You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Relegation 22/23
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Relegation 22/23


Page 21 of 85 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 >
jabber Flag pease pottage 06 Feb 23 7.51pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Goals can come from anywhere and all count. A particular favourite of mine was route one against Manchester United whereby Guaita punted a long ball for Schlupp to head on into the path of Ayew who calmly side footed past a hapless De Gea, marvellous.

That must've been the last time he scored

 

PJEagle Flag London 06 Feb 23 8.26pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

De Boer was hardly through the door when he announced his intention to play 532 despite not knowing his players nor whether they were capable of playing the formation.
He alienated the squad , would not adapt, and his reign was short lived.

Similarly Vieira joined and ,before working with the players, immediately announced an intention to ply 433 with ‘one number 6 and two number 8s’ in midfield.
Fortunately we had Gallagher, McArthur and Kouyate who had the right skill set to make the formation work and we played effective and eye catching football.
All looked very promising.
However, this season we haven’t had those three players and I would contend that only Doucoure is comfortable in the ‘one number 6 and two number8’s’ formation.
Schlupp, Eze, Olise, Hughes and Luka have all been tried in the formation and none have looked comfortable.
Our midfield formation this season has neither protected our back four nor provided a good service to our forwards.
The tendency has been to blame the players as not good enough, but it could equally be argued that they don’t suit the roles they are being asked to perform.
Hughes and Luka don’t have the energy and arguably need to play in a 4 or 5 man midfield.
Schlupp and Ayew have physical qualities, but ultimately are not authentic midfield players in their reading of the game.
Eze and Olise have bags of natural talent , but their work off the ball mean they are not suitable to play the number 8 roles.
Maybe the two new additions and the hopeful return of McArthur will mean that we can get the midfield formation to work again.
Nonetheless, it’s difficult to understand why we’ve played the first half of the season with players playing in roles that they struggle with.
Good management is about making the most of available resources and this surely entails playing players in their most effective positions rather than being wedded to a particular tactical formation.


Does anyone know when Andersen is back? He's a big miss

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 06 Feb 23 8.45pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

De Boer was hardly through the door when he announced his intention to play 532 despite not knowing his players nor whether they were capable of playing the formation.
He alienated the squad , would not adapt, and his reign was short lived.

Similarly Vieira joined and ,before working with the players, immediately announced an intention to ply 433 with ‘one number 6 and two number 8s’ in midfield.
Fortunately we had Gallagher, McArthur and Kouyate who had the right skill set to make the formation work and we played effective and eye catching football.
All looked very promising.
However, this season we haven’t had those three players and I would contend that only Doucoure is comfortable in the ‘one number 6 and two number8’s’ formation.
Schlupp, Eze, Olise, Hughes and Luka have all been tried in the formation and none have looked comfortable.
Our midfield formation this season has neither protected our back four nor provided a good service to our forwards.
The tendency has been to blame the players as not good enough, but it could equally be argued that they don’t suit the roles they are being asked to perform.
Hughes and Luka don’t have the energy and arguably need to play in a 4 or 5 man midfield.
Schlupp and Ayew have physical qualities, but ultimately are not authentic midfield players in their reading of the game.
Eze and Olise have bags of natural talent , but their work off the ball mean they are not suitable to play the number 8 roles.
Maybe the two new additions and the hopeful return of McArthur will mean that we can get the midfield formation to work again.
Nonetheless, it’s difficult to understand why we’ve played the first half of the season with players playing in roles that they struggle with.
Good management is about making the most of available resources and this surely entails playing players in their most effective positions rather than being wedded to a particular tactical formation.

The strange thing about De Boer was in his last game, away to Burnley, we played fantastic, 27 shots to their 4, the worst luck i have ever seen, and we lost 1-0, to a Chung Lee back pass, strange to think if we had won easily like we should have if he would have been sacked.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

YT Flag Oxford 06 Feb 23 9.27pm

Originally posted by jabber

That must've been the last time he scored

You've forgotten his goal in our last win, against Bournemouth.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

jabber Flag pease pottage 06 Feb 23 10.21pm

Originally posted by YT

You've forgotten his goal in our last win, against Bournemouth.

I did wow how prolific.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Feb 23 10.28pm

Could be we’re only looking at 2 places to go down with City !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Feb 23 11.34pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Southampton and Bournemouth are almost certs to be relegated.

Some Southampton supporters want Jones to be relieved of his duties after 6 defeats in 7 PL games on his watch.
He did however join the club when they were 18th and they have signed 5 players in the January 'Window' for a total of around £60 Mill.

Edited by Willo (06 Feb 2023 11.37pm)

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 07 Feb 23 1.12am

Originally posted by PatrickA

You could say the same of the likes of Bobby Moore, Bobby Charlton and more recently Ray Wilkins, Tony Adams and Frank Lampard.
Being a great player, and having a great deal more football knowledge than the average fan, does not necessarily equate to being a great manager .
If one accepts the manager is always right ,when his decisions are queried by supporters, you may as well do away with discussion forums.
No doubt managers would be very content with this outcome.

As I said it's all about opinions

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

PJEagle Flag London 07 Feb 23 2.34am

Originally posted by steeleye20

We are not even half-way through the campaign.

I am thinking depth of squads, injuries, will any of our young academy players come through for example, 22 games to play in the PL is quite a stretch.

The challenge is to survive until end of season. A lot of players will go then at the end of their contracts and wwe will then have. (Hopefully) a massive influx of new talent

 

taylors lovechild Flag 07 Feb 23 6.59am

Originally posted by Jacey

Frankly,if we are to stay in the Premiership,we should urgently look to appoint Sam or Roy,to guarantee survival.
Otherwise,stay with Mr.Nice Guy PV,who is slowly but surely leading us to the Championship.

Screw that, let's bring back Mr Bouncebackability, or how about Dave Bassett, is he still alive? Warnock was great too. In fact, I propose we only look at retired managers who like to swear a lot.

 

The Dolphin Flag 07 Feb 23 7.47am

Patrick A - great post.
It boils down to PV needing to get the best out of what he has got instead of taking us down trying to play the beautiful game.
Adapting and being pro-active are what he needs to be right now but he continues to bang the same drum and we keep losing.
Be sure, losing is a mentality when it keeps happening and I am worried.
Luka may not be anyone's idea of what we need right now but he could protect the back 4 leaving Doucoure to go forward a bit more.
Maybe with the new players arriving that might not now be needed but it would have been a good idea over the last ten games or so.
He is a square peg/round hole Manager - never a good thing!

 

YT Flag Oxford 07 Feb 23 8.30am

Originally posted by jabber

I did wow how prolific.

Why the sarcasm? I never said he was prolific, I merely pointed out that you had made an incorrect statement about him.

But since you used the word 'prolific; in terms of the current goal-shy squad, he IS relatively prolific.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

taylors lovechild Flag 07 Feb 23 8.52am

I'm sorry but Luka is no longer the answer to any question other than 'Who is the next player to get booked?' He seems like a great character but he's no longer up to it at PL level and he takes so long on the ball the referee probably considers stopping his watch for timewasting.

The facts are that results against all but the big 6 are pretty good:

6 wins
4 draws
3 defeats

22 out of a possible 39 points

Against the big 6 (Chelsea, Arsenal, United, City, Spuds, Liverpool) they are not great:

0 wins
2 draws
6 defeats

2 points out of a possible 24

What this says to me is our more patient, controlled play is effective against weaker opposition, but doesn't offer enough threat against the big teams. On paper this puts us in a strong position if a similar pattern follows for the remainder of the season as we only have 4 games left against the big 6 due to the ridiculous scheduling of our fixtures.

Of course you cannot guarantee the second half will pan out the same as the first, but I do think our fixtures since the WC have cast a negative light on us as only the Fulham game is one we may have expected more from. In our 10 years in this PL stint our points against the big 6 are memorable, but few and far between.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 07 Feb 23 8.53am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Patrick A - great post.
It boils down to PV needing to get the best out of what he has got instead of taking us down trying to play the beautiful game.
Adapting and being pro-active are what he needs to be right now but he continues to bang the same drum and we keep losing.
Be sure, losing is a mentality when it keeps happening and I am worried.
Luka may not be anyone's idea of what we need right now but he could protect the back 4 leaving Doucoure to go forward a bit more.
Maybe with the new players arriving that might not now be needed but it would have been a good idea over the last ten games or so.
He is a square peg/round hole Manager - never a good thing!

Spot on, Derry was a Realist, PV is a Fantasist.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Feb 23 8.55am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Screw that, let's bring back Mr Bouncebackability, or how about Dave Bassett, is he still alive? Warnock was great too. In fact, I propose we only look at retired managers who like to swear a lot.

Dave Bassett was present at the AFC Wimbledon v Stockport game a couple of weeks ago.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 07 Feb 23 8.56am

Originally posted by PatrickA

De Boer was hardly through the door when he announced his intention to play 532 despite not knowing his players nor whether they were capable of playing the formation.
He alienated the squad , would not adapt, and his reign was short lived.

Similarly Vieira joined and ,before working with the players, immediately announced an intention to ply 433 with ‘one number 6 and two number 8s’ in midfield.
Fortunately we had Gallagher, McArthur and Kouyate who had the right skill set to make the formation work and we played effective and eye catching football.
All looked very promising.
However, this season we haven’t had those three players and I would contend that only Doucoure is comfortable in the ‘one number 6 and two number8’s’ formation.
Schlupp, Eze, Olise, Hughes and Luka have all been tried in the formation and none have looked comfortable.
Our midfield formation this season has neither protected our back four nor provided a good service to our forwards.
The tendency has been to blame the players as not good enough, but it could equally be argued that they don’t suit the roles they are being asked to perform.
Hughes and Luka don’t have the energy and arguably need to play in a 4 or 5 man midfield.
Schlupp and Ayew have physical qualities, but ultimately are not authentic midfield players in their reading of the game.
Eze and Olise have bags of natural talent , but their work off the ball mean they are not suitable to play the number 8 roles.
Maybe the two new additions and the hopeful return of McArthur will mean that we can get the midfield formation to work again.
Nonetheless, it’s difficult to understand why we’ve played the first half of the season with players playing in roles that they struggle with.
Good management is about making the most of available resources and this surely entails playing players in their most effective positions rather than being wedded to a particular tactical formation.


Couldn’t have put it any better. Totally agree with your comments on PV’s team this season and his inability to adapt to a playing style to suit the players we now have? Let’s hope the two new additions can make the difference, otherwise we will go down :-(


 

southnorwoodhill Flag 07 Feb 23 9.26am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Spot on, Derry was a Realist, PV is a Fantasist.

He's a fantasist in the sense that he believes the type of football he played and players he played with at Arsenal under Wenger (Henry, Bergkamp, Cole, Ljungberg etc) and the French national side can be recreated at Palace with the likes of Eze, Schlupp, Ayew etc.
Clearly this is what he knows and can't be blamed for it, he's played with the very best, but failing to adjust his expectations and adopting a more pragmatic approach may well be his downfall.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 07 Feb 23 9.55am

I don’t get this obsession with Shaun Derry. The very epitome of a one trick pony style of management. He’s failed at two lower league clubs. His approach to player management may have been effective at junior level at Palace, but it’s a different scenario at first team level. The Sergeant Major methodology doesn’t work there.

Anybody on here played on his team in the Robert Eaton games ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

palace99 Flag New Mills 07 Feb 23 10.22am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I don’t get this obsession with Shaun Derry. The very epitome of a one trick pony style of management. He’s failed at two lower league clubs. His approach to player management may have been effective at junior level at Palace, but it’s a different scenario at first team level. The Sergeant Major methodology doesn’t work there.

Anybody on here played on his team in the Robert Eaton games ?

a story from a Cambridge supporting mate. When managing there he reported the chairman/owner to the management association for bullying.

Now, whilst i'm not supporting bullies, for 'hard man' Derry to consider he was being bullied by a old bloke in a suit seems a little bizarre

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 07 Feb 23 10.29am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I don’t get this obsession with Shaun Derry. The very epitome of a one trick pony style of management. He’s failed at two lower league clubs. His approach to player management may have been effective at junior level at Palace, but it’s a different scenario at first team level. The Sergeant Major methodology doesn’t work there.

Anybody on here played on his team in the Robert Eaton games ?

Me neither, also he was actually pretty s*** as a player for us, I think a lot of people have forgotten this because he was part of the team that escaped relegation on the last day in Sheffield

 

Page 21 of 85 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Relegation 22/23