This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I don’t think that’s necessarily a right wing view - I think most people would agree with it. the working person should do better than the long-term sponger. It is a right wing view. Because those politicians who defile it are always on the Left. Taxing the shyte out of workers and meanwhile shoveling money at losers. Affordable housing is a reality in most of the rest of the Planet.....only the decadent West cannot seem to manage. And you can include american puppet State South Korea in that. With the lowest rate of fertility on the Planet. Generous dole makes housing unaffordable for working people. Sweden, Ireland, France. getting back to the OP, Climate change activists seem to be very similar to the people who went off the deep end about Covid. Edited by PalazioVecchio (30 Jan 2024 7.33pm)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Not in the least bit true. I care about all genuine problems. The solutions for many are relatively easily achievable and manageable. Others are long standing societal issues. Culture is never destroyed. It is just constantly evolving. Overcrowding and housing shortage have always existed somewhere and can be dealt with. Murder isn’t new. Nor is organised crime. Who knows if peadophile gangs existed in the past. Peadophiles certainly did and their crimes went largely unreported and uninvestigated. Fruitcakes have existed in one form or another since time began and so has the belief that one tribe is better than another. People have always abused the law. The British tribe is not being replaced. It’s being extended. Nor is the media being taken over by the left. With the dominance of Murdoch, and his like, that’s a really silly idea. Nor is free speech being constrained. Respect for others is being expected. They are big enough mistakes but your biggest one by far comes in your last comment. Climate change has nothing at all to do with weather. The climate has everything to do with weather. I'm not going to disagree with a list of your disagreements. It's a waste of my time. Oh, and it's paedophile.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
As I said, the rate of new discoveries has naturally flattened compared with the 18th and 19th centuries. You are correct there is some debate as to the extent of man made climate change, and certainly discussion around that is valid - there is however no serious debate as to its existence and indeed the fact it’s a major threat to humanity. I agree that achieving any sort of global alignment in this space is exceptionally difficult - as you say, particularly in light of the economic reality many countries face - but that does not mean it’s a goal not worth pursuing. Technological advancements can make economic growth possible without destroying the planet, and these alternative energy solutions will only become cheaper and more efficient over time. I don’t understand why advancements in or indeed the pursuit of ‘green energy’ would be considered nonsense - it’s the most practical and achievable solution to our over reliance on finite energy sources which have damaging impacts and technology has made major strides in this space in recent years. I’m afraid your claim on global population is just not a fact at all I think the second half of your post is indicative of your issue with this topic, and you’re certainly not unique in this - you view environmental movements as some sort of personal attack on your own behaviours and actions, which it isn’t really at all. Of course individual life choices make minimal difference, and I would agree far more time and energy should be directed to state-level changes rather than asking people to recycle their milk cartons or whatever else. Of course you will find people profiteering in these type of movements, but I don’t view the existence of some exploitative characters as a reason not to take the broader point seriously. What we need is realism, not excuses to exploit people. Global consensus on this won't come until most countries are experiencing the disastrous effects that climate change could bring. Right now, everything is within manageable limits for most nations. If we are going to make sacrifices, they need to have a practical value. We have to balance the need for greater amounts of energy with the need to be 'greener'.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The climate has everything to do with weather. I'm not going to disagree with a list of your disagreements. It's a waste of my time. Oh, and it's paedophile.
Weather is what happens every day.. Climate is what happens over extended periods.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Can you example a few right wing opinions ? Your three examples aren’t exclusively right wing views. They are simplistic views which can be, and are, held by those whose politics are from both the left and the right. Better examples would include xenophobia, strident nationalism, chauvinism, dislike of public ownership or regulation, any restrictions on personal liberty, belief in self rather than collective responsibility.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Your three examples aren’t exclusively right wing views. They are simplistic views which can be, and are, held by those whose politics are from both the left and the right. Better examples would include xenophobia, strident nationalism, chauvinism, dislike of public ownership or regulation, any restrictions on personal liberty, belief in self rather than collective responsibility. And yet the supposedly right wing party in Britain has had three females and an Asian as leader and took us into the common market.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Your three examples aren’t exclusively right wing views. They are simplistic views which can be, and are, held by those whose politics are from both the left and the right. Better examples would include xenophobia, strident nationalism, chauvinism, dislike of public ownership or regulation, any restrictions on personal liberty, belief in self rather than collective responsibility. Well if these 3 examples are spoken of they are deemed right wing and are only simplistic iyo because the wall gets put up to stop a discussion because….They are deemed right wing racist and xenophobic as just a few descriptors .
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I don’t think that’s necessarily a right wing view - I think most people would agree with it. Welfare as a topic certainly can divide along left/right lines, but I don’t think many would disagree with the basic principle that working should create better life outcomes for an individual. I do think many on the right’s obsession with benefits and spongers is interesting though, and certainly overlaps with the Murdoch point I made earlier - it’s a literal drop in the ocean versus tax evasion and avoidance by the rich and corporates, yet so many seem completely fixated on welfare instead. There’s absolutely no contest as to what has a bigger impact on the public purse. Welfare cost approximately £230 billion in 2022-2023 - albeit I suspect the cost is greater if other relevant stuff was included.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
And yet the supposedly right wing party in Britain has had three females and an Asian as leader and took us into the common market. According to some here the Conservative Party isn’t right wing but another iteration of the scourge of liberal democracy. They have always had a noisy hard right faction whose views tend towards the attitudes I listed but were moderated by the need to compromise with the larger group on the centre right. Something that looks to be nearing its end.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Well if these 3 examples are spoken of they are deemed right wing and are only simplistic iyo because the wall gets put up to stop a discussion because….They are deemed right wing racist and xenophobic as just a few descriptors . Whilst those who oppose all immigration, regardless of its consequences, can have racist or xenophobic motivations not all do, and opposing climate change measures not at at all. Claiming Y-L was right, possibly.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Whilst those who oppose all immigration, regardless of its consequences, can have racist or xenophobic motivations not all do, and opposing climate change measures not at at all. Claiming Y-L was right, possibly. Most don't. You look at the effect of mass immigration on this country and see everything that was predicted come to pass. That is not to say that some migrants have not been of benefit to this country or that we should close the door to everyone. What is now required is a much more selective immigration policy, reducing numbers to hundreds, and a change of attitude towards the illegal migrant crisis which is better suited to the modern world. If it were me, I'd also deport criminals of foreign heritage, even if they were born here. If the country concerned would have them, I'd deny all immigration from that country going forward. It won't happen of course. Our governments are too weak. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (31 Jan 2024 9.42am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
Welfare cost approximately £230 billion in 2022-2023 - albeit I suspect the cost is greater if other relevant stuff was included. It's only estimated 4% of that amount is fraudulently claimed - as you say, the existence of a welfare system in itself is not the issue, so I don't think the total cost is a particularly relevant figure. With no fraudulent claims at all, it would still cost hundreds of billions a year. Money out of the public purse is the same, whether it's fraudulently claimed benefits or unpaid tax, the result is exactly the same - rich people also use public infrastructure. We as a society have been engineered to despise those people on benefits, who are nearly all powerless nobodies, more than we hate the corporates and the rich, who are the ones in the position to set the very tax laws that suit them, as well as influence the media narrative around that. It's all a big racket, and benefit claimants are a useful pawn.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
It's only estimated 4% of that amount is fraudulently claimed - as you say, the existence of a welfare system in itself is not the issue, so I don't think the total cost is a particularly relevant figure. With no fraudulent claims at all, it would still cost hundreds of billions a year. Money out of the public purse is the same, whether it's fraudulently claimed benefits or unpaid tax, the result is exactly the same - rich people also use public infrastructure. We as a society have been engineered to despise those people on benefits, who are nearly all powerless nobodies, more than we hate the corporates and the rich, who are the ones in the position to set the very tax laws that suit them, as well as influence the media narrative around that. It's all a big racket, and benefit claimants are a useful pawn. 4% ! Sure, does anyone seriously believes that. Add a zero and it would be nearer the mark.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
4% ! Sure, does anyone seriously believes that. Add a zero and it would be nearer the mark. If you don't like facts, just invent your own!
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
If you don't like facts, just invent your own! How can an estimate be a fact ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
It's only estimated 4% of that amount is fraudulently claimed - as you say, the existence of a welfare system in itself is not the issue, so I don't think the total cost is a particularly relevant figure. With no fraudulent claims at all, it would still cost hundreds of billions a year. Money out of the public purse is the same, whether it's fraudulently claimed benefits or unpaid tax, the result is exactly the same - rich people also use public infrastructure. We as a society have been engineered to despise those people on benefits, who are nearly all powerless nobodies, more than we hate the corporates and the rich, who are the ones in the position to set the very tax laws that suit them, as well as influence the media narrative around that. It's all a big racket, and benefit claimants are a useful pawn. It depends how you interpret the sums. 4% is still £8.3bn according to government figures. Or the equivalent to 250,000 people fraudulently claiming the national average salary.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Most don't. You look at the effect of mass immigration on this country and see everything that was predicted come to pass. That is not to say that some migrants have not been of benefit to this country or that we should close the door to everyone. What is now required is a much more selective immigration policy, reducing numbers to hundreds, and a change of attitude towards the illegal migrant crisis which is better suited to the modern world. If it were me, I'd also deport criminals of foreign heritage, even if they were born here. If the country concerned would have them, I'd deny all immigration from that country going forward. It won't happen of course. Our governments are too weak. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (31 Jan 2024 9.42am) Everyone wants to stop the illegals. It’s doing it in a way which doesn’t conflict with our international treaty obligations and without risking the consequences of doing so which is the difficulty. Although it produces the biggest headlines illegal immigration is only a relatively small part of the whole though. Unless you want to stop families being together by stopping the family route, denying universities vital income from overseas students and our industries, especially the health and social care sector, from being staffed you simply cannot limit the numbers in the way you seek. It’s not possible. Denying any British citizen their right of abode on the basis of their heritage is a really bright idea. Good luck with that.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Everyone wants to stop the illegals. It’s doing it in a way which doesn’t conflict with our international treaty obligations and without risking the consequences of doing so which is the difficulty. Although it produces the biggest headlines illegal immigration is only a relatively small part of the whole though. Unless you want to stop families being together by stopping the family route, denying universities vital income from overseas students and our industries, especially the health and social care sector, from being staffed you simply cannot limit the numbers in the way you seek. It’s not possible. Denying any British citizen their right of abode on the basis of their heritage is a really bright idea. Good luck with that. And yet the health and social care services in Cornwall cope.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Everyone wants to stop the illegals. It’s doing it in a way which doesn’t conflict with our international treaty obligations and without risking the consequences of doing so which is the difficulty. Although it produces the biggest headlines illegal immigration is only a relatively small part of the whole though. Unless you want to stop families being together by stopping the family route, denying universities vital income from overseas students and our industries, especially the health and social care sector, from being staffed you simply cannot limit the numbers in the way you seek. It’s not possible. Denying any British citizen their right of abode on the basis of their heritage is a really bright idea. Good luck with that. But illegal immigrants don’t work. How does that help these vital industries and services.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Everyone wants to stop the illegals. It’s doing it in a way which doesn’t conflict with our international treaty obligations and without risking the consequences of doing so which is the difficulty. Although it produces the biggest headlines illegal immigration is only a relatively small part of the whole though. Unless you want to stop families being together by stopping the family route, denying universities vital income from overseas students and our industries, especially the health and social care sector, from being staffed you simply cannot limit the numbers in the way you seek. It’s not possible. Denying any British citizen their right of abode on the basis of their heritage is a really bright idea. Good luck with that. If rules were in place that when one person comes over, they can't bring their family over then people wouldn't need to do it. If they didn't want to be apart from their families they wouldn't come. Loophole after loophole is what is being exploited. They all need to be shut down quickly. One quick immigration bill in line with Australia or New Zealand and there you go. The constant flow of third rate people entering the country can end.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.