You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ban Islamic immigration. Yes or no?
November 22 2026 12.40am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ban Islamic immigration. Yes or no?


Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
silvertop Flag Portishead 22 Jul 16 11.34am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

It probably hurt the American war effort more than it helped anyone as well. Absurdly stupid decision, for purely ignorant reasons that denied the US access to a huge resource.

And of course we didn't intern anyone in either War. Crikey, the amount of intelligence and willing, ready-made spies we had at our disposal who we simply transported to some remote dump and held for 5 years. What a waste.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 22 Jul 16 11.52am

I think this is a shut the gate after the horse has bolted idea in truth.

I believe it is always reviewed retrospectively as a shameful event when particular nationalities are interned or deported during war time. One often loses sight of the actual intention which is to protect the population or the nation. In reality, the value of these events in the past are definitely in question.
As far as I'm aware, there was no "enemy" attack by Germans, Italians etc, living in Britain prior or during WW2 and this is a key difference to current events and the Irish troubles where Muslims and Catholics were involved in attacks on the mainland. For that reason alone, I think there is definitely a case to ban all Muslim immigration. There would be an outcry from the liberals but as a father and husband I place the safety of my family way above politics, religion or the needs of immigrants. The moral arguments are therefore secondary to me.
Could deportation or internment be another option? I think we must be very careful to remember that a very large chunk of the British Muslim population hate ISIS as much as the rest of us. I would be more inclined to encourage Muslims to embrace Western culture but be very harsh in dealing with sympathisers as there can be no IRA style negotiation.
Given the current escalating problems, I would think it wise to an open mind and keep all options on the table.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (22 Jul 2016 11.52am)

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 22 Jul 16 12.01pm

Originally posted by silvertop

And of course we didn't intern anyone in either War. Crikey, the amount of intelligence and willing, ready-made spies we had at our disposal who we simply transported to some remote dump and held for 5 years. What a waste.

I believe that we did use such people in WW2 for espionage purposes. Read up about the SOE and its activities.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

BritofQatar Flag Manchester 22 Jul 16 12.24pm

All rather embarrassing this message board some people's lack of knowledge on the subject is worrying. The generalisation that all Muslims are Arabs is far from true I think the top ten most populated Islamic countries only Iran (Arab/Middle East) is in the list the remainder are from India, Malaysia etc. Generalising all Muslims are Arabs doing wrong is so far from the truth... And for record I have been living in the Middle East for the last 5 years as an immigrant... Interesting reading from both parts of the word on these issues.

Edited by BritofQatar (22 Jul 2016 12.25pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 22 Jul 16 12.37pm

The biggest argument against a ban on Muslim immigration is the practical issues.
How would you deploy such a policy?
Would you be selective about which countries it applied to?
Is it even legal in peace time?

I think there is a stronger case to be selective of individuals rather than an entire religion but the value of such a policy would be hard to assess in practical terms beyond the intuitive idea of less Muslims equals less terrorists. There would be no honour in doing it just to yield to public opinion or win votes.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 22 Jul 16 12.40pm

Originally posted by BritofQatar

All rather embarrassing this message board some people's lack of knowledge on the subject is worrying. The generalisation that all Muslims are Arabs is far from true I think the top ten most populated Islamic countries only Iran (Arab/Middle East) is in the list the remainder are from India, Malaysia etc. Generalising all Muslims are Arabs doing wrong is so far from the truth... And for record I have been living in the Middle East for the last 5 years as an immigrant... Interesting reading from both parts of the word on these issues.

Edited by BritofQatar (22 Jul 2016 12.25pm)

No, I wont have that.

Many of them are British.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Jul 16 4.50pm

Originally posted by topcat

I don't think you read the post from Mapletree correctly. He was (obviously sarcastically) calling on banning US police officers because of the number of people they kill, you are the one that assumed he meant black people.

No I didn't, you obviously didn't read my post correctly. I knew he wasn't making a point about a racial group.

I introduced the racial point and its connection to violence to counter the regular unbalanced propaganda pushed by the left on Police in general and American Police specifically.


Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jul 2016 5.01pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Jul 16 4.57pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Most Kurds are also Muslim, a fact that most people tend to forget when talking about Muslims. In around 75-80% of those fighting IS are Muslim.

Many Kurds are Muslims with a small m. A lot are also secular Muslims.


Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jul 2016 5.06pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Jul 16 5.12pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

It probably hurt the American war effort more than it helped anyone as well. Absurdly stupid decision, for purely ignorant reasons that denied the US access to a huge resource.

Yeah, hugely damaging.....?

These comments are pure revisionism with no knowledge of what might of happened if no internment happened. There is no telling how many attacks it stopped.....from zero to many.

I think its naivete to suggest that America had no reason to worry.


Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jul 2016 8.03pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Jamesrichards8 Flag 22 Jul 16 6.03pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Yeah, hugely damaging.....?

These comments are pure revisionism with no knowledge of what might of happened if no internment happened. They is no telling how many attacks it stopped.....from zero to many.

I think its naivete to suggest that America had no reason to worry.

Of course you're right.
Unfortunately the political correctness of today's society makes Japanese internment an instant 'frown-upon' subject. Many on this site would rather risk the lives of actual natural born citizens than make a difficult, yet controversial decision. It may not be pleasant, but as I said before, times of great turmoil require such an approach.
I don't agree with the argument that, because it's 'indeterminable' how many lives would actually be saved by restricting Islamic immigration, to do so would be a pointless act. The point is you are using your knowledge of the demographics of the typical enemy and making an informed decision in order to keep as many out as possible. It's like saying that air bags are useless because it's impossible to say how many lives they will save in the next year. Make an informed decision based on probability.
I also do not agree that, because the majority of anti-IS fighters are Muslim, to restrict Islamic immigration would alienate that group? Huh? will the anti-IS groups suddenly sympathize with Isis because the UK is securing their borders after Isis affirmed they would send operatives among refugees? I don't think anyone would blame us. The more I think about it, the more it seems like weak-hearted liberal nonsense to avoid this inevitable decision

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 22 Jul 16 6.06pm

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

Of course you're right.
Unfortunately the political correctness of today's society makes Japanese internment an instant 'frown-upon' subject. Many on this site would rather risk the lives of actual natural born citizens than make a difficult, yet controversial decision. It may not be pleasant, but as I said before, times of great turmoil require such an approach.
I don't agree with the argument that, because it's 'indeterminable' how many lives would actually be saved by restricting Islamic immigration, to do so would be a pointless act. The point is you are using your knowledge of the demographics of the typical enemy and making an informed decision in order to keep as many out as possible. It's like saying that air bags are useless because it's impossible to say how many lives they will save in the next year. Make an informed decision based on probability.
I also do not agree that, because the majority of anti-IS fighters are Muslim, to restrict Islamic immigration would alienate that group? Huh? will the anti-IS groups suddenly sympathize with Isis because the UK is securing their borders after Isis affirmed they would send operatives among refugees? I don't think anyone would blame us. The more I think about it, the more it seems like weak-hearted liberal nonsense to avoid this inevitable decision

How is it in any way inevitable? There was a reason the world laughed when Trump proposed this in the States - it's too nonsensical to even consider.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 22 Jul 16 6.37pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

How is it in any way inevitable? There was a reason the world laughed when Trump proposed this in the States - it's too nonsensical to even consider.

Trump is a self serving politician but the more of us die in attacks the less people will laugh.

 

Jamesrichards8 Flag 22 Jul 16 6.46pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

How is it in any way inevitable? There was a reason the world laughed when Trump proposed this in the States - it's too nonsensical to even consider.

The world laughed, did they? Which media sources are you using, out of curiosity? Because I think far fewer people laughed than the media might suggest. I am currently in California, with family, and no one that I've spoken to is laughing about that proposition. Actually, especially after the new attacks today, I would say that it won him many followers.

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

legaleagle Flag 22 Jul 16 7.06pm

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

Of course you're right.
Unfortunately the political correctness of today's society makes Japanese internment an instant 'frown-upon' subject. Many on this site would rather risk the lives of actual natural born citizens than make a difficult, yet controversial decision.
It may not be pleasant, but as I said before, times of great turmoil require such an approach.

....................................................

Forgive my "correctness" let alone "political correctness" but you seem to be somewhat overlooking the fact that the internment was a bulk one of all Americans of Japanese ancestry...including "natural native born citizens" who's families had been in the US for some generations.....or can "natural born citizens" only ever apply to WASPS?

James Ellroy's recent novel "Perfidia" is interesting about the internment.It's fiction but nonetheless shines a light on the essential randomness and corruption underlying the process in Southern California

Edited by legaleagle (22 Jul 2016 7.07pm)

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 22 Jul 16 10.00pm

Originally posted by Straightbackup

Sorry mate but you simply can't compare the internment of the Japanese with what's happening today - they are entirely different scenarios.
And your talk of 'net deaths' is also a moot point because you can't possibly quantify how many people will die in the future as a result of the marginalisation of all Muslims in the name of today stopping the 'odd terrorist getting through'
The reason these attacks are being carried out by nationals of the countries in which these terrorist live (and were often born) is in part due to exactly this fact- a minute proportion of Muslims feel extremely marginalised by their treatment at the hands of bigots and Islamaphobes and to an extent what they are seeing in the sensationalist media.
Add some serious mental health issues to the mix and what do you get? A lunatic who is fighting a 'holy war' that doesn't YET exist in the name of an organisation that know that the only way they can ever win is for WW3 to come to fruition. Because they are also f***ing insane

Nail on head.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Jamesrichards8 Flag 22 Jul 16 10.37pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Nail on head.

I fail to understand. The Muslim who stabbed the women in France for offending him with their comparative state of undress was feeling marginalized by islamophobic society? No. He was annoyed at the cultural differences when it was HE who was in the foreign country. Are we supposed to change our cultural values and limit our freedom of expression to prevent the poor radicals from feeling marginalized? What a democracy. An alien minority can influence the actions of the majority. Some of these posts make me sick

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (22 Jul 2016 10.40pm)

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 22 Jul 16 11.06pm

Originally posted by Straightbackup

Sorry mate but you simply can't compare the internment of the Japanese with what's happening today - they are entirely different scenarios.
And your talk of 'net deaths' is also a moot point because you can't possibly quantify how many people will die in the future as a result of the marginalisation of all Muslims in the name of today stopping the 'odd terrorist getting through'
The reason these attacks are being carried out by nationals of the countries in which these terrorist live (and were often born) is in part due to exactly this fact- a minute proportion of Muslims feel extremely marginalised by their treatment at the hands of bigots and Islamaphobes and to an extent what they are seeing in the sensationalist media.
Add some serious mental health issues to the mix and what do you get? A lunatic who is fighting a 'holy war' that doesn't YET exist in the name of an organisation that know that the only way they can ever win is for WW3 to come to fruition. Because they are also f***ing insane


Excuse me but I do believe you are talking utter b@llocks.

What about all the Indians, Jews, Africans etc who have settled in Europe over the past 50 years. These people you could argue have just as much reason to feel disenfranchised however they don’t result to mindless killings.

Making excuses for these dicks whilst trying to put the blame on society is frankly pathetic.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Jul 16 11.54pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Nail on head.

Not really.

It's a reality that extreme interpretations of various Islamic texts give validity to killing the enemies of Islam.

Islam is only a peaceful religion to those who choose that interpretation of it.....unfortunately if you wish to interpret otherwise there are plenty of violent verses and instructions to follow.

Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jul 2016 11.56pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Straightbackup Flag Crystal Palace 23 Jul 16 12.53am

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

I fail to understand. The Muslim who stabbed the women in France for offending him with their comparative state of undress was feeling marginalized by islamophobic society? No. He was annoyed at the cultural differences when it was HE who was in the foreign country. Are we supposed to change our cultural values and limit our freedom of expression to prevent the poor radicals from feeling marginalized? What a democracy. An alien minority can influence the actions of the majority. Some of these posts make me sick

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (22 Jul 2016 10.40pm)


Mate, the bloke is mentally ill- the only difference is that the agenda from the right wing red-top comics have to point out that he's Muslim. If he was a white, drug abusing alcoholic who turned on his neighbours because his imaginary friend told him to do it would he be doing it because he was Baptised?
Stop trying to justify the irrational actions of a f***ing idiot as a religious cause- it's utter boll***s

 


'Impulse' advert- Advertising campaign whose slogan is expected to change in the light of Rajiv Gandhi's assassination: 'If someone you don't know suddenly offers you flowers- run like f***!'

Straightbackup Flag Crystal Palace 23 Jul 16 12.54am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Not really.

It's a reality that extreme interpretations of various Islamic texts give validity to killing the enemies of Islam.

Islam is only a peaceful religion to those who choose that interpretation of it.....unfortunately if you wish to interpret otherwise there are plenty of violent verses and instructions to follow.

Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jul 2016 11.56pm)

Pardon the irony but Jesus titty f***ing Christ. Have you read a Bible???

 


'Impulse' advert- Advertising campaign whose slogan is expected to change in the light of Rajiv Gandhi's assassination: 'If someone you don't know suddenly offers you flowers- run like f***!'

Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ban Islamic immigration. Yes or no?