You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 16 2026 8.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus (LOCKED)


Page 171 of 753 < 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 >
BlueJay Flag UK 20 Apr 20 2.17am

Originally posted by SavoyTruffle

My grandad was released from a hospital back to his care home the same day there have been the first covid-19 death in the same hospital. Thankfully he was fine and admittedly this was before lockdown, but understand there is still very little testing on elderly patients leaving hospital for unrelated issues corona treatment. Potentially putting someone infected back into a group of very vulnerable people.

Indeed. No plan, no protection, nothing. Carers milling in and out all day and night with zero testing taking place. A recipe for disaster.

Multiple estimates have care home deaths at 6000 -7000 higher than this time last year, though of course where people aren't tested this is an inconvenient truth that can be ignored by those at the helm. A combination of a government avoiding responsibility and a small percentage of people who decide that being inconvenienced for absolutely any period of time is a stretch too far, help to put the most vulnerable in society at risk.

Of course there's a balance between reducing deaths by isolating and the impact of the economy, but clearly action taken thus far isn't all that out there considering the nature of what we're facing. And countries with a "we've got it sussed" attitude like Germany and Japan are fast realising that their numbers are also getting out of control, so if anything they will be in lockdown when we've emerged from it.


 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 20 Apr 20 6.14am

Originally posted by BlueJay

Indeed. No plan, no protection, nothing. Carers milling in and out all day and night with zero testing taking place. A recipe for disaster.

Multiple estimates have care home deaths at 6000 -7000 higher than this time last year, though of course where people aren't tested this is an inconvenient truth that can be ignored by those at the helm. A combination of a government avoiding responsibility and a small percentage of people who decide that being inconvenienced for absolutely any period of time is a stretch too far, help to put the most vulnerable in society at risk.

Of course there's a balance between reducing deaths by isolating and the impact of the economy, but clearly action taken thus far isn't all that out there considering the nature of what we're facing. And countries with a "we've got it sussed" attitude like Germany and Japan are fast realising that their numbers are also getting out of control, so if anything they will be in lockdown when we've emerged from it.


The care home deaths are very tragic indeed along with all deaths from C19. Testing kits are available to purchase along with PPE for the correct money. Before the hammering I would gently state that lots of care homes are privately run. They take clinical advice from the NHS bodies but operational running and staffing is their responsibility. Why are they limited on PPE when they had the same info at the same time as the government. Why havent or didnt they have a stock of it. Procurement should be part of this operation. Blaming the government for bad info is one thing but blaming them for your own failings is another. Its like running with the hounds and play with the fox. Profit before care in some cases.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 20 Apr 20 6.18am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

The comparison has been made by far more qualified people than me.

But you carry on, don't worry your little self about it....just tell yourself what you wish to.

Kindly post without the insults please

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 20 Apr 20 6.48am

I totally get the points being made about care homes and it must be very worrying for those with relatives residing in or working in one. However, as far as I am aware, many are privately owned and charge upwards of £1000 per week. Surely then, the owners should be responsible for the well-being of residents and staff ( I would imagine this is a selling point on any literature), therefore should they not be providing PPE from their undoubted high profits? To put the blame solely at the Government’s door is, in my opinion, unfair and letting the owners of the hook.
NHS run homes are of course a different matter

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 20 Apr 20 7.32am

Originally posted by BlueJay

Indeed. No plan, no protection, nothing. Carers milling in and out all day and night with zero testing taking place. A recipe for disaster.

Multiple estimates have care home deaths at 6000 -7000 higher than this time last year, though of course where people aren't tested this is an inconvenient truth that can be ignored by those at the helm. A combination of a government avoiding responsibility and a small percentage of people who decide that being inconvenienced for absolutely any period of time is a stretch too far, help to put the most vulnerable in society at risk.

Of course there's a balance between reducing deaths by isolating and the impact of the economy, but clearly action taken thus far isn't all that out there considering the nature of what we're facing. And countries with a "we've got it sussed" attitude like Germany and Japan are fast realising that their numbers are also getting out of control, so if anything they will be in lockdown when we've emerged from it.


Lies, Damn lies, and statistics. Leaving out a sizable chunk of potential CV-19 deaths from care homes is a convenient way of 'getting things under control'.

And privatisation of previously Government-operated facilities is also distancing authority from due diligence and accountability.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 20 Apr 20 8.34am

Originally posted by cryrst

The care home deaths are very tragic indeed along with all deaths from C19. Testing kits are available to purchase along with PPE for the correct money. Before the hammering I would gently state that lots of care homes are privately run. They take clinical advice from the NHS bodies but operational running and staffing is their responsibility. Why are they limited on PPE when they had the same info at the same time as the government. Why havent or didnt they have a stock of it. Procurement should be part of this operation. Blaming the government for bad info is one thing but blaming them for your own failings is another. Its like running with the hounds and play with the fox. Profit before care in some cases.

Because they were guaranteed PPE would be supplied by Local Authorities.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 20 Apr 20 8.35am

Originally posted by Spiderman

I totally get the points being made about care homes and it must be very worrying for those with relatives residing in or working in one. However, as far as I am aware, many are privately owned and charge upwards of £1000 per week. Surely then, the owners should be responsible for the well-being of residents and staff ( I would imagine this is a selling point on any literature), therefore should they not be providing PPE from their undoubted high profits? To put the blame solely at the Government’s door is, in my opinion, unfair and letting the owners of the hook.
NHS run homes are of course a different matter

It is well known most are unprofitable. Often only surviving through charitable cross subsidisation

[Link]

[Link]


Edited by Mapletree (20 Apr 2020 8.38am)

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 20 Apr 20 9.15am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Because they were guaranteed PPE would be supplied by Local Authorities.

So they waited for that email then, not being proactive with their experience; or not as the case seems to be. Local authorities are also somewhat self governed as well. Look at the wages of their bosses compared to MPs wages. What does that tell you about who's in charge.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 20 Apr 20 9.20am

Originally posted by Mapletree

It is well known most are unprofitable. Often only surviving through charitable cross subsidisation

[Link]

[Link]


Edited by Mapletree (20 Apr 2020 8.38am)

So these ones went bust and 1000s havent. The positive is surely that fact alone. How many care home owners live in a two up two down. Not many if any. Taking dividends has undoubtedly taken profits or the slush fund. Go on companies house and check their accounts. I'm sure the evidence of the spending and wages will be there. Including dividends taken.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 20 Apr 20 9.23am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Lies, Damn lies, and statistics. Leaving out a sizable chunk of potential CV-19 deaths from care homes is a convenient way of 'getting things under control'.

And privatisation of previously Government-operated facilities is also distancing authority from due diligence and accountability.

The old privatisation number eh. Let's have full on socialism to eradicate it. Or nationalism as at least we can think we are in control. Hows your ex council house or one definitely sold by AN other within any chain you may have bought your own house in.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 20 Apr 20 9.51am

There is also a question of perception over lockdown - in London there have been, so far, 3825 deaths against 903 across Scotland. Obviously the population is much lower and I’m in no way trying to dismiss the loss but the stats aren’t as alarming when you’re dealing with 10 deaths a day as opposed to hundreds.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Apr 20 9.53am

Originally posted by Mapletree

It is well known most are unprofitable. Often only surviving through charitable cross subsidisation

[Link]

[Link]


Edited by Mapletree (20 Apr 2020 8.38am)

2 reasons then. Reduction of government funding and ownership. The final paragraph....

‘There must be a recognition that private equity and hedge funds are not suitable owners of homes for the elderly and infirm. This is not because financiers are unalloyed villains who would sell their own granny rather than pay for her to be in a decent care facility. Mainly, it is because their business model doesn’t work.’

Sounds like quite a few will be run on debt and therein lies a big problem, especially when you have an unexpected cost like this. This virus could really damage their industry more in the future losing residents moving in.

 


COYP

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 20 Apr 20 9.58am

Originally posted by cryrst

The care home deaths are very tragic indeed along with all deaths from C19. Testing kits are available to purchase along with PPE for the correct money. Before the hammering I would gently state that lots of care homes are privately run. They take clinical advice from the NHS bodies but operational running and staffing is their responsibility. Why are they limited on PPE when they had the same info at the same time as the government. Why havent or didnt they have a stock of it. Procurement should be part of this operation. Blaming the government for bad info is one thing but blaming them for your own failings is another. Its like running with the hounds and play with the fox. Profit before care in some cases.

20 years ago I owned a 29 bed care home. So my knowledge is out of date but I don't think things have changed so much, and if anything for the worse.

I relied on a manager on all operational matters, including PPE, and she in turn relied on external advice whenever something out of the ordinary happened. I am certain we would now have been following government advice, and not taking independent decisions, as we didn't have the expertise to do so.

Most of the time it's a real struggle to recruit enough staff, especially reliable good ones. As a consequence you frequently have to rely on agencies who bleed you dry. On many occasions you have no choice other than to use them to ensure a safe, and legal, staffing level. Many residents are funded by their local authorities, who pay the rate they determine is correct, and not what you feel is appropriate. The gap between the two was large in my day and with austerity must now be bigger.

So the idea that a care home is a very profitable business is a myth. It can be very challenging. The people who bought my home to add to their group went bankrupt 3 years later.

The rewards in running a home are rarely financial. The reward comes from giving people a good place to live and enjoy their latter years. There is a lot of love in a care home. It was an experience I treasure and from which I learned a great deal.

I can only imagine what it must be like at the moment and my heart goes out to the residents, their families and the many devoted, hard working and loving staff who give so much of themselves to make people's lives better.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 20 Apr 20 10.03am

Originally posted by cryrst

So they waited for that email then, not being proactive with their experience; or not as the case seems to be. Local authorities are also somewhat self governed as well. Look at the wages of their bosses compared to MPs wages. What does that tell you about who's in charge.

No, no and no in that order

Our Local Authorities have been excellent but they in turn had to be supplied.

We were able to source some PPE privately at an early point, that is no longer feasible.

Why the hell keep knocking people. What on earth has local authority pay structure got to do with this.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 20 Apr 20 10.07am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

2 reasons then. Reduction of government funding and ownership. The final paragraph....

‘There must be a recognition that private equity and hedge funds are not suitable owners of homes for the elderly and infirm. This is not because financiers are unalloyed villains who would sell their own granny rather than pay for her to be in a decent care facility. Mainly, it is because their business model doesn’t work.’

Sounds like quite a few will be run on debt and therein lies a big problem, especially when you have an unexpected cost like this. This virus could really damage their industry more in the future losing residents moving in.

Most are run by charitable trusts, many set up generations ago by e.g. Churches. Some are run as small businesses by entrepreneurs, often originally doctors. The biggest issue is that Local Authorities can't afford to pay the break-even rate, which in most cases is in the region of £1,000 within London. So private payers have to subsidise. Then we had the increase in minimum wages without any equivalent increases in Local Authority funds. For many that was game over.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 20 Apr 20 10.08am

Originally posted by cryrst

So these ones went bust and 1000s havent. The positive is surely that fact alone. How many care home owners live in a two up two down. Not many if any. Taking dividends has undoubtedly taken profits or the slush fund. Go on companies house and check their accounts. I'm sure the evidence of the spending and wages will be there. Including dividends taken.

You have so little idea of what you are typing about, I give up on this subject with you.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 20 Apr 20 10.18am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

2 reasons then. Reduction of government funding and ownership. The final paragraph....

‘There must be a recognition that private equity and hedge funds are not suitable owners of homes for the elderly and infirm. This is not because financiers are unalloyed villains who would sell their own granny rather than pay for her to be in a decent care facility. Mainly, it is because their business model doesn’t work.’

Sounds like quite a few will be run on debt and therein lies a big problem, especially when you have an unexpected cost like this. This virus could really damage their industry more in the future losing residents moving in.

In fact it's possible they will all fill up, as the NHS tries to shift people that are bed-blocking. This is a problem that should have been addressed before now but is wrapped up in the complexity of when Local Authorities and when CCGs pay. And the lack of funding for both.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 20 Apr 20 10.38am

Originally posted by Mapletree

In fact it's possible they will all fill up, as the NHS tries to shift people that are bed-blocking. This is a problem that should have been addressed before now but is wrapped up in the complexity of when Local Authorities and when CCGs pay. And the lack of funding for both.

Do care homes have to pay business rates?

If yes that is something that should be changed. They should pay a lower rate mainly for refuse collection I thought I read that GP's surgeries also have to pay, ridiculous.

 


One more point

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Apr 20 10.40am

Originally posted by Mapletree

In fact it's possible they will all fill up, as the NHS tries to shift people that are bed-blocking. This is a problem that should have been addressed before now but is wrapped up in the complexity of when Local Authorities and when CCGs pay. And the lack of funding for both.

Into care homes with the virus circulating in them and between nearby care homes via agency staff. Going to be a long ordeal in care homes.

 


COYP

cryrst Flag The garden of England 20 Apr 20 10.41am

Originally posted by Mapletree

You have so little idea of what you are typing about, I give up on this subject with you.

What you mean is I can have an opinion as long as it's yours. Fair enough you are right. Yet again!
It is business though and if they run at a loss then it's a bad business. Would you not agree with that. Unless they have cash flow.

 

Page 171 of 753 < 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic