You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we on a path to disaster ?
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we on a path to disaster ?


Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
manoftaste Flag Hastings 22 Dec 19 6.26pm

This has been an interesting thread to read. Points I take from it are:
(1) We are playing very unattractive football. In the end, football is about entertainment, and there's not been much of that this season;
(2) We are punching above our weight, and for that both the chairman and manager should be applauded. But it won't last for ever, and Roy will surely go sooner rather than later;
(3) We have nothing tangible to show for 6 years in the Premiership. Parts of the stadium (esp. the Arthur Waite stand) are an embarrassment. We all got excited about the new main stand plans, but they seem to have come to nought;
(4) Our squad is old and threadbare, Wilf is clearly going to leave, there's not much sign of youngsters emerging from the Academy, and splurging millions on signings like Benteke and Sakho has been a mistake that shouldnt be repeated.
Solutions? No obvious answers but:
(1) Shouldnt we recruit a young deputy to Roy now with the idea he should assume the reigns in, say, 12 months time?
(2) Shouldn't we make a start on the new stand now (and if JS wont sell the bit of land we need then modify the plans accordingly, allowing for expansion when/if that land becomes available)?
(3) With the £50m from AWB and £70m+ from Wilf, surely it should be possible to sign half a dozen promising youngsters from lower league clubs assuming that, with good coaching and easing into first team duties, at least half will come good over next 12-18 months?
(4) Couldn't the chairman convene a public meeting fans can attend where he outlines where he sees the club going (and how we get there) medium-term, so we can at least try to understand what the strategy is?

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 22 Dec 19 6.36pm

Originally posted by manoftaste

This has been an interesting thread to read. Points I take from it are:
(1) We are playing very unattractive football. In the end, football is about entertainment, and there's not been much of that this season;
(2) We are punching above our weight, and for that both the chairman and manager should be applauded. But it won't last for ever, and Roy will surely go sooner rather than later;
(3) We have nothing tangible to show for 6 years in the Premiership. Parts of the stadium (esp. the Arthur Waite stand) are an embarrassment. We all got excited about the new main stand plans, but they seem to have come to nought;
(4) Our squad is old and threadbare, Wilf is clearly going to leave, there's not much sign of youngsters emerging from the Academy, and splurging millions on signings like Benteke and Sakho has been a mistake that shouldnt be repeated.
Solutions? No obvious answers but:
(1) Shouldnt we recruit a young deputy to Roy now with the idea he should assume the reigns in, say, 12 months time?
(2) Shouldn't we make a start on the new stand now (and if JS wont sell the bit of land we need then modify the plans accordingly, allowing for expansion when/if that land becomes available)?
(3) With the £50m from AWB and £70m+ from Wilf, surely it should be possible to sign half a dozen promising youngsters from lower league clubs assuming that, with good coaching and easing into first team duties, at least half will come good over next 12-18 months?
(4) Couldn't the chairman convene a public meeting fans can attend where he outlines where he sees the club going (and how we get there) medium-term, so we can at least try to understand what the strategy is?

Unfortunately, I’m pretty sure the AWB ££ went to service the growing club debt , with the remainder on the Summer transfer business and new contracts for existing players.

We’re running on empty despite bringing in over £140 m a year. That’s his crazy football has got. Tekkers and Sako alone will have drained close to 90 mill from the club by the time they leave on a free. This is the harsh reality, unless we find an owner with very very deep pockets ... pretty much like most of the clubs outside the top 8 the best we can hope for is mid table obscurity and the occasional win against the big boys.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 22 Dec 19 7.50pm

We are balanced precariously on a mince pie.

 

AERO Flag 22 Dec 19 7.55pm

As previously me the time to rebuild is upon us ,the stadium and the squad .If not done soon the trap door awaits .

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Dec 19 7.56pm

It might not be that long when we are in pitchy seas when we will not so much flounder but succumb to the tempest, each wave picking us up and hurtling us further from the shore.We will be creaking like the 'Mayflower' in a gale.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 22 Dec 19 8.18pm

Originally posted by Willo

It might not be that long when we are in pitchy seas when we will not so much flounder but succumb to the tempest, each wave picking us up and hurtling us further from the shore.We will be creaking like the 'Mayflower' in a gale.

Lol, survival of the one who farts the loudest.

 

Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 22 Dec 19 9.26pm

Originally posted by becky
I think things would improve and players used off the bench, I personally think its a bit of a protest from Roy not using players he had no say in buying. It just does not work with Parish and Freedman deciding who would fit in with the Managers plans, He already stated in one interview that we never brought in full backs in case of injury, He really needs cash and to decide who we buy


Therein lies the conundrum for me......how do you plan for post-Roy? Start buying players now, and they could well be an expensive mistake if they do not fit with the plans/style of any new manager. Using up what funds are available to buy more additions to the bench warmers would be stupid.

Don't buy, and you will have trouble attracting a decent replacement for Roy, and even if you do then he would only have a severely restricted amount of time to find players to suit him and the team.

A real chicken and egg situation - but agree that something needs to be done. Maybe once we unload some more of the 'dead wood' purchases?

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 22 Dec 19 10.07pm

Originally posted by manoftaste

This has been an interesting thread to read. Points I take from it are:
(1) We are playing very unattractive football. In the end, football is about entertainment, and there's not been much of that this season;
(2) We are punching above our weight, and for that both the chairman and manager should be applauded. But it won't last for ever, and Roy will surely go sooner rather than later;
(3) We have nothing tangible to show for 6 years in the Premiership. Parts of the stadium (esp. the Arthur Waite stand) are an embarrassment. We all got excited about the new main stand plans, but they seem to have come to nought;
(4) Our squad is old and threadbare, Wilf is clearly going to leave, there's not much sign of youngsters emerging from the Academy, and splurging millions on signings like Benteke and Sakho has been a mistake that shouldnt be repeated.
Solutions? No obvious answers but:
(1) Shouldnt we recruit a young deputy to Roy now with the idea he should assume the reigns in, say, 12 months time?
(2) Shouldn't we make a start on the new stand now (and if JS wont sell the bit of land we need then modify the plans accordingly, allowing for expansion when/if that land becomes available)?
(3) With the £50m from AWB and £70m+ from Wilf, surely it should be possible to sign half a dozen promising youngsters from lower league clubs assuming that, with good coaching and easing into first team duties, at least half will come good over next 12-18 months?
(4) Couldn't the chairman convene a public meeting fans can attend where he outlines where he sees the club going (and how we get there) medium-term, so we can at least try to understand what the strategy is?

1. Is it ? You can play free flow attacking football, get beaten more often than not and get relegated, Is that what you want ?
2. Well, he's 72 so that's pretty obvious. Good to see you giving him some credit though
3. No we haven't and it's disappointing that investment for redevelopment was secured but no real progress made. I see the reasons as being a change to the Americans commitment and the usual issues with trying to get permissions to get anything done in urban areas.
4. Hindsight is a wonderful thing and no more so than in the transfer market. Benteke looked to be the proven goalscorer we needed at this level and Sakho's loan performances were above and beyond what we had at the time in that position

Solutions ;

1. How often do football clubs do that ? Who is out there that would be willing to work under Hodgson for a year, to his methods, tactics, player selections ? I don't see that working.
2. We can't make a start on the new stand without the funds to do it and all the permissions in place. If the Americans are pulling out then presumably their original investment, ring fenced for stadium developments, is no longer available
3. Half of the income from AWB os going towards the Academy and gaining the Category 1 status the club needs to compete for the best youngsters. We haven't got any money yet for Zaha and may not do until next summer.
Your solution re promising young players you make sound easy - it really isn't !
4. No need for a public meeting when so many social media channels are available. I agree, I would like to know more specifics but SP clearly has little positive to share at this time because that is one thing he is very quick to do - share good news asap !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

HeathMan Flag Purley 23 Dec 19 12.28am

Having looked at this thread, i looked at the BBC report on Saturday's match. True to his word Roy had three academy players on the bench. By definition Academy players are in a lower league just like the Championship which has given the P L Sheffield United and Wolves, and a couple of useful young English Managers. The three on the bench must have impressed Roy, and need PL game time to develop. sadly Roy (unlike for the Bournemouth Match first (and only0 did a substitution at 86 minutes. Who knows what the result would have been had Meyer - on the field at 65 minutes been joined by two of the Academy bench members at 70 minutes. They might have shone as brightly as AWB did. COYP

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 23 Dec 19 5.58am

Originally posted by NEILLO


We can't make a start on the new stand without the funds to do it and all the permissions in place. If the Americans are pulling out then presumably their original investment, ring fenced for stadium developments, is no longer available

I no longer believe that guff about funding for stadium development being ring fenced as I don't think it was ever delivered. If there was ringfenced funding for any purpose it would show up in the accounts but nothing is there.

Substitute "promised" for "ringfenced" perhaps

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 23 Dec 19 6.24am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I no longer believe that guff about funding for stadium development being ring fenced as I don't think it was ever delivered. If there was ringfenced funding for any purpose it would show up in the accounts but nothing is there.

Substitute "promised" for "ringfenced" perhaps

Good post. Didn't believe a word of it at the time. Would be happy to be proved otherwise.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 23 Dec 19 8.39am

At the sake of repetition, there is nothing to suggest this is anything other than a vanity project with some shiny powerpoint from an architect and possibly a lovely model in Steve P's office.

The broader question is do fans have a right to expect truthful full disclosure from owners and chairmen, I say not.

We like to think we do but we don't.

The CPFC2010 team is in a different position to many other owners/past owners as they did save the club from extinction.

That in the opinion of many makes them immune from criticism for ever. I am pleased for those from that group who managed to sell and make some money, well done and thanks for your part in the history of the club.

There is a fair bit of chat about the team " reaching the next level ". If we stop becoming perennial participants in the relegation dogfight then we will have reached a next level, and considering what Roy has had to work with in terms of inherited players and lack of cash to spend is something of a miracle in itself.

And, forget the new stand while current ownership structure in place.

If we have new owners in control with patience and pots of cash we might get some stadium development

Happy Xmas to all

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Good post. Didn't believe a word of it at the time. Would be happy to be proved otherwise.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 23 Dec 19 8.55am

Originally posted by HKOwen

The CPFC2010 team is in a different position to many other owners/past owners as they did save the club from extinction.

That in the opinion of many makes them immune from criticism for ever. I am pleased for those from that group who managed to sell and make some money, well done and thanks for your part in the history of the club.

No one is immune from criticism in perpetuity; be eternally grateful by all means, but future actions must be judged on their merits, and not on the history, which, at best, can only provide mitigation for future mistakes.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Dec 19 9.14am

We are certainly on the path to having to replace a number of players who are either in their 30s or will be in 2020 :
PVA, Ward,Sakho,Cahill,Kelly,Dann,Kouyate,McArthur,McCarthy,Benteke.

An ageing squad and a rebuilding will be necessary but those listed above will not swell the coffers to any significant degree.

Edited by Willo (23 Dec 2019 9.29am)

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 23 Dec 19 10.06am

Originally posted by Willo

We are certainly on the path to having to replace a number of players who are either in their 30s or will be in 2020 :
PVA, Ward,Sakho,Cahill,Kelly,Dann,Kouyate,McArthur,McCarthy,Benteke.

An ageing squad and a rebuilding will be necessary but those listed above will not swell the coffers to any significant degree.

Yes, unfortunately we've managed to get ourselves into a right Catch 22.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Painter Flag Croydon 23 Dec 19 10.08am

Originally posted by Willo

It might not be that long when we are in pitchy seas when we will not so much flounder but succumb to the tempest, each wave picking us up and hurtling us further from the shore.We will be creaking like the 'Mayflower' in a gale.

You will start up, we are doomed relegation forecasting soon. Toughest league in the world and we are 12th, a disaster is supporting teams like Stoke, who’s fans have put the whole team up for sale on eBay.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Dec 19 10.13am

Originally posted by Painter

You will start up, we are doomed relegation forecasting soon. Toughest league in the world and we are 12th, a disaster is supporting teams like Stoke, who’s fans have put the whole team up for sale on eBay.

I have not used the words "Disaster" in terms of our prospects but I am reminded of the song "There may be trouble ahead".

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 23 Dec 19 10.19am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I no longer believe that guff about funding for stadium development being ring fenced as I don't think it was ever delivered. If there was ringfenced funding for any purpose it would show up in the accounts but nothing is there.

Substitute "promised" for "ringfenced" perhaps

Who knows...the answer I fancy is somewhere in Delaware.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Jacey Flag 23 Dec 19 10.33am

Originally posted by Willo

We are certainly on the path to having to replace a number of players who are either in their 30s or will be in 2020 :
PVA, Ward,Sakho,Cahill,Kelly,Dann,Kouyate,McArthur,McCarthy,Benteke.

An ageing squad and a rebuilding will be necessary but those listed above will not swell the coffers to any significant degree.

Edited by Willo (23 Dec 2019 9.29am)

An aging squad, an aging Manager, all in need of replacing in the not too distant future.

Edited by Jacey (23 Dec 2019 10.33am)

 

JohnB Flag 23 Dec 19 10.42am

Originally posted by Willo


PVA, Ward, Sakho, Cahill, Kelly, Dann, Kouyate, McArthur, McCarthy, Benteke.

That's got to be what? £600k a week's worth of wages combined? Value for money

 

Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we on a path to disaster ?