This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Matov
I won't repeat all the reasons why that just isn't true but you can sure of one thing. There has been a bucket load of water under the bridge but there is a reservoir upstream which is waiting to come down and plenty of rain forecast. This is just a set back. A skirmish in a long war. Wounds will be repaired and breath drawn but the fight for the future of our country must go on. But I would suggest that many people who thought a second referendum a good idea might benefit from perhaps having a copy of 'Democracy for Idiots' awaiting them under their Winterfest trees on the 25th of this month. Democracy in the UK is delegated to our representatives. Referendums don't work for complex issues. Look at the the problems this last one has caused. And perhaps a basic course in mathematics, especially when it comes to percentages? Irrelevant diversion. We can all do the maths. It's whose calculations should be considered which is disputed. However I would also like to wish you a very festive couple of weeks now and with hopes that come 2020 we can all try to move on from a period in British history which has perhaps bought out the worst in many of us. Till my dying day I will never regret voting Leave and will ALWAYS struggle to comprehend how anybody ever thought that trying to have the votes of 17 plus million people usurped was going to end well but as a newspaper columinst put it at the weekend, the war is over. Try harder with your efforts at comprehension. People don't feel as I do for no reason. Complex issues should not be decided by referendums in a representative democracy. If our Parliament mistakenly held one they should have had the balls to admit that and accept the consequences, then hold the GE. Not one of the parties had those balls. They let us down. Lets try and make a go of the peace now. Please do. Others will be busy planning the next strategy.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Didn’t I read that you don’t think the MPs should be able to do or think a,b or c now there’s a big majority a it’s your job to make sure they don’t. The attitude of both major parties has been to tighten their hold over their MPs and threaten them with expulsion if they vote against the whip. This will only get worse now. The result will be that it isn't our representatives setting the agenda and deciding what's best for us. It's the paymasters of the Tories. You know full well that MPs have been under the wing of the party, followed party policy and followed that through with the constituents understanding they’ll do that, for years and years. You’ll also know nearly all vote for the party leader. You are the only person on here who thinks otherwise, and as I’ve said, it’s very very boring. Some degree of party control is needed for smooth government but the overall direction ought to be in the hands of our elected representatives and not elsewhere. Unless they are free to vote according to the consciences that's impossible. And anyway, chris123 pointed out the final sentence under the role of an MP to prove you’re factually wrong anyway as well. I fail to see how, why or where that is.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Lend me your time machine. Control is under the government of the day. That was and is the point. To represent the view of the majority vote. It is. The MPs though ought to be controlling the government of the day and not the other way around. It is this that I am pointing out because unless the MPs are in control they cannot represent anyone. They are just voting machines. Depends what you value being an outsider of. A federal European state? Yes please and thank you. We’ll trade, but not give away our sovereignty and everything else to become lap dogs to Brussels. That old chestnut! It is, and always was, a myth. Just scaremongering nonsense fed to you by those with a vested interest in breaking up the EU. Brussels doesn't have any lap dogs. They are our servants and not our masters. The left, left of centre or centre will have their day. As has been discussed on here, it’s inevitable with the changing demographic, as planned by New Labour. We need a functional and coherent opposition now, but they’ve p1ssed it up, nobody else. I agree with this. Whether Labour can recover depends on them. I favour the emergence of a totally new party.
Blair gets much more right than he does wrong. If he still led Labour we would not be in this mess.
Labour are a total shambles and probably finished. I have no time at all for Corbyn, his type or his supporters. Any thoughts you have to the contrary need to be eradicated from your mind. The issues are not handled by experts. They’re left alone. Laissez faire. And incidentally, labour want lots more immigration, now. See the result a bit clearer yet? And then we have the Lib Dem’s who wanted to cancel Brexit. Their 4% increase of naff all isn’t a lot. The EU isn’t going to allow itself to be reformed unless a long drawn out actual exit tempts others to follow us. Unrestricted laissez faire in today's interdependent and complex world won't deliver what we need. The problems are far too big for that. Immigration will continue much as before. Mark my words there will be continuing moans about it for ever. I wanted to cancel Brexit! The LibDems got squeezed but that doesn't mean their arguments weren't popular. The EU may be forced to reform if populism grows and too many voters continue to get their misinformation from web forums. Edited by Rudi Hedman (18 Dec 2019 10.49am)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That I notice them doesn't mean I read every word. Often I will skim something, get the drift and decide it's pointless trying to respond. Thus I ignore it. No-one on the hard right really accepts that's where their views are. It takes others to see that. This is my take. Ken Clarke, Michael Heseltine and John Major are on the right. "Tommy Robinson" is on the furthest fringe of the far right. Decide for yourself who you are closest to in outlook. So if your not with us, your against us is what you are admitting then.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
When we have PR then that remark will have some validity. Right now we have the will of a minority who have given it to a party who regard their MPs as just lobby fodder. Who is actually deciding the policy direction from here on is unknown but it isn't the people and their representatives! 52% is a majority but that was ignored
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Some may have noticed I hardly posted anything during the election period, as I concentrated on trying to get Labour activists to see how stupid it was to leave Corbyn as their leader. Unsurprisingly I failed as spectacularly as I do here but I I also learned quite a lot. In my view they are not going to change direction and as a consequence are destined to become a protest group. I returned to see what the impact of the result would be for this group. I anticipated triumphalism but actually saw very little. What I also expected was the abuse and insults that seem to follow whatever I say. I wondered if this would increase and It has. I feared the huge majority would validate their opinions in the minds of the hard right and embolden them. From the little sample here that fear seems to be justified. If it is repeated across the country, and especially in Parliament, then I worry about the impact on our social cohesion in the coming 5 or more years. Without an effective opposition what stands in the way of the Tories to do whatever they want? Another poster recently described the cabal of members here who delight in attacking me, for my style as much as my arguments, as “numpties” and in the past few days they seem to have been going out of their way to justify that description. Nevertheless, as I understand that they are often seeking confirmation of their bias by shooting the messenger whilst ignoring the message, I don’t take it personally or respond in kind. However it really doesn’t get anyone very far and from my point of view banging my head against a brick wall is pretty pointless when all it achieves is a headache. That’s especially true is the wall is particularly dense or thick. What we have witnessed in the past day or two has more resembled the kids nursery I once owned than an adult debate. Of course in a nursery the staff would intervene and stop the bullying. Many of you would now be sitting on the naughty step until you apologised. Of course here that doesn’t happen as the staff join in. To continue the analogy it is like the teacher in a playground hiding behind the bike shed having a sly fag with the principal bully whilst sympathising with the mob giving a kicking to the unfortunate they have decided doesn’t fit in. So I now don’t intend to respond to posts which in my judgement are primarily intended just to attack me. I will post my observations as I see fit and ignore any response which doesn’t engage with the argument. I now expect that any reply will be of the "I don't care" variety. Ah, cerebral hygiene. Always a good option and one firmly espoused by plenty of people
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I thought you were about to flounce. Only an 1/8 less arrogant than usual so 7/8 of the usual arrogance. First paragraph was particularly amusing and eyebrow raising that you always think you can change everyone and their thinking. The daily few dozen posts telling people how parliament runs, when it doesn’t, and isn’t the full procedure, even if it is in the procedure is why you get some stiff replies. And you’re surprised. One day you might see why there’s an issue here. For someone with intelligence you’re displaying a lack of some in this respect. You’ve also used principles only when they suit you. Majority votes for example. I haven’t seen much too personal apart from when they’ve had the 11th incorrect lesson of how parliament works, when actually it doesn’t. If you didn’t do this then there’s a good chance your replies and experience would be different, however, you’re here as an activist and are therefore not going to listen I expect in your relentless forcing of opinion, because that is what it is, not fact or the exact science a lot of activists seem to think what they’re pushing is. I guess they need that thick skin, relentless endeavour and deafness to try and browbeat everyone. However, you might be a likeable chap so I wish you goodnight.
Relentless endeavour eh? I think he likes you Wisbech.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Relentless endeavour eh? I think he likes you Wisbech. I was being polite. Some of the ignorant to any other view activists on tv in the last week don’t deserve manners from the public seeing how they interrupt, talk over opponents or just people and ignore any results or evidence in front of them. Like listening to cold call monkeys on the phone.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
It must be very frustrating to interview people that cynically avoid answering questions and actively talk you out to prevent discourse. It was a tactic I first suffered from in Romania in the early 90s. The politicians there would literally speak for hours to avoid actually talking. The height of rudeness and abuse of power This week I have seen Ash Sarkar apologise for interrupting on the late night sky news press preview. I almost choked in bed on my late night water. Maybe they’ve all received a memo. People aren’t impressed. Edited by Rudi Hedman (18 Dec 2019 11.09pm)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
It must be very frustrating to interview people that cynically avoid answering questions and actively talk you out to prevent discourse. It was a tactic I first suffered from in Romania in the early 90s. The politicians there would literally speak for hours to avoid actually talking. The height of rudeness and abuse of power How did you suffer from it? Can we add political interviewer to your already lengthy CV
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Wisbech - You bear remarkable similarities to someone who has been in the news a lot recently. Who do you know who's strongly held opinions and convictions are disliked by and out of kilter with the majority, who believes that only his way is the right way and who is always unfailingly polite. Yes you're correct it's Jeremy Corbyn I said I wouldn't respond to such comments again but because of your position I will make an exception. Out of kilter with the "majority"? Are you seriously suggesting that the views expressed here represent the majority? The views here are certainly part of the majority that achieved the election result but they are very far from being in the Tory mainstream. Many are more in tune with Farage, or even further to the right. Certainly not the "one nation" Conservatism that Johnson now claims as his own! My views and Corbyn's are poles apart but that's not the only difference. Corbyn is detested by all except a fairly small and increasingly insignificant minority. I am just detested on here. I know of nowhere else where I receive such treatment. There are a number of web forums where I receive fulsome praise and where people with your kind of views are routinely unmercilessly ridiculed. I don't though hang around such places as, unlike many here, I am not looking for constant confirmation of my own biases. So the differences are many.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Out of kilter with the "majority"? Are you seriously suggesting that the views expressed here represent the majority? The views here are certainly part of the majority that achieved the election result but they are very far from being in the Tory mainstream. I have noticed before that you have a very crafty way of twisting your replies so that they aren't actually replying to the question at all so you obviously have something in common with Boris Johnson as well. When I said that your views were out of kilter with the majority I'm sure that everyone else realised that I was referring to the majority of the population of England and not this forum
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I have noticed before that you have a very crafty way of twisting your replies so that they aren't actually replying to the question at all so you obviously have something in common with Boris Johnson as well. When I said that your views were out of kilter with the majority I'm sure that everyone else realised that I was referring to the majority of the population of England and not this forum There was nothing "crafty" involved as that is exactly the point I replied to! Not for the first time here perfectly straightforward responses are misinterpreted. Whether deliberately or through a genuine lack of comprehension is an open question. That you think I am "out of kilter" doesn't mean I am because the views here are just a sub section of the majority. They are therefore not representative of the majority. Corbyn's views are "out of kilter" with everyone other than his core support. .
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Not for the first time here perfectly straightforward responses are misinterpreted. Whether deliberately or through a genuine lack of comprehension is an open question. When whingeing on both publically and via Private Message about your perceived lack of moderation on this forum and how people are allowed to get away with all sorts of insults I would like to remind you that suggesting that people lack comprehension is just a polite way of saying that someone is stupid. Please note that in common with the general guidelines for moderating this forum you haven't been issued with a yellow card
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.