You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Buy Back Clause
November 22 2026 8.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Buy Back Clause


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Jul 17 5.02pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

It wouldn't be so bad if the players were brought up through their academies but they aren't as they just buy up talent and loan them out for others to develop.

Whatever happened to Michael Hector who we were after a couple of years ago but who signed for Chelsea instead and disappeared into obscurity?

Wasn't he loaned back to Reading then was loaned out to a German club last season ? Don't know specific details so will need to check.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 26 Jul 17 5.13pm

Originally posted by Willo

A contractual negotiation and agreement between the buying club and selling club.If the buying club is content with the transfer agreement then fine - they have got the player they want.

Perhaps our club would enter into a similar deal with a club wishing to purchase one of our assets in similar circumstances.

Hey Wilo my point isn't that clubs don't have a choice my point is market saturation to some extent takes that choice away.

Maybe if there was a limit to how many players clubs could loan out and sell with buy back clauses or if those clauses had more of a market lead reduced saving then I'd feel different.

But honestly I feel we are looking at the tip of a very big iceberg that's gonna come crashing in to the Prem.

Very easy to take the simplistic view that the buying club doesn't have to agree. Until you look at how saturated the division is with loaned out talent from the top clubs.

Next move we are just now seeing, is them trying to insert buy back clauses.

This is just the start.

And as for maybe our club will do the same, sorry that doesn't make it right. (I don't think)

Edited by Goldfiinger (26 Jul 2017 5.15pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Jul 17 5.25pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Hey Wilo my point isn't that clubs don't have a choice my point is market saturation to some extent takes that choice away.

Maybe if there was a limit to how many players clubs could loan out and sell with buy back clauses or if those clauses had more of a market lead reduced saving then I'd feel different.

But honestly I feel we are looking at the tip of a very big iceberg that's gonna come crashing in to the Prem.

Very easy to take the simplistic view that the buying club doesn't have to agree. Until you look at how saturated the division is with loaned out talent from the top clubs.

Next move we are just now seeing, is them trying to insert buy back clauses.

This is just the start.

And as for maybe our club will do the same, sorry that doesn't make it right. (I don't think)

Edited by Goldfiinger (26 Jul 2017 5.15pm)

We have just loaned Loftus-Creek - are our supporters saying we are developing him for Chelsea's benefit ?

Huddersfield went up with positive contributions from loanees from Liverpool, Man C, Chelsea.Didn't do them any harm !

And we,a PL club loaned out Boateng,KaiKai,Anderson,Ladapo etc - we all hope they have come back as better players !

Edited by Willo (26 Jul 2017 5.25pm)

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 26 Jul 17 5.58pm

can someone explain why the small club can't look elsewhere if a big club insists on an unreasonable buyback?

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 26 Jul 17 6.26pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

can someone explain why the small club can't look elsewhere if a big club insists on an unreasonable buyback?

Of course they can, the point is...

The big clubs buy all of young players and leave a very small pool for the rest.

Now they're able to buy even more knowing that can simply loan or sell them on and buy them back..

The problem is isn't that they do it the problem is the saturation causes smaller clubs to have LESS choice elsewhere.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 26 Jul 17 6.31pm

Originally posted by Willo

We have just loaned Loftus-Creek - are our supporters saying we are developing him for Chelsea's benefit ?

Huddersfield went up with positive contributions from loanees from Liverpool, Man C, Chelsea.Didn't do them any harm !

And we,a PL club loaned out Boateng,KaiKai,Anderson,Ladapo etc - we all hope they have come back as better players !

Edited by Willo (26 Jul 2017 5.25pm)

Thanks for making my case in point, the market is saturated with loan players. Now imagine if everyone sells there players with buy back clauses. Surely that benefits the larger clubs far far more than it would the smaller clubs.

I guess the counter argument is every transfer is done like this even when a United buys a player from a scunthorpe. Let them have a buy back clause set £10m above the price and they can buy them back when there worth £160m !

FACT is the uber rich elite would never let that happen, and the agent of the young lad would never put that clause in place.

So therefore it dramatically only helps the rich get richer.

If you can't understand that and want to keep repeating that everyone has a choice then ok be simplistic

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 26 Jul 17 6.34pm

There is a 'limit' of talent available. Rich clubs have a 'monopoly' of that talent. The 'market' is broken. Therefore there needs to be an 'adjustment' made to make the 'market' work properly.

Surely even a die-hard conservative can see that 'intervention' is needed.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 26 Jul 17 6.43pm

Originally posted by Willo

We have just loaned Loftus-Creek - are our supporters saying we are developing him for Chelsea's benefit ?

Huddersfield went up with positive contributions from loanees from Liverpool, Man C, Chelsea.Didn't do them any harm !

And we,a PL club loaned out Boateng,KaiKai,Anderson,Ladapo etc - we all hope they have come back as better players !

Edited by Willo (26 Jul 2017 5.25pm)

How is it good for football that a team can get promoted with half of their team being loan players, they don't even own. How is that fair or right?

Half there prize money goes where? Straight back to the top super clubs so they can pay more loan fees.

Rich get richer by strangling the market.

But yes Wilo that's right, fair and good for the sport. Ok

 

majorkaios Flag Trowbridge, Wilts 26 Jul 17 7.11pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Actually, selling property and recoup8ng a % of an increase in value where planning consent is secured is quite common. They are called overage clauses. You make the buyer do all the work but both sides benefit if the clause is well drafted.

Likewise, if this provision is properly drafted, why shouldn't we do ok? Say the clause doesnt bite for 3 years and he is the nuts. We get a brilliant player on an extended "loan" and get 50% of what we paid back. Who says he will continue to be that good. And how else would we secure a player who is that good and has that much experience in this league for such a young age for such a price in this crazy market?

The ideal thing, of course, is to stay in this league, continue to grow, develop a well stocked academy and thus become a club that makes use of these provisions.

Agreed COYP ... Adding a few solid cup runs into the bargain may help to boost revenues as well.

 


School, SN.Juniors, SN High, Selhurst. 1st match 1972 CP 2 N. Utd 1. Thank you, John Jackson and Vince Hilair for brightening our darkest days. I moved to the west country in 1983. Always Proud and 'Glad All Over' to be a Palace Fan. ))

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 26 Jul 17 7.41pm

But back Claude.

IMG_0739.JPG Attachment: IMG_0739.JPG (24.12Kb)

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

coulsdoneagle Flag London 26 Jul 17 8.01pm

But back clauses are particularly unfair with a set price. Ultimately these big clubs can afford to monopolise the young talent and ensure they are protected when letting them go. I think first refusal is okay. As Arsenal had with Fabregas when he went back to Chelsea, it ensures that should the player leave the club can get him but doesn't limit the potential the selling club can make, or force their hand to sell an asset that they have grown.

buy back clauses are unfair but it's unlikely to change because it favours the bigger teams and that's the way this league is going.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 26 Jul 17 8.10pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Of course they can, the point is...

The big clubs buy all of young players and leave a very small pool for the rest.

Now they're able to buy even more knowing that can simply loan or sell them on and buy them back..

The problem is isn't that they do it the problem is the saturation causes smaller clubs to have LESS choice elsewhere.

so all the big clubs have more talent than they need and all the small clubs have less. correct?

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 26 Jul 17 8.31pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

But back clauses are particularly unfair with a set price. Ultimately these big clubs can afford to monopolise the young talent and ensure they are protected when letting them go. I think first refusal is okay. As Arsenal had with Fabregas when he went back to Chelsea, it ensures that should the player leave the club can get him but doesn't limit the potential the selling club can make, or force their hand to sell an asset that they have grown.

buy back clauses are unfair but it's unlikely to change because it favours the bigger teams and that's the way this league is going.

This is the reason the PL was invented. So that the elite in England could catch up with their continental counterparts. And boy have some of them caught up

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 26 Jul 17 9.30pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

so all the big clubs have more talent than they need and all the small clubs have less. correct?

Yes so the big get bigger and the small are impeded by the market and haven't got the same fair opportunity to grow.

The larger clubs suck up all the youth players and now instead of just loaning them out, we are about to witness the start of them selling them with clauses which mean they'll let all the other clubs give them exposure and train them, just so they can hedge there bets and not disturb their first team with players who may or may not make it. Then buy them back at a stupidly low mark up.

It'll control the market far far worse than the loan system.

But it seems many think now we're in the big time it matters not as long as we get in on the action.

Sorry but I thought that's the type of things 'our' fans don't like.

Edited by Goldfiinger (26 Jul 2017 9.37pm)

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 26 Jul 17 9.33pm

I believe buy back clauses are banned in France.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 26 Jul 17 9.33pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Yes so the big get bigger and the small are impeded by the market and haven't got the same fair opportunity to grow.

It's been this way for years. We've been in the PL for 5 years now but haven't really made any headway on the big teams. We've got a much better first team to show for the time we have been up there. Maybe a few tweaks to the infrastructure and a raising of our profile. That's about it though.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 26 Jul 17 9.39pm

And buy back clauses are going to make it a thousand times harder for clubs to grow.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 26 Jul 17 9.43pm

The kicker is...

The clubs buying back the player don't even have to offer them first team football. I.e. They could have far better players themselves and still take them back if they can then sell them on for more...

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 26 Jul 17 9.51pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

The kicker is...

The clubs buying back the player don't even have to offer them first team football. I.e. They could have far better players themselves and still take them back if they can then sell them on for more...

You really seem to be pants wetting today.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 26 Jul 17 10.26pm

lol fair point.

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Buy Back Clause