You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Who is to blame?
November 21 2026 10.14pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who is to blame?


Page 3 of 22 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Matov Flag 14 Dec 19 11.18am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

That fact has not yet risen to the surface in the aftermath of the result but I predict that it will and as a consequence there will be a renewed push to see PR installed in the UK. That push won't just come from people like me but from those on the right who also feel under represented.


Out of interest, in terms of PR, does 52 beat 48?

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 14 Dec 19 11.21am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Poor old Wisbech.

The Tories will be in power for a decade at least.

As I have told you countless times I am, and have always been, traditionally a Tory voter. I am just not a right wing Tory. I side with the Ken Clark, Michael Heseltine view of Tory politics and take exactly the same approach as they both do over Brexit.

The current Labour party are the primary cause of this debacle. Without their weakness Brexit would not have happened.

Let's see which type of Tories are in power for the coming decade. If the ERG are consigned to being a noisy but ineffective nuisance again and true "One Nation" Conservatism triumphs, then I won't be unhappy at all. With a soft Brexit, a very close alignment with the EU and a big distance from Trump then all should be OK.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 14 Dec 19 11.27am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

For what I expect you to ask and that, of course, depends on your perspective.

If you voted Tory then right now maybe you feel only celebrations are in order, but I am not so sure. Since the size of the majority was known just about everyone has suggested this means that Johnson's new government can sideline the ERG, ignore Farage and pursue a much softer Brexit deal. Something they must do if they stand any chance of reaching a deal in 12 months. Along with the fact that many of their new MPs come from constituencies with very different priorities to their southern heartlands this could well mean a move to the centre is about to happen, something seemingly confirmed today by Johnson himself.

For a hardline Brexiteer this has to be a disaster. Who is to blame? Farage is! If he hadn't tried (and succeeded) to spike the LibDems in the south by standing down all those candidates, the Tory majority would have been much smaller, and he might even have had a handful of his own MPs. With a smaller majority Johnson would need the ERG onside and his room for maneuver would be much less. If we now get a soft Brexit then you can blame Farage.

If you are a remainer then the blame falls on several heads. Cameron for his miscalculation but mostly on Corbyn for choosing to stay as Labour leader when it was obvious that he is so unpopular that failure was inevitable. The opportunity existed a few months ago to remove Johnson, install a temporary PM and a cross party government of national unity with the sole purpose of holding a confirmatory vote on whether the country wanted the "deal" or now wanted to remain. It only required Corbyn to agree and then stand aside. His stubbornness is to blame for the fact that although even with this landslide result more people voted for a party that wanted such a vote than did not, we still don't get one.

The other thing to blame is our out of date voting system which is no longer fit for purpose. Many, if not most, people seem to have voted against something rather than for it. This isn't healthy in a democracy. We need people to vote for what they want and for that to be proportionately represented in the Parliament so that compromises can be reached by our representatives.

This is a watershed moment in the UK's political life. A united Ireland now looks a racing certainty to me in the next 10 years. Scotland looks less certain but will be a continuing thorn.

I am not though without hope. The coming days and weeks will tell a lot. If Johnson reshuffles and sends the likes of Rees Mogg and Patel to the back benches then he will have made a good start. I hope Labour totally collapses and that a new centre left party emerges, funded by both more moderate unions, and socially responsible wealthy citizens and businesses. Whether the current LibDems provide the foundations for such a development is an open question, given the failed attempt by the 2 Davids almost 40 years ago but we need such a party now as never before. There are many wonderful politicians who would immediately fit into such a party. All they need is the structure.

No chance she is establishing a good reputation as Home Secretary (from those that work for her not the media)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 14 Dec 19 11.31am

Originally posted by becky

1. The majority of your fellow citizens obviously did want to exit - that's why Johnson won - and that was after seeing the implications for the last 3 and odd years!

Untrue. Only 47% of those who voted did so for parties that wanted to exit without first holding a second referendum on the terms. 53% voted for those who did. Only our first past the post system got the result.

2. That makes the assumption that there will still be an EU to rejoin by the time the mood in this country changes - I doubt that there will be, or at least, not in it's current form.

A reformed EU is needed. Those countries who wish for closer political alignment must be allowed to have it, whilst those who don't must be allowed to retain their independence. A two speed Europe was under discussion 30 years ago. I presented a paper on it to a London society back then. It's not new but it is inevitable. We ought to remain as the leader of the second group.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 14 Dec 19 11.32am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

PR doesn't allow minority parties to hold power at all. It just allows those who support them to be fairly represented

The Greens with 3% of the vote wouldn't dictate anything under a PR system. They would though be represented so their votes would matter. More relevantly the Brexit Party got 2% of the vote, even after committing political suicide, but no seats at all.

Of course as an EU advocate I don't want us to exit. Nor do a majority of our fellow citizens, now they have seen what the implications are. Do you seriously think that if in 2016 we had voted to remain that would have shut up the likes of Farage?

No. A battle has been lost but the war is far from over. A soft Brexit will make it much easier to re-enter when the mood of the country changes. As it surely will. Only when is in doubt and not if.

Please give it a rest, very tiresome. You have been bleating on about how, in 2016 people did not know what they are voting for. Now after over 3years of debate and media coverage (plenty of which was negative towards leaving) you cannot say people did not know, they did and still voted to leave. Please don't carry on about the majority still voted to remain because in 2016 the majority voted to leave but that, in your mind, was not acceptable

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 14 Dec 19 11.32am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Since when has expressing opinions been "talking down" except in the minds of those who lack confidence in their own?

The plain fact is that despite this landslide of a result being squarely the responsibility of a poorly led Labour Party more people voted for parties in favour of a final vote on Brexit than those who oppose one.

That fact has not yet risen to the surface in the aftermath of the result but I predict that it will and as a consequence there will be a renewed push to see PR installed in the UK. That push won't just come from people like me but from those on the right who also feel under represented. The one thing you can be quite sure about is that those who oppose Brexit will not be "shut up" by this. They will reflect, regroup and continue the fight. The first task being to ensure we don't do any more damage than is absolutely necessary if and when we do leave. If some predictions are true Brexit might not finally "be done" until after the NEXT election and who knows what the political landscape might be by then.

That you believe that my views, and by the way those of 53% of those who voted, are irrelevant, really is "talking down". Never during the aftermath of the 2016 referendum did anyone suggest that a 52% vote was irrelevant! All that was ever suggested was that as the basis of the question was inconclusive further work was needed.

Yes, some fine MPs have lost their seats because of their determination to put their principles above blind personal ambition. In other words they did what every MP is supposed to do and used their conscience on our behalf. We have lost their wisdom, at least temporarily, simply because of the first past the post system. A system which can see a total blockhead returned in some constituencies provided they wear the correct label. We don't want sheep in our Parliament. We want thinkers and leaders.

With the greatest of respect I never experienced a frisson of excitement at perusing the 'Thoughts of Chairman Wisbech'.

In actual fact I assumed a repose of semi-paralysis and let out such a yawn I could have been a hedgehog preparing for hybernation.

We are certainly on different sides of the house on the matters that were raised but at least Wisbech took the time and effort to make a lengthy contribution to the debate.

Finally, "We want thinkers and leaders", I have to assert that Corbyn is neither and this could be applied to many, if not all on his front bench.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 14 Dec 19 11.39am

Originally posted by chris123

Consigned to the BBS then.

Having posted on there recently and received a torrent of abuse for my troubles, he would be welcomed with open arms. I cannot believe some of the stuff on there

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 14 Dec 19 11.40am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Some people would vote Labour if a dog turd was the leader. There is definitely an age divide that will remain in place but I feel that the immigration issue will be a big part of driving traditional Labour voters over to the Tories. There is no other credible party that represents those concerns with Labour being perceived as Mass immigration friendly.

They did

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 14 Dec 19 11.42am

Originally posted by Matov


Probably mirror the rest of the Left at the moment and indulge in a slanging match between the Red Corbys and the Remain Retards in trying to blame the other.

Oddly enough for me I have some sympathy with the Corbys. In 2017 on the back of a manifesto promise to honour the 2016 result, Labour did pretty well all things considered.

In 2019, now effectively backing a f***ing long, drawn out farce to ensure that we remained, they get spanked.

For my money Corbyn was a c*** in 2017 and remains so in 2019 so that can be negated as the primary factor. But their policy on Brexit has almost changed 180'.

Don't get me wrong, I have buckets of corn ready for poppin and my most comfortable deckchair, stolen from a beach in Brighton all set up as I relish these t***s having months, possibly years, long scrap but I have a horrible suspicion that Labour will not survive this now. That there simply is not anybody who can unite them behind one leader and one message. The fault lines might be fatal.

All that fun short-lived.

And for many years before that

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 14 Dec 19 11.42am

Originally posted by Jimenez

You lost & the reason? The Drivel above.

Agreed

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 14 Dec 19 11.46am

But when 52% vote to leave, that is not a majority? and should be ignored, interesting though process

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 14 Dec 19 11.50am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Having posted on there recently and received a torrent of abuse for my troubles, he would be welcomed with open arms. I cannot believe some of the stuff on there

I dare say,if I decided to join the BBS and propound my political views, I would be tarred and feathered, thrown in the pestle and mortar and pummelled.From reading some of the posts on HOL I have concluded that my political leanings are at variance with many who grace that site !

I am certainly not averse to fiesty exchanges and full and frank discussions but I suspect some on there would lower their bar to the levels where personal insults would take the place of mature and healthy debate.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 14 Dec 19 11.54am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Only 47% of those who voted did so for parties that wanted to exit without first holding a second referendum on the terms. 53% voted for those who did. Only our first past the post system got the result.

Wisbech - you're a loser and the sooner you accept the fact the sooner you will be at peace with yourself and the world around you

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Dec 19 11.55am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3494055]

The "remain" activists are to blame for the landslide. I am far from happy with the majority Mr Buffoon has, but what do the activists expect? They ridiculed, vilified, harassed, and disrespected the "leave" voters. For three years! What they didn't do was listen. They knew best.

What they overlooked was the fact that the "leavers" won a democratic vote. Whether that was legally binding, advisory, or whatever, it was democratic. And they wanted to ride roughshod over it.

We all know the tactics which were used to thwart our departure from the EU, and witnessed the glee emanating from the gloating activists. Everyone noticed it both leave and remain.

Now we are faced with outcome of a majority government that nobody wants because a bunch of over-educated but under-experienced activists didn't get what they wanted.

Is the correct answer they insulted and slurred anyone who voted for Brexit and then 5 weeks ago those same people are telling us don't forget to vote Labour we must stop the Tories getting in. Well 5m Labour supporters voted to leave and they can be forgiven for feeling a bit miffed when the person who insulted them tells them to vote for the party that now refuses to respect their vote from 2016.

This was the opinion of a senior Labour figure on the night of the election. He had the sense to state the Labour has to start engaging with it core voters not insulting them or ignoring them for the London bubble.


Anyway what do I know I'm just a stupid leaver.

 


One more point

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Dec 19 12.06pm

"WE"

A reformed EU is needed. Those countries who wish for closer political alignment must be allowed to have it, whilst those who don't must be allowed to retain their independence. A two speed Europe was under discussion 30 years ago. I presented a paper on it to a London society back then. It's not new but it is inevitable. We ought to remain as the leader of the second group.

----
Wisbech most people would agree that the EU needs reforming however they don't which is why we are leaving. If Merkel had given Cameron some sugar your side would have won.

It's pointless talking about hypotheticals. If and when the EU does reform then our politicians will know doubt take a closer look I am not against re-joining a looser alignment as long as power remains with our Parliament.

If your correct then the EU has the perfect opportunity now to start that reform when we enter the trade negotiations. They can offer Boris a deal which could becomes the basis for a 2 tier Europe however I think that is highly unlikely.

As I see it you are making assumptions that are simply not there at the moment. Maybe in a few years when the EU misses our revenue you could be right but at this moment I have not heard any of the key players urging this.

Edited by Badger11 (14 Dec 2019 12.06pm)

Edited by Badger11 (14 Dec 2019 12.07pm)

 


One more point

samprior Flag Hamburg 14 Dec 19 12.06pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Wisbech - you're a loser and the sooner you accept the fact the sooner you will be at peace with yourself and the world around you

Can I just say when Wisbech and others engage in debate that doesn't resort to name calling I actually find it quite interesting with salient points made on both sides.

It's a shame when it descends into name calling and not a good reflection of the people who do so.

Keep it friendly fellas

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Dec 19 12.09pm

Originally posted by samprior

Can I just say when Wisbech and others engage in debate that doesn't resort to name calling I actually find it quite interesting with salient points made on both sides.

It's a shame when it descends into name calling and not a good reflection of the people who do so.

Keep it friendly fellas

Agreed. I don't agree with his view point but we are not the BBS. People should take a look at the vileness on their. If this board becomes like that I'm out of here.

 


One more point

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 14 Dec 19 12.31pm

Originally posted by samprior

Can I just say when Wisbech and others engage in debate that doesn't resort to name calling I actually find it quite interesting with salient points made on both sides.

It's a shame when it descends into name calling and not a good reflection of the people who do so.

Keep it friendly fellas

I always try and argue my case free from any personal insults or slurs.

I might fervently disagree with what I might consider hogwash and dismiss the post in such terms, but alas I don't resort to plummeting the depths by insulting the intelligence of the poster or using other forms of personal vilification.

If indeed I have caused any offence by my comments,it has been by accident rather than design and my sincere apologies if this has been the case.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 14 Dec 19 12.44pm

I found political debate on HOL interesting and a beacon of generally good humour and respect for different views.

It's when we get to discussing Palace that the veneer of civilised behaviour is exposed !

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 14 Dec 19 12.51pm

Interesting speech given by Boris Johnson this morning in Sedgefield which he finished by saying that Members of Parliament should never forget that they are servants and not masters and they are there to do the bidding of the electorate

 

Page 3 of 22 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Who is to blame?