You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?
November 16 2026 11.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?


Page 3 of 12 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
chateauferret Flag 23 Oct 16 9.57pm

Originally posted by palace-metros

If only it were that simple eh? Out of interest, how do you think we would fare if all EPL teams concentrated on getting results and playing to their strengths which is apparently your rather simplistic view of footballing success. Or are you suggesting that every other team is playing to their maximum potential except CPFC?

I get a bit frustrated that some of our own supporters do not seem to understand that we do not have strength in depth because we are only a fifth year EPL club. We simply haven't got the clout to pay £50-60k per week for back up players to sit on the bench and frankly the players of quality we would need to cover every position wouldn't want to sit on the bench at Palace - not yet. Demanding instant or near instant success also means that we will only ever buy in first XI players from now on. So forget youth development. If the fan base will not allow time for a change in playing style, experimenting with youth players has got no chance.

It isn't my view of "success" at all, merely a more appropriate approach for where we are now than talking as though we're Barcelona. For the time being, anyway.

Funnily enough you go on to cite some of the reasons why I said what I said, so perhaps you'd better check that you disagree with me before biting my head off.

And I don't give a twopenny toss what other clubs do because I don't support them.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Oct 16 10.04pm

Originally posted by rikz

And we go to Europe and get a manager that gives us one great season. Then he just uses us as a stepping stone like koeman, pochettino and goes to a bigger Club and we are back to square 1

This is where thereabouts one of the issues lies.

We just need to survive and a bit more without season long danger. AP will probably deliver. The problems with overhauling is not one a chairman with a long term plan views as good business, and that includes football club business as well, especially when the club is 25 to 30 years behind the field and all the plans SP has. We just have to accept it if we don't like it for whatever reason.


Edited by Rudi Hedman (23 Oct 2016 10.08pm)

 


COYP

Matlock Flag matlock Derbyshire 23 Oct 16 10.12pm

You are spot on mstrobez everything you say is dead right to many palace fans looking at clueless Pardew though rose tinted glasses time for a change

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 23 Oct 16 10.13pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Or will we be branded as "fake fans" and "bed wetters".

The smugness from some fans was almost as cringeworthy as the smugness from himself after beating stoke Sunderland and Boro.

In the last 31 (yes, 31) games we've won 5 - that includes the 3 mentioned above.

Someone please make a case given our first 11, which genuinely has quality, that that is good enough.

All this "team in transition" is aload of turd as well. When we win games like we did against stoke it's because of the players we have on the pitch and the fact Pardew likes high intensity and power. Besides that he is clearly tactically inept - I thought that even when we were on a good run.

Expecting to get a fair bit of abuse and contemplated saying anything but in fairness I don't really care - some people really need to wake up.

Edited by Mstrobez (23 Oct 2016 4.48pm)

Yes it's absolutely outrageous. We have played 9 games and are only 11th in the table. Any other manager would have had us in the top 3 and flying high....let's keep changing managers until that happens...it will so work.
As for changing style, retaining possession and playing out from the back ... yes let's give up on that too. I really miss watching that old Palace that couldn't string 3 passes together and would just hoof it out and hope for a lucky bounce.

 

Aray Flag South London 23 Oct 16 10.19pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Or will we be branded as "fake fans" and "bed wetters".

The smugness from some fans was almost as cringeworthy as the smugness from himself after beating stoke Sunderland and Boro.

In the last 31 (yes, 31) games we've won 5 - that includes the 3 mentioned above.

Someone please make a case given our first 11, which genuinely has quality, that that is good enough.

All this "team in transition" is aload of turd as well. When we win games like we did against stoke it's because of the players we have on the pitch and the fact Pardew likes high intensity and power. Besides that he is clearly tactically inept - I thought that even when we were on a good run.

Expecting to get a fair bit of abuse and contemplated saying anything but in fairness I don't really care - some people really need to wake up.

Edited by Mstrobez (23 Oct 2016 4.48pm)

To answer the question succinctly. No

Clearly you're not a fan - fair enough. But your argument is silly. We've only won 5 out of 31...but you want someone to make the case that is acceptable given our CURRENT starting 11???!!!!

Anyway...What's he done this season that's so wrong? We're creating chances and not being ripped apart.

You would have to admit it was bad luck to lose Punch at such short notice - he's a key player for us as is Soare and of course Dann.

As for the game. We could have been one nil up had Benteke's header in the first half not hit the post.

Do you think that Manure were good enough today with their starting 11? Think they should fire Jose?

Teams and individuals play badly sometimes. Yesterday I thought we had a number of poor performances. But is that the coach's fault? If it happens too often maybe but we've had some good games so far this season.

We are 11th in the league. That'll do a quarter of the way into the season.


Edited by Aray (23 Oct 2016 10.19pm)

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 23 Oct 16 10.56pm

Originally posted by Matlock

You are spot on mstrobez everything you say is dead right to many palace fans looking at clueless Pardew though rose tinted glasses time for a change

Irony or do you have a suggestion for AP s replacement?

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 24 Oct 16 12.04am

Originally posted by sickboy

Irony or do you have a suggestion for AP s replacement?

He is more ill than Sickboy I fear.

And I very much doubt he could name a replacement.

Irony doesn't exist on this board. But sarcasm and insult is rife.

Hope that helps.....

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

citizensmudge Flag midlands 24 Oct 16 4.50am

Originally posted by bubble wrap

OP is entitled to have his say, why should he feck off and support another team? think you might be better off at Millwall with your potty mouth, you mentioned M.United and Chelsea in the same post absolute filfth.

And I'm entitled to have mine sunshine so jog on.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 24 Oct 16 7.56am

If you are a manager in the PL of a mid or lower-mid table team and you have have any sort of success you are invariably snapped up by a bigger team. To my mind only Ranieri and possibly Howe have the full backing of their supporters plus some modicum of success in the PL last season. This says a lot about the state of the modern football fan; the gimme more generation. If any of the three promoted teams fail to stay up then their managers will probably lose the confidence of some supporters too.

I look down the table and I would say probably two thirds of the teams currently have whinging, over-expectant fans complaining their manager is rubbish. Personally I think we have one of the best teams that I can remember in the last 25 years and we are making a real effort to play better football. I would be incredibly surprised if anyone could find a manager who would do better with what we have and who would want to come to us.

Also, we're only three points off Manure right now

Edited by taylors lovechild (24 Oct 2016 8.00am)

 

The Dolphin Flag 24 Oct 16 8.33am

I too think that the word "slate" is probably harsh.
I am not a Pardew lover at all and I think that long term he will cost us money without achieving much - yes I know we got to an FA Cup final but we lost and if he had anything about him he would have called the players over after we scored and told them what to do in the lst 8 minutes instead of doing a stupid dance!
We have to see what happens this season but he has some good players at the club now and he needs to make it work - there are no excuses in my opinion.
We should be able to achieve at least 50 points this season with our current squad but already we have dropped points at home against West Brom, Bournemouth and West Ham - we got 1 point from those three games - I expected 6 minimum.
We don't look like scoring unless it is through Benteke (yes - I know Stoke - but they were truly awful that day)and he alone will not score the goals we need.
We ball watch, we don't mark closely enough, we are not aggressive enough, we have no real Leader on the field - the list goes on.
AP needs to sharpen up and get Palace back to a team who fights when things aren't going so well - I just don't see that Palace spirit anymore and in my opinion there is only one man responsible for that I'm afraid!
I love Palace - I have supported them for over 50 years and just because I don't like the Manager will not stop me supporting them and wanting us to win every game.
I hope he proves me ridiculously wrong!

Edited by The Dolphin (24 Oct 2016 8.34am)

 

Mikep1981 Flag Sutton 24 Oct 16 8.46am

Alan Pardew teams have never had the best defensive reord. This is whats letting us down at the moment, whether a good defensive coach can help this not sure.

Being in the premier league for our longest period has raised all our expectations i think we are a 10-15 place team i cant see us breaking into top 10 for couple of years if we stay up.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 24 Oct 16 9.22am

Originally posted by Mikep1981

Alan Pardew teams have never had the best defensive reord. This is whats letting us down at the moment, whether a good defensive coach can help this not sure.

Being in the premier league for our longest period has raised all our expectations i think we are a 10-15 place team i cant see us breaking into top 10 for couple of years if we stay up.

What do you think will happen in the next couple of years then to change this?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 24 Oct 16 9.28am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

To my mind only Ranieri and possibly Howe have the full backing of their supporters plus some modicum of success in the PL last season.

I had to laugh when I read winning the Premiership being described as just a "modicum of success" but hey ho, this is HOL after all

 

Part Time James Flag 24 Oct 16 9.33am

I think this forum could be the best forum ever for neutral supporters to come and have a read of. Gawd bless you all.

 




Painter Flag Croydon 24 Oct 16 9.43am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I too think that the word "slate" is probably harsh.
I am not a Pardew lover at all and I think that long term he will cost us money without achieving much - yes I know we got to an FA Cup final but we lost and if he had anything about him he would have called the players over after we scored and told them what to do in the lst 8 minutes instead of doing a stupid dance!
We have to see what happens this season but he has some good players at the club now and he needs to make it work - there are no excuses in my opinion.
We should be able to achieve at least 50 points this season with our current squad but already we have dropped points at home against West Brom, Bournemouth and West Ham - we got 1 point from those three games - I expected 6 minimum.
We don't look like scoring unless it is through Benteke (yes - I know Stoke - but they were truly awful that day)and he alone will not score the goals we need.
We ball watch, we don't mark closely enough, we are not aggressive enough, we have no real Leader on the field - the list goes on.
AP needs to sharpen up and get Palace back to a team who fights when things aren't going so well - I just don't see that Palace spirit anymore and in my opinion there is only one man responsible for that I'm afraid!
I love Palace - I have supported them for over 50 years and just because I don't like the Manager will not stop me supporting them and wanting us to win every game.
I hope he proves me ridiculously wrong!

Edited by The Dolphin (24 Oct 2016 8.34am)

Not really into slating the manager, as ultimately it's the players who let us down. In defence of Pardew, he has no worse than any other manager in the last 25 years, in my view better than most.

Wishing for better things is natural, but not always achievable. Man Utd have a so called super manager, the most expensive player in the world, one of the most expensive squads, but still look rubbish.

It's not an easy job, this is the most competitive league in the world.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 24 Oct 16 9.58am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I had to laugh when I read winning the Premiership being described as just a "modicum of success" but hey ho, this is HOL after all

I only added modicum because I included Bournemouth. Your nit-picking hyperbolic response is more common place. I hope you, Snow White and the other dwarves get to laugh at this post too.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 24 Oct 16 10.10am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Leicester on paper aren't better than us really. People are getting carried away because they won the league - would swap Fuchs with Kelly, Huth or Morgan with Damo and Mahrez with townsends but other than that I don't see any superiority "on paper". My biggest issue with Pardew is I don't see any improvement - if results were poor but you could see evidence of us evolving then fair enough but it's bulls*** in my opinion. Tactically we have looked completely lost for a long long time and we only ever seem to look good when we do the exact thing pardew supposedly wants to come away from which is sitting deep and nicking a couple by set pieces/on the break. The reason we are good at those things are because of the defensive foundations laid out by Pulis.

Under pardew, as time goes on, we look weaker and weaker at the back - regardless of injuries. It's all well and good saying you want to change the style of play but the goals we've scored this season have typically mainly been from set pieces or headers from Benteke. The only change I see is us looking more flimsy at the back.

My point is we should expect to win more games given players we've signed under him, if we go on a little 3 game run it's nice but I honestly do not think many managers would've struggled to beat Sunderland Stoke and Boro with the players we had at our disposal. I just don't see us pushing on and fulfilling our actual potential under Pardew.

if you think we're as good as the League winners then there's no point in trying to put forward a rational argument as to whether Pards/Palace are any good/should be doing better

 

Hoof Hearted 24 Oct 16 10.20am

i agree with a lot of the sentiment on here from both sides.

I can see where the OP is coming from.... it doesn't take much for us to slip back in form does it?

I want to know why we don't "press" teams? Okazaki was closing us down like his life depended on it, and Ward let him go to score their 2nd. Where was our urgency, fight or spirit that Okazaki showed?

I also agree with the rest in that now is not the time to "slate" Pardew. We would have benefited on Saturday if Dann and Puncheon played, but even so Leicester City away is a fixture we traditionally lose 2-0. As it was we dominated the first half hour and didn't turn this into goals.... it's not Pardew's fault Benteke didn't score with that header or last week's penalty is it?

I expect we will lose again on Saturday v Liverpool according to recent form, but hope we don't.

Pardew and Parrish are slowly improving the club in my opinion, and we have to be patient, but it doesn't hurt to have a discussion about our progress every now and then.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 24 Oct 16 10.27am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

i agree with a lot of the sentiment on here from both sides.

I can see where the OP is coming from.... it doesn't take much for us to slip back in form does it?

Pardew and Parish are slowly improving the club in my opinion, and we have to be patient, but it doesn't hurt to have a discussion about our progress every now and then.

Quite so.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 24 Oct 16 10.58am

I can have some sympathy with the frustration, as one minute we are quality and the next very poor.

However, that said, this is our 4th full season in the top flight. Look at the other teams who have been around that long: West Brom, Sunderland, Swansea, Southampton, West Ham and Leicester. Now three of those had very good seasons, two of them were anomalous and the other because they are a very well run club.

Given that, is expecting to finish top 10 in a league with the old big 4 plus Man City, Spurs and Leicester that realistic when you also have teams like Southampton and Everton?

Change doesn't happen over night (99% of the time) and of it does, that can be very detrimental (see: QPR, Cardiff, ManUre, Spurs back in the day..).

Slating Pardew isn't the answer when we've lost a bad game in shocking rain and another versus the champions of England.

 


[Link]

Page 3 of 12 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?