurotransmitters, genetics and hormonal secretions are very complicated, especially when dealing with behaviour. They tend to be associated with behavioural phenomena, usually in relation to abnormality (such as serotonin reuptake being linked with depression). Of course, with that, the argument about misandry becomes somewhat justified, because most complaints about male behaviour linked to things like violence against women, sexual violence etc also has a strong biological basis as well. The problem with this kind of generalisation, is that its false. Its based on studies of abnormality. The role of equality should never be 'you must be this', but about opening up the opportunity for people to pursue options. Granted we are limited by biological factors; I doubt women can ever achieve the same kind of physical achievement of most professional male athletes - But almost any women who puts in the physical focus to become a female athlete is going to rank men who don't put that effort in. This stems from a problem in how we view biological differences, because they're based largely on evidence acquired from outliers. For example, when studying violence in men, there is a genetic trait common among murderers, but attributing this becomes problematic when you find out this genetic trait is present in about 20% of the population who have never committed an act of violence. What we know about 'how parts of the brain function' comes more from studying the unlucky few that we know have suffered brain damage (again outliers). Obviously, there are differences between men and women, and individuals, but these more define the limits of our ability, than the ability itself. But I'd imagine that most physically fit men would struggle in a race against Kelly Holmes. Not because of genetic differences, but because of the capacity of effort put in by the latter. And that's really what counts, in the end, what you make of yourself, rather than what you're made of.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Then you imagine wrong. There is no doubt there are differences between men and women. It is just not possible to ascertain them with certainty due to the overlay of environmental and social issues. This was fully recognised by Mill. Better to read the original text, or at least a précis, rather than make assumptions that may (or may not) happen to fit your argument or world view.
This may help:
'Science has 'proven' stuff and then found out that is was wrong.....guess what found it to be wrong and made corrections? S C I E N C E. It happens when ideas are contested.....where is the contesting in this area from science? Mill had no access to the modern day research we have had from science on the biological differences between the sexes......it is standard and accepted in the field that men and women are biologically different and that results in behavioural differences....they aren't contested. Please point out to me that areas in biological study where there is doubt on behavioural differences. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Dec 2017 4.07pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Ah, you mean James Damore, that well known scientist. Amazing how he hit on the differences so accurately when social scientists have been wrestling with them inconclusively since The Scottish Enlightenment. Not exactly a learned treatise taking into account all of the relevant research and theory available, now was it? The last 117 years of so there has been an argument between biology and psychology, which biology has progressively been losing - Resulting in the 'Crisis of Social Sciences' in the 70s and 80s. The problem really becomes on of paradigm - Biology does not deal with individuals, but species. Which means its good at generalisations, but very poor when it comes to specifics relating to individuals.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
'Science has 'proven' stuff and then found out that is was wrong.....guess what found it to be wrong? S C I E N C E. Mill had no access to the modern day research we have had from science on the biological differences between the sexes......it is standard and accepted in the field that men and women are biologically different and that results in behavioural differences....they aren't contested. Problem is that the same argument applies, in that biology isn't very good at reliably identifying that the differences in these behaviours are biologically determined; they're correlational. Its the absurdity of the nature / nurture argument - Its unsolvable, because people have bought into a false scientific paradigm - which science has long moved on from. Its the relationship between nature and nurture that's important, not one or the other. We are both socially and biologically constructed, the two are really inseparable. Attempts to prove one or the other, have always failed, because they've mistakenly embraced self fulfilling assumptional bias.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Ah, you mean James Damore, that well known scientist. Amazing how he hit on the differences so accurately when social scientists have been wrestling with them inconclusively since The Scottish Enlightenment. Not exactly a learned treatise taking into account all of the relevant research and theory available, now was it? He cited uncontested research. State what behaviours you think have unknown causes or the biological community are 'inconclusive' about concerning the differences between men and women.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Problem is that the same argument applies, in that biology isn't very good at reliably identifying that the differences in these behaviours are biologically determined; they're correlational. Its the absurdity of the nature / nurture argument - Its unsolvable, because people have bought into a false scientific paradigm - which science has long moved on from. Its the relationship between nature and nurture that's important, not one or the other. We are both socially and biologically constructed, the two are really inseparable. Attempts to prove one or the other, have always failed, because they've mistakenly embraced self fulfilling assumptional bias. There is a consensus in the field that nature is 50 to 80 of behaviour....on intelligence at least.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
Thanks! We now have a standard by which to judge all of the many facts you have expressed about which you seemed equally certain. I don't have time to devote to dancing to your specific tune. The democrats in Washington are bound by corporations but the wider base has gone very far to the progressive left. That's my opinion.....this is an opinion forum.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.