You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Grenfell - who's to blame
November 21 2026 9.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Grenfell - who's to blame


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
jeeagles Flag 02 Nov 19 12.38pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

I went to Health and Safety training with a trade union about a year ago, and one official had an encyclopaedic knowledge of all the regulations - apparently in the H&S Act of 1974 the laws, codes of practice and guidance are under three separate categories (as in all Acts of Parliament) but the 'guidance' is not legally binding - all the construction interests involved over time have lobbied MPs to put the codes of practice requirements into the guidance section so that they are no longer legally binding. This is why setting up the official enquiry so the Fire Service are investigated a year before the MPs are in part two of the enquiry is a stich up and a smoke screen - it's the people who altered the law to make that cladding legal who are responsible, all any self-respecting journalist need do is go back through Hansard to find all those secondary legislation committees who changed the law, who arranged and populated these committees and who may have been lobbying them and you'll find the real culprits - that's the context, bit too big maybe, the fire service were poor, but the way it's being presented to the public is a smoke screen.

You've got quite a lot wrong with this post.

The Health & Safety at work at is enabling legislation, and all the regulations that come out of it are legally binding. Guidance is sometimes not legal binding using words like "should" rather than must. It's also criminal legislation and someone is going to go down for the issue surrounding the cladding. If it is just guidance, you still need to show really strong reasons as to why you ignored it. It might be the manufacturer, contractor, designers or client, or a combination of them but they will go down for it.

There were multiple failures which caused the disaster. It is right to check if the fire brigade responded well and see what they can do next time, but they should not get any blame. They were running into an inferno, no training or experience could have prepared then for it because it simply hadn't happened before.

In all these inquiries, 7/7 or Hillsborough etc the inquiry and press seem to forget that the emergency services are simply normal people dealing with extraordinary event. There's always going to be mistakes.

Good to see such public support for the Fire brigade on all social media though. The public know that they gave it everything the could and a hero's.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 Nov 19 4.03pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

You've got quite a lot wrong with this post.

The Health & Safety at work at is enabling legislation, and all the regulations that come out of it are legally binding. Guidance is sometimes not legal binding using words like "should" rather than must. It's also criminal legislation and someone is going to go down for the issue surrounding the cladding. If it is just guidance, you still need to show really strong reasons as to why you ignored it. It might be the manufacturer, contractor, designers or client, or a combination of them but they will go down for it.

There were multiple failures which caused the disaster. It is right to check if the fire brigade responded well and see what they can do next time, but they should not get any blame. They were running into an inferno, no training or experience could have prepared then for it because it simply hadn't happened before.

In all these inquiries, 7/7 or Hillsborough etc the inquiry and press seem to forget that the emergency services are simply normal people dealing with extraordinary event. There's always going to be mistakes.

Good to see such public support for the Fire brigade on all social media though. The public know that they gave it everything the could and a hero's.

The cladding may have been to the standards in place at the time.
You cannot retrospectively change that because this happened.
Cladding now has to be a different standard because of grenfell.
Unfortunatly there are many changes made after the event.
It's about learning from mistakes.
Heysel,paddington,grenfell,Hillsborough etc.
Sending someone down so you feel better wont change this being the way.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 02 Nov 19 6.21pm

if interested parties have been 'lobbying' MPs so that unsafe materials can be used without it being automatically illegal but subject to interpretation by lawyers then those interested parties are responsible - to what degree their responsibility is criminal depends on how much they knew they were increasing risk and the nature of the lobbying, e.g.were some of the MPs involved on the payroll of some of these organisations?

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 02 Nov 19 9.20pm

Originally posted by YT

Do you have any examples to back up these words?

The fact that it even happened in the first place. Okay, saying that 'nothing' is learned may be overly negative, but 'we will learn lessons from x' is a daily occurrence on our screens. There is always in life far more brushing under the carpet and diverting blame than there ever is learning.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 Nov 19 10.22pm

Originally posted by dollardays

The fact that it even happened in the first place. Okay, saying that 'nothing' is learned may be overly negative, but 'we will learn lessons from x' is a daily occurrence on our screens. There is always in life far more brushing under the carpet and diverting blame than there ever is learning.

More so in our very own individual lives outside of the establishment.
How many times have you said
"I'm never drinking again"
Mistakes were made with fatal consequences but revenge isnt the answer.
More people are killed on the roads every week than in grenfell.
Trevor Philip's made a point on the purge program I saw earlier on sky.
He questioned if the fact that so many people didnt speak in one language possibly contributed to some of the chaos experienced in the tower.
Food for thought.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 03 Nov 19 12.17am

Originally posted by cryrst

More so in our very own individual lives outside of the establishment.
How many times have you said
"I'm never drinking again"
Mistakes were made with fatal consequences but revenge isnt the answer.
More people are killed on the roads every week than in grenfell.
Trevor Philip's made a point on the purge program I saw earlier on sky.
He questioned if the fact that so many people didnt speak in one language possibly contributed to some of the chaos experienced in the tower.
Food for thought.

I feel like it's also important to have answers to questions. 'If I'm in this situation what would I do?' There was shades of 9/11 to this in that people were told to 'stay put' and due to the one off nature of the event and with little else to go on, many did just that. If I ever find myself in a situation like this I'll be bolting for the exit.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 03 Nov 19 7.07am

Originally posted by dollardays

I feel like it's also important to have answers to questions. 'If I'm in this situation what would I do?' There was shades of 9/11 to this in that people were told to 'stay put' and due to the one off nature of the event and with little else to go on, many did just that. If I ever find myself in a situation like this I'll be bolting for the exit.

But you would understand an instruction if it was to stay put or leave though.
Many of these people didnt understand the language.
That could have been a contributing factor in how they reacted.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 03 Nov 19 7.57am

Originally posted by dollardays

There's plenty of blame to go around but the pattern is that it's always innocent people that pay the price.. and that nobody is ever held to account, and nothing ever learned.

And borne by the fact that there other buildings with the same or similar cladding caught in inertia.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 03 Nov 19 11.50am

Originally posted by cryrst

More so in our very own individual lives outside of the establishment.
How many times have you said
"I'm never drinking again"
Mistakes were made with fatal consequences but revenge isnt the answer.
More people are killed on the roads every week than in grenfell.
Trevor Philip's made a point on the purge program I saw earlier on sky.
He questioned if the fact that so many people didnt speak in one language possibly contributed to some of the chaos experienced in the tower.
Food for thought.

Trevor Phillips has done well to rein in some of the political correctness gone mad stuff which even unabashed liberals like myself are finding hard to take, esp the extreme trans stuff and people wanting to ban dressing up as Pocahontus at fancy dress parties in case native americans take offence, but seeing this I wonder if he is taking the Melanie Phillips route of lefty turning into daily mail columnist, the language issue is hardly an issue where this is concerned, its about what happens if there are not enough checks and balances to stop crooked business and crooked politicians doing grubby deals with indifference to their consequences

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 03 Nov 19 12.56pm

This is nothing new but I have noticed recently that when we have this big enquiries all sorts of people come crawling out of the woodwork looking for a payday err I mean claiming to represent the community.

That certainly seems to be the case with Grenfall all sorts of people were turning up saying that they had to be heard and whipping up the locals.

I wonder how many millions have been spent on Lawyers fees. It seems these days you can't have an public enquiry without everybody being represented by a lawyer all at the taxpayers expense of course.

Nice work if you can get it.


 


One more point

Invalid user 2019 Flag 03 Nov 19 7.10pm

Originally posted by chris123

And borne by the fact that there other buildings with the same or similar cladding caught in inertia.

Exactly. It's always someone elses problem, and if we get a Grenfell repeat they will no doubt be plenty more of reports and fingerpointing.. and little action.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 04 Nov 19 10.03am

Originally posted by dollardays

Exactly. It's always someone elses problem, and if we get a Grenfell repeat they will no doubt be plenty more of reports and fingerpointing.. and little action.

However, Moore-Bick’s report reveals that senior brigade officers were shown a slide presentation about the risks to “Tall Building Facades” in October 2016, eight months before the Grenfell tragedy. The document outlined a series of fires in Britain and overseas where flames had spread due to combustible cladding.

Cotton was in charge of safety at the time of the presentation, but admitted to the inquiry that she had not seen it.

The year before they'd been a presentation on the risks posed by Tall Building Facades to senior brigade officers. From the paper yesterday - Moore-Bick states in his report: “Even the commissioner herself, who had been in charge of safety and assurance at the LFB at the time of the Tall Building Facades slide presentation in 2016, admitted she was unfamiliar with it at the time of the Grenfell Tower fire. She could not explain why its circulation had been limited to a small group of fire engineers.”

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 05 Nov 19 11.53am

Originally posted by cryrst

But you would understand an instruction if it was to stay put or leave though.
Many of these people didnt understand the language.
That could have been a contributing factor in how they reacted.

I think if you can't understand instructions and there is a huge fire, your inclination generally would be to leave. So not speaking English might not have been a drawback in that situation. Understanding the instructions to stay and putting too much stock in that unfortunately likely resulted in deaths.


 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 05 Nov 19 1.13pm

Originally posted by dollardays

I think if you can't understand instructions and there is a huge fire, your inclination generally would be to leave. So not speaking English might not have been a drawback in that situation. Understanding the instructions to stay and putting too much stock in that unfortunately likely resulted in deaths.


Instructions face to face yes but shouting to someone through smoke,,doors and around corners.
That's likely a probable breakdown point.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Nov 19 2.14pm

I want to know if it turns out that someone had about 15 plugs from one socket and the fire was caused by a short - will it still be everyone else's fault? Particularly if it was then delayed in being reported?
Lack of any type of personal responsibility rife these days. No doubt though, even if something like that caused the fire - we won't be told.
Obviously the cladding spread the fire but it had to start somewhere. Just a thought.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Fatherken Flag 05 Nov 19 2.23pm

The blame for Grenfell is modern day living .
We all want thing things cheaper , we buy things on line and moan about high street shops closing , we buy supermarket bake beans they are the same as Heinz but are cheaper and thinner but are still bake beans . This also happens in construction , surveyors will go for the cheaper material , it complies to the said standard [ as do bake beans ] but not as good . With food and clothes this make no different but in construction we have all unfortunately seen the consequent's .

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 05 Nov 19 2.25pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I want to know if it turns out that someone had about 15 plugs from one socket and the fire was caused by a short - will it still be everyone else's fault? Particularly if it was then delayed in being reported?
Lack of any type of personal responsibility rife these days. No doubt though, even if something like that caused the fire - we won't be told.
Obviously the cladding spread the fire but it had to start somewhere. Just a thought.

Careful there mate.
You will get called all sorts for being sensible.
I feel your frustration though tbh.
And yes personal blame is not allowed due to the fact that.....
No I wont sorry.

 

W12 05 Nov 19 2.55pm

We used to call these things tragic accidents because that's what they were.

Now it's just an exercise in apportioning blame depending on whose side you are on.

That cultural shift is what happens when you consistently tell people that they part of a victim hierarchy perpetuated by evil white men.

 

DanH Flag SW2 05 Nov 19 2.59pm

Originally posted by W12

We used to call these things tragic accidents because that's what they were.

Now it's just an exercise in apportioning blame depending on whose side you are on.

That cultural shift is what happens when you consistently tell people that they part of a victim hierarchy perpetuated by evil white men.

So you shouldn't try to get to the bottom of why things happen?

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 05 Nov 19 3.01pm

Originally posted by W12

We used to call these things tragic accidents because that's what they were.

Now it's just an exercise in apportioning blame depending on whose side you are on.

That cultural shift is what happens when you consistently tell people that they part of a victim hierarchy perpetuated by evil white men.

No such thing as accidents anymore.
They are now incidents, as accident implies nobody is to blame, when in reality someone is always responsible. Yup, bollox i know.

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Grenfell - who's to blame