You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Our Daughter Holly
November 19 2026 5.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Our Daughter Holly


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 12 Mar 04 2.22am

Quote the despotic banana at 12 Mar 2004 1:51am

Quote Cucking Funt at 12 Mar 2004 1:28am


I can see what you're getting at but paedophiles are as responsible as anyone else in controlling their urges. Just because someone may fancy blondes more than brunettes doesn't mean that he's going to abduct, torture and rape them. If someone feels that that is where his inclinations lie, then there is help available, be that via their GP or through the many, free confidential counselling services that are available. It is safe to classify Huntley and his type as evil because he knew that he had those urges - if he acknowledged them as being wrong, somewhere along the line conscience would have kicked in. But it didn't. He actively concealed his past brushes with the law for related offences, he showed utterly no remorse during the trial and even now he refuses to reveal what truly happened that day; anyone with a shred of humanity or decency would have at least done that, if only to put the girls' parents out of their misery. He's content to sentence them to a lifetime of anguish, knowing that they'll never know what really happened to their daughters. Why not acknowledge that evil exists instead of trying to find some justification for them, be it mental problems or some kind of flaw in society? This guy is a monster, pure and simple, and I think you're on very, very shaky ground if you suggest that we are no better than his kind; the overwhelming majority of us have an acute sense of right and wrong, something Huntley failed to demonstrate and continues to do so.

1. Being attracted to blondes isn't a criminal offence though.

Not relevant. The point is about the pursuit of one's urges and the lengths one will go to in order to fulfill them.

2. If Huntley did intentionally kill the girls then yes, his continued refusal to reveal what actually happened to the girl's families is utterly heartless. But if his testimony was the truth then what more has he to say?

His testimony was proved to be false. His alibis did not correspond and the explanation he offered for the girls' deaths was manifestly absurd. Have you read the transcripts?

3. I acknowledge that evil exists and I'm not trying to justify it, but I believe that those who seek to punish evil with such fervent blood-lust, either through vigilante action or by calling for capital punishment are themselves no better than the evil they so loathe.

It's not about blood lust or vigilante action. Society has an absolute right to make and enforce laws that are not only just but represent the will and the sensitivities of its members. In such circumstances, the death penalty is justifiable - this has been the view of philosophers all the way back to Ancient Greece and of the majority of the great 'humane' figures in history.

4. We are no better than 'his kind' as you put it. We all are, after all, human and therefore it could have just as likely have been one of us in his position. And if we consider that then maybe we won't be so quick to bay for blood next time.

If, as you say, 'one of us' is in that position, then we have no reason to expect to be treated particularly leniently. I'm happy to use the phrase 'his kind' because, as a member of a civilised society, I consider him to be outside the parameters within which one could be considered part of that society. Society is too large and too complex to be able to permit or even show lenience to crimes of this nature. To show any kind of tolerance towards people who commit these kind of crimes is, in fact, dangerous to the structure of that society as a whole - tolerance of something which is clearly anti-social can only weaken it.

Edited by Cucking Funt (12 Mar 2004 2:26am)

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

reborn 12 Mar 04 7.52am

There are certain crimes that mean you forfit the right to live amongst the rest of the human race and this was one of them.

Pete mate, what can I say , the sincerity of your post shone through. You're a stronger man than me, I couldn't watch it.

Despo, I am afraid whilst I see some of your logic you and the bleeding herats like you are perpetuating the myth that somehoe these people are victims. They should die. End of.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

martin.cpfc Flag Halifax... (South London at heart) 12 Mar 04 7.58am

Quote the despotic banana at 11 Mar 2004 11:11pm

Secondly, this is a problem of our own making - if paedophiles weren't so reviled by society then they wouldn't turn to such desperate measures. Paedophiles need to be helped not loathed. Tabloid papers whipping up frenzies and encouraging lynch mobs solves nothing, and it only makes the problem worse. If a paedophile knows that if he makes his problem public then he's going to be ostracised or worse, then he's better off keeping it a secret and letting it gnaw at him from the inside until one day he snaps with terrible consequences. We need to show them compassion and humanity, not seek to destroy them - it is not a conscious decision on a paedophile's part to become attracted to young children, they do not wake up one day and decide to find children arousing. Rather it would appear to be a mental problem, perhaps stemming from being abused as a child. It is not their fault, and we must acknowledge that.

A load of rubbish!

These sick "Humans" should be strung up or locked away from civilised society for ever!

Anyone who is tempted to harm kids shouldn't be allowed in public areas.

Have you got kids Despotic?


Edited by martin.cpfc (12 Mar 2004 8:00am)

 


“Going to war without France is like going deer hunting without your accordion.”
–General Norman Schwartzkopf

Palace Hero Flag Melbourne, Australia 12 Mar 04 8.43am

I agree with what you are trying to say Despotic, in theory it is right. In a forgiving and open world, crimes like this may not have been commited, and sick people like Huntley would hopefully have gotten the help they needed before doing something as unforgiveable as killing those poor girls.

However, that is only a theory. Communism in theory is the most perfect, utopic and democratic system for people to live by. Similar to your ideals, it is about people working for the benefit of others. However in practice it collapses, as human nature doesn't allow such equality. Just like in this situation, human nature will never allow Ian Huntley to ever be forgiven, nor in peoples eyes can justice ever be achieved. Killing him is too good, but nothing else is harsh enough. That is the sad reality of the situation, and no matter how much you want more kindness in the world to prevent crimes like those against Holly and Jessica, the crime has been commited and no longer does any rehabilitation apply to Huntley. He has gone past the point of no return and like has been said, has forfeited both the right to live amongst other people, or live at all.

I wont chastise your opinions Despo, you have a right to them and I don't think they carry any malice at all, in fact it is obviously the opposite. You aren't advocating Huntley, just pointing out the possibilities in the situation. But in such a sensitive issue, your opinion should have been kept to yourself, as most people aren't going to accept it, and respond aggresively. A better way to go about things is to apply your theories in the future, to prevent these sorts of crimes. Because no matter how good your intentions are, they no longer apply to Ian Huntley or any other criminal that has done such a terrible deed.

 

jcreedy Flag 12 Mar 04 9.55am

Quote the despotic banana at 11 Mar 2004 11:56pm

Obviously if sex with women above the age of 16 was outlawed tomorrow you'd have the strength of mind to go your whole life without giving in to your sexual desires. You can't imagine what it must feel like to have that gnawing away inside you for years, and you can't imagine what lengths that would drive you to. Obviously I don't condone rape or murder but let's face it, society drives them to it.

Edited by the despotic banana (11 Mar 2004 11:57pm)


Despotic, I'm sure most of us had a burning desire from when we started puberty to shag something. That doesn't mean we had such a lack of self control that we overpowered and raped somebody just because we could. Huntley has no excuses, no matter how s***ty his childhood/past life was. Do you think Holly's parents are wrong to want to kill Huntley? I don't have any children and can't imagine what it's like, but I should think wanting to take revenge on the murderer of your child is a perfectly natural feeling.
However, If certain people had done their jobs properly, Huntley wouldn't have been in the school and may have been locked up years ago.


 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

Bexter Flag By the Sea 12 Mar 04 10.17am

i didn't watch it because i was out, but i don't think i could have anyway. we do live in a very f-ed up country at the moment, family values are a rare thing and we are seen abroad (in places like italy for instance which has strong family values and much less child crime) as a nation of perverts and child abusers. and we are, and it's shocking and embarrassing and tragic. i don't know how we deal with it but it is a major problem. not saying i understand why he did it or feel any sympathy for him, but he is one case of many and it is scary. i cannot even begin to feel what the parents felt, just the pictures of holly's dad in the paper were enough for me. tragic.

 

Moose Flag In the sewer pipe... 12 Mar 04 10.21am

Quote Palace Hero at 12 Mar 2004 8:43am

I agree with what you are trying to say Despotic, in theory it is right. In a forgiving and open world, crimes like this may not have been commited, and sick people like Huntley would hopefully have gotten the help they needed before doing something as unforgiveable as killing those poor girls.

However, that is only a theory. Communism in theory is the most perfect, utopic and democratic system for people to live by. Similar to your ideals, it is about people working for the benefit of others. However in practice it collapses, as human nature doesn't allow such equality. Just like in this situation, human nature will never allow Ian Huntley to ever be forgiven, nor in peoples eyes can justice ever be achieved. Killing him is too good, but nothing else is harsh enough. That is the sad reality of the situation, and no matter how much you want more kindness in the world to prevent crimes like those against Holly and Jessica, the crime has been commited and no longer does any rehabilitation apply to Huntley. He has gone past the point of no return and like has been said, has forfeited both the right to live amongst other people, or live at all.

I wont chastise your opinions Despo, you have a right to them and I don't think they carry any malice at all, in fact it is obviously the opposite. You aren't advocating Huntley, just pointing out the possibilities in the situation. But in such a sensitive issue, your opinion should have been kept to yourself, as most people aren't going to accept it, and respond aggresively. A better way to go about things is to apply your theories in the future, to prevent these sorts of crimes. Because no matter how good your intentions are, they no longer apply to Ian Huntley or any other criminal that has done such a terrible deed.

That is an excellent post, PH.

Despotic, society just will never understand, accept or forgive crimes such as Huntley's. I'm not even sure I'd want the Utopian society that would try.

Although I'm sure that some paedophiles bitterly regret what they have done, the overriding fact in this case is that Huntley's only regret was getting caught. His defence was primarily along the lines of "I killed them, now prove I did it on purpose." In that way, he has never shown remorse for what he did, and has never provided any sort of closure to Holly and Jessica's parents. The bloke is an animal and deserves to end his days in prison (I'm against the death penalty and that would be too good for him anyway). Let him spend the rest of his miserable existance mulling over what he's done, by himself, in a cell, with none of the cushy privileges some other prisoners seem to enjoy.

 


Goodness is what you do. Not who you pray to.

Bexter Flag By the Sea 12 Mar 04 10.23am

indeed, he wont be seeing the light of day so no point in giving him any therapy. not to say it's not a good idea to try and nip future huntley's in the bud with some kind of help - not for their sakes so much as any future victims.

 

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 12 Mar 04 10.41am

Quote Petealiator at 11 Mar 2004 10:47pm

The program tonight.

I don't know what to say. It had me in tears throughout much of it. It upset me immensely, I really shouldn't have watched it, but I knew I would have to. I'm left feeling so very hollow and defeated by the sickness of this vile filthy world of perverts and evil, but my absolute and total admiration of the Wells family gives me something positive to cling to. Something to continue to strive for. Wonderful, strong, good people. The unimportant ordinary backbone of this island.

But I'm left feeling that with the aid of well-meaning liberal ideals and human rights for all no matter what; evil is winning the battle.


I feel the same. I was out last night but when I got home at around midnight the Mrs was still crying from this programme.

 

Bexter Flag By the Sea 12 Mar 04 10.49am

how are liberal thinkers to blame for the evils of huntley? not being fiesty - just want to hear why!

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 12 Mar 04 10.51am

Right, let me first apologise to Despotic for last night's rant. I was in no mood for a row and it was a childish knee-jerk reaction. You are a decent enough lad and as Palace Hero said, there in no malice in your beliefs.

I don't really think it's worth arguing the toss over this either, I think the gulf between our basic beliefs is far too wide to bridge. You believe that all Human life is - for want of a better word - sacred, I don't! Your beliefs are basically biological, i.e. we're all the same, we're all Human, whilst mine are more spiritual, even religious if you like, I believe that mankind is becoming a worthless steaming pile of s***! I believe that evil lurks among us and is spreading like a disease and it lurks in the shape of human beings yet is no more human than the great white shark and has about the same capability for compassion. I believe mankind is embroiled in a battle between the forces of good and evil and evil is winning and is being aided by liberal attitudes. I believe the only way to cure the world of it's ills, to cure it's evil, is to face it head on, to fight it and eradicate it. I don't give a s*** if in your eyes that makes me as bad as the Huntley thing and his kind because I know I am a good man.

The workings of a normal mind: Damn my gambling, it's like a drug, I just can't seem to stop and now I could really do with some serious dosh, in fact if I don't come up with twenty grand in the next two weeks I'm finished, I'll loose everything. I could rob a bank; the money would certainly make me feel a lot better, I'd keep the house, she wouldn't leave me and I'd be able to sleep at night, at the very least the terrible crushing anxiety would ease off a bit. I could go for debt counselling but society has already marked me out as a credit risk and a bad person, so f*** that, counselling won't help anyway, I need money and I need it NOW! But if I rob a bank, someone could get hurt, someone could even get killed! What to do? Hang on, what am I thinking, rob a bank? Maybe kill someone because of my own selfish needs and desires? f*** that! I'm no bank robber! I'm no killer! I'll go and talk to citizens advice! I'll even go and see my doctor. I'll talk to the wife. Maybe old Ron next door'll lend me a score!

The workings of the insectile mind of the Huntley thing:
Need, need, need, want, want, want, gotta have, must have, WILL HAVE, need, need, want, oh f***, look what I've done! Oh s***, oh s***, oh s***, I'm in trouble, I'm in trouble, they see me, they see me, TROUBLE, BIG TROUBLE NOW, their eyes, their eyes, they'll tell, they'll tell, oh f*** they'' tell, kill, kill, kill, kill! Oh f***, oh f***, oh f***. Burn, burn, burn! Safe, safe, just lie, just lie, calm, calm, lie, calm, lie. Happy again.

The clear difference between good and evil.

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Bexter Flag By the Sea 12 Mar 04 11.00am

what are the rates of child murder and peadophilia in less 'liberal' countries? or how about 'liberal' ones with strong family identity? why do mothers sit by and let their new boyfriends beat their kid to death in this country? where have we gone wrong? i don't know, i think blaming 'liberal' thinkers is an easy way to not have to face the fact that this country has few morals compared to others. by the way, for the record, i think he should rot in jail, get no help, get no luxuries, get beaten up, and i am not a pacifist or a commie - just for the record!

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 12 Mar 04 11.06am

Bexter, I'm not blaming liberal thinkers at all, I'm saying that liberal attitudes aid these monsters in their endevours, it's because of liberal attitudes that so many of these things are on the street, preying on innocence instead of rotting in a cell or - given my way - dead!

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Jay_Palace Flag 12 Mar 04 11.08am

I think that it is actually important to look beyond the obvious in this case, and instead ask the question WHY was a man with a history of sexual attacks against young women allowed to be put into a position where he would have day to day contact with young children?

I'm not going to get drawn into why Huntley did what he did and who's responsible for it, but the fact remains that there was a vetting process in place specifically designed to stop individuals such as Huntley from coming into contact with children, and yet this process was totally ignored.

We need to establish who was responsible for this happening, and make an example of them. There is too much of a 'don't blame me, because it's not MY fault' attitude in this country, and it is about time that people who mess up are made accountable for their actions.

I expect to see heads roll over this whole debacle.

 


Bexter Flag By the Sea 12 Mar 04 11.08am

how do 'liberal' attitudes aid these monsters?

Edited by Bexter (12 Mar 2004 11:08am)

 

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 12 Mar 04 11.13am

Quote Bexter at 12 Mar 2004 11:08am

how do 'liberal' attitudes aid these monsters?

Edited by Bexter (12 Mar 2004 11:08am)


The data protection act (or the police interpretation of it) is one example. It doesn't stop a credit company accessing your financial history yet it stops a police force making available the very information that could have saved the lives of the girls.

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 12 Mar 04 11.16am

Quote Bexter at 12 Mar 2004 11:08am

how do 'liberal' attitudes aid these monsters?

Edited by Bexter (12 Mar 2004 11:08am)


Oh come on Bexter, liberal attitudes towards dangerous sex offenders and their all-important rights ensures that one of these monsters could be living next door to young children and the family have no right to know! It's called Rule 43! Remove liberal attitudes from the equation and you end up with a hard line and that hard line is likely to mean JUSTICE!

Edited by Petealiator (12 Mar 2004 11:17am)

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Bexter Flag By the Sea 12 Mar 04 11.17am

hang on - we get spied on in this country more than most places! you get caught on cctv at least once a day, i think jumping on liberal attitudes is a bit rich, the system is s*** yes, outdated yes, changing - yes. how about poverty? do you not think alot of the kids killed in domestic abuse come from generally poor familes? i'm not blaming poverty - i'm not blaming anything although i think it is the breakdown of the family to a great degree, but why that is happening, i don't know.

 

Bexter Flag By the Sea 12 Mar 04 11.18am

pete - i wasn't saying that they aren't to blame, i just wanted you to explain! jeez..... i'm not blaming anything, or not blaming anything here!

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 12 Mar 04 11.26am

Quote Bexter at 12 Mar 2004 11:17am

hang on - we get spied on in this country more than most places! you get caught on cctv at least once a day, i think jumping on liberal attitudes is a bit rich, the system is s*** yes, outdated yes, changing - yes. how about poverty? do you not think alot of the kids killed in domestic abuse come from generally poor familes? i'm not blaming poverty - i'm not blaming anything although i think it is the breakdown of the family to a great degree, but why that is happening, i don't know.


I agree, much of our problems stem from the break down of good old family values and old fashioned morals in this country, but liberal attitudes in the church must surely burden some of the blame for the break down of the sanctity of marriage. The break down of discipline and respect in today’s young stems from liberal attitudes in schools and the preoccupation with children’s rights. The breakdown therefore of family and morals stems from liberal attitudes.

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Our Daughter Holly