You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Is Capitalism Broken?
November 21 2026 11.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is Capitalism Broken?


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Oct 17 2.38pm

Originally posted by hedgehog50

Capitalism is largely people living their lives. It is businesses producing goods and services that people want. If people don't want their products or they are of too poor a quality or too expensive, the business goes bust, and businesses that do provide what people want, thrive. In socialist economies, the only products available are those that some planner decides should be produced. Whatever the quality or price of these products, you are stuck with them, there is no other choice. However bad the goods and services are they can continue forever - no constraints on them whatsoever.

So why does advertising and branding exist - Surely these are necessary to convince people that they need or desire something, or to create a false value of quality.

Captialism is very good in so much it feeds into peoples aspirations, where as socialism really doesn't. Also capitalist economies are effective at trading externally, to deal with shortages, which Communist ecconomies cannot do (if all you produce are TVs it doesn't really matter how good their quality might be, if you want to sell them, and its all you have to sell, your going into a buyers market, and you have to sell, because the country producing all the wheat for bread has just had a famine).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Oct 17 2.49pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

None of which though relates to capitalism, as a system of economics, which is generously, only around 400 years old, and not carried on a biological trait.

The paradigm your describing applies only the definitions of a species, not to individuals within a species where behaviour is generated and perpetuated in a social, not biological environment.

The hypothesis you present, is rejected almost universally as invalid in social sciences (including Psychology, Sociology and Anthropology), the notion of functionalism or biological determinism have been reduced to being factors of behaviour, not causal definitions of behaviour - and replaced by more complex models.

You can't reduce human behaviour to the 'selfish gene', even that's rejected as feasible in Evolutionary Psychology. Dawkins in the selfish gene is only describing a model that fits within the requirements of biological science paradims - Its not a statement of truth.

Its a useful, and beneficial model for understanding how genetics and evolution operate within a species over time, its not a 'literal thing'.

There is no evidence to support the idea that genes define behaviour, they may contribute to it, but then not as much as social surroundings and external peers do.

Again, I can't seperate things as you are. I think the problem here is complexity. It's easy to reject relationships that cannot be easily seen.
A factor of behaviour is still significant and let's be honest, we really don't understand it.

Genes clearly do produce advantageous behaviour, albeit by chance, but this in turn must allow for a more successful proliferation of genes. Social systems must be an extension of similar animal behaviour.

The gene does not 'know' this but this is the vehicle by which a randomly selected advantageous gene are reproduced in greated numbers. There is no conscious effort by a gene but it's vehicle, the animal, is driven by mechanisms that aid the process. Capitalism evolved via this process.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (23 Oct 2017 2.49pm)

 

Park Road Flag 23 Oct 17 2.50pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Capitalism is the production of surplus, to be sold, at a profit.

Proto-capitalism (realistically, capitalism in its earliest form) dates back to Luca Pacioli (1447 to 1517) who documented a mathematical text that effectively invented Double Entry Book Keeping - a necessary precursor to capitalism (a system of effectively establishing profit and loss).

The second pre-requisite was the break down of the notion of a divinity driven world, which came from the renascence and the notion of work being 'good' in its own right (The Protestant Work Ethic). Prior to this the idea of wealth being 'good', rather than as a means for doing good works, was non-existent.

The third pre-requisite for capitalism is an controlled means of monetary exchange (i.e. a system of money that is based on a fixed value, rather than the individual value of the coins).

Also, slavery made capitalism somewhat questionable - Arguably, countries tend to become capitalist, when they've dropped slavery (which is an oddly unprofitable form of labour - the main reason slavery tended to die out was really the death of agrarian economics - Slaves are efficient in agriculture - they're massively inefficient in industry).

The fourth pre-requisite was availability of luxuary goods and effective means of production. In earlier times, pre-Industrialisation (ie the end of an aggraian economy and urbanisation). Whilst the majority of the population were dispersed widely, trade was a limited resource, and production limited.

Industrialisation and the rise of industrial production was effectively the final catalyst.

But you don't really have a documented concept of capitalism, until the Philosopher Adam Smith.

Learnt a lot there thanks.
Especially the slavery angle and agriculture.
Very complex but reinforcing the fact that human nature is all for one as long as its me.

 

tome Flag Inner Tantalus Time. 23 Oct 17 2.53pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

None of which though relates to capitalism, as a system of economics, which is generously, only around 400 years old, and not carried on a biological trait.

The paradigm your describing applies only the definitions of a species, not to individuals within a species where behaviour is generated and perpetuated in a social, not biological environment.

The hypothesis you present, is rejected almost universally as invalid in social sciences (including Psychology, Sociology and Anthropology), the notion of functionalism or biological determinism have been reduced to being factors of behaviour, not causal definitions of behaviour - and replaced by more complex models.

You can't reduce human behaviour to the 'selfish gene', even that's rejected as feasible in Evolutionary Psychology. Dawkins in the selfish gene is only describing a model that fits within the requirements of biological science paradims - Its not a statement of truth.

Its a useful, and beneficial model for understanding how genetics and evolution operate within a species over time, its not a 'literal thing'.

There is no evidence to support the idea that genes define behaviour, they may contribute to it, but then not as much as social surroundings and external peers do.

Also, not sure if you've come across some of the recent work by George Monbiot and Sophie Raworth - quite interesting stuff suggesting that individualism and in it for yourself attitudes can't be automatically deemed the 'natural' order of things.


[Link]

[Link]

Instead, there is an argument that humans are inherently social and that supporting collective aims is more likely to create happiness.

 


A one and a two...

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 23 Oct 17 3.02pm

Originally posted by hedgehog50

Capitalism is largely people living their lives. It is businesses producing goods and services that people want. If people don't want their products or they are of too poor a quality or too expensive, the business goes bust, and businesses that do provide what people want, thrive. In socialist economies, the only products available are those that some planner decides should be produced. Whatever the quality or price of these products, you are stuck with them, there is no other choice. However bad the goods and services are they can continue forever - no constraints on them whatsoever.

Rubbish.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Oct 17 3.08pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

What is capitalism, UK style.

Materialism, consumerism, inequality, increasing poverty including child poverty, homelessness, exclusion social deprivation, ruined prison system, law only for the rich, desperate housing situation.

I could go on and it is quite preventable IMO.

A left wing labour government could tackle some of these but not the tories who have caused most of the problems.

What is the point of any system that does not benefit the majority only a few rich people.

This one of the most deluded posts I have seen for a while.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 23 Oct 17 3.09pm

the Hunter-Gatherer lifestyle and system of survival is really the only thing mankind is adapted to.

Asking us to live under all these other systems is like asking a goldfish to tapdance.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Stirlingsays Flag 23 Oct 17 3.09pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721


Only very dangerous people, or foolish people, think they know what human nature is.

The success or failures....or to be more accurate the effectiveness of systems is evident in how they relate to human nature. The reactions to systems themselves will tell you a lot about the reality of human nature...indeed sociological degrees study them.

Those who think they can control and change human nature and produce successful outcomes are the fools. Far more realistic to design systems that best utilise its more productive parts. Create systems that try to contain its more destructive parts.

The only realities that keep civilisation together are the fact that we feed meat to the beast to keep it quiet. Once you knocked the electric out and food ran low....then the reality of human nature would wipe the veneer off all the warm worded BS that people talk out of the window.

On and I know the current trend is to blame that on masculinity but that's like blaming a coin for having two sides.

Edited by Stirlingsays (23 Oct 2017 3.18pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 23 Oct 17 3.10pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

This one of the most deluded posts I have seen for a while.

You would say that, but not have an answer to the points.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 23 Oct 17 3.16pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

You would say that, but not have an answer to the points.

But your points turn something serious into a comic format. We are talking about the fundamentals of nature and how it relates to different systems.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Oct 17 3.16pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

You would say that, but not have an answer to the points.

Like you did in your last post to the Hog?

There are no sensible points. It is just idealistic, partisan mumbo jumbo.

Poverty in Britain is not significant. There will always be relative poverty. Communism does not work. The Labour Party wil do nothing except increase our debt.
Deal with it.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 23 Oct 17 3.21pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

the Hunter-Gatherer lifestyle and system of survival is really the only thing mankind is adapted to.

Asking us to live under all these other systems is like asking a goldfish to tapdance.

There's a lot of truth to that. That is essentially the man working and the mother bringing up children. It doesn't work for everyone.

In this country once globalisation occurred that essentially meant we continually got poorer as competition increased. People are punished for wanting to follow that model now.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Oct 17 3.23pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

the Hunter-Gatherer lifestyle and system of survival is really the only thing mankind is adapted to.

Asking us to live under all these other systems is like asking a goldfish to tapdance.

But that evolved into this. The problem for me is that most humans have become a slave to the system rather than living a more utopian lifestyle.
The other problem is numbers. Society has allowed too many humans to exist. That has improved quality of life in terms of health but it will also ultimately be the end of us.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Oct 17 3.48pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

the Hunter-Gatherer lifestyle and system of survival is really the only thing mankind is adapted to.

Asking us to live under all these other systems is like asking a goldfish to tapdance.

Not anymore. My view is that humans, are unusual in nature, because they aren't specialised, on an evolutionary basis they have three things, that are more or less unique. What probably sets humans aside isn't that there best suited to their environment, but able to adapt to a wide variety of environments.

Biologically humans are generalists. Their unique in that they have language, and a ridiculous number of mirror neurons (thousands of times more than any other species). These two traits, probably more than anything gave humans a massive benefit. They could communicate in a very complex manner (using tens of thousands of sounds), tool use and have a monumental capacity to learn.

Where as other species tend to rely on being fast, stronger, doing more damage, being better camouflaged etc humans are able to resolve problems, and more importantly effectively discuss how to solve a problem, and design a tool to overcome that problem.

We're still doing that. We don't evolve to over come a problem, we construct a tool or set of tools to deal with the problem (from spears and fire, to complex machines and medicine).

We're probably one of the few known species to not resolve evolutionary problems, through biological specialisation.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Oct 17 3.49pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Like you did in your last post to the Hog?

There are no sensible points. It is just idealistic, partisan mumbo jumbo.

Poverty in Britain is not significant. There will always be relative poverty. Communism does not work. The Labour Party wil do nothing except increase our debt.
Deal with it.

It is if your poor.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Oct 17 3.52pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

It is if your poor.

Ba dum tish.

The definitions of poverty have changed.

Who wouldn't like a society where everyone was rich?

Trouble is that someone would always be richer than another and some lefty would be complaining about it.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Oct 17 3.53pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

But that evolved into this. The problem for me is that most humans have become a slave to the system rather than living a more utopian lifestyle.
The other problem is numbers. Society has allowed too many humans to exist. That has improved quality of life in terms of health but it will also ultimately be the end of us.

Not really, homo sapiens show very little evidence of evolution having occurred over the time the species has been around.

In fact, quite the opposite, a lot of our 'primal evolutionary' mechanisms such as the endocrine system are maladaptive (the flight or fight response for example, works on a primal basis, but in modern man is a cause of many illnesses and problems).

The only likely real differences between a homo sapian from around 2m years ago, and now, is going to be social complexity and culturally inherited concepts. I would be surprised if they were biologically much different.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 23 Oct 17 3.57pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Ba dum tish.

The definitions of poverty have changed.

Who wouldn't like a society where everyone was rich?

Trouble is that someone would always be richer than another and some lefty would be complaining about it.


Your glib dismissal speaks volumes.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Oct 17 4.00pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Not really, homo sapiens show very little evidence of evolution having occurred over the time the species has been around.

In fact, quite the opposite, a lot of our 'primal evolutionary' mechanisms such as the endocrine system are maladaptive (the flight or fight response for example, works on a primal basis, but in modern man is a cause of many illnesses and problems).

The only likely real differences between a homo sapian from around 2m years ago, and now, is going to be social complexity and culturally inherited concepts. I would be surprised if they were biologically much different.

Well if you could see biological evolution over such a short time in the dominant species then that would be remarkable.
I was referring to th evolution of hunter gatherer to farmer to the current existance. That is an evolution of ideas born out of perceived advantage and circumstance.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 23 Oct 17 4.03pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Yawn.

More attention seeking.

Sorry for bringing up topics in the news that might engender debate.

You've posted a lot on it (but contributed little) considering...

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Is Capitalism Broken?