This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by .TUX.
I'm sure the majority have paid in for many many years but due to inflation (1300% since the 70's) they've not put anywhere near enough to cover their costs in later life though. This problem will never go away. Indeed.
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses. |
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
Evidence doesn't support either of your claims. All evidence shows immigrants pay more in than they take out and are less likely to claim benefits or healthcare than people from the UK. They also provide a significant proportion of the NHS staff (my wife is French and is a doctor at Great Ormond Street Hospital dealing with children with traumatic brain injuries and othe neurological conditions such as brain cancer as an example). Really? All evidence? This is simply untrue. I find that like your post on 'free speech' yesterday it's not the true picture. I would be interested in where you get this evidence for all immigrants. To get a net benefit you have to select only immigrants from a select number of countries, for example the EU or take from a set number of years and avoid the reality of older immigrants. When you stop cheery picking your evidence base the reality is that immigration to the UK costs the UK tax payer more than it brings in: Fact. Even when you account for the most positive spin. Immigrants get old too and it's a ponzi scheme which is impossible to sustain and anyone with more common sense than ideology can see that.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by europalace
"it would require rises of 3p in the pound on each of income tax, VAT and National Insurance by 2033." The simplest way of funding the increase necessary for the NHS to function is simply to scrap brexit.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Really? All evidence? This is simply untrue. I find that like your post on 'free speech' yesterday it's not the true picture. I would be interested in where you get this evidence for all immigrants. To get a net benefit you have to select only immigrants from a select number of countries, for example the EU or take from a set number of years and avoid the reality of older immigrants. When you stop cheery picking your evidence base the reality is that immigration to the UK costs the UK tax payer more than it brings in: Fact. Even when you account for the most positive spin. Immigrants get old too and it's a ponzi scheme which is impossible to sustain and anyone with more common sense than ideology can see that.
But looking at your links Stirling, I don't know if any of them really prove that immigration is a huge burden on the taxpayer (except the Mail, but you can't really expect much balance in an article by them in the lead up to the referendum). Migrant Watch simply disputes some of the assumptions of a previous study without providing any counter research, while the BBC article just makes the point that non EEA migrants over a long period take more in welfare and public service provision because they have lived here for longer and have therefore grown old. But they have also - the majority of them - worked in britain, paid taxes like the rest of us and, you would imagine, many will have come from former colonies where their families' labour had contributed to British wealth at a minimal expenditure for generations? Even as someone who was at best ambivalent about Brexit, you can clearly see the economic effects of a downturn in net migration. The endless supply of cheap service labour is drying up, which is surely a major factor in so many high street stores closing their doors. Walk down the road wherever you are and look how many signs are in the windows asking for people to work in Costa, KFC, Pret etc. That could be the trigger for the next recession very easily in the next couple of years, as productivity continues to fall off a cliff. Edited by serial thriller (24 May 2018 11.26am)
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
But looking at your links Stirling, I don't know if any of them really prove that immigration is a huge burden on the taxpayer (except the Mail, but you can't really expect much balance in an article by them in the lead up to the referendum). Migrant Watch simply disputes some of the assumptions of a previous study without providing any counter research, while the BBC article just makes the point that non EEA migrants over a long period take more in welfare and public service provision because they have lived here for longer and have therefore grown old. But they have also - the majority of them - worked in britain, paid taxes like the rest of us and, you would imagine, many will have come from former colonies where their families' labour had contributed to British wealth at a minimal expenditure for generations? Even as someone who was at best ambivalent about Brexit, you can clearly see the economic effects of a downturn in net migration. The endless supply of cheap service labour is drying up, which is surely a major factor in so many high street stores closing their doors. Walk down the road wherever you are and look how many signs are in the windows asking for people to work in Costa, KFC, Pret etc. That could be the trigger for the next recession very easily in the next couple of years, as productivity continues to fall off a cliff. Edited by serial thriller (24 May 2018 11.26am) First things first. I replied to a post that made a claim that wasn't accurate. So when you introduce an argument, as you do in your first paragraph, that it's about the amount of the burden.....well then we are onto different territory. I agree with you that different methodologies will obviously relay different scales. The left took early report claims from the Labour survey study using sliced and diced statistics and made claims that were false pictures of immigration as a whole. All Migration watch did was actually wait for the full study to be released and then relate the actual true picture from statistics from the same study! Not the slicked and diced ones that activists used. It's true that immigration costs us more than it brings in. Like I said, it's bleeding obvious to anyone with common sense. If you are going to allow citizenship to immigrants then they are going to bring in independents. They are going to grow old....Hence all you are doing is providing short term answers and actually just making the problem bigger and worse down the line. This is even when you completely ignore the social cohesion cost and discord that immigration costs. The terror attacks we have to endure. The ghettoization....all of which the left does completely. I state again, the way immigration is practiced in this country is a unsustainable ponzi scheme that creates a bigger and bigger problem. You require a larger and larger young foreign workforce to sustain the older citizen base. It doesn't work and it's a fraud committed on the British people. The sustainable model is the one Japan use. You can work as a foreigner but you can't have citizenship or bring your independents and eventually you have to go back.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| .TUX. |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
First things first. I replied to a post that made a claim that wasn't accurate. So when you introduce an argument, as you do in your first paragraph, that it's about the amount of the burden.....well then we are onto different territory. I agree with you that different methodologies will obviously relay different scales. The left took early report claims from the Labour survey study using sliced and diced statistics and made claims that were false pictures of immigration as a whole. All Migration watch did was actually wait for the full study to be released and then relate the actual true picture from statistics from the same study! Not the slicked and diced ones that activists used. It's true that immigration costs us more than it brings in. Like I said, it's bleeding obvious to anyone with common sense. If you are going to allow citizenship to immigrants then they are going to bring in independents. They are going to grow old....Hence all you are doing is providing short term answers and actually just making the problem bigger and worse down the line. This is even when you completely ignore the social cohesion cost and discord that immigration costs. The terror attacks we have to endure. The ghettoization....all of which the left does completely. I state again, the way our currency is practiced in this country is a unsustainable ponzi scheme that creates a bigger and bigger problem. You require a larger and larger young foreign workforce to sustain the older citizen base. It doesn't work and it's a fraud committed on the British people. The sustainable model is the one Japan use. You can work as a foreigner but you can't have citizenship or bring your independents and eventually you have to go back.
EFA
Buy Litecoin. |
|
|
Keep banging that drum Tux!
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| .TUX. |
|
|---|---|
|
I will bud as it's the biggest elephant in the room. Edited by .TUX. (24 May 2018 12.11pm)
Buy Litecoin. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
How can you have contributed when you have just arrived? Hospitals are full of foreign workers because they can often earn more here than in their own countries where as many British workers were never offered enough pay or encouraged into training. More short sighted government policy. And I suggest that anyone calling someone a bigot while hiding being their laptop is a cowardly t***. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (24 May 2018 10.33am) You can't judge a population based on a few examples. The evidence is clear and widely available that as a population immigrants are less of a burden on a per capita basis than those born in the UK. NHS is in trouble because of massive real terms funding cuts! It's clear you don't understand health economics. I'd suggest you shouldn't be immune from being called out for bigotry because you're being a bigot on an online forum.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
You can't judge a population based on a few examples. The evidence is clear and widely available that as a population immigrants are less of a burden on a per capita basis than those born in the UK. So what? They are still a net drain not a benefit. They shouldn't be allowed citizenship on anything like the numbers today, nor be able to bring in dependents. If an argument can be made for individuals then that should be done on a select basis. Coming automation in concert with a controlled young working foreigner base who can't stay, that is the best answer to a growing old population. A working foreigner base that are chosen from select criteria. This is the model Japan are using and it's working.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Really? All evidence? This is simply untrue. I find that like your post on 'free speech' yesterday it's not the true picture. I would be interested in where you get this evidence for all immigrants. To get a net benefit you have to select only immigrants from a select number of countries, for example the EU or take from a set number of years and avoid the reality of older immigrants. When you stop cheery picking your evidence base the reality is that immigration to the UK costs the UK tax payer more than it brings in: Fact. Even when you account for the most positive spin. Immigrants get old too and it's a ponzi scheme which is impossible to sustain and anyone with more common sense than ideology can see that.
This is more a question of when someone ceases to be an immigrant. Maybe we should have stopped anyone coming to the country post 1066. The articles you post point out that native Britons are a net drain over the same period. When you control for factors such as age it's clear that migrants contribute more on a net basis (or are less of a drain).
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
First things first. I replied to a post that made a claim that wasn't accurate. So when you introduce an argument, as you do in your first paragraph, that it's about the amount of the burden.....well then we are onto different territory. I agree with you that different methodologies will obviously relay different scales. The left took early report claims from the Labour survey study using sliced and diced statistics and made claims that were false pictures of immigration as a whole. All Migration watch did was actually wait for the full study to be released and then relate the actual true picture from statistics from the same study! Not the slicked and diced ones that activists used. It's true that immigration costs us more than it brings in. Like I said, it's bleeding obvious to anyone with common sense. If you are going to allow citizenship to immigrants then they are going to bring in independents. They are going to grow old....Hence all you are doing is providing short term answers and actually just making the problem bigger and worse down the line. This is even when you completely ignore the social cohesion cost and discord that immigration costs. The terror attacks we have to endure. The ghettoization....all of which the left does completely. I state again, the way immigration is practiced in this country is a unsustainable ponzi scheme that creates a bigger and bigger problem. You require a larger and larger young foreign workforce to sustain the older citizen base. It doesn't work and it's a fraud committed on the British people. The sustainable model is the one Japan use. You can work as a foreigner but you can't have citizenship or bring your independents and eventually you have to go back.
Where are the ghettos? Tower Hamlets or Stoke on Trent? Or is it Londonderry, where levels of poverty exceed the previous two even though most immigrants are Irish? There is a big difference between us and Japan which is that in most of the cases of migration in to our country, migrants are coming from areas where we have extended our political authority. In the case of Commonwealth migrants, that means that many of them are actually citizens, coming from countries like Jamaica where they were British subjects before we even took Ireland. In the more modern case of the EU, we were one of the earlier entrants who aggressively pushed for the inclusion of Eastern European and Baltic states. This allowed our banks to push tarriff free loans on them (and allowed us to fly for peanuts and get pissed in Krakow, Split etc). Then when their citizens took advantage of free movement the other way, we took their cheap trade but routinely demonized them using some of the oldest cultural stereotypes in the book. Unless Britain takes some responsibility for our actions abroad we will be condemned to repeat history over and over again. And as im sure you could more eloquently summarise than me, it is the poor on both sides that suffer.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
The baby boomers have benefited from innumerable things no longer available to younger generations, wealth (largely held by older people) has continued to grow apace, yet incomes (largely earned by the younger) stagnate. Evidence shows that the baby boomers spent more relative to older generations than the young do now, yet the young are still relatively poorer and cost of living, especially housing, significantly higher. Having paid in is not an argument as everyone will do so, it's just a matter of timing. You can't use that as an excuse to pillage from future generations. The elderly don't have some sort of divine right to resources without the responsibility of replacing them. Let's not overlook that fact that there is a huge number of pensioners who are STILL contributing through tax, so we're not all getting something for nothing! (...and the NHS is funded as much through taxation revenue as from NIC contributions, as has done for very many years, before anyone brings that point up)
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
You can't judge a population based on a few examples. The evidence is clear and widely available that as a population immigrants are less of a burden on a per capita basis than those born in the UK. NHS is in trouble because of massive real terms funding cuts! It's clear you don't understand health economics. I'd suggest you shouldn't be immune from being called out for bigotry because you're being a bigot on an online forum. Do immigrants stop having children when they come here then? Or are immigrants the ones with the highest birth rates in the UK?
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
We can’t do that. It’s racist or xenophobic, despite most of the world operating that way. The increases needed or treatment to be dropped are no surprise. We could start charging a few people for prescriptions, appointments, missing appointments. You make that sound like it's a bad thing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by becky
Let's not overlook that fact that there is a huge number of pensioners who are STILL contributing through tax, so we're not all getting something for nothing! (...and the NHS is funded as much through taxation revenue as from NIC contributions, as has done for very many years, before anyone brings that point up) No tax on much of their wealth though which is the big problem. That and gold plated pensions, which are being funded by tax and the work of the young. BT etc have to plug their pension deficits by cutting jobs, wages, benefits etc of current staff not the ones who creamed it off the top for years and are now retired. Also any wealth that is taxed is taxed at a significantly lower rate than income.
|
|
|
Originally posted by europalace
"it would require rises of 3p in the pound on each of income tax, VAT and National Insurance by 2033." Sadly that's an incredibly simplistic view..the system needs to be reformed at the same time...cutting much of the waste, resulting in a potential net increase in tax of 1p in the pound. That money should also be ringfenced for certain things, such as nurses and preventative care...not just for consultants; agency staff; over inflated drug prices and another layer of middle management.
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
Although there are 120 thousand non-British citizens working in the NHS... The people 'contributing next to nothing' are the elderly, whose number is also going up year on year and who are in most need of medical support and social care. How are we supposed to solve that crisis without turning to migration? -.-'
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
BT etc have to plug their pension deficits by cutting jobs, wages, benefits etc of current staff not the ones who creamed it off the top for years and are now retired. Wow. You are a very bitter man
|
|
|
Originally posted by aquickgame2
They ( the different governments ) took out as much as they wanted during my working life,I had no choice as to what they wanted,where they allocated it. Now its my time to take as much as I can out of it..selfish,you bet I am. I've argued for a few years on here about 'choosing' where a portion of our taxes go to. The usual, defence, NHS, Judical system and Education would be ringfenced in my ideal world...with the remaining 20% of someones tax burden going to up to 4 different areas. These areas could all 'tout' for my support accordingly.
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.