You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mateta
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mateta


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
eag-les Flag Coulsdon 09 Feb 21 9.31am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Yes, Sorloth, Benteke, Batshuyai and now Mateta. They can’t all be totally crap playing at this level and why we need a fresh approach. We keep trying to change our centre forward to score goals, whereas in reality we should be changing our ageing midfield and our way of getting the ball to the striker in the first place.

Hallelujah...spot on! (plus of course we should be changing the dinosaur managing them)

Wise up Mr Parish

 


If I agreed with you we'd both be wrong

Steve T Flag Cumbria 09 Feb 21 9.49am

Yes absolutely spot on. You cannot blame the lad who got no service all night. It is the midfield that needs to be sorted. I look at Croydon lad Emile Smith Rowe and wonder why he gets snapped up by Arsenal and not Palace. Mind you even if we had, he'd probably be classed as too young and shipped out on loan somewhere. And why not give some youngsters a chance to at least sit on the bench like other clubs do. Instead they are told they are not good enough by the manager!!
After the game the team were described on NBC sport in USA as a "drab and boring team". I think that sums us up perfectly at present.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 Feb 21 10.07am

I lost count of the number of times last night i was saying just cross the bloody ball.

We need an out and out winger who doesn't like to cut in and shoot but prefers to whip the ball in.

We can't expect Mateta to score unless he gets some decent service.

As for Ayew he does some good stuff but I have tw complaints:

1. His decision making last night was poor shooting and dribbling in stead of crossing the ball.

2. He doesn't know how to play in tandem with his strike partner, he plays too far away from him and not off him.

Edited by Badger11 (09 Feb 2021 10.11am)

 


One more point

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Feb 21 10.11am

Originally posted by Steve T

Yes absolutely spot on. You cannot blame the lad who got no service all night. It is the midfield that needs to be sorted. I look at Croydon lad Emile Smith Rowe and wonder why he gets snapped up by Arsenal and not Palace. Mind you even if we had, he'd probably be classed as too young and shipped out on loan somewhere. And why not give some youngsters a chance to at least sit on the bench like other clubs do. Instead they are told they are not good enough by the manager!!
After the game the team were described on NBC sport in USA as a "drab and boring team". I think that sums us up perfectly at present.

I believe they were being generous.

For far too long we have been a dreadful watch and when one considers our home performances and results,the team have totally failed supporters who made the journey to Selhurst Park hoping and praying for at least a shot on target.

 

Steve T Flag Cumbria 09 Feb 21 10.21am

Just as well there are no supporters at Selhurst as by now they may have been a lynching or two. Palace were absolutely dire last night. No game plan and the passing was even worse than usual. Yes the pitch was a disgrace but Leeds seemed to make it work.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 09 Feb 21 10.28am

Leeds cut through our lines like a sharp knife in hot butter. And why on earth keep passing the ball backwards especially under such dire conditions?
Let us face it, when Palace is bad, we are by far the worst side in PL.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 09 Feb 21 11.13am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Mateta looks slow, gangly, low work rate, and unable to do anything other than wait for a brilliant cross. How is that any different than Benteke or Sorloth?

Really, Mateta looks like the the stupidest signing we've had in recent years, which is really saying something.

Given it was his first game with zero service this is a bit OTT. If he has as many games as Big Ben has over the last few seasons it would be pretty hard for him not to beat his stats

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Feb 21 11.20am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Given it was his first game with zero service this is a bit OTT. If he has as many games as Big Ben has over the last few seasons it would be pretty hard for him not to beat his stats

I am not forming a judgement after the lad on his debut game, and in his first introduction to the PL played for 65 mins in a team where most of the players never emerged with any credit whatsoever.Mbappe and Messi would have struggled last night.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 09 Feb 21 11.23am

Bloody hell, give him a chance. Poor b****** has only played one game, it's a bit early to be writing him off. Seem to remember Speroni had some shocking appearances for us when he first joined, he proved to be ok though didn't he?

As others have said, we could have Lewandowski, Kane, Messi or Ronaldo up front for us and then still wouldn't score goals as they wouldn't see the ball.

Jesus turned water into wine but even he wouldn't have been able to convert our service into goals. Partially because he was scared of crosses.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

davehuggins Flag 09 Feb 21 11.28am

Had a few decent touches and can see potential but how on earth we can judge any player in that performance last night is beyond me. Hoping for good things to come, but IMO we missed the boat as usual on Ollie Watkins.

 

SnapperKain Flag SE25 6PU 09 Feb 21 11.28am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

Bloody hell, give him a chance. Poor b****** has only played one game, it's a bit early to be writing him off. Seem to remember Speroni had some shocking appearances for us when he first joined, he proved to be ok though didn't he?

As others have said, we could have Lewandowski, Kane, Messi or Ronaldo up front for us and then still wouldn't score goals as they wouldn't see the ball.

Jesus turned water into wine but even he wouldn't have been able to convert our service into goals. Partially because he was scared of crosses.

Was just thinking the exact same thing. I know we were sh!te last night, but blaming the new bloke seems a bit off. The whole team wasn't at it's best, we looked low in confidence pushing forward, too many passes back and our midfield was flat and without ideas.

I don't think you can say whether Mateta is any good or not based on last night, just not enough game time to make that determination.

 


The trouble with computers, of course, is that they're very sophisticated idiots

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 09 Feb 21 11.33am

Originally posted by SnapperKain

Was just thinking the exact same thing. I know we were sh!te last night, but blaming the new bloke seems a bit off. The whole team wasn't at it's best, we looked low in confidence pushing forward, too many passes back and our midfield was flat and without ideas.

I don't think you can say whether Mateta is any good or not based on last night, just not enough game time to make that determination.


He made some absolute howlers that season and I remember hoping he'd never play for us again! He's my favourite ever Palace player now.

Absolutely right, you can't blame a new player for something that has been building up for 2/3 seasons.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 09 Feb 21 11.43am

What a bunch of absolute arse.

He played with his back to goal receiving 30, 40 yard "passes" that any striker would have struggled with. On the occasions when he had something to compete for he did nice flicks and layoffs.

Bats ALMOST NEVER does this.

He had one ball to feet in the box (at an awkward angle) and slipped because that pitch was so unsteady it should have been illegal.

What the actual f*** could he have done?

I wonder how many of those slagging him off after 60 minutes in a new, higher intensity league also wrote off Bamford and loved calling him Bumfluff.

We lost to Leeds. They were better than us. Case closed.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Skip Flag 09 Feb 21 11.57am

I thought he did okay. Looked a bit raw but at least tried to close the ball down. He probably did more running in 65 minutes than Beneteke has done all season, which is why he faded.

A very difficult debut. I can't quite understand the thinking in having him as an unused sub for 2 games and then throwing in him in the deep end by including him in a team whose entire back 4 shouldn't be anywhere near starting for a Premier League team. Our captain looks shot to bits and needs replacing ASAP and our best player is injured.

The only players that did okay last night were Jairo, Eze and maybe Townsend.

I know PVA has been indifferent this season but he played in our last 2 games that we won so I am not sure why he was shoved into midfield and then hooked at half time when it didn't work out.

Really poor from Roy last night who was given a lesson in how to play exciting football from a newly promoted team whilst standing in his technical area muttering away to himself.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 09 Feb 21 12.02pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

What a bunch of absolute arse.

He played with his back to goal receiving 30, 40 yard "passes" that any striker would have struggled with. On the occasions when he had something to compete for he did nice flicks and layoffs.

Bats ALMOST NEVER does this.

He had one ball to feet in the box (at an awkward angle) and slipped because that pitch was so unsteady it should have been illegal.

What the actual f*** could he have done?

I wonder how many of those slagging him off after 60 minutes in a new, higher intensity league also wrote off Bamford and loved calling him Bumfluff.

We lost to Leeds. They were better than us. Case closed.

100% this

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 09 Feb 21 12.15pm

Considering the absolute crap performance of most of those behind him last night, there is no way anyone can be totally judgmental about Matetas performance.
Palace were as so often is the case virtually non existent in the opposition box, but Matetas , work on the night showed a lot of promise, on and off the ball. He was strong in the tackle ,held the ball well most times, and closed down well compared with many around him. Linking well in the play that was all to often only happening in deep positions. His height allowed him to win one or two balls in the air that isn’t always the case with the forwards we already have. It must be clear by now that any so called striker is going to struggle to actually strike in this team with this set up. That performance last night can only be used to judge the whole team , certainly not a debutant having to try and improve what looks more and more now as a team not good enough to cope with the more mobile outfits in this league.

 

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 09 Feb 21 12.21pm

Our injury list didn't help, I would like to see how he gets on playing with MacArthur wilf and schlupp in the side. We didn't deserve anything from the game, but having said that we contributed massively to their two goals

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 09 Feb 21 2.18pm

He didn't get off to the best start in the game but I thought he did ok as it went on considering we barely offered him any support. He showed a few glimpses of nice touches and link up play which is promising.

Tbh I'll hold judgement on him this season though as the world's best would struggle up top with our current lineup.

I just hope his confidence isn't shot to pieces by the time we can strengthen in the summer. We have been a bit of a strikers graveyard in recent years.

Edited by samprior (09 Feb 2021 2.19pm)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 09 Feb 21 2.29pm

There was one occasion when he made a run wide left when he took off and showed he is actually quick. To be honest though, he had zero service and there was generally 30-40 yards between him and our midfield when Leeds had the ball as we had to play so deep due to the complete lack of pace in the middle. As such he was made to look a bit aimless just running between their defenders as they played keep ball.

To write him off when he didn't have one chance on goal is mad. He might be no good, but I thought he actually looked like a younger Bentenke (which would be no bad thing if we got the Villa era Bentenke).


 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 09 Feb 21 2.30pm

Mateta's first game for us and first game in the PL. I'm amazed how people are so astute as to be able to judge his abilities and qualities already.

He played in a team that put in a pretty poor performance overall. I'd want to see how he performs over the rest of the season before stating a view. I expect it will take him a bit of time to adjust to the speed and style of the PL. Give the lad a chance.

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mateta