You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Max Meyer thread


Page 3 of 27 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
CrazyBadger Flag Ware 05 Nov 18 4.25pm

Originally posted by Bangell

This looks great in theory, but of course we have nobody capable of being an effective lone striker. Also, it's a very offensive formation unless we snap back into a 4-5-1 off the ball - and do we think we can rely on Wilf to stick to defending down the flank, or think that this would be an effective use of his talent?

That said, this would have been a formation worth trying even with a dud Ayew up front against ultra-defensive Newcastle at home.

Kelly - Tomkins - Sakho
AWB - Luka - Kouyate - PVA
Meyer
Townsend - Zaha

Edited by CrazyBadger (05 Nov 2018 4.25pm)

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

kayjaybee Flag orpington 05 Nov 18 4.29pm

For me, after zaha he would be next on the teamsheet,put him just in front of Luka and kouyate in a roaming role, the guy is absolutely class but is not a defensive midfielder hopefully someone on the coaching staff will make it evident to Roy before he gets the hump and wants away.

 

Kant Flag exeter 05 Nov 18 6.45pm

Too much criticism of Roy here. Meyer was started yesterday and was not especially impressive. His finishing was particularly poor. Given the limited tools at his disposal I think Roy is doing a decent job and if he’d enjoyed the rub of the green we’d now be in a more comfortable position. It’s a shame that we’ve lost the momentum of last season but constantly slagging off Roy’s judgement is getting a little tiresome.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Nov 18 7.06pm

Originally posted by Kant

Too much criticism of Roy here. Meyer was started yesterday and was not especially impressive. His finishing was particularly poor. Given the limited tools at his disposal I think Roy is doing a decent job and if he’d enjoyed the rub of the green we’d now be in a more comfortable position. It’s a shame that we’ve lost the momentum of last season but constantly slagging off Roy’s judgement is getting a little tiresome.

You said it. Meyer’s first game, played on the left. Until Roy alters the rigid formation and tactics there will be frustrated fans. I was frustrated last season but he was delivering the points at an impressive rate. He may have benefited a lot with Cabaye and RLC compared to this season, but to just keep it the same without them, and then not bring the only creative player other than Wilf until only just now, Roy has to look at himself and what he’s doing, as we are.

Meyer is not a defensive midfielder and Luka didn’t defend on his own last season. So what do we play? 4-4-2, with Meyer on the bench, or a few minutes if he’s lucky or a busy game played out of position on the left vs a top 4 team.

Roy is just delaying the inevitable. Get some more creativity with one of a couple of players able to provide any or we’re in serious trouble and Roy may have to go, however it happens.

Roy is a great chap but we’re just hoping for the bounce of the ball this way so far, and we’re not exactly blessed with clinical finishers. Twice we had players having to pass to nobody in the box because they had 3 defenders about to make them surrender the ball. PVA and Zaha in the first half. Who was playing centrally? Nobody creative.

We need goals. Wilf cannot do it on his own but the Arsenal cameo appearance showed what Meyer and Wilf can do. They both occupy and scare defenders. The rest do not.

 


COYP

PatrickA Flag London 05 Nov 18 7.23pm

I hope I’m proved wrong but I don’t think it will work out for Meyer at Palace.
It’s not that he’s a bad player or that Roy is a bad manager.
I’ve observed Roy over a long period and I don’t think I can recall him using this type of player.
His prototype of a midfield player is Morrison at WBA, Murphy at Fulham and Mcarthur with us.
He tends to be very loyal to these consistent, steady players where you know what you’re getting and who suit his conservative approach.
This has served him well over his career so it’s difficult to be too critical.
As others here have pointed out Meyer probably needs to play in a central midfield role with two holding players behind him.
This would enable to him to link the midfield with the forwards.
However, I can’t recall Roy using this system.
He has tried to shoehorn Meyer into a narrow midfield role on the left but it was evident yesterday than, other the first ten minutes, he had no influence on the game and spent his time chasing shadows.
I can’t see Roy starting him ahead of Luka, Mcarthur or Kouyate.

 

the.universal 05 Nov 18 7.56pm

Originally posted by Rogers Don

Played out of position out wide and totally ineffective. He has to play in the centre behind Sorloth with Zaha and Townsend out wide and two defensive players. I would prefer McArthur and Luca, although the latter needs to stop giving the ball away. Meyer should also take the free Kicks and corners instead of Luca.

That’s a front 2 to strike fear into the best defences in the land.

I seriously hope you’re on the wind up.

 


Vive le Roy!

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 05 Nov 18 8.10pm

Thought he started very brightly yesterday and played some neat passes in and around the box. He faded and his finishing wasn't great but that's to be expected of someone who has barely played in the league so far.

Let's also not forget the opposition on the day who could well win the league this season. I want to see him again in a similarly advanced position against weaker opposition where he will have a split second more on the ball and slightly larger gaps to pass into. Still think he is potentially class.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 05 Nov 18 8.59pm

I dont think people are turning against Meyer at all... I think some people, myself included just pointed out that Meyer looked out of his depth yesterday and faded quite badly after a very good first 15-20 minutes.

I'm not sure if the OP is Meyers mum or another family member but he takes it very personally if people criticise Meyer and totally over reacted and said I was 'picking' on Meyer yesterday when I raised this point.

Nobody... no matter how good they are is immune from criticism.. it's not picking on someone or turning against them it's just simply saying what you felt of there performance.

Edited by kennybrowns leftfoot (05 Nov 2018 9.13pm)

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

matthau Flag South Croydon 05 Nov 18 9.27pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

I dont think people are turning against Meyer at all... I think some people, myself included just pointed out that Meyer looked out of his depth yesterday and faded quite badly after a very good first 15-20 minutes.

I'm not sure if the OP is Meyers mum or another family member but he takes it very personally if people criticise Meyer and totally over reacted and said I was 'picking' on Meyer yesterday when I raised this point.

Nobody... no matter how good they are is immune from criticism.. it's not picking on someone or turning against them it's just simply saying what you felt of there performance.

Edited by kennybrowns leftfoot (05 Nov 2018 9.13pm)


He was played out of position. He’s a central attacking no 10 type player and that’s all he can play.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 05 Nov 18 10.26pm

Originally posted by matthau


He was played out of position. He’s a central attacking no 10 type player and that’s all he can play.

Except for the whole of last season when he was a very deep playmaker

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 05 Nov 18 10.35pm

A lot of clutching at straws going on here IMO.

The squad desperately lacks attacking quality / flair and irrespective of what position he's played in Meyer hasn't thus far looked like the player to bring it.

Roy's been dealt a s*** hand with the changes to the squad over the summer.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Nov 18 10.44pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

A lot of clutching at straws going on here IMO.

The squad desperately lacks attacking quality / flair and irrespective of what position he's played in Meyer hasn't thus far looked like the player to bring it.

Roy's been dealt a s*** hand with the changes to the squad over the summer.

Did you watch the Arsenal match?

 


COYP

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 05 Nov 18 11.23pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Did you watch the Arsenal match?

Yes, he did well. Lively and brought a bit of energy when he came on. Also a rare moment of quality with his volley against Wolves. But I didn't see him beat anyone or open up their defence. Noticed he got shrugged off the ball very easily twice in the middle when he had posession.

Not saying he's a bad player but he's being talked up and isn't a replacement for RLC or Cabaye and I've seen little to suggest he's going to create or score a lot of goals.

On the evidence all this season is we have a chronic lack of attacking quality. Roy is doing a good job with very weak options and has been let down by players bottling it in front of goal at key moments.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 06 Nov 18 6.49am

If we play 3 in the middle and can’t afford to have one player (Meyer) who might offer a bit More than blocking tackles and shielding our defence ( if we play 3 like that , then we are using 8 to defend and 3 to attack) , we might aswell call it a day.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 06 Nov 18 7.02am

A lot of people said RLC wasn't good enough when he first signed for us complaining that they couldn't see what all the fuss was about. After he was given more time on the pitch he grew into his role and ended up playing a key role in our survival. Personally I can see the quality that Meyer possesses and I just think he needs a run of games to get up to speed with the PL. I think Roy wants to accommodate him, hence playing without a recognised striker against Chelsea.

I do think people's patience levels are insanely short and in Meyer's case I don't even think he has even played badly. I also think like when Cabaye signed the hype that preceded the signing means that some people think he is supposed to me some sort of Messiah and his failure to live up to that means he is being crucified.

 

A89M Flag Streatham 06 Nov 18 9.21am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

A lot of people said RLC wasn't good enough when he first signed for us complaining that they couldn't see what all the fuss was about. After he was given more time on the pitch he grew into his role and ended up playing a key role in our survival. Personally I can see the quality that Meyer possesses and I just think he needs a run of games to get up to speed with the PL. I think Roy wants to accommodate him, hence playing without a recognised striker against Chelsea.

I do think people's patience levels are insanely short and in Meyer's case I don't even think he has even played badly. I also think like when Cabaye signed the hype that preceded the signing means that some people think he is supposed to me some sort of Messiah and his failure to live up to that means he is being crucified.

Yup. I remember the RLC comments as well and it seems to be the same for Meyer. Regarding his physicality I don't see a problem, its an outdated view in my eyes as the PL is full of slight players who are able to use their ball control to get out of tight areas or draw a foul from it.

Almost every game Meyer has come on, he has given the opposition more to think about than just Wilf e.g Watford away, Arsenal or Wolves. I personally believe he'd flourish as the no.10 but if Roy used him in the same role he did on Sunday against weaker opposition with Wilf drifting out wide also, I can see this working as they seem to have a good connection for such little time together.

Cabaye came in as a creative player who could score goals, he did very little of either but he kept the ball and kept us ticking over and we are now really missing him. Not all players have to either score or create goals to be a real asset to the team.

Edited by A89M (06 Nov 2018 9.23am)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 06 Nov 18 9.41am

Originally posted by A89M

Yup. I remember the RLC comments as well and it seems to be the same for Meyer. Regarding his physicality I don't see a problem, its an outdated view in my eyes as the PL is full of slight players who are able to use their ball control to get out of tight areas or draw a foul from it.

Almost every game Meyer has come on, he has given the opposition more to think about than just Wilf e.g Watford away, Arsenal or Wolves. I personally believe he'd flourish as the no.10 but if Roy used him in the same role he did on Sunday against weaker opposition with Wilf drifting out wide also, I can see this working as they seem to have a good connection for such little time together.

Cabaye came in as a creative player who could score goals, he did very little of either but he kept the ball and kept us ticking over and we are now really missing him. Not all players have to either score or create goals to be a real asset to the team.

Edited by A89M (06 Nov 2018 9.23am)

That's a sensible post that sums Meyer up nicely. He is in my opinion a very good player, but as you also allude to, he is never going to be a Cabaye replacement. If anyone is going to try and fill those boots out of our current squad it has to be Reidewald or Kouyate, neither of which currently appear able to.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Nov 18 9.44am

Originally posted by A89M

Yup. I remember the RLC comments as well and it seems to be the same for Meyer. Regarding his physicality I don't see a problem, its an outdated view in my eyes as the PL is full of slight players who are able to use their ball control to get out of tight areas or draw a foul from it.

Almost every game Meyer has come on, he has given the opposition more to think about than just Wilf e.g Watford away, Arsenal or Wolves. I personally believe he'd flourish as the no.10 but if Roy used him in the same role he did on Sunday against weaker opposition with Wilf drifting out wide also, I can see this working as they seem to have a good connection for such little time together.

Cabaye came in as a creative player who could score goals, he did very little of either but he kept the ball and kept us ticking over and we are now really missing him. Not all players have to either score or create goals to be a real asset to the team.

Edited by A89M (06 Nov 2018 9.23am)

Perhaps we could do with a Cesc Fabregas, or a Pablo Hernandez to provide that creative spark.

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 06 Nov 18 10.22am

Originally posted by Willo

Perhaps we could do with a Cesc Fabregas, or a Pablo Hernandez to provide that creative spark.

Perhaps. However, we signed Meyer, who is quality as far as I can tell, and as far as the much better informed than me pundits say. If we are going to pay all this money for him then we should play to his strengths.

I question whether we can find a system that puts Zaha and Meyer centre stage and it might be a Gerrard / Lampard type of problem.

I have confidence that we will get it right, but what “right” is is beyond me.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Nov 18 10.30am

Originally posted by dp

Perhaps. However, we signed Meyer, who is quality as far as I can tell, and as far as the much better informed than me pundits say. If we are going to pay all this money for him then we should play to his strengths.

I question whether we can find a system that puts Zaha and Meyer centre stage and it might be a Gerrard / Lampard type of problem.

I have confidence that we will get it right, but what “right” is is beyond me.

Gerrard and Lampard played almost the same position but in a part of the pitch where you can have 2 of them. Zaha and Meyer don’t play in the same position or only the same position and with 3 in front of a defensive midfield partnership there’s room there.

 


COYP

Page 3 of 27 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread