You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What Have the Owners done Wrong?
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What Have the Owners done Wrong?


Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
CpfcWeTrust1 Flag 03 Feb 24 11.46pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The board hired the manager who they knew too well. It's not just the keeper but franca as well.

What exactly has Franca done so wrong apart from not being selected?

There's no crystal ball DF has got for the young players, if he comes good once he gets a run of games then everybody will keep quiet again. For now he's been played whenever we are out the game or for 10 mins. Not exactly a good run out for him is it?

As far as I can see, he looks half decent.

As for the managerial appointment. Yes, I agree the board hired the manager but on reflection from how the second half of last season went with Roy, you can see a reasoning for it.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Feb 24 11.52pm

Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1

What exactly has Franca done so wrong apart from not being selected?

There's no crystal ball DF has got for the young players, if he comes good once he gets a run of games then everybody will keep quiet again. For now he's been played whenever we are out the game or for 10 mins. Not exactly a good run out for him is it?

As far as I can see, he looks half decent.

As for the managerial appointment. Yes, I agree the board hired the manager but on reflection from how the second half of last season went with Roy, you can see a reasoning for it.

My issue with franca is the signing happening with Roy in charge. Or Roy in charge of Franca. We have a strategy that doesn't fit with the manager, and at £18mil we can't afford to waste with other holes in the squad.

 


COYP

CpfcWeTrust1 Flag 03 Feb 24 11.57pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

My issue with franca is the signing happening with Roy in charge. Or Roy in charge of Franca. We have a strategy that doesn't fit with the manager, and at £18mil we can't afford to waste with other holes in the squad.

I'm of the opinion that DF and the board expected Roy to bother trying out Franca and didn't expect Roy to yet again stick with the same group every season.

Same goes with Ahemada. I havent seen him be too awful and yet we see nothing of him either.

Your view I understand and its a fair argument but I just don't understand Roy's logic nor do I feel he has the fight in him anymore.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Feb 24 12.16am

There isn’t a straightforward answer to this.

There is a lot on and off the field that doesn’t feel right.

But really that’s all we have - perception. We don’t know the detail of what really goes on within the ownership.

We have two passive investors that seem content to have Parish run the club. The other investor appears to be at loggerheads with the others and who himself doesn’t inspire confidence when you look at the other clubs he’s involved with.

So you could lay all responsibility at Steve Parish’s door as being the one that ultimately calls the shots.

Where I think he has it wrong is that he has left the club in a limbo state when re-appointing Hodgson for another season. How was that a forward move ?

For a club with little money , the club found around £60m in the last two transfer windows. But we fall between two possible strategies ; building a team around our major playing assets or sell one to improve the strength and depth of the squad.

I think we are heading towards the latter, but for the moment we aren’t doing either.

I commend Steve Parish for what he has achieved since 2010. But I think he’s going through a period where his decision making is questionable. I think he’s hanging around to oversee the new stand completed and his 60th birthday before he looks for the exit.

For now though he’s taken a gamble on just getting through this season. That may come back to bite him

 


Old, Ungifted and White

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 04 Feb 24 12.49am

The issues have all been pointed out in various posts.

Decision making at board level in wrong hands.

The Moby Dick main stand has become an obsession for SP who is also desperate to get in front of the cameras.

Nothing we as supporters can do.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 04 Feb 24 1.19am

Originally posted by NEILLO

There isn’t a straightforward answer to this.

There is a lot on and off the field that doesn’t feel right.

But really that’s all we have - perception. We don’t know the detail of what really goes on within the ownership.

We have two passive investors that seem content to have Parish run the club. The other investor appears to be at loggerheads with the others and who himself doesn’t inspire confidence when you look at the other clubs he’s involved with.

So you could lay all responsibility at Steve Parish’s door as being the one that ultimately calls the shots.

Where I think he has it wrong is that he has left the club in a limbo state when re-appointing Hodgson for another season. How was that a forward move ?

For a club with little money , the club found around £60m in the last two transfer windows. But we fall between two possible strategies ; building a team around our major playing assets or sell one to improve the strength and depth of the squad.

I think we are heading towards the latter, but for the moment we aren’t doing either.

I commend Steve Parish for what he has achieved since 2010. But I think he’s going through a period where his decision making is questionable. I think he’s hanging around to oversee the new stand completed and his 60th birthday before he looks for the exit.

For now though he’s taken a gamble on just getting through this season. That may come back to bite him

You've saved me writing a very long post and therefore others being subjected to my long winded rambling NEILLO, I completely agree.

With no evidence asides from seeing the situation pan out as it has, I was very much of the opinion Parish thought keeping Roy was the equivalent of 'securing another season' whilst he builds a stand as his monument.

Unfortunately, this is football and it does not always pan out as such. Perhaps I've missed a trick in not holding as much resentment toward Parish as others seem to, and I'm not suggesting I have any let alone all the answers, however I am witnessing this apparent strategy faltering big time.

Football atrocious and ineffective, we're on course for relegation, players unhappy, fans incandescent, manager without answers and perhaps justifiably facing extreme hostility. Something has to change. If Parish does nothing, that will be his legacy and will almost nullify anything preceding it.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Far away fan Flag On the border of jungle 04 Feb 24 3.32am

Parish is woke to frightened to run them down to there face, no heart in a lot off the players, if a chairman like Noades the players would be worried with a rubbish performance like that, over played wan - ker s

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 04 Feb 24 6.26am

Whatever problem in the club, the simple solution now to avoid relegation? Change of manager, that is the only thing what we can do really.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 04 Feb 24 7.08am

Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1

I'm of the opinion that DF and the board expected Roy to bother trying out Franca and didn't expect Roy to yet again stick with the same group every season.

Same goes with Ahemada.

I read an article a few months ago about the process used in transfers and once fees and wages etc have been agreed the final process is for the player to discuss with the manager how he would fit in and what his expectations were.

It seems to me that the final part is what is missing and Roy Hodgson introduces himself when the player arrives at the club

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 04 Feb 24 7.26am

Exactly how I saw it too -

Originally posted by Nicholas91

You've saved me writing a very long post and therefore others being subjected to my long winded rambling NEILLO, I completely agree.

With no evidence asides from seeing the situation pan out as it has, I was very much of the opinion Parish thought keeping Roy was the equivalent of 'securing another season' whilst he builds a stand as his monument.

Unfortunately, this is football and it does not always pan out as such. Perhaps I've missed a trick in not holding as much resentment toward Parish as others seem to, and I'm not suggesting I have any let alone all the answers, however I am witnessing this apparent strategy faltering big time.

Football atrocious and ineffective, we're on course for relegation, players unhappy, fans incandescent, manager without answers and perhaps justifiably facing extreme hostility. Something has to change. If Parish does nothing, that will be his legacy and will almost nullify anything preceding it.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 04 Feb 24 8.05am

We are totally disjointed from chief executive (Parish) down through the board (the owners) through to management, strategy, academy, players, fans and direction.
We are in need of one big overhaul. Problem is, I dont see it coming ......yet.
If we dont take drastic action at management level imminently I fear we will slide down.
How come nearly everyone on here is seeing it, but nothing is being done.

 

WJK1960 Flag 04 Feb 24 8.32am

I was at the game yesterday and yes we were poor, but I do think there is a danger of a gross overreaction to an absolutely horrendous injury situation.

Yes we could do better defending at and scoring from corners, and yes I wish Roy would play Franca more often, but these are marginal issues compared with not having 3 of our best 5 players regularly available since the start of the season. And with Wilf going, arguably 4 out of our 6 best players from last season are not available on a consistent basis this season. I would suggest any mid table team would struggle in those circumstances and why we end up putting out the midfield we did yesterday.

Turning on the players looks terrible and is not going to help. And I can't see how the owners can be held responsible for the
injury situation. We do really need to come together.

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 04 Feb 24 9.02am

The owners are not responsible for the injury situation, but they are responsible for not considering it might happen and having a balanced squad. Was the £40million or so spent in the summer, mainly on Henderson and Franca, the best use of that money?

They have deemed getting a left wing forward in to replace Wilf as something we’ll do if we can. Our recruitment policy has not seen the best value for money spent.

It isn’t easy, but I wish they would issue a statement saying how they have made mistakes, they are behind Roy (or sack him) and try to galvanise the situation.

But it’s just silence and the toxicity will continue.


quote=WJK1960;3854307]

I was at the game yesterday and yes we were poor, but I do think there is a danger of a gross overreaction to an absolutely horrendous injury situation.

Yes we could do better defending at and scoring from corners, and yes I wish Roy would play Franca more often, but these are marginal issues compared with not having 3 of our best 5 players regularly available since the start of the season. And with Wilf going, arguably 4 out of our 6 best players from last season are not available on a consistent basis this season. I would suggest any mid table team would struggle in those circumstances and why we end up putting out the midfield we did yesterday.

Turning on the players looks terrible and is not going to help. And I can't see how the owners can be held responsible for the
injury situation. We do really need to come together.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 04 Feb 24 9.49am

The problem is the Ridiculous position have got themselves into over voting rights, 4 holders with 25% voting rights, so 3 have to agree to get anything done, 2 each its stalemate, farcical, and the blame lays squarely with Textor for allowing Parish to call the tune, it should be as shares held, Textor 45%, Blitzer and Harris 16% each and Parish with his 10%, Roberto Franca 5% and 4% held by small investors, until that is sorted the Status Quo will continue, with nobody able to make a decision.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Feb 24 10.37am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

The problem is the Ridiculous position have got themselves into over voting rights, 4 holders with 25% voting rights, so 3 have to agree to get anything done, 2 each its stalemate, farcical, and the blame lays squarely with Textor for allowing Parish to call the tune, it should be as shares held, Textor 45%, Blitzer and Harris 16% each and Parish with his 10%, Roberto Franca 5% and 4% held by small investors, until that is sorted the Status Quo will continue, with nobody able to make a decision.

Not having a harmonised Board is where the problems start and then filter down through the club.

However, I have no confidence in Textor being the one calling the shots.

I think Parish has done a really good job overall, but recently I see signs of someone who has been in their job too long.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

CpfcWeTrust1 Flag 04 Feb 24 10.47am

Surely the easiest and first thing every fan should be doing, is getting behind the team. They don't have to support Roy but if anything could be clearer, the team needs the fans to push them on. Frankly the morale is probably shot to pieces, confidence is at an all time low, the players probably are questioning why they are at the club, they have Roy managing his defensive but leaking goal tacticsand imagine being one of the young players when fans are shouting and swearing at you. It seems like a s***show for them just as much as the fans.

If one thing I learnt from Everton last season, getting behind the team and making their stadium a hard place to go, kept them up last season.

If we cling on in this league then we will rest easy that Roy will be gone, injuries will subside, on the whole... the squad looks great if there's no injuries and with a different manager, it could be quite exciting.

Edited by CpfcWeTrust1 (04 Feb 2024 10.48am)

 

Adrift Flag Creepy Crawley 04 Feb 24 10.56am

Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1


............

Guaita left the club so they did need a second goal keeper and SJ did get injured. I dont agree with the amount spent nor do I think Henderson is much good but Roy keeps playing him.


...............

Surely not after yesterday

 

CpfcWeTrust1 Flag 04 Feb 24 11.58am

Originally posted by Adrift

Surely not after yesterday

You would hope not but I expect Roy will play him again.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 04 Feb 24 12.46pm

In fairness to SP he's tried to draw investment as and when its been needed to keep us in the division whilst trying to protect the club from the wrong type. So the current ownership structure has evolved through necessity and without Textor's money a couple of years back we'd already be in the Championship.

What I find really curious are the stories that Harris and Blitzer didn't understand the concept of relegation when they acquired their shares and (by inference) that their attitude to investment changed as a result.

As others have said a degree of complacency set in pre-season with the club gambling heavily on the three promoted teams not being good enough along with Forest.

I think there's been complacency amongst some of the fans as well with all the social media full of comment about what a great squad we had, Zaha no longer needed etc when IMO that wasn't the case.

Clearly there was a lack of height / strong headers of the ball which was exposed a bit towards the end of last season most notably against West Ham.

You could go on and on but most of all the lack of any real attacking quality or intensity throughout the whole team or squad when we lose two players. The warning signs were there pre-season.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 04 Feb 24 2.37pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

In fairness to SP he's tried to draw investment as and when its been needed to keep us in the division whilst trying to protect the club from the wrong type. So the current ownership structure has evolved through necessity and without Textor's money a couple of years back we'd already be in the Championship.

What I find really curious are the stories that Harris and Blitzer didn't understand the concept of relegation when they acquired their shares and (by inference) that their attitude to investment changed as a result.

As others have said a degree of complacency set in pre-season with the club gambling heavily on the three promoted teams not being good enough along with Forest.

I think there's been complacency amongst some of the fans as well with all the social media full of comment about what a great squad we had, Zaha no longer needed etc when IMO that wasn't the case.

Clearly there was a lack of height / strong headers of the ball which was exposed a bit towards the end of last season most notably against West Ham.

You could go on and on but most of all the lack of any real attacking quality or intensity throughout the whole team or squad when we lose two players. The warning signs were there pre-season.


This is recycled misinformation.

The claims the Americans do not understand relegation etc is BS.

Those Americans are not rookies they would have over the years learnt numerous things about the sport.

How do you know SP has tried to draw investment you don't and he has not even put in place simple things like merchandise distribution worldwide.

Over a decade in this league and the Palace brand especially with US owners should have been spread yet you cant buy a Palace shirt in US unless you import it.

If we was so hard up as well SP should have stepped aside a long time ago him hanging around putting nothing in is not good for the club considering he claimed he would only be short term.

Why no stadium sponsor even if only 10m a year this could have been used towards ground improvements.

We are not missing Zaha people have overrated him and forget when he does nothing or sulks (The big loss form him was we got no £ for him should have let him go years ago but SP again bad business wanting unrealistic fee so another player walks for free)

Backroom setup is done on the cheap when you have the likes of Pardew coming into the club and forcing changes that sums up how poor it really was and I suggest people to go look who the backroom people are they really are not Prem quality mostly people who have some tie to Palace.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What Have the Owners done Wrong?