This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I think we can all agree to the extent that shouting abuse at people doing their job isn't a good thing. But of course, calling the referee a w***er or abusing players with insulting language that is not racist seems to be OK, especially if they are White and British. Well according to the media anyway.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Straw man stuff again. One more time. Do you think it is reasonable for policemen with sticks to attempt an arrest for using insulting words when the consequences of that clearly made matters far worse? Not all that strawman since you've now completely backtracked from saying that the crowd were attacked with sticks in an unprovoked fashion. In answer to what fragment of a point remains, racial abuse, as stated is not included in the price of a ticket and is against the law and terms of attendance. Therefore certainly it is absolutely fine for the police to remove someone from the grounds in such circumstances. If they are obstructed from doing so or attacked in the line of duty, they are fully within their right to defend themselves. I'm inclined to support them over those unable to control their behaviour in a very basic way. Footage of this entire incident was recorded in Ultra HD. If innocent Hungarian fans completely minding their own business and not trying to obstruct an arrest were mindlessly battered by what you appear to think was an out of control group of police attacking anybody then they can expect significant compensation. Of course though that is exceeding unlikely to occur, because the scenario you've dreamt up is logically very unlikely to have happened.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Not all that strawman since you've now completely backtracked from saying that the crowd were attacked with sticks in an unprovoked fashion. In answer to what fragment of a point remains, racial abuse, as stated is not included in the price of a ticket and is against the law and terms of attendance. Therefore certainly it is absolutely fine for the police to remove someone from the grounds in such circumstances. If they are obstructed from doing so or attacked in the line of duty, they are fully within their right to defend themselves. I'm inclined to support them over those unable to control their behaviour in a very basic way. Footage of this entire incident was recorded in Ultra HD. If innocent Hungarian fans completely minding their own business and not trying to obstruct an arrest were mindlessly battered by what you appear to think was an out of control group of police attacking anybody then they can expect significant compensation. Of course though that is exceeding unlikely to occur, because the scenario you've dreamt up is logically very unlikely to have happened.
Are you incapable of comprehending? Are you doing this on purpose?
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
But of course, calling the referee a w***er or abusing players with insulting language that is not racist seems to be OK, especially if they are White and British. Well according to the media anyway. For one if you call someone a pr!ck on a football pitch I'm not sure that anyone thinks its more 'okay' if the target is black or 'white and british'. As a side point, players can of course also be 'black and british'. Secondly, insults or words hold different weight at any given time. While the likes of the n word hold very little weight for you because you bizarrely spend endless hours rallying against those on the receiving end of such language, in society as a whole it is widely agreed that calling someone a t0sser or similar is rather tame when compared to peppering someone with racial slurs.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
For one if you call someone a pr!ck on a football pitch I'm not sure that anyone thinks its more 'okay' if the target is black or 'white and british'. As a side point, players can of course also be 'black and british'. Secondly, insults or words hold different weight at any given time. While the likes of the n word hold very little weight for you because you bizarrely spend endless hours rallying against those on the receiving end of such language, in society as a whole it is widely agreed that calling someone a t0sser or similar is rather tame when compared to peppering someone with racial slurs.
Please don't give me the one insult is different to another routine. That is crap. An insult is an insult. You and I might think that insulting people is generally unacceptable, but the media and the police, it seems, only care when it is about racism. If there is one type of poster who really annoys me it is the ones who deliberately avoid the obvious.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Are you doing this on purpose? If someone uses racist language towards a steward and it is reported by them, there is little option but to remove that individual. If the police are obstructed or attacked when doing their job, I would expect them to act in the same way as they would if that happened in any any circumstance. You favour mob rule in this case, because you disagree with the politics of it, and have a proven history or rounding on those who have been racially abused, rather than those who engage in such behaviour.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
If someone uses racist language towards a steward and it is reported by them, there is little option but to remove that individual. If the police are obstructed or attacked when doing their job, I would expect them to act in the same way as they would if that happened in any any circumstance. You favour mob rule in this case, because you disagree with the politics of it, and have a proven history or rounding on those who have been racially abused, rather than those who engage in such behaviour.
If you can't see that this is about politics and not about the public interest then I really don't care or feel further need to persuade you. Be careful what you wish for.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Please don't give me the one insult is different to another routine. That is crap. An insult is an insult. So if someone shouting t0sser across the road it you, you'd greet it as the same as if they shouted out pedo would you? Glad to hear it old bean. You stick with that colourful approach to life. If someone called your wife a 'dizzy blonde' that's the same as calling her the c word in front of you is it? Words of course hold different weight and consequence in a society. Again, just because you get a cathartic thrill of berating black people who don't simply put up with being called the n word and the like, it doesn't make your fantasy world become real.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I think we can all agree to the extent that shouting abuse at people doing their job isn't a good thing. Yes, never a bad rule to adhere to
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
So if someone shouting t0sser across the road it you, you'd greet it as the same as if they shouted out pedo would you? Glad to hear it old bean. You stick with that colourful approach to life. If someone called your wife a 'dizzy blonde' that's the same as calling her the c word in front of you is it? Words of course hold different weight and consequence in a society. Again, just because you get a cathartic thrill of berating black people who don't simply put up with being called the n word and the like, it doesn't make your fantasy world become real. People have a choice if they are a t0sser or a pedo. People don't have a choice if they are black, gay, french or disabled. Calling out one is fair game. Calling out another is wrong.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
So you're be fine with bananas thrown onto the pitch and monkey chants then? By your logic that behaviour is perfectly acceptable and all just part and parcel of the game. Just an insult after all, no better or worse than anything else, no need to exclude and nothing for the police to get involved in. I would suggest the reality is that most people know different.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
In this case, Hungarian supporters, forced by UEFA and now FIFA to play games behind closed doors because of racism, and launched a racist attack on a steward. On the balance of probabilities, he's likely to be right in most cases. As for the practical gestures Barnes called for: Yesterday lots of posters got their knickers in a twist over a tube map listing successful black people from History. I don't believe you are calling for more action to help vulnerable kids away from a life in crime because any initiative is greeted with protests. Normally, with whataboutery (what about working class white kids?) as you fail to grasp that help for a minority group does not exclude initiatives that can help out other struggling groups, even though that's the picture extremist groups such as PA want to paint. I note none of the regulars would post this article... I think it is fair to imagine that Hungarians are not as attuned to multiculturalism as we are, and for obvious reasons. So given that, it seems rather sensational to make a big public spectacle of the obvious just so that everyone can look all virtuous and woke.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
So you're be fine with bananas thrown onto the pitch and monkey chants then? By your logic that behaviour is perfectly acceptable and all just part and parcel of the game. Just an insult after all, no better or worse than anything else, no need to exclude and nothing for the police to get involved in. I would suggest the reality is that most people know different.
Wow. You must be running out of straw. I think I have had enough of your nonsense for one day.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
People don't have a choice if they are black, gay, french or disabled. Calling out one is fair game. Calling out another is wrong. I'm just saying it in terms of this idea that all 'insults' are equal, and that using the most insulting terms to either project towards someone or describe groups of people are all somehow magically equal regardless of how all of those words or groups are perceived in society. Yes clearly calling someone a prat is very different from calling a black person the n word and so on. I just figured I'd use examples of words that are seen as especially insulting (c word etc) to help spoonfeed someone who says 'an insult is an insult' while clearly in no way even believing that himself.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Wow. You must be running out of straw. I think I have had enough of your nonsense for one day. Are you sure you don't want to make another 50 whining posts about black people like you do every other day (while telling black people that they should ignore absolutely everything that annoys them).
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
What a wonderful thread. So worthwhile. So decent.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I think it is fair to imagine that Hungarians are not as attuned to multiculturalism as we are, and for obvious reasons. So given that, it seems rather sensational to make a big public spectacle of the obvious just so that everyone can look all virtuous and woke. I generally only see it when people post links on here fishing for controversial opinions. The Mail have been doing it for decades. Now algorithms on your social media will search for posts that will deliberately antagonise you, in order to keep you reading for longer. No one watches TV anymore. There was a story posted on here the other day about a trans bicycle repair shop from an obscure magazine. If people started realising how few and far between events like that are, then maybe they would feel less threatend Try cutting out the people who are pushing the stories to get a rise out of you, then talk to the people around you. The majority of people are decent. 1% of crime makes 99% of the news.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
What a wonderful thread. So worthwhile. So decent. Yes, let's shut it down, so we can't talk about race issues. Good idea. John Barnes wants to talk about it, but then, he has a brain.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.