You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > South Africa
November 21 2026 10.14pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

South Africa


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Stirlingsays Flag 30 Aug 18 9.33pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

I think you have to be realistic and say that this is going to happen.


Oh I see.....interesting that. I don't remember the left being so accepting when apartheid was there.

Does this mean we can do it then? We have racial groups doing better than whites here. Can we take their businesses?


Originally posted by johnno42000

I was just trying to see a way which would enable the current farmer to get something out of the situation. I have no doubts that black Africans have the ability to work hard, have perseverance, common sense and dedication. What they may not have is the skill.


Out of every 100 people you will have a percentage able to do it....this is true of every group.

However, you need enough within that group to dominate over the corrupt and basal.

Tell me which Africa country has done this.

This failure cannot be excused away over long time spans.


Originally posted by johnno42000

I presume they see the land grab as a form of nationalisation which has been done in this country. I'm sure some of the old coal mine owners, for instance, would have seen the forced taking of the mines in a similar way to the farmers.

No, because this isn't being done to black owned farms, which accounts for around 20-25 percent......Funnily enough those farms are failing.

Strange that isn't it.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Aug 18 9.36pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

I agree with you about pumping more money into parts of Africa. There may be the odd occasion where emergency food aid is required but apart from that I agree with you that we shouldn't.

The left and right both have questions to answer about Africa as it was used as a type of virtual cold war area in the 60's, 70's and 80's with both the right supporting countries and the left supporting countries.

I agree with you that Africa has been exploited.....Mainly because the governments there are so corrupt and willing to screw over their own people for a piece of the pie.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Aug 18 9.47pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

Are you suggesting black Africans have not progressed for thousands of years (as of now) or should the 'have' in your post read 'had'?

Africa has been progressed by accessing the technology and development of other cultures.

God knows where Africa would be otherwise.

The gulf between the Africans and Europeans when we first went over there was night and day.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 30 Aug 18 10.17pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

Are you suggesting black Africans have not progressed for thousands of years (as of now) or should the 'have' in your post read 'had'?

Thank you for that grammatical correction, however, the point remains the same. Any progress sub Sarahan Africans have made toward the first world has been down to Europeans.
Of course, you could argue that Europeans were all descended from Africans, but that does not necessarily promote the achievements of those who were left behind.

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 31 Aug 18 12.31am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


Yet in Zimbabwe they just carried on regardless.

Destroyed their own country..... what was once the bread basket of Africa became a country that relied on food aid.

Africa is just one story of disaster after another.

Some people might begin to wander if it has something to do with IQ......weird how the graphs of IQ and wealth seem to correlate.

Some people might say that the idealogs have been lying to us and themselves for decades.....because they want the world to be one way when it's another.

Why is it that Africa just gets lumped into one big country, despite it being one on the most diverse continants on the planet. Would you compare peasants on donkeys in Hungary with city workers in London? That's how people talk when it comes to Africa. Your not the only one, it happens a lot in the media aswell.

Africa is the 2nd largest continant in the world, covering the 2nd largest land mass. There are many countries with different rates of developement and is currently right up there with the best places to invest in the world. Even growth rates in the poorest regions of sub-saharan Africa are an average of 3% + and if you look at countries like Ghana then it is even higher at around 8.5% up from 5% last year. Leading economists, the IMF and World bank all state that high grow rates will contiunue in many African countries for at least another decade. This even after the 2014 comodities crash.

Ethiopia for instance is currently the third-fastest growing country of 10 million or more people in the world, GDP is now 5 times what it was even in 2011, China being top. Ethiopia also has a young population that is highly educated and tech savvy. It is also one country that despite many attempts by Europeans at the time to invade, enslave and exploit, has never been colonised. Unfortunately for Italy, they were "given" Ethiopia as their patch of Africa, only to be kicked out by a well equipped and tactically skilled Ethiopian army and it has remained an African country in the true sense ever since. Other African countries did not fare as well.

In relation to the bread basket of Africa that was long ago, before European countries decided they wanted a piece of the pie (or loaf) and I believe that truly ended when the IMF and World Bank offered many "developing" nations cheap loans, with conditions on international trade for those countries. Only after the loans were taken out, they hiked up interest rates to deal with domestic inflation in the U.S. to levels that meant those countries where unable to pay back monies borrowed and then they were forced to take out more loans in order to pay off the interest or face Bankruptcy. Then came the debt crisis and those countries have been paying ever since. Add corrupt politicians, funded by western companies in order to continue the money making status quo and you have the recipe for exploitation and now the Chinese have caught on.

I'm not pretending that Africa as a continant is some kind of uptopia any more than Europe or any other continant and there are certainly some african countries that are in serious problems, due solely to the corrupt nature of their leaders. Equatorial Guinea comes to mind but in rural China, the fastest growing and second largest economy in the world, millions go hungry and corruption is rife in some places and yet I don't see "poverty p***." adverts stating that just £3 a month will buy pork and rice for a chinese child.

It would be silly, post brexit, for the U.K. not to invest in the most investable region on the planet and yet you chose to describe the entire continant as "just one story of disaster after another".

The world is investing in African countries right now due to their huge natural resourses and in many countries, young educated populations. I'm not saying that you or anyone else who has posted on this thread is pushing an agenda but I believe that there are some that prefer to push the narrative of starving African children with flies around there mouths, lead by utterly corrupt leaders, which is not the case when discussing Africa as a whole.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Stirlingsays Flag 31 Aug 18 1.42am

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

Why is it that Africa just gets lumped into one big country, despite it being one on the most diverse continants on the planet. Would you compare peasants on donkeys in Hungary with city workers in London? That's how people talk when it comes to Africa. Your not the only one, it happens a lot in the media aswell.

The reason I can quite confidently lump Africa together with a lot of criticism is because actually it isn't that diverse. Many of its countries share the same common problems, just to differing degrees.

We only have seven continents, of which only five have significant populations. (I'm going to discount Australia and Antarctica due to the relative small populations given land size)

Europe
North America
South America
Asia
Africa

In terms of those continents I seriously have to question your suggestion that Africa is more 'diverse' than any of those.....Certainly racially.

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

Africa is the 2nd largest continant in the world, covering the 2nd largest land mass. There are many countries with different rates of developement and is currently right up there with the best places to invest in the world. Even growth rates in the poorest regions of sub-saharan Africa are an average of 3% + and if you look at countries like Ghana then it is even higher at around 8.5% up from 5% last year. Leading economists, the IMF and World bank all state that high grow rates will contiunue in many African countries for at least another decade. This even after the 2014 comodities crash.

You appear to not understand that extremely poor countries can have high growth rates yet remain deeply poverty ridden.

Even small investments in these countries is going to result in significant growth when previous investment is so low.

Africa is by far the poorest population dense continent on this earth. That's what happens when the number of people with reasonable IQs is too low to maintain stable and rule based non tribal institutions.

Africa literally had to have them set up by frigging foreigners....and when they left they fell by the wayside.


Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

Ethiopia for instance is currently the third-fastest growing country of 10 million or more people in the world, GDP is now 5 times what it was even in 2011, China being top. Ethiopia also has a young population that is highly educated and tech savvy. It is also one country that despite many attempts by Europeans at the time to invade, enslave and exploit, has never been colonised. Unfortunately for Italy, they were "given" Ethiopia as their patch of Africa, only to be kicked out by a well equipped and tactically skilled Ethiopian army and it has remained an African country in the true sense ever since. Other African countries did not fare as well.

Ethiopia did indeed have parts of it colonized......what are these previous failed 'attempts' you are talking about?

Both the Italians and British colonized parts of what is now known as Ethiopia. The eastern region of Ethiopia, at that time, was colonized by the British for example.

Interestingly while Italy were there in 36-41 they abolished slavery in Ethiopia freeing over 400,000 slaves....Showing that even a fascist state could run Ethiopia in a more civilized fashion than they could themselves.

As for the Ethiopians kicking Italy out, In 1941, the British defeated the Italian forces and occupied Italian East Africa. Britain returned Haile Selassie to power and pressured him to mirror’s Italy’s abrogation of slavery if he wanted to maintain Britain’s support.

As for the growth rate, again, this is due to incredibly low economic bases and in reality most of the growth is coming because of external investment.

Africa is a continent that relies on food aid and foreign investment.


Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

In relation to the bread basket of Africa that was long ago, before European countries decided they wanted a piece of the pie (or loaf) and I believe that truly ended when the IMF and World Bank offered many "developing" nations cheap loans, with conditions on international trade for those countries. Only after the loans were taken out, they hiked up interest rates to deal with domestic inflation in the U.S. to levels that meant those countries where unable to pay back monies borrowed and then they were forced to take out more loans in order to pay off the interest or face Bankruptcy. Then came the debt crisis and those countries have been paying ever since. Add corrupt politicians, funded by western companies in order to continue the money making status quo and you have the recipe for exploitation and now the Chinese have caught on.


The fact that Africa contains incredibly poorly run countries isn't the fault of the IMF nor any other 'bank'.

The fact that countries full of corrupt elite fools get exploited by arsehole banks is a bit like complaining about the fact that sharks attack the defenceless. I will agree that this is unethical yet this is nature and Africa itself contains few examples of ethical history itself.

'The Strong Do What They Can, And The Weak Suffer What They Must.' (Thucydides)


Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

I'm not pretending that Africa as a continant is some kind of uptopia any more than Europe or any other continant and there are certainly some african countries that are in serious problems, due solely to the corrupt nature of their leaders. Equatorial Guinea comes to mind but in rural China, the fastest growing and second largest economy in the world, millions go hungry and corruption is rife in some places and yet I don't see "poverty p***." adverts stating that just £3 a month will buy pork and rice for a chinese child.

It would be silly, post brexit, for the U.K. not to invest in the most investable region on the planet and yet you chose to describe the entire continant as "just one story of disaster after another".

The world is investing in African countries right now due to their huge natural resourses and in many countries, young educated populations. I'm not saying that you or anyone else who has posted on this thread is pushing an agenda but I believe that there are some that prefer to push the narrative of starving African children with flies around there mouths, lead by utterly corrupt leaders, which is not the case when discussing Africa as a whole.

Africa does have potential because its so open to exploitation and has so many elites who care little for their underclass and far more about feathering their nests......I've already made the point about incredibly low economic bases and growth rates and also about the fact that is growth isn't Africa's work but via external investment....which isn't being done for charity I might add and as you no doubt appreicate.

Africa is a disaster, not only to itself but for wider humanity as we only have to turn to it to observe how poorly the relatively dim 'kid' get treated in the classroom of the real world.

Personally I would be very very careful with any investment in Africa. These are not countries with stable institutions......Your suggestion that Africa can point to an educated workforce is laughable in comparison to any other major continent.


Edited by Stirlingsays (31 Aug 2018 2.20am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Mr Palaceman Flag 31 Aug 18 1.51am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Africa has been progressed by accessing the technology and development of other cultures.

God knows where Africa would be otherwise.

The gulf between the Africans and Europeans when we first went over there was night and day.

I would say that Europe and this country in particular has progressed by accessing the resoures, wealth, manpower, trading systems and culture of some African nations. That continues to this day.

African history did not start or end with the slave trade.

There was a gulf in the 19th century, in military terms, on the west coast and South Africa.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Stirlingsays Flag 31 Aug 18 1.53am

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

I would say that Europe and this country in particular has progressed by accessing the resoures, wealth, manpower, trading systems and culture of some African nations. That continues to this day.

African history did not start or end with the slave trade.

There was a gulf in the 19th century, in military terms, on the west coast and South Africa.

Delusion.

This country and the European continent progressed far faster than Africa from as far back as Rome.

We sky rocketed away during and after the enlightenment and its subsequent scientific investments and culture.....just as we continue to now....What is Africa producing in intellectual capital for the world?

Look at South East Asia.....societies with higher average IQs that follow rules whilst allowing for innovation succeed....with or without past western colonialism.

The exploitation of Africa happened but it was a footnote in the development of this country and Europe.

Edited by Stirlingsays (31 Aug 2018 3.51am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Spiderman Flag Horsham 31 Aug 18 7.43am

Originally posted by steeleye20

That surprises me as she has been putting immigrants in cages for years in the UK.

FFS I worked for Immigration for many years and never saw anything that resembled a cage. Do you mean detention? Should no immigrant be detained? What about the drug runners,paedos,rapists? And yes, illegal immigrants have broken the law as well, but believe me there are thousands more not detained than are detained.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 31 Aug 18 7.52am

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

I would say that Europe and this country in particular has progressed by accessing the resoures, wealth, manpower, trading systems and culture of some African nations. That continues to this day.

African history did not start or end with the slave trade.

There was a gulf in the 19th century, in military terms, on the west coast and South Africa.

This country? So it's all Britain's fault?

How surprising that you would have that opinion.

Total nonsense of course.

Africa has been exploited by just about everyone because it has not progressed in part or as a whole for thousands of years. Exploitation is a direct result of the lack of development, not the other way around.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 31 Aug 18 9.49am

Guys, you are all forgetting about the stand out country in Africa, Wakanda. We could learn so much from that technology advanced nation.

Africa's problems are complex one solution (not THE solution)is to allow Africa better trade access to the EU instead of shutting out many of it's products. I hope that PM May does this once we Brexit.

Edited by Badger11 (31 Aug 2018 9.50am)

 


One more point

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 31 Aug 18 10.00am

Originally posted by Badger11

Guys, you are all forgetting about the stand out country in Africa, Wakanda. We could learn so much from that technology advanced nation.

Africa's problems are complex one solution (not THE solution)is to allow Africa better trade access to the EU instead of shutting out many of it's products. I hope that PM May does this once we Brexit.

Edited by Badger11 (31 Aug 2018 9.50am)

I think it needs to be understood that if all the world's third world countries became developed it would use up Earth's resources in a blink.

It is a dream that can never happen.

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 31 Aug 18 11.27am

Originally posted by Badger11

Guys, you are all forgetting about the stand out country in Africa, Wakanda.

Edited by Badger11 (31 Aug 2018 9.50am)

Hollywood didn't realise Wakanda has a great big wall keeping out illegal immigrants Trump would be proud of.

Edited by Penge Eagle (31 Aug 2018 11.27am)

 

johnno42000 Flag 31 Aug 18 12.49pm

Isn't one of the boosts to a peoples progressing cross pollination of ideas? Rome has been mentioned but they had a lot of ideas from Greece and other countries around the Med.

Likewise a lot of information that was lost during the Dark Ages was saved within the Arab world and then re-introduced when the Moors invaded Spain.

Likewise, in the Far East, China was a leader in ideas and passed them on through contact with other civilisations.

We have been fortunate to have received new ideas, skills etc from being invaded and have taken these and added to them.

To say Southern Africa had not progressed as rapidly as other areas is probably true (the same with the North American Indians and Aboriginal tribes in Australia) but I think that is mainly due to the fact there was little (if any) contact with the world outside of that area, although they did create some amazing structures such as Great Zimbabwe, Naletale etc.

There are also some beautiful artefacts which have been found that are easily on a par with that found in the UK up to the early Middle Ages. Gold working, statues, carvings etc. Perhaps they just found their level and could live contentedly at that point?

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 31 Aug 18 1.24pm

More people than ever are coming out of poverty in Africa and it's because of the free market and capitalism. Life expectancy has risen dramatically also. Many of the African governments operated under a centralised, socialist system and have finally broken away from it, with a lot of red tape slashed for new businesses also.

However, it is also true to say that only a handful of African countries are not corrupt (Benin, Botswana, Ghana, Namibia, Senegal). The Marxist and racist policies of South Africa is not only going to cause a lot of deaths but economic catastrophe also, while the the rest of the world just watches. If Theresa the Appeaser had any balls, she would tell the South African leader to clean up this racist mess against the whites and we will then trade with you.

Edited by Penge Eagle (31 Aug 2018 1.28pm)

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 31 Aug 18 1.50pm

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

More people than ever are coming out of poverty in Africa and it's because of the free market and capitalism. Life expectancy has risen dramatically also. Many of the African governments operated under a centralised, socialist system and have finally broken away from it, with a lot of red tape slashed for new businesses also.

However, it is also true to say that only a handful of African countries are not corrupt (Benin, Botswana, Ghana, Namibia, Senegal). The Marxist and racist policies of South Africa is not only going to cause a lot of deaths but economic catastrophe also, while the the rest of the world just watches. If Theresa the Appeaser had any balls, she would tell the South African leader to clean up this racist mess against the whites and we will then trade with you.

Edited by Penge Eagle (31 Aug 2018 1.28pm)

Mrs May does not find South Africa marxist or racist (unlike her 'hostile environment' she is re-discovering Africa after the UK left it behind.

Nothing doing there, and the Kenyan PM expresses what Africa thinks, that she is only visiting because she is desperate.

The old colonial masters return with the begging bowl.

Under the EU foul regime I have continued to enjoy South African wines as they are good quality and value thanks to the single market.

To suggest South Africa is 'marxist' is utter nonsense.

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 31 Aug 18 3.28pm

Originally posted by steeleye20


To suggest South Africa is 'marxist' is utter nonsense.

Yet another socialist/communist country going to the wall through death and poverty. Hard for you to accept with your left wing principles I know.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 31 Aug 18 4.16pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

Isn't one of the boosts to a peoples progressing cross pollination of ideas? Rome has been mentioned but they had a lot of ideas from Greece and other countries around the Med.

Likewise a lot of information that was lost during the Dark Ages was saved within the Arab world and then re-introduced when the Moors invaded Spain.

Likewise, in the Far East, China was a leader in ideas and passed them on through contact with other civilisations.

We have been fortunate to have received new ideas, skills etc from being invaded and have taken these and added to them.

To say Southern Africa had not progressed as rapidly as other areas is probably true (the same with the North American Indians and Aboriginal tribes in Australia) but I think that is mainly due to the fact there was little (if any) contact with the world outside of that area, although they did create some amazing structures such as Great Zimbabwe, Naletale etc.

There are also some beautiful artefacts which have been found that are easily on a par with that found in the UK up to the early Middle Ages. Gold working, statues, carvings etc. Perhaps they just found their level and could live contentedly at that point?

That is a very round the houses way of admitting what has already been stated. Europe has achieved a technological level that no other civilization has managed in forty thousand years. It appears that Africa has been at the bottom of the league since man first left it.
Maybe the species that arrived in Europe and Asia before Homo Sapiens had a few genes that gave an advantage to mixed species offspring in terms of invention and organisation.
Of course, no scientist will ever admit that.
It took them this long to figure out that Neanderthals and Saps copulated at all.

 

johnno42000 Flag 31 Aug 18 4.53pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

That is a very round the houses way of admitting what has already been stated. Europe has achieved a technological level that no other civilization has managed in forty thousand years. It appears that Africa has been at the bottom of the league since man first left it.
Maybe the species that arrived in Europe and Asia before Homo Sapiens had a few genes that gave an advantage to mixed species offspring in terms of invention and organisation.
Of course, no scientist will ever admit that.
It took them this long to figure out that Neanderthals and Saps copulated at all.

Asia has reached this point as well and, what they and Europe both have in common, is interaction with other cultures and populations. Would the UK have progressed as much if the Romans and others had not invaded? I'd guess they wouldn't have if they had remained completely isolated. I think eventually they would have contacted the other places in Europe as it is relatively close to the UK and gained extra skills that way.

Interestingly some of the early populations in South Africa had the skills to domesticate cattle and farm producing wheat and other crops. They also worked metal, including iron and lived in settlements so they had advanced. The southern African made this progression even though they were far further from other cultures than the people were in Europe.

I should add that I think the land grab is wrong and highly stupid. The government should encourage the white farmers to take on apprentices to learn the trade and then grant them land when qualified. The way they are doing it at present will help no one and I fear it will cause a famine.

Edited by johnno42000 (31 Aug 2018 4.57pm)

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 31 Aug 18 5.12pm

There's so many people on here pussy-footing around.

Why not just come out and say that Black Africans are thicker than the rest of the planet's population ? It may well be the case. Who knows ?

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > South Africa